Blue butterflies back in San Francisco, after Xerces extinction
Cal Academy of Sciences and The Presidio join conservation efforts to bring blue butterflies back to San Francisco coast.
Genetic sequencing links Silvery blue butterflies to extinct Xerces blue.
From March through May 2025 scientists hope to see new generation of silvery blue butterflies emerge after introduction to new Presidio habitat.
OAKLAND, Calif. - In the San Francisco Bay Area, the Xerces blue butterfly went extinct along the San Francisco coast some 80 years ago, but now the California Academy of Sciences and the Presidio Trust have identified a similar species of blue butterfly and are trying to introduce it back to the region where the Xerces blue butterfly was once so common.
Durrell Kapan, a senior research fellow at the California Academy of Sciences, is part of that effort and spoke with Jana Katsuyama on the Four to explain the effort:
Most butterflies…most organisms that go extinct are due to habitat loss. So California, after the gold rush, especially San Francisco, saw a lot of development. And so most people don't know that most of San Francisco was awash with dunes. Pretty much the first two-thirds away from the ocean was all dunes. That was a perfect habitat for a butterfly, a little blue butterfly, that flew, feeding on a specific host plant called deer weed. It's a pea family plant with an orange and red flower. Those plants didn't have the dunes to live in, and the butterflies didn't have the plants or the dunes, and so they went extinct.
Now you have identified butterflies that are very closely related: the Silvery Blue butterflies that are in Monterey County. How did you use genetic sequencing to identify the connection between these two species?
I'm super fortunate to have a great team here at the California Academy of Sciences. We were able to extract DNA non-destructively from a leg of one of the specimens of silvery blues that we had in the collection. And so we were able to compare the DNA from a bunch of Xerces and a bunch of silvery blue butterflies, which we hypothesized to be the closest relative, to sort of narrow down which ones were closer. And I'm super happy to be part of this team at the Cal Academy that can do that kind of work. So that's the basic story.
How were you able to restore that habitat that you said was lost, and introduce dozens of the silvery blue butterflies to San Francisco's coastline? Why is it important to bring butterflies back?
That was one year ago…about a year ago, in April. But the work on this habitat has been going on for a long time. The Presidio and the National Park Service have been restoring habitat among other groups across the city since the mid-90s. It's part of their mandated work, and only when the restoration is kind of mostly ready to go would we be interested in bringing back species that couldn't migrate there on their own, like, in this case, the silvery blue butterfly as a stand in for the extinct Xerces blue butterfly.
Why is it important to have that stand in, if you will, to be in the ecosystem, in the habitat there?
Well, the basic idea is that the butterfly presents like a single organism that does a job. The job is to feed on plants. As adults, they pollinate certain plants, they may have an interaction with ants, and they'll be prey. But that job, in this case, for the Xerces blues, is actually outsized, because that's a very, it's an inspirational butterfly. The Xerces was the first known invertebrate to go extinct in North America. It became the namesake of the Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation. So working on putting a blue butterfly back where Xerces used to fly is extremely inspiring for conservationists and communities, community members and others.
You mentioned that this was actually released last year. How are you tracking it? Or are you tracking the success of this?
Yeah, we're, we're tracking it pretty much since late February. It's a very small chance that eggs that were laid last spring could be close to becoming pupa into adults as early as mid-March and as late as May. So we're going out there every single sunny day to look.
That must be so exciting to be able to see that in action after all of that hard work before. Everybody thinks of butterflies as being so beautiful, but in a global sense, why is it so important to have species preservation and for all of us as individuals to try and support those populations?
So monarchs are another species which is really interesting. They're migratory, so they sample different habitats. Like the wintering habitat for the Eastern monarch is in Mexico…they increased…they doubled since last year, which was a very low number. It's like not so low, but still a low number.
They also have a monarch population in California, and they have been doing okay, and then they started to go down in 2020, to a very low number, back up to the hundreds of thousands, and then just this last year, they're down again in the low numbers. So those kind of butterflies are like canaries in the coal mine, because they sample different habitats for wintering, where they stay in these eucalyptus groves…Then in the spring, they need milkweed to migrate towards their summer habitats. They need milkweed in their summer habitats.
And then there's a supergeneration that migrates down to Mexico or onto coastal California for the winter. Those are two separate populations. They're kind of out of sync. So the monarch news is good for East right now. It's kind of dire for the west right now. But those butterflies themselves are like canaries in a coal mine, like I said. They're pollinators, they're prey, and they're amazing herbivores. So, without butterflies and other insects that eat plants, plants would be growing out of control.
A conversation with Durrell Kapan, senior research fellow at the California Academy of Sciences.
