Leinster House bike shed report says no value for money assessment carried out
A new external report has also found that it did not present the costs to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission before going ahead with the project, nor did the body responsible for running Leinster House ask about the cost.
The new bike shed, which provides parking for 36 bikes, caused consternation in September when it emerged that the structure had cost €345,000.
A report written in September 2024 by OPW Chair John Conlon stated that the cost was 'completely not acceptable' and 'not consistent with the scale of the project'.
He referred the case to Deloitte to conduct an external audit.
The report, published on Thursday stated that 'a value for money assessment was not conducted for the Bike Shelter project and currently is not standard practice for elective capital expenditure less than €500,000'.
It also stated that the OPW did not 'communicate an estimate of costs to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission prior to the approval to proceed being received'.
Deloitte stated: 'Our internal audit review has identified the absence of some fundamental good practices in how certain elective capital works (including the Bike Shelter) below the €500K threshold are being initiated, approved, managed and delivered.
'The most fundamental of these control gaps is the absence of a value for money assessment which would have allowed informed OPW personnel to evaluate the cost benefit of building a covered bicycle shelter in the requested location within the Leinster House campus.'
Deloitte stated that while it 'appreciated' that the OPW 'deals with some very large multi-million Euro capital projects' and that many of its processes are designed for larger projects, 'the importance of adhering to good practice for all capital expenditure (including elective capital works below €500K) cannot be overstated'.
The report stated that some 'expected practices' outlined in the Public Spending Code were followed by the OPW.
This included the 'performance of a simple assessment, development of a project specification and plan, preparation of project costing, and development of a project procurement strategy".
It added that 'the reasons for the costs associated with the Bike Shelter project should have been documented in a value for money assessment which should have been performed within the OPW as part of a robust options appraisal process'.
Deloitte stated that 'a formal and documented sense check on cost vs benefit together with lower cost alternatives, and the option of doing nothing, should then have been presented back to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission as part of a robust options appraisal'.
They said: 'Approval to proceed with the project should only have been formalised when these evaluations were complete.'
The report further found that the OPW did not inform the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission of the estimated project costs at any stage of the Bike Shelter project.
It added: 'The June 2021 decision to proceed with the Bike Shelter project was made without presentation or discussion of project costs – the HOC did not request cost information and the OPW did not present cost information.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Overpaying your mortgage and shorter terms are not always a good idea
If your dream of buying a first home has come true, being mortgage -free some day might be next on your wish list. Paying off the mortgage is one of the first things many people say they would do if they won the Lotto . If you don't have endless funds, however, protecting or growing the money you do have rather than paying down debt can be a wiser choice. Yes, there are a few ways to knock years off your mortgage and tens of thousands of euro off the interest bill – just consider your wider finances first. Don't dwell too much on paying off your mortgage early if you're a first-time buyer, says Lorraine Cooke of Jigsaw Financial Solutions . 'First-time buyers can be very anxious and focused on overpaying the mortgage to save interest, or to have a shorter mortgage – but I would say, don't get too caught up with the term,' says Cooke. READ MORE Those borrowing over a shorter term will be mortgage-free faster, and will pay less interest, but their monthly repayments are going to be higher. This can impinge on their choices right now. Going long, however – for 35 years, for example – doesn't mean you will be stuck with your mortgage for 35 years. The average mortgage in Ireland only lasts about five to eight years, says Cooke. Some people sell up, clearing that mortgage before taking out another. Others will switch their mortgage to another bank for a more competitive rate. You can always just shorten the term then, says Cooke. Going too short at the outset, however, can create cash-flow pain. Take, for example, someone who fixed their mortgage three years ago at 1.95 per cent who is now rolling off that rate on to a higher 4.5 or 4.7 variable rate, says Cooke. [ Why now is not the time to be complacent on mortgage arrears Opens in new window ] This jump in repayments will be even higher if they are on a shorter term, causing potential cash-flow problems, not least as first-time buyers are more likely to be those also facing steep costs with younger families. 'I would tell first-time buyers to consider the longest term available at the outset because you can always reduce the term at any point in time with no questions asked by the lender,' says Cooke. 