"Stop singing the same song": Indians rip into Sabeer Bhatia's GDP shame post
Agencies Hotmail's Sabeer Bhatia
Hotmail co-founder Sabeer Bhatia has landed in the middle of a fierce online storm after he publicly criticised India's economic celebration. On 10 June, Bhatia took to social media platform X to post:'Instead of hanging your head in shame that 415 million people in India survive on $3.10/day, you brag about being the world's 4th largest economy. Shame on you.'That one sentence lit a match. The platform caught fire.His comment came shortly after India marked its economic rise to fourth place globally, overtaking Japan. But instead of praise, Bhatia's remark drew widespread condemnation from Indian users across political and professional backgrounds.
Bhatia's post was quickly labelled as bitter, out of touch, and based on outdated data. Many users questioned whether he was aiming his words at India's political class or at ordinary citizens.
One user responded, 'For whom was this post? Political leadership of India? If yes then have balls to say so. If it's for common citizens then it's incorrect as they are not bragging.'The sentiment deepened as another said, 'You have made your point. Now, instead of moving on, you sing the same song every day to farm engagement? Shame on you.'Then came the personal attacks.
'Surname badal le phle (change your surname, first),' wrote one user, accusing Bhatia of using his Indian identity only when convenient. Bhatia co-founded Hotmail in the mid-1990s and sold it to Microsoft in 1997 for an estimated $400 million. Since then, his career has included several tech ventures, none of which matched his initial success.Many online critics reminded him of this fact.'You sold Hotmail for $400 million in Dec 1997. How many billions have you made since then? ZERO – All your ventures failed miserably. And you are lecturing here on X to the fastest growing economy,' one user posted.Another fired back, 'Come back to India and make something like Hotmail, i.e., pioneer something under your birthplace. Talents like yours run away on the first one-way flight when green grass is shown. The irony is that India produces such wasteful talents.'Bhatia did not ignore the comments. He engaged. In response to a user who mocked him for relying on social media, saying:'What happened to Rafael? You were supposed to gift the nation. Do something productive in life. As it looks, you are now dependent on Social Media for living,'Bhatia replied, 'Another personal attack. When losers like you don't know how to counter my way of thinking, you resort to personal attacks. Weak minded and insecure.'Another user had questioned Bhatia's understanding of debt and pride, posting:'You're just an idiot. Why are you bragging about being the world's No. 1 economy with $36–37 trillion in debt?'To which Bhatia clarified, 'US never bragged about being the top economy in the world.'The debate only grew louder from there. One comment summed up the anger many felt:'We, Indians living in India, don't need validation or permission from you to feel proud about something. And if you must know, please consult @WorldBank about facts before blabbering anything you wish!'Despite the flood of criticism, Bhatia stood firm. He doubled down. As the post gained traction, he republished the same comment in Hindi, seemingly to reach a wider Indian audience.His critics saw it as more provocation. For some, it was another attempt at attention. For others, it was a sign that he believed in what he posted, no matter the fallout.A small but noticeable section of users did agree with Bhatia. They echoed concerns about income inequality and called for greater focus on structural reforms rather than GDP rankings.But for the majority, the issue wasn't just what Bhatia said—it was how he said it, and from where.The question remains: how much weight should public figures living abroad carry in domestic economic debates? And when they speak, should they listen as much as they post?
(Disclaimer: This article is based on a user-generated post on X. ET.com has not independently verified the claims made in the post and does not vouch for their accuracy. The views expressed are those of the individual and do not necessarily reflect the views of ET.com. Reader discretion is advised.)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Hyphenating US-Pak: Doing business with gunmen
Howdy, phenomenal pardners! Michael Kurilla (left) & Asif Munir, Florida, 2023 The Trump regime's reported invitation to Pakistan Army chief Asim Munir to attend the 250th US Army Day celebrations in Washington tomorrow has stirred various vectors of speculation. Chief among them: Potential reset in US-Pakistan relations. Pakistan's prospective utility within an emergent Trump doctrine that views bilateral ties primarily through an economic lens. Revival of a counterterrorism partnership between Islamabad/Rawalpindi and Washington. Implications of such a warming of US-Pakistan ties on US-India relations. In New Delhi, this apparent shift in Washington's posture has come as a surprise. What is even more startling is the timing - coming on the heels of India's retaliation against Pakistan for its involvement in the Pahalgam terrorist attacks on civilians. A significant part of Trump's appeal among Indians, both in India and the diaspora, stemmed from his tough stance on terrorism. During Trump 1.0, he publicly called out Pakistan's duplicity in his very first tweet of 2018, accusing it of 'lies and deceit' while receiving billions in US aid. He subsequently cut $300 mn in aid to Pakistan, a move that built on the Obama administration's earlier decision to withhold one-third of all military assistance to the country. During Trump 2.0, consistent with his recalibrated approach toward various global actors, the US president has markedly diverged from his earlier stance, Pakistan being no exception. In February, the Trump regime departed