Jana Katsuyama is a reporter for KTVU. Email Jana at jana.katsuyama@fox.com. Call her at 510-326-5529. Or follow her on Twitter @JanaKTVU and read her other reports on her bio page.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
25-07-2025
- CBS News
Relative of extinct Xerces butterfly helps restore California habitat destroyed in its demise
A butterfly that went extinct decades ago after the destruction of its Bay Area habitat is now the driving force behind its restoration with the help of a close relative now fluttering in its terrain. At the Presidio in San Francisco, researchers, community scientists, and park officials gathered recently in hopes of filling a vacancy at a newly restored sand dune habitat with prospective new residents. It's taken 30 years to restore these dune habitats. Now, another historic effort is underway to restore another lost treasure. Scientists are hoping the silvery blue, a small butterfly native to North America, will take up residence and perform a critical function once done by the extinct Xerces blue. Professor Durrell Kapan, senior research fellow with the California Academy of Sciences, heads up the experimental project. He recently carried a cooler bag to the dunes near Lobos Creek in the Presidio National Park, withdrew a smaller cooler pouch, and removed small plastic containers, each holding a single silvery blue butterfly. All of them sipped on a cotton ball soaked in fruit punch-flavored Gatorade, which seems to be their favorite sustenance during these exercises. As the morning sun rose and the area warmed up, the silvery blues were released underneath a mesh fabric so they could acclimate. Later, the mesh was removed, and volunteers tracked their flight for about an hour. "By bringing back this butterfly, we are bringing back more of what used to be here," said Lewis Stringer, associate director of natural resources at the Presidio Trust. "We are expecting that the silvery blue will fill the gap that was left by the Xerces extinction," explained Dr. Phoebe Parker-Shames, wildlife ecologist for the Presidio. Before the Gold Rush, the Xerces blue thrived in sprawling coastal dunes around San Francisco that stretched from the Presidio through Ocean Beach, Fort Funston, and the Richmond and Sunset neighborhoods. The species kept the habitat healthy by pollinating plants and serving as food for other animals, such as birds and lizards. Rapid urban development destroyed the dunes, and that destroyed the Xerces. One report indicates that the last Xerces spotted in the area occurred in 1943. "This is an iconic species that literally was the first butterfly or invertebrate to go extinct in North America," said Kapan. "[The project is] an amazing opportunity to try to regenerate those missing connections using its closest relative. It's an opportunity to try to practice how we fix the environment." Genetic sequencing at Cal Academy confirmed the closest living relative to the Xerces blue is the silvery blue. Like the Xerces, silvery blues also like cold foggy weather, dune habitats, and deerweed on which they lay their eggs. Scientists were allowed to gather silvery blues living near the coast of Monterey and relocate them to San Francisco's Presidio. Parker-Shames said that adding the silvery blues to the dune habitat at the Presidio helps build resilience into a warming world. "If one year it's too hot for a particular species and their population sort of has a dip, there's another species there that can help fill the same role," she noted. The unprecedented effort is a four-year project that involves Cal Academy, the Presidio Trust, Creekside Science, the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, and Revive and Restore. The McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity is also involved. This effort to make San Francisco more resilient and increase biodiversity is part of a larger effort exemplified in the urban nature alliance known as "Reimagining San Francisco." Last year, scientists released the first batch of silvery blues, and observations suggest success. Each released butterfly has a small mark added to their wings for identification. The scientists are now spotting unmarked butterflies. They say these unmarked silvery blues are the offspring of the first released butterflies flitting around the park. So far this year, about 50 silvery blues have been released. Driggs and Mills have already seen a newly released female laying eggs on the deerweed. "It's really cool, honestly," said Driggs.
Yahoo
22-07-2025
- Yahoo
Scientists work to understand why dozens of whales have recently died in the San Francisco Bay Area
Scientists are investigating a sharp rise in the number of whales killed in the San Francisco Bay Area in 2025 even as local whale pods struggle to recover from a massive die-off in 2019. The California Academy of Sciences said on Monday that researchers had logged the deaths of 21 gray whales, two unidentified baleen whales, and one minke whale in waters near San Francisco this year so far, compared to 14 in 2019 and 15 in 2021. Researchers also reported an "unusually high" number of gray whale sightings in the region, with more than 30 individuals confirmed versus only six in 2024. "This latest gray whale caught everyone a bit by surprise, given how late in the season it is and the fact that we had not sighted the species in the Bay in nearly two weeks," Kathi George, director of cetacean conservation biology at the Marine Mammal Center in nearby Sausalito, told ABC News. "It shows signs of concern for this population as it moves forward into the future... we know that climate change is changing ocean conditions and changing prey available availability for these whales in the Arctic." Researchers have reported an "unusually high" number of gray whale sightings in the region recently (Alfredo Estrella / AFP via Getty Images) A young male gray whale beached at Kirby Cove, on the Marin Headlands near San Francisco (Marjorie Cox / The Marine Mammal Center) Eight of the gray whales were probably killed by vessel strikes, the Academy said, but the cause of death for the others was uncertain. Nor was it clear why so many whales were visible in the Bay Area this year. Gray whale populations in the North Pacific are still reeling from an estimated 45 per cent drop between 2019 and 2023, during which nearly 700 whales died along the west coast of North America. A gray whale breaching (NOAA Fisheries) That episode, known by scientists as an "unusual mortality event", is thought to have slashed whale numbers from around 20,500 in 2019 to just over 14,500 in 2023. A study in 2023 found evidence that melting Arctic sea ice had prolonged the die-off, in comparison to previous such events, by disrupting the food chain of algae and plankton on which gray whales ultimately depend. Gray whales are highly social animals (AFP via Getty Images) Gray whales are large, highly social filter feeders that migrate up and down the west coast of North America, traveling thousands of miles from their summer feeding grounds near Alaska to their winter breeding areas off western Mexico. Once common in the Atlantic Ocean too, they were hunted in huge numbers by humans for their blubber throughout the 19th century. Now they exist in two populations in the northwest and northeast Pacific, with the former group being officially endangered. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
21-07-2025
- Yahoo
Why whales are dying off the San Francisco coast, according to researchers
Nearly two dozen whales have died in the San Francisco Bay Area in recent months, according to animal rescue groups. A total of 19 gray whales, two unidentified baleen whales and one minke whale have died in the Bay Area region so far this year, according to the California Academy of Sciences. At least seven of the gray whale deaths have been determined to be suspect or probable vessel strikes, according to the organization. MORE: 6 gray whales have died in San Francisco in the past week as authorities scramble for answers In addition, there has been an "unusually high" number of whale sightings in the Bay Area this year, with more than 30 individual gray whales confirmed in the region via photo identification, the Academy said, noting that the whales' physical conditions have ranged from normal to emaciated. About a third of the whales have stayed in the region for at least 20 days and researchers expect more sightings for another couple of weeks before the whales migrate north to Arctic feeding grounds. The whales breed off the coast of Mexico but should be farther north at this time of year, Kathi George, director of cetacean conservation biology at The Marine Mammal Center in Sausalito, Calif., told ABC News. In 2024, just six gray whales were sighted in the region. Researchers are investigating the potential reasons behind the "massive" spike in sightings this year. Animal rescue groups in the region have not responded to this many dead gray whale deaths since the unusual mortality event in 2019 that saw more than 70 gray whale deaths on the West Coast, and another event in 2021 in which 15 whales died in the Bay Area, according to the California Academy of Sciences. An estimated 45% of the North Pacific gray whale population was lost between 2019 and 2023, the California Academy of Sciences said. MORE: What to know about the toxic algae bloom killing marine life in Southern California In previous unusual mortality events, the gray whale population has typically rebounded but after 2019, the populations have experienced continued declines, George said. The population was estimated to be at nearly 27,000 in 2016 but fell to as low as 13,230 animals in the winter of 2022-2023 as a result of the mass mortality event, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). Marine researchers in the U.S., Mexico and Canada are monitoring the health of the gray whale population in hopes of gaining further insights into the unusual mortality event, the organization said. Earlier this year, scientists in Southern California have reported a record-low gray whale calf count, "which is a cause for concern," according to the Academy. Only about 85 gray whale calves migrated past Central California on their way to feeding grounds in the Arctic earlier this year, according to NOAA. "It shows signs of concern for this population as it moves forward into the future," George said. "What we're trying to learn is we know that climate change is changing ocean conditions and changing prey available availability for these whales in the Arctic." MORE: NOAA declares deaths of 70 gray whales on US west coast 'unusual mortality event' The Bay Area serves as a "puzzle piece" to the gray whales' lengthy annual migration, George said. Dead whales have been reported in the San Francisco Bay Area since March 30, when a female gray whale was found dead at Black Sands Beach, located in the Golden Gate National Recreation Area. The animal died from a probable vessel strike, according to The Marine Mammal Center. In May, six gray whales died in the region within a week. The latest death occurred on July 7 at the Richmond Long Wharf, located about 20 miles north of San Francisco, according to The Marine Mammal Center. A dead female adult gray whale washed up adjacent to the Richmond-San Rafael Bridge after suffering from blunt force trauma by a suspected vessel strike, the organization said. A necropsy revealed hemorrhaging on the animal's left side, between the head and pectoral fin, likely as a result of the strike, according to the Center. "This latest gray whale caught everyone a bit by surprise given how late in the season it is and the fact that we had not sighted the species in the bay in nearly two weeks," George said in a statement. An estimated 80 whales die annually from vessel strikes, according to the Center for Biological Diversity. Gray whales typically have a "very low profile" in the water that can make them difficult to see, unlike other coastal whales, such as humpback whales, according to the Academy. "It's vital that all boaters – from large commercial vessels to sailboats – be 'whale aware' and continue to slow down," the California Academy of Sciences said. Further south, thousands of marine animals have been sickened by an unprecedented toxic algae bloom that has overrun the Southern California coasts. Species such as seabirds, sea lions and dolphins have been impacted by elevated levels of the neurotoxic domoic acid produced by the algae blooms in the region. However, the harmful algae blooms aren't related to the recent whale deaths in the Bay Area because gray whales transiting north don't stop in Southern California to feed, George said. "That is something we test for, though, when we are doing he necropsies – to see what they may have been exposed to recently," she said. Solve the daily Crossword