'But if you want to increase the term, there will be questions.' Get the basics right Take care of some basic financial housekeeping first before considering whether to overpay your mortgage, advises Cooke. This means looking at your mortgage in the context of your overall finances, not as something that stands alone. Firstly, do you have a three- to six-month net salary emergency fund accessible for unforeseen events? This should be prioritised over increasing your mortgage repayments. If you lose your job, or are suddenly faced with big bills, having savings rather than having to resort to an expensive short-term loan to cope is going to be more cost effective. Income protection insurance should be another priority, says Cooke. A serious illness that prevents you from working can have a significant impact on your ability to keep a roof over heads and bills paid. There is tax relief on income protection premiums too, so if you are paying 40 per cent tax, relief is paid at this rate. Consider this as a priority before throwing spare cash at the mortgage. Make sure your mortgage protection insurance is up to scratch too. If you die, the right policy will pay off the mortgage, sparing loved ones. [ Move now or wait: First-time buyer and fixed mortgage rates Opens in new window ] Get mortgage protection insurance before switching too. You will be older than when you first borrowed and, if you have health issues, you may not get cover at all. Switchers should also ask their provider to reassign the existing policy to the new lender. Prioritise pension If you've got those basic financial building blocks in place and still have disposable income to spare, it can be wiser to max out your pension first before overpaying the mortgage, says Cooke. This gives you a shot at growing the money you have, rather than using it to pay down debt. The earlier you start putting money into your pension, the longer the runway there is for your money to grow. This is because of 'compounding' – if you put money in a fund last year and it made a 6 per cent return, this year you will earn interest on your original investment plus interest on the 6 per cent return you made last year. When left for long enough, an investment can grow exponentially. That's why prioritising pension when you are younger, above mortgage overpayments, can be a better idea. You can get a tax rebate on pension contributions too – you won't get that by putting the money towards the mortgage. If you are in your 30s and on the higher 40 per cent rate of income tax, for example, you will get 40 per of your permitted pension contribution back in a rebate. So, if you can put €1,000 a month into your pension, it will only cost you €600 – you will get €400 back. Why not put this free money towards a mortgage overpayment? 'Having a longer mortgage term can give you a bit more flexibility and breathing space in the short term to get your pension in place,' says Cooke. 'Consider taking a 35-year term, even for the first couple of years, [assuming you are young enough to qualify for it], and reduce it down then.' 'Make use of the tax efficiencies that are there,' she says. Instead of using after-tax income to pay down debt, use it to grow your wealth with a pension. Likewise, if you come into a redundancy payment, an inheritance or a bonus payment consider making a backdated pension contribution first, says Cooke. [ Live long and prosper: Five simple steps to maximise your pension Opens in new window ] Those nearing the finish line of their mortgage can be particularly keen to pay it down, says Cooke. 'They may have €80,000 outstanding on the mortgage and €20,000 in savings and be asking: 'Should I offset that against the mortgage and clear it quicker?',' says Cooke. Instead, ask yourself, do I have any other commitments or objectives for the money, such as kids going to college. Look at the bigger picture rather than being so focused on the mortgage, she advises. Always remember that, as much it might weigh on you, your mortgage is likely the cheapest debt you will ever incur. Overpaying If you've got the basics in order and have prioritised investing in your pension, then making additional mortgage repayments is a good idea. It can save you thousands and get you mortgage free faster. Mortgage overpayment is certainly a more attractive option than hoarding spare cash in a low-interest savings account. As a rule of thumb, if your mortgage rate is close to, or higher than, a savings rate, then it is a good idea to overpay rather than save. 'The interest savings from overpaying will most often outweigh the returns from a traditional savings account,' says Aisling McNamara or . 'Overpaying means you will pay less interest over the lifetime of the mortgage,' says McNamara. If you are on a variable interest rate, you can overpay by as much as you like, without penalties. For those on a fixed rate, the interest rate and repayments are fixed, though some lenders still allow you to overpay up to a limit. [ Mortgage or pension? Where to put your spare cash Opens in new window ] Fixed-rate customers with Avant Money, for example, can overpay 10 per cent of the balance each year, says McNamara. With Bank of Ireland, the maximum overpayment is 10 per cent of your normal monthly repayment amount, or €65, whichever is greater, she says. Take a mortgage loan of €330,000 over 30 years at an interest rate of 3.5 per cent with monthly repayments of €1,480. Overpaying by €100 a month will see you pay off the loan four years and six months earlier, knocking about €30,500 off the cost of your mortgage. Monthly overpayments can be stopped or started any time at your discretion too. Switch to save Don't make the mistake of overpaying your mortgage if you are on an unnecessarily high interest rate – that's money down the drain. Switching to the cheapest available interest rate is the best way to make progress on your mortgage; otherwise, you are paying needless extra money. There are legal and valuation costs involved in switching, but some lenders offer cashback to cover the cost. Even if they don't, a broker will tell you if switching will still be more cost effective over time. To really blow the socks off your mortgage, switch to that lower interest rate, but keep your monthly repayments the same. That way, you'll reduce the term and the interest you pay and feel no extra pain. If you do end up selling up in future, you'll have more equity in your home and you'll have paid much less interest too.