from its broader aid-cutting policy to authorise $397 mn in security assistance to Pakistan. This was specifically aimed at supporting a US-backed programme for maintenance and technical support of Pakistan's F-16 fighter the assistance explicitly stated that it was not to be used for operations against India, reopening of funding channels to Pakistan signalled a broader trend of policy reversal. In March, Trump publicly thanked Pakistan for its assistance in the arrest of Mohammad Sharifullah, a suspect linked to multiple terrorist attacks, including the 2021 Abbey Gate bombing in recently, Trump's consistent attempts to place Pakistan on equal footing with India, particularly following the India-Pak military escalation in May, appear driven by strategic reinforcing this shift, US Centcom chief Michael Kurilla referred to Pakistan as a 'phenomenal partner' in counterterrorism efforts. Similarly, Paul Kapur, Trump's incoming assistant secretary of state for South and Central Asian affairs, affirmed that the US would 'pursue security cooperation where it is beneficial to US interests while seeking opportunities for bilateral collaboration in trade and investment'. Together, these moves reflect a deliberate and coordinated strategy for renewed strategic engagement with apparent rapprochement between the US and Pakistan may be driven largely by Trump's personal inclinations, and a possible desire to secure future economic deals. For Pakistan, warming ties with Washington represent a strategic gain, however temporary. Any signs of improving relations between Islamabad/Rawalpindi and Washington stand in sharp political contrast to the stance of former PM Imran Khan and his supporters in Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI).Khan had accused the US of orchestrating the fall of his government, and maintained that he would never have agreed to American demands for military bases in his country. If PTI continues to remain a significant political force, any future US requests for enhanced military presence - even under the guise of counterterrorism - are likely to face resistance. Conversely, if Trump intensifies efforts to strike an economic deal with Pakistan, the resulting political reverberations within the country could become even more tough posture during his first term - marked by launching a trade war with China, pursuing a 'maximum pressure' strategy against Iran culminating in the killing of Iranian general Qasem Soleimani, and publicly calling out countries like Pakistan for sponsoring terrorism - is now giving way to a policy of modus vivendi, driven by an outsized prioritisation of US interests, particularly economic US-China economic deal reportedly 'finalised' on June 11 underscores this clear shift in US diplomacy - one that increasingly sidelines concerns of Washington's allies, partners and friends. While this approach may serve immediate US interests, especially in economic terms, it risks prompting a strategic recalibration by other nations in how they engage with the the shadow of recent military escalation between India and Pakistan, Pakistan's detente with the US may present an opportunity for Trump. But the strain this reset places on India-US relations could prove detrimental to both countries in the long run. The divergence between New Delhi and Washington is now most pronounced on the issue of Pakistan and, more broadly, on India has strongly reaffirmed its zero-tolerance stance against terrorism following the Pahalgam attack, the Trump regime appears increasingly willing to engage Pakistan as a counterterrorism partner. In doing so, Trump seems to be prioritising unilateral US interests over shared strategic concerns that have long underpinned the India-US partnership. Unlike his first term, when Trump's South Asia policy broadly aligned with the US-India strategic convergence, his bilateral bets in his second gig risk further destabilising an already fragile region. (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. How a nudge from Cyrus Mistry helped TCS unlock a USD1 billion opportunity Explainer: The RBI's LAF corridor and its role in rate transmission Is Zomato under siege? Quick commerce may be the next telecom Operation Sindoor, Turkey, Bangladesh played out as India hosted global airlines after 42 years Coal on one hand and green on the other; this company balances both Stock Radar: Bandhan Bank stocks break out from 1-month consolidation; what should traders do? Check target & stop loss Combination of strong brand & higher margins equals long-term investment: 5 stocks with an upside potential of up to 23% Two Trades for Today: A PSU energy major for 7.5% rise, a large-cap refinery stock for close to 6% upmove These mid-cap stocks with 'Strong Buy' & 'Buy' recos can rally over 25%, according to analysts
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Air India plane crash: At $120 million+, insurance claim to be costliest for Indian aviation
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel The catastrophic crash of an Air India flight in Ahmedabad on Thursday is likely to trigger the costliest aviation insurance claim involving an Indian airline, with claims estimated to exceed $120 million, people familiar with the matter the estimated payout, the hull loss—the insured value of the aircraft— alone could be around $80 million, while passenger liability compensation could add between $30-50 total liability payout could be significantly higher, with one estimate pegging potential passenger-related claims at over $100 million, given the presence of several high-networth individuals AIG was the lead insurer and others including New India Assurance had written part of the policy. The aircraft was covered under a global reinsurance programme, placed in the London market, whereby most of the risk is ceded to international insurers like Tata AIG, New India Assurance, National Insurance, United India, Oriental