29 palm trees axed in New Panvel 5 months ago, but work yet to begin, says activist
Panvel civic body felled 29 mature palm trees five months ago for a road widening and drainage repair project, but the work is yet to commence
NAVI MUMBAI: Five months ago, 29 mature palm trees, two decades old, were felled in New Panvel (E) by the
Panvel civic body
. The reason given was the necessity for a civic project involving road widening and drainage repair, as the trees were planted on the pavement covering the drainage channel. However, the civic body has not yet commenced the work.
A local tree activist wrote to the civic chief on April 15, alleging that the project was merely an excuse to remove the palm trees to meet the demands of some societies in the area.
These societies allegedly influenced the Tree Authority to grant the necessary permission with the support of an ex-corporator. When the trees were axed in December last year, the tree activist complained to the Panvel civic body's Tree Authority, claiming it was an unjust action that destroyed the area's greenery.
The complainant, tree activist Parshuram Vogety, stated, "I submitted the written complaint to the Panvel civic chief on April 15 after I saw that the civic project of road widening and drainage repair, for which 29 palm trees were axed five months ago, had not started. But the concerned Tree Authority has not responded to the complaint even after a fortnight."
He added, "The hacked Palm trees grew majestically to 14 metres in height over the last 25 years. There was not even a centimetre of space left for road widening. Also, when trees are planted on the footpath covering the drainage channel, there is always a possibility that when the trees grow, they will damage the drainage channel as the tree roots penetrate the ground. The Panvel civic body has planted trees on the pavements in Khanda Colony and New Panvel (E). What is the point in planting trees if they are not allowed to grow freely or are hacked for selfish reasons? Trees are hacked before and during the monsoon by societies and municipal corporation employees, by MSEDCL officials, during festive occasions such as the Ganpati festival by pandal owners, by shopkeepers who see them as a hindrance to their signboards, by builders, etc. The stretch of road on which the Palm trees exist is frequented by scooters and cars only, and has very little traffic. I have never seen flooding on this road during the monsoon. Instead of concentrating on cleanliness and other high-priority works, PMC is the first in hacking and trimming trees."
Panvel civic body's assistant municipal commissioner (Tree Authority) Swarup Kharge said, "The road widening and drainage repairing work was proposed by Panvel civic body's engineering department. The proposal mentioned the necessity to cut down 29 Palm trees creating obstacles for the project. Hence, in May, a notice was published in local Marathi newspapers for objections or suggestions, if any, within one week. As there was no response, the trees were felled. However, the felled trees will be compensated by planting the same number of trees in the vicinity for which the engineering department has demarcated an area."
An official from Panvel civic body's engineering department informed that, on March 26, the tender estimated at Rs 98.91 lakhs was invited for the drainage repairing (RCC slab) work in sector 4, New Panvel from Madhumati CHS till Krishna Arcade CHS.
As the drainage RCC slab will occupy less area, the road will get widened. After the technical and financial bidding is finalised, the drainage RCC slab work order will be issued to the contractor who bags the tender.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
7 hours ago
- Indian Express
Vidarbha's ‘Zudpi' scrub lands are ‘forest' lands: how SC ruling has struck a balance between development and environment concerns
After several decades of litigation over about 86,000 hectares of Zudpi jungle (shrub forest) lands peculiar to Maharashtra's eastern Vidarbha region, the Supreme Court last month ruled that such lands should be considered as 'forest' lands. On May 22, the top court provided clarity on the usage of Zudpi lands, saying they cannot be converted without prior approval from the central government, and only after complying with the conditions laid down by the court. An official report referred to by the court says Zudpi is a Marathi word that literally translates to bushes or shrubs, and Zudpi land means an inferior type of unoccupied land with bushy growth. The term was used for all wastelands that were not occupied by individual farmers for cultivation and other purposes. According to the report, Zudpi jungle lands are peculiar to six districts of eastern Vidarbha (Nagpur division) – Nagpur, Chandrapur, Gadchiroli, Bhandara, Wardha, and Gondia – and have been used for non-forest purposes for the past several decades. These lands, traditionally used for grazing, were classified as Gairan under the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966. For decades, legal status uncertain Vidarbha's Zudpi lands remained in a legal limbo for decades due to administrative lapses, inconsistent government actions, and contrasting interpretations of India's forest laws. Initially vested with the Revenue Department, these lands were used for development, public amenities like schools, health centres, water pipelines, burial grounds, and for allotment to landless farmers. They were also used for infrastructure projects, including railways, defence, and irrigation. After the reorganisation of states in 1960, similar lands elsewhere in Maharashtra were recorded as Gairan or Gurcharan. However, in Vidarbha, they continued to be classified as 'Zudpi Jungle' due to bureaucratic inaction. The Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (FCA) prohibited diversion of forest land without the Centre's approval. However, in November 1987, the Maharashtra government issued an order declaring Zudpi lands as 'scrub forests' that would not attract the provisions of FCA, and handed them to the Revenue Department for afforestation and grazing purposes. This 1987 Government Order was challenged by the Bombay Environmental Action Group (BEAG) before the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court. While this plea was pending, the Centre in February 1992 changed and relaxed its earlier position. It clarified that Zudpi Jungle would continue to be treated as 'forest lands' under the FCA; however, for the part of Zudpi lands that were used for non-forest purposes, the state government shall make a proposal to the Centre seeking its approval under the FCA. Taking a cue from the Centre's decision, the Maharashtra government in 1994 withdrew its 1987 order. With these changing positions, ambiguity prevailed until the Supreme Court's December 12, 1996 judgment in the 'TN Godavarman Thirumulpad' case, which stated that Zudpi lands would also be treated as 'forest lands' under the FCA. In 1998, a High-Powered Committee appointed by the state government recommended that 92,115 hectares should be declared protected forests and 86,409 hectares that were unfit for forest use should be de-notified. Eight years ago, the state government again pushed to denotify Zudpi jungle lands. In 2019, the Maharashtra government, through the Divisional Commissioner, Nagpur, filed an interim application and sought the SC's approval to exclude the latter category of land from the purview of FCA. The SC formed a Central Empowered Committee (CEC), which filed its first report after site visits. Since some issues were yet to be resolved, the SC last year sought another report from the CEC. This report formed the basis of the SC's May 22, 2025 verdict. GOVERNMENT: The Maharashtra government argued that Zudpi lands were never forest lands, and due to the reorganisation of states and the inaction of certain officials, the revenue records were never corrected. As such, these lands continued to be erroneously described as Zudpi lands in revenue records. The state argued that denying it relief would lead to 'grave and irreparable damage' to lakhs of citizens, and would stall several projects. INTERVENER: Environmentalist Prasad Khale, intervener in the case, however, argued that de-notifying these lands would degrade healthy forests and disrupt wildlife corridors. He submitted that the 2025 CEC report had ignored ecological concerns, including those of wildlife corridors and the protection of scrub forests, which should not be used for non-forest activities. SC directives strike a balance The Bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Bhushan R Gavai and Justice Augustine Masih said that it could arrive at a solution to 'balance the rights of the citizens at large on one hand and the interest of the environment on the other hand' due to the efforts made by the CEC. The SC recognised that a large number of Zudpi lands in Nagpur city alone had public utilities such as the High Court building, defence buildings, state secretariat, graveyards, etc. It said citizens residing on these lands for years, or farmers could not be deprived of their residence or livelihood. Therefore, the Supreme Court held that Zudpi jungle lands would be treated as forests, but made exceptions for lands allotted for non-forest use before December 12, 1996. For such lands, where classification (purpose) hadn't changed, the state would be required to obtain the Centre's approval under Section 2 of the FCA for their deletion from the list of forest areas. The court said the Centre shall consider proposals without imposing compensatory afforestation conditions, and should not seek deposition of Net Present Value (NPV) levies. The court directed the Centre and the state to consult and finalise a proposal format within three months with prior approval of the CEC. For post-December 12, 1996 allotments of Zudpi lands, the Centre shall process proposals only after ascertaining reasons and ensuring action against the officers who took allotment decisions in violation of the SC's directions. Special Task Forces in each district will remove encroachments made after October 25, 1980, within two years. All commercial allotments post-October 25, 1989, are to be treated as encroachments. The court clarified no land may be diverted to non-government entities after scrutiny. The Revenue Department must transfer remaining Zudpi lands to the Forest Department within a year, which are to be used for compensatory afforestation. Other Zudpi lands will not be allowed for compensatory afforestation unless certified by the Chief Secretary. Benefitting the state's development plans The verdict has in some ways paved the way for infrastructure and other development works that the state government plans to undertake on certain tracts of lands, after obtaining approval from the central government. Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis welcomed the ruling, calling it a boost to Vidarbha's stalled development. The CEC will monitor the transfer of forest land, as directed by the SC. States and Union Territories have been directed to reclaim possession of such lands from occupiers and hand them over to the Forest Department. The SC had said that if reclaiming possession is not in the public interest, the state/UTs shall recover land costs from occupiers and use them to develop forests.