Irish Examiner
6 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Legacy of the Liberator: The 250th anniversary of Daniel O'Connell's birth celebrated
Daniel O'Connell believed in peaceful reform, democracy and civil rights. The 250th anniversary of the birth of one of our most important figures — in his lifetime viewed as "the uncrowned king of Ireland" — will be widely celebrated this year with a commemorative programme at home and abroad, which kicked off at Derrynane House on Wednesday (August 6). Taoiseach Micheál Martin will deliver the O'Connell lecture at Derrynane House as part of the Daniel O'Connell Summer School, which takes place in Caherciveen and Derrynane on August 29-30. The school will host a full programme of speakers with representatives from universities in the UK and the US. The Bar of Ireland is planning an autumn commemoration with the Department of the Taoiseach, and various events are in the pipeline through our network of embassies. These will begin with a ceremony at the Reform Club in London in September, hosted by the Irish Ambassador to honour its former member. The anniversary will be marked by receptions at embassies in Rome, Paris and the US. HISTORY HUB If you are interested in this article then no doubt you will enjoy exploring the various history collections and content in our history hub. Check it out HERE and happy reading Hardly a year goes by without some memorabilia relating to Daniel O'Connell, known as the Liberator — who delivered Catholic Emancipation in 1829 — surfacing at auction. Daniel O'Connell by PJ Haverty RHA (1794-1864), courtesy Derrynane House (OPW). Lots relating to him are usually sought after. There are plenty of portraits, including one of the most noted of all by Joseph Patrick Haverty from the OPW Collection, illustrated here. A leather gun case belonging to O'Connell (a pacifist) and stamped Derrynane House was sold by Marshs in Cork for €980 in December 2023. Daniel O'Connell's gold pocket watch made €26,000 at hammer at Fonsie Mealy. The previous year, his pocket watch made €26,000 at hammer over a top estimate of €6,000 at a sale by Fonsie Mealy. Whyte's sold a 19th-century coloured lithograph for €600 in 2024 over a top estimate of €150 His early experience of the French Revolution put O'Connell off mob violence for good, but inevitably, for a man of his time, he was involved in a couple of duels. Among the people he offended was Robert Peel, British prime minister, by continuously referring to him as "Orange Peel" while he served as chief secretary for Ireland. John Doyle's portrait of Daniel O'Connell. A half-length portrait of O'Connell holding a pistol by the Irish artist John Doyle (grandfather to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle) failed at Bonhams Irish sale in 2023. As in any auction, not everything sells. The Bank of Ireland is gifting a statue of O'Connell, currently in its College Green branch in Dublin, to Leinster House, where it will be unveiled later this year. An Post issued two stamps by artist David Rooney last week, and gold and silver-proof coins will be issued by the Central Bank. Local authorities and the Irish Georgian Society are among those marking the 250th anniversary, and RTÉ has created a new documentary.
Irish Independent
07-08-2025
- Irish Independent
Refurbishment works at Wicklow courthouse subject to national funding
The former courthouse has been closed due to health and safety concerns since September 2010. Since then, Bray has served as the main court venue for County Wicklow. The Office of Public Works (OPW) has provided the Courts Service with costings and options for the full restoration of Wicklow Courthouse, ranging in price from around €13 million to €17 million. The Courts Service has also advised Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan that Wicklow Courthouse was included in its submission for the NDP. This means that further progress in relation to the building and timeline for its complete refurbishment will depend on funding allocated under the revised plan. Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers completed a review of the plan in July 2025, however there was little detail on what specific projects will receive funding. In the meantime, the OPW has recently undertaken some works to preserve the roof of the building to address the dry rot which has spread to the adjoining buildings. The Courts Service has further advised that, while open to making the courthouse available for community usage, it is not currently able to do so for health and safety reasons. Despite that, officials from the Court Service have liaised with Wicklow County Council and made the adjoining former Library building available to the council, which has been used as a Ukrainian hub since 2022. In addition, the Courts Service are open to engaging with all interested parties on how the building can be used in the future.
