Opposing Israel is not anti-Semitic
Doukas swiftly responded on X, stating, 'We have proven our strong opposition to violence and racism, and we do not take lessons in democracy from those who kill civilians.' Frustrated by the narrative equating criticism of Israel with hatred of Jews, he added, 'it is revolting that the ambassador concentrates on graffiti (that is clearly wiped off) while an unprecedented genocide is taking place in Gaza.'
Doukas' remarks shed light on a broader frustration with efforts to divert attention away from Israel's actions in Gaza. Since Israel launched its offensive on October 7, 2023, over 60,800 people, many of them children, have been killed, and at least 149,880 others wounded.
The death toll continues to rise daily as Gaza faces forced starvation and widespread destruction. Despite this, many Western governments continue to label any criticism of Israel's actions in Gaza — including its ethnic cleansing of the enclave and the violence in the occupied West Bank — as anti-Semitic. This labelling serves to shut down meaningful discussion about the ongoing crisis.
The tactic manifests in various ways, from the discrediting of activists and human rights organisations that speak out against Israel's military actions, to laws passed in countries like the US and the UK that equate any denunciation of Israel with anti-Semitism. Such attempts to blur the lines between legitimate political critique and anti-Semitism risk trivializing genuine instances of hatred and bigotry against Jewish people. While it is crucial to combat all forms of racism and hate speech, it is equally important to distinguish between legitimate criticism of a government and expressions of bigotry.
The exchange between Mayor Doukas and Ambassador Katz also highlights a growing divide within Western nations. More and more citizens are increasingly unwilling to offer blind support for Israel, particularly in light of the ongoing campaign in Gaza to annihilate Palestinians for the furtherance of expansionist ambitions of a 'Greater Israel.' By challenging the ambassador's focus on graffiti and calling out Israel's actions in Gaza as 'an unprecedented genocide', Doukas has aligned himself with a broader movement that refuses to let the defence against anti-Semitism obscure genuine human rights concerns.
His remarks underscore an important point: while combating anti-Semitism needs to be confronted, it should not come at the expense of the right to criticise Israel. People should be free to voice concerns about Israeli policies without fear of being labelled as Jew-haters. Free expression is a cornerstone of democratic society, and it must remain a protected space for serious, open discussions, especially when it concerns the lives of Palestinians who are fighting for their right to live in their ancestral lands, free from occupation and violence by a colonial settler state.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Hezbollah vows to fight disarmament as Lebanon PM slams civil war ‘threats'
BEIRUT: Hezbollah leader Naim Qassem vowed Friday to fight government plans to disarm his group, with Lebanese Prime Minister Nawaf Salam accusing him of making 'unacceptable' threats to unleash civil war. Qassem gave a televised address after meeting with Iran's security chief Ali Larijani, whose country has long backed the Lebanese group. Hezbollah emerged badly weakened from last year's war with Israel, and the Lebanese government – under US pressure – has ordered the army to draw up a plan to disarm the group by the end of the year. Iran, whose so-called 'axis of resistance' includes Hezbollah, has also suffered a series of setbacks, most recently in its own war with Israel, which also saw the United States strike its nuclear facilities. 'The government is implementing an American-Israeli order to end the resistance, even if it leads to civil war and internal strife,' Qassem said. 'The resistance will not surrender its weapons while aggression continues, occupation persists, and we will fight it… if necessary to confront this American-Israeli project no matter the cost.' He urged the government 'not to hand over the country to an insatiable Israeli aggressor or an American tyrant with limitless greed', adding the state would 'bear responsibility for any internal explosion and any destruction of Lebanon'. President says Lebanon determined to disarm Hezbollah Prime Minister Salam later denounced the remarks, saying on X that they 'constitute an implicit threat of civil war'. He added that 'any threat or intimidation related to such a war is totally unacceptable'. Salam also hit back at Hezbollah's characterisation of the disarmament push as an American-Israeli effort. 'Our decisions are purely Lebanese, made by our cabinet, and no one tells us what to do,' he said. 'The Lebanese have the right to stability and security… without which the country will not be able to recover, and no reconstruction or investment will take place.' Before the war with Israel, Hezbollah was believed to be better armed than the Lebanese military. It long maintained it had to keep its arsenal in order to defend Lebanon from attack, but critics accused it of using its weapons for political leverage. Qassem said Friday that Hezbollah and its political ally Amal would not be organising any street protests against disarmament at this time, but threatened to do so in future. Iran's Supreme National Security Council chief Larijani was in Beirut this week, and held talks with Qassem as well as with President Joseph Aoun. Iran has expressed its opposition to the government's disarmament plan, and has vowed to continue to provide support, with Lebanese officials recently hardening their tone towards Hezbollah and its patron. Both the president and the prime minister took issue with Iran's recent statements during Larijani's trip, with Salam saying Lebanon rejects 'any interference in its internal affairs'.