and ICICI Lombard General have retained less than 10% of the risk, market participants said. State-owned reinsurer GIC Re has 5% on the reinsurance treaty and will see a claim of about $4.1 million, they said.'Today's incident… is expected to trigger claims under both the hull and liability sections due to the total loss of the aircraft and the fatalities. Such losses generally affect multiple reinsurers, as airline fleet policies are often placed on a facultative basis involving several participants. Since liability claims take time to quantify, it is currently difficult to assess the impact on future pricing," said Ramaswamy Narayanan, CMD of GIC Re.'This would be one of the biggestever claims involving an Indian airline,' said Sourav Biswas, aviation business head at Alliance Insurance Indian carriers have witnessed few major accidents. In 2010, a Boeing 737 operating from Dubai crashed on landing at Mangalore, killing 158. Another crash at Kozhikode in 2020 claimed 21 these two incidents led to insurance payouts of about $60–70 million, including hull and liability, insurance industry insiders said. A Tata AIG spokesperson said as the lead insurer for Air India, the company is closely monitoring the situation. Air India's liability limit is up to $1.5 billion, an inurance executive aware of the subject said. There could be around $250,000 per passenger potential liability for bodily injury or bodily injury leading to death, added the person who did not want to be named. The crash is likely to harden reinsurance rates across the board. Aviation insurance is a global pool, and any large loss in one part of the world impacts pricing everywhere.'This will affect renewals next year,' a senior reinsurance executive said.'Aviation rates may go up globally, and more so in markets like India where loss ratios have otherwise been benign.' Tata Group-owned Air India's aviation insurance policy is typically renewed on April 1 each year, with a panel of insurers led by global brokers in New India Assurance had traditionally led the placement for the national carrier, Tata AIG is understood to have taken over that role since the airline's privatisation. New India and other Indian insurers now hold supporting roles, industry executives said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Indian inventors set patent records
Bengaluru: Anil Agiwal, an alumnus of IIT Kharagpur, rose as one of India's prominent inventors, filing an impressive 2,010 patents in the country. This milestone was highlighted through a GreyB research study, a consultancy known for its expertise in innovation intelligence, which ranked him among the Top 50 Indian inventors driving patent filings in India. Agiwal's work centres on breakthroughs in cellular communication, notably in 4G, 5G, and 5G Advanced radio access technologies. Agiwal, associated with Samsung Research America, is noted not only for his 2,010 Indian patents but also for holding 471 US patents. His journey began with a campus placement at Samsung R&D Institute Bangalore following his graduation from IIT Kharagpur in 2002. GreyB's assessment considered patents published between 2016 and 2023 within each inventor's portfolio. Kapil Bhattad, an IIT Madras graduate who now serves as senior director of engineering at Qualcomm in Bangalore, holds 1,647 patents. He completed a BTech in electrical engineering from IIT Madras in 2002 and went on to receive a PhD from Texas A&M University. Jaidev Rajnikant Shroff, Chairman and Group CEO of UPL, and Vikram Rajnikant Shroff, a director in the company, ranked third and fourth with 1,195 and 998 patents, respectively. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo Venkateswarlu Jasti, chairman and managing director of Suven Life Sciences, took the fifth ranking with 788 patents. The GreyB listing aims to spotlight the notable achievements of Indian inventors by analysing the Top 50 in the country. Ajit Manocha, president and CEO of SEMI, a microelectronics industry group, said: "Semiconductor companies honour and reward employees for their patents, recognising this as the lifeblood of innovation. Employee inventors are typically rewarded with a combination of financial incentives and recognition. These may include cash bonuses, plaques, and public acknowledgment, often tied to milestones in the patent process, like application filing or patent issuance. Early in my career at AT&T Bell Labs, my patents helped me advance my career. I put a premium on rewarding my employees for their patents at every stop in my career." According to Satya Gupta, president of the VLSI Society of India, an increase in the number of patents often leads to a drop in quality. "Out of 1,000 patents filed globally, only 10 may be impactful. This is the story not just with Indian companies but also multinationals. They want to accumulate patents," he said. Gupta also highlighted that patents are generally registered to company names, not individual employees, due to standard intellectual property clauses in employment agreements that assign ownership of such creations to the employer. GreyB's findings showed that inventors and researchers working at Qualcomm, Microsoft, Apple, Google, and several Asian firms including Samsung, Huawei, Oppo, and Xiaomi, made the largest number of patent submissions in India. This underscores India's growing importance as a market for global technology firms. In 2025, 3,520 patents were approved from 9,000 applications. Indian inventors received over 1 lakh patents in 2024. IESA president Ashok Chandak noted that both Indian and global technology companies have started viewing intellectual property as a vital strategic resource. They use it to stand apart in the market, accrue economic benefits, create enduring business models, attract investors, raise company evaluations, and strengthen their positions in international negotiations. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .
