Mike Dailly: Prisoners in Scotland need hope not needles
Worryingly, the committee has heard that around 17 per cent of prisoners who weren't drug users before incarceration become substance users once in jail.
Drugs enter prisons through various ways, including the use of drones to fly them onto the prison estate. Synthetic cannabinoids are prevalent along with bromazolam, benzodiazepines, cocaine and steroids.
Drugs come in a range of formats, including paper, card, powder or a waxy substance.
Kirsten Horsburgh, chief executive officer at the Scottish Drugs Forum (SDF) gave evidence to the committee on May 28.
The SDF is a Scottish charity whose vision is for 'A Scotland free from drug-related health and social harm'. Its funding comes ostensibly from the Scottish Government and other statutory bodies.
At the committee's May meeting, Ms Horsburgh said: 'We need to have the uncomfortable discussion about what harm reduction in prison means. Does it mean providing safer injecting equipment or safer smoking equipment? Does it mean having discussions with people about how they can use their drugs more safely?'
The proposal made a stir. Are we now suggesting supplying free needles to prisoners to inject themselves with drugs? Giving out free vapes so people can smoke cannabis in jail?
Annmarie Ward, chief executive officer of Faces and Voice for Recovery UK (FAVOR) believes the SDF's position is nonsensical.
She said: 'Apparently, the answer to Scotland's prison drug crisis isn't less drugs in prisons, but more syringes to help the problem go smoothly. It's like solving knife crime by handing out free whetstones'.
Annmarie notes that the Scottish Prison Service say violence in prisons is rising. Drugs are being flown in on drones. Inmates are vaping benzos and mixing synthetic opioids into their tea. She ridicules the SDF's answer to this problem by making drug use easier for inmates.
We need to ask: Is this all we have to offer people in prison? Have we given up and now seek managerial solutions for human decline?
For Annmarie Ward, the problem in Scotland is the lack of access to abstinence treatment, detox and rehabilitation services. Which is why FAVOR have backed a Right to Addiction Recovery Bill – currently being considered by the Scottish Parliament - introduced by Douglas Ross MSP.
In England, some prisons offer abstinence-based recovery wings, acknowledging that going into prison might be a vital chance to break the cycle of drug use. We don't offer this in Scotland. Why not?
As Annmarie Ward said: 'Prisons should be places where people are interrupted in their addiction, not supported in it. Where the chaos stops, not where it's managed more hygienically.
"Needles and vape kits in Barlinnie won't restore dignity. They'll entrench dependency and signal, loud and clear, that the state has given up on these men'.
If we want to achieve real harm reduction, we need to give human beings hope. We need to give people access to detox and rehabilitation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
My mother accompanied my father to AA and then realised she was an alcoholic
Scotland's drugs minister has told how her mother was persuaded to go to Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) with her father, before realising she too had a drinking problem. Maree Todd was given the post by First Minister John Swinney in June, and has never spoken of her personal link to addiction. But with her father celebrating four decades of sobriety this year, the minister said she hopes his story will show people 'that change can happen'. In her childhood, Todd's parents, John and Christina, drank heavily, but when she was 12, the pair decided to get sober. It was not until a friend from their west Highland village – who was in recovery himself – approached her father to ask him to seek help that the process truly began. Accepting the invitation to AA, her mother was eventually persuaded to go along, but only after being erroneously told it was normal for spouses to attend with their partners. PA Media Todd, left, with her father and sister 'They persuaded my mum by telling her, and it's a funny thing, they said it was normal for wives and spouses to go along to the meeting as well, because she was not at all convinced that this was an issue for her,' Todd told the PA news agency. 'My mum went along to this meeting and literally had this road to Damascus moment as she sat there listening to the testimonies around the table and thought 'actually this is where I am'… she realised that there and then.' Todd's father did not engage much with AA again, but this year he celebrated his 40th year sober. The minister's mother died in 2022, with 38 years of sobriety behind her – excluding a 'handful' of relapses. While there was no ill will between her father and AA, Ms Todd described him as a 'typical West Highlander'. 'He's a lovely, lovely man, but talking isn't really his thing,' she said. 'He actually feels guilty about that sometimes, he says he thinks he sets a bad example to other people who are trying to stop because it's so important to access help and it's not common to be able to stop on your own.' Todd – who was elected to the Scottish Parliament in 2016 after 20 years as a pharmacist – said her childhood was generally a good one other than her parents drinking, and she speaks emotionally of the impact recovery programmes like AA had on the lives of her parents and her own. 'My mum's relationship with AA continued and it was a profound part of her life, a profound part of our lives as we grew up,' she said. Fighting back tears, she added: 'When my mum died, it was a really profound experience for myself and my sister to be able to say thank-you to the fellowship for what they had done to help our parents to get sober and to recognise the impact, particularly my mum, had on so many other people's lives.' During the period her parents were drinking, Ms Todd said the local community where she grew up ensured her and her sister Fiona were taken care of. 