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
UN says at least 1,760 killed while seeking aid in Gaza since late May
JERUSALEM: The UN human rights office said Friday that at least 1,760 Palestinians had been killed while seeking aid in Gaza since late May, a jump of several hundred since its last published figure at the beginning of August. 'Since 27 May, and as of 13 August, we have recorded that at least 1,760 Palestinians have been killed while seeking aid; 994 in the vicinity of GHF (Gaza Humanitarian Foundation) sites and 766 along the routes of supply convoys. Most of these killings were committed by the Israeli military,' the agency's office for the Palestinian territories said in a statement. That compares with a figure of 1,373 killed the office reported on August 1. The update came as Gaza's civil defence agency said at least 31 people were killed by Israeli fire on Friday, including 12 who were waiting for humanitarian aid. The Israeli military said its troops were working to 'dismantle Hamas military capabilities', adding its forces were taking precautions 'to mitigate civilian harm'. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties accessing swathes of the territory mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defence agency and the Israeli military. Israel's Gaza plan risks 'another calamity': UN On Wednesday, the chief of staff of the Israeli military said plans had been approved for a new offensive in Gaza, aimed at defeating Hamas and freeing all the remaining hostages. The military intends to take control of Gaza City and nearby refugee camps, some of the most densely populated parts of the territory, which has been devastated by more than 22 months of war. In recent days, Gaza City residents have told AFP of more frequent air strikes targeting residential areas, while earlier this week Hamas denounced 'aggressive' Israeli ground incursions in the area. The Israeli government's plans to expand the war have sparked an international outcry as well as domestic opposition. UN-backed experts have warned of widespread famine unfolding in the territory, where Israel has drastically curtailed the amount of humanitarian aid it allows in. Hamas's October 2023 attack which triggered the war resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Israel's offensive has killed at least 61,827 Palestinians, according to figures from the health ministry in Hamas-run Gaza which the United Nations considers reliable.
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan rejects statements regarding creation of ‘Greater Israel'
Pakistan condemned on Friday recent statements made by Israeli government for a 'Greater Israel' and called on the international community to reject such 'provocative notions'. 'Pakistan strongly condemns and rejects recent statements made by the Israeli Occupying power, alluding to the creation of so-called Greater Israel, and its designs aimed at the forcible displacement of Palestinians from Gaza,' the Foreign Office (FO) said in a statement. Islamabad called on the international community to outrightly reject such provocative notions that constitute a 'flagrant violation of the international law', principles of the UN Charter, as well as the relevant United Nations resolutions. Israel steps up Gaza City bombing after Netanyahu vow to expand offensive 'Such statements reflect the occupying power's intention to entrench its illegal occupation, as well as its complete contempt for all international efforts aimed at achieving lasting peace and stability in the region. The international community must take immediate and tangible measures to prevent the occupying power from further destabilising the region, and to end its ongoing crimes and atrocities against the Palestinians.' Pakistan reaffirmed its full support for the Palestinian people's legitimate rights, including the right to self-determination and the establishment of an independent, viable, and contiguous State of Palestine, based on pre-1967 borders, with Al-Quds Al-Sharif as its capital. More than 61,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israel's aggression since October 2023, according to Gaza health officials. Most of Gaza's population has been displaced multiple times and its residents are facing a humanitarian crisis, with swaths of the territory reduced to rubble.
