Oneida Co. Sheriff faces arson charges after Kellogg Ave. fire
UTICA, NY (WUTR/WFXV/WPNY) — An Oneida County Sheriff's Deputy is facing arson charges after allegedly setting a fire at a home while on duty in West Utica.
The Utica Fire Department was called to the Kellogg Avenue fire at approximately 4:30 am on Wednesday, April 9. Upon their arrival, smoke was visible from the two-story home. According to firefighters, the owner was able to knock down some of the fire with two extinguishers available to them before their arrival.
An initial investigation found that the fire started at the rear of the building and was confined to the rear of the building. The fire required an extensive overhaul in the rear of the building to extinguish hot spots throughout the building.
Utica firefighters reported no injuries at the scene.
The Daily Sentinel reported that the fire was ruled an arson by Utica Police later Wednesday morning. Police also named Oneida County Sheriff's Deputy Aaron Alshaman as a potential suspect.
The Sentinel also reported that on Friday, April 11, the Oneida County Sheriff's Office filed an application for a Temporary Extreme Risk Protection Order against Alshaman. The order sought to relieve him of any firearms he owned because he allegedly posed a risk to himself or others.
The application also stated that during the fire on April 9, Alshaman was on duty as a sheriff's deputy and that an Automated Vehicle Location system showed that he was near the scene of the fire. According to the application, Alshaman was also in an 'intimate relationship' with one of the residents at the time of the fire.
'After an investigation into the cause of the fire, it was determined that it was arson At this time, the respondent is believed to be the person that started the fire based on strong physical evidence…
This behavior is uncharacteristic for the respondent and calls into question his mental state. It is believed that the respondent, due to his uncertain mental health, should not be allowed to possess or purchase any firearms at this time.'
— Quoted from the Oneida County Sheriff's Office's application for a Temporary Extreme Risk Protection Order against Deputy Aaron Alshaman.
The protection order has since been granted, and Alshaman has been placed on leave by the Oneida County Sheriff's Office. A hearing is scheduled for Wednesday, April 16.
The fire — and the alleged arson — remain under investigation.
This is an ongoing investigation. We will provide more information as it becomes available to us.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
29-05-2025
- Yahoo
Emaciated Dog 'Days From Death' Found Left in New York Apartment to Starve
On May 16, authorities in Clark Mills, N.Y., rescued a starving pit bull mix they found abandoned in an empty residence Rescuers took Rhett the dog to a veterinary hospital, where he received a blood transfusion and treatment for anemia The Oneida County Sheriff's Office has charged an individual with aggravated cruelty to animals in connection with Rhett's caseRhett, the pit bull mix, is fighting for another chance at May 16, the Kirkland Police Department and local animal control from Clark Mills, N.Y., discovered Rhett starving and emaciated alone in an apartment, seemingly abandoned to die. "Rhett was extremely emaciated, weak, and unable to get up on his own; therefore, he was transported to a local vet," the Oneida County Sheriff's Office, which took over the investigation into Rhett's case from the Kirkland Police Department, shared in a Facebook post. According to WKTV, Clinton Pet Vet provided life-saving care to Rhett after authorities pulled the dog from the abandoned apartment. To survive the neglect he has endured, Rhett, who also spent time at Upstate Veterinary Specialties, has received an emergency blood transfusion and treatment for starvation, anemia, and fleas so far. Rhett's rescuers said that the dog was likely "days from death" without any intervention, so the canine is not out of the woods yet. Kindred Spirits Greyhound Adoption Inc. is overseeing Rhett's continued recovery and started a GoFundMe page to cover the dog's mounting medical expenses. "His owners had moved and left him locked in their apartment to fend for himself. No one knows how long he'd been there, but we were told he was probably days from death. Anger and sadness permeated our practice. To see pictures of him is startling, but to see him in real life is absolutely shocking," the fundraiser page shared about Rhett's condition. The page added that after a few touch-and-go moments, Rhett moved out of the veterinary hospital and into a foster home, where he "continues to slowly improve." As of May 29, the GoFundMe has reached its $6,000 goal. In an update, Kindred Spirits thanked everyone for their donations. The rescue shared that Rhett "continues to move in the right direction" and is currently on a prescription diet and physical therapy plan to help him regain weight, strength, and mobility. Rhett has also found justice on his road to recovery. On May 28, the Onedia County Sheriff's Office announced that it "determined Lindsay Meelan (36) of Clark Mills was responsible for Rhett's condition." In response, investigators took Meelan into custody. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. "Meelan was charged with Aggravated Cruelty to Animals, a felony, Torture/Injure/Not Feed Animals, a misdemeanor, and a Violation of Dog Control Procedures, a violation. Meelan was released with appearance tickets and is due back in Kirkland Town Court on June 17th, 2025, at 5:30 PM," the sheriff's office added. Read the original article on People
Yahoo
27-05-2025
- Yahoo
Monday night Whitesboro Street fire under investigation
UTICA, NY (WUTR/WFXV/WPNY) — A late-night Memorial Day fire is under investigation by Utica Fire Marshals on Whitesboro Street. Firefighters were called to 1134 Whitesboro Street at approximately 8:15 pm on Monday, May 26. Upon their arrival, firefighters were met with fire coming from the side of the residence and extending toward the second floor. An enclosed front porch was involved in the flames with the fire extending to partitions on the second floor. Firefighters were able to quickly knock down most of the fire with water. The Utica Fire Department says that an extensive overhaul was needed to extinguish hot spots, which extended into the roof and ceiling of the residence. Firefighters were able to get the fire under control in approximately one hour. No one was injured in the fire, but it is unknown how many people occupied the residence. The Utica Fire Department was assisted at the scene by the Utica Police Department and National Grid. The cause of the fire remains under investigation by the Utica Fire Marshal's Office. This is an ongoing investigation. We will provide more information as it becomes available to us. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
23-05-2025
- Yahoo
Gerling murder case begins with pretrial motions
UTICA, NY (WUTR/WFXV/WPNY) — The trial of the man accused of murdering a Utica City School District principal last summer began in earnest on Friday with pretrial hearings. Lawyers for Jeremy Kirch and District Attorney Todd Carville stood before Judge Robert Bauer on Friday, May 23 to be heard on several motions. While Judge Bauer did deny the suppression of several pieces of evidence, several hearings were granted to determine the validity of certain pieces of evidence. Kirch was arrested in August of 2024 and was charged with second-degree murder in the death of his girlfriend — Elizabeth Gerling, a former principal at Columbus Elementary in Utica. Kirch was found in the city of Rome soon after her death and subsequently arrested. Scholarship fund established for former Utica teacher Bauer granted a motion for a Sandoval-Ventimiglia hearing, which will determine if behavioral evidence can be used in the trial. A mental evaluation — to determine Kirch's fitness to stand trial — was conducted, but Carville said that evaluation is under review. Bauer denied a motion to suppress statements Kirch made to law enforcement. Bauer did grant a Huntley Hearing to determine if the statements being used by the prosecution were voluntary or not. Bauer also denied motions to suppress other evidence, including identifying testimony and physical evidence. However, hearings have been granted to determine the admissibility of both the testimony and evidence. A Mapp-Dunaway Hearing was granted to assess the circumstances of Kirch's arrest. It will also be used to assess the seizure of Kirch's trailer and truck, which were impounded for the reasons of executing the search warrant. Bauer granted the other following motions: To have the court review search warrants for Kirch's truck, trailer home and phone, as well as the defendant's blood, and A review of the grand jury minutes to assess the sufficiency of the legal instructions given. Bauer denied the following motions: Search warrants to Blink and Ring cameras at Gerling's home A change of venue, citing that the defense had not proven a reasonable cause of unfair or impartial ruling. However, Bauer said, if circumstances change, that ruling can be reconsidered. Directing the prosecution to supply defense with an electronic copy of all of their evidence. The case is scheduled to reconvene on Thursday, July 17 at 10:30 AM for suppression hearings. Also up for discussion during the suppression hearings will be a claim by the defense that Kirch did not know his calls from the jail were being recorded. After the suppression hearings, both sides will discuss going to trial. You can look at the full hearing from Eyewitness News Reporter Kayla Bruce below: Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
