Pope Francis' legacy in the US: A more open, and then divided, church

Boston Globe

22-04-2025

Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
He pushed church leaders to be pastors, not doctrinaires, and elevated bishops in his own mold, hoping to create lasting tonal change in the church through its leadership. He gave voice to the growing share of Hispanic Catholics, as the US church grew less white, and appointed the first Black cardinal. He allowed priests to bless same-sex couples and made it easier for divorced and remarried Catholics to participate in church life.
Advertisement
In doing so, he captured the imaginations of millions both inside and outside the US church who had long felt rejected. At a time of increasing secularization, the world's most visible Christian leader gave hope to many US non-Catholics who saw in him a moral visionary while much of public Christianity in America took a rightward turn.
Advertisement
'He made the church a more welcoming place,' said Joe Donnelly, former Democratic senator from Indiana, who was the US ambassador to the Holy See under President Biden. 'For Americans of all different economic strata, for divorced Americans, for basically everyone in our country, his arms were always open.'
Yet it was this same transformative vision that ultimately fueled the rise of an energized conservative Catholic resistance, which further divided the church in America. Francis' cardinals had a minority voice among US bishops, and in the final years of his papacy, powerful conservative lay Catholics once again made ending abortion their dominant priority. Conservative Catholic backlash to values like Francis' helped return Donald Trump to the White House, with Vice President JD Vance, a Catholic convert, by his side, advancing priorities that conflicted with the pope's.
Midway through his papacy, parishes were roiled by revelations that church leaders in the United States covered up sexual abuse for decades, reminding many of their distrust of the church at every level. The pope's regained popularity diminished, as US bishops faced a host of federal and state investigations. Many Catholics grew weary waiting for the Vatican to solve the continuing crisis, with more than one-third considering leaving the faith, according to a Gallup poll.
Francis offered some reforms, and in a high profile case expelled Theodore McCarrick, a former cardinal, from the priesthood after the church found him guilty of sexually abusing minors and adult seminarians over decades. It appeared to be the first time a cardinal was defrocked for sexual abuse. But for many people, these actions were not enough.
Advertisement
With his death Monday, Pope Francis leaves behind an American church that is pulled in opposite directions, on social issues, politics, and tone, mirroring the polarized country it inhabits.
Still, in the end, the sense of Francis' pastoral legacy remains palpable in many American pews.
'How he speaks about contemporary issues, I think it has allowed a lot of people in our community to feel seen and heard,' said the Rev. Matthew O'Donnell, 38, pastor of St. Moses the Black Parish, on the South Side of Chicago. 'No doubt the church has changed. Speaking as a priest, I think that what he has called the church to be is pastoral.'
The United States itself was not Francis' main priority. He visited the country only once, in 2015, and he intentionally arrived from Cuba, one more way to show his global priorities. The United States has the fourth-largest Catholic population in the world, behind Brazil, Mexico, and the Philippines. But it is a small fraction of the church's more than 1 billion Catholics, many of whom live in the peripheries he sought to elevate.
But Francis also knew the power of the US church on the global stage, and used and challenged it as he saw fit. Though the church is a religious institution, guiding 52 million US Catholics, it is also a political body, and his tenure intersected with changes in US politics.
He oversaw the church during a transformational decade of US leadership. At the start, he aligned himself with former president Barack Obama's foreign policy, showing that Rome and Washington could work together on progressive issues, not simply conservative ones. His Vatican helped secretly broker the United States' detente with Cuba. He also supported the Iran nuclear deal and Palestinian statehood. For many it felt as though the overlapping Obama and Francis eras signaled a progressive trajectory on the world stage.
Advertisement
Francis became the first and only pope to address Congress, where he pleaded for unity to solve global crises, and received standing ovations. He challenged both political parties — Democrats to support religious liberties and the value of human life, and Republicans to embrace immigrants and the need for environmental protections. He left the chamber to serve lunch at a soup kitchen.
His visit showed his immense popularity, as Catholics and non-Catholics alike filled streets in Washington, New York and, finally, Philadelphia, where the 10,000 tickets for his Mass were snapped up in 30 seconds.
Beginning when Trump ran for president in 2016, Francis challenged his actions and rhetoric toward migrants, questioning his purported Christian values.
'A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian,' Francis said, hours after he celebrated a 200,000-person Mass in Mexico along the US border at the time. By the Rio Grande, he laid flowers to remember those who died trying to cross, as US security officials watched from the other side.
'He used his gravitas in the beginning formidably,' said Ken Hackett, who was US ambassador to the Holy See under Obama. 'Really in those early years, he made a difference.'
At the same time, Hackett said, 'in a way, he's aggravated some of the ideological tensions in the United States.'
Advertisement
A stark partisan divide emerged among American Catholics over the course of Francis' papacy. At the start, Catholic Republicans and Democrats both held him in high regard, according to the Pew Research Center. But by 2024, about 90 percent of Catholic Democrats viewed him positively, compared with just 63 percent of Catholic Republicans.
Conservative frustration was part political, part religious. Often it was born of what conservatives perceived as the pope's fixation on US policies he did not like, like Trump's mass deportation plans, instead of other issues like human rights abuses in China.
When Biden, who regularly attends Mass and has spent a lifetime steeped in Catholic practice, was elected, US bishops advanced a conservative push to deny Biden communion because of his support of abortion rights — even after the Vatican told them not to.
'The pope never really took him to task for that,' said Jim Nicholson, who was US ambassador to the Holy See during Bush's first term. Supporting abortion, he said, 'is antithetical to principled teaching of the church.'
This article originally appeared in
.