'When I was minister for children and young people I used to say it takes a village to raise a child, and I came from a good village,' she said. 'So when my parents were drinking, I had adults all around me who were looking out for me and who made sure I was fed and safe. 'That is a really important thing from the community that I grew up in, people knew what was happening and they looked out for us.' Going through university to a job in the health service, then to Parliament and eventually ministerial office is not the usual path trodden by someone whose parents struggled with addiction, Ms Todd said her family never normalised the situation. 'We knew that what was happening in our house wasn't normal, we knew that other houses weren't like that,' she said. 'That's another thing about growing up in a close-knit, small community.' That is not to say that the girls did not feel 'shame', she said, adding: 'We did, but we did not have that burden of trying to cover up what was happening at home, it wasn't possible, it was very visible and, actually, I look back and I think that's a real blessing.' Despite there being anger and shame in growing up with parents struggling with addiction, Ms Todd said she never lost the love for her family. 'I was ten, 11, 12 years old and there were moments of real shame, moments of real anger,' she said. 'Throughout this, I loved my parents; they were really loving. 'I don't want anyone to get the wrong impression. 'One of the reasons that I'm so sorted is because the only thing my parents got wrong was the drinking.' Despite being in the public eye for almost a decade, Ms Todd has not spoken about her parents' struggles. She said her father is happy with her discussing it now, because they both hope his four decades of sobriety will inspire others. 'One of the reasons I'm so keen to talk about it is because I want people who read your work or come across your work to understand that change can happen,' she said. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
My mother accompanied father to AA and then realised she was an alcoholic
Scotland's drugs minister has told how her mother was persuaded to go to Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) with her father, before realising she too had a drinking problem. Maree Todd was given the post by First Minister John Swinney in June, and has never spoken of her personal link to addiction. But with her father celebrating four decades of sobriety this year, the minister said she hopes his story will show people 'that change can happen'. In her childhood, Todd's parents, John and Christina, drank heavily, but when she was 12, the pair decided to get sober. It was not until a friend from their west Highland village – who was in recovery himself – approached her father to ask him to seek help that the process truly began. Accepting the invitation to AA, her mother was eventually persuaded to go along, but only after being erroneously told it was normal for spouses to attend with their partners. PA Media Todd, left, with her father and sister 'They persuaded my mum by telling her, and it's a funny thing, they said it was normal for wives and spouses to go along to the meeting as well, because she was not at all convinced that this was an issue for her,' Todd told the PA news agency. 'My mum went along to this meeting and literally had this road to Damascus moment as she sat there listening to the testimonies around the table and thought 'actually this is where I am'… she realised that there and then.' Todd's father did not engage much with AA again, but this year he celebrated his 40th year sober. The minister's mother died in 2022, with 38 years of sobriety behind her – excluding a 'handful' of relapses. While there was no ill will between her father and AA, Ms Todd described him as a 'typical West Highlander'. 'He's a lovely, lovely man, but talking isn't really his thing,' she said. 'He actually feels guilty about that sometimes, he says he thinks he sets a bad example to other people who are trying to stop because it's so important to access help and it's not common to be able to stop on your own.' Todd – who was elected to the Scottish Parliament in 2016 after 20 years as a pharmacist – said her childhood was generally a good one other than her parents drinking, and she speaks emotionally of the impact recovery programmes like AA had on the lives of her parents and her own. 'My mum's relationship with AA continued and it was a profound part of her life, a profound part of our lives as we grew up,' she said. Fighting back tears, she added: 'When my mum died, it was a really profound experience for myself and my sister to be able to say thank-you to the fellowship for what they had done to help our parents to get sober and to recognise the impact, particularly my mum, had on so many other people's lives.' During the period her parents were drinking, Ms Todd said the local community where she grew up ensured her and her sister Fiona were taken care of. 'When I was minister for children and young people I used to say it takes a village to raise a child, and I came from a good village,' she said. 'So when my parents were drinking, I had adults all around me who were looking out for me and who made sure I was fed and safe. 'That is a really important thing from the community that I grew up in, people knew what was happening and they looked out for us.' Going through university to a job in the health service, then to Parliament and eventually ministerial office is not the usual path trodden by someone whose parents struggled with addiction, Ms Todd said her family never normalised the situation. 'We knew that what was happening in our house wasn't normal, we knew that other houses weren't like that,' she said. 'That's another thing about growing up in a close-knit, small community.' That is not to say that the girls did not feel 'shame', she said, adding: 'We did, but we did not have that burden of trying to cover up what was happening at home, it wasn't possible, it was very visible and, actually, I look back and I think that's a real blessing.' Despite there being