Hindustan Times
2 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Will develop riverfront project to be best in country: Pune civic chief
Pune municipal commissioner Naval Kishore Ram on Thursday directed officials to develop the city's riverfront project into an iconic, world-class initiative, aiming to make it the best in the country. The civic chief visited the ongoing project near Bund Garden on the occasion of World Environment Day and participated in a tree plantation drive. 'I have seen riverfronts in several foreign countries, and we are working in the same direction. With greater effort, our project has the potential to surpass even the Sabarmati riverfront in Ahmedabad,' he said. Yuvraj Deshmukh, incharge, riverfront project said that construction is underway along a 9-km stretch — from Sangamwadi to Bund Garden (3.7km) and Bund Garden to Mundhwa Bridge (5.3km). 'Sections from Sadalbaba to Ganesh Ghat (300 metres) and at Koregaon Park (800 metres) have been completed. We are also replacing invasive tree species with native ones along the riverbank,' he said. Additional municipal commissioner Prithviraj BP aid, 'To mark World Environment Day, PMC planted 1,250 trees, each between 10 and 15 feet tall. Of these, 850 were planted on forest land, 150 at Yerawada Jail, and 250 along the riverfront project.'
Hindustan Times
2 days ago
- Hindustan Times
PMC launches tree clinic van to promote urban green health
To mark the World Environment Day, the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) on Thursday launched the tree clinic van that will inspect and ensure health of trees besides promoting environmental awareness among citizens, said officials. Pune municipal commissioner Naval Kishore Ram inaugurated the facility in the presence of additional municipal commissioner Prithviraj BP and other officials. Officials and staff from the tree authority department demonstrated the van's operations during the launch. 'The tree clinic van will cover injured trees by removing nails, metal wires, or damaged cages. Besides, following expert advice from botanists and tree experts, it will raise public awareness about tree plantation, protection, and care,' said Ashok Ghorpade, garden superintendent, PMC. The initiative also supports PMC's ongoing campaign 'Plant Trees, Save Trees' focussing on the importance of green cover in urban areas. PMC has urged citizens to report any injured or neglected trees to 9146383383, toll-free 18001030222, WhatsApp 9689900002, Chatbot: 8888251001 and As per officials, PMC also launched a new IEC (information, education, communication) van to spread messages about tree conservation and urban environmental responsibility. The civic body, along with private organisations and NGOs, planted 3,879 saplings across various departments. PMC is offering local saplings at ₹5 each to citizens and voluntary organisations from June 5 to August 14 under the tree plantation drive. Saplings can be collected from the Chhatrapati Sambhaji Garden Nursery, near Balgandharva Rangmandir, Jungli Maharaj Road; between 8am and 4pm (excluding Sundays and public holidays). Citizens can contact 9689930024 and 9689938523 for more details regarding the green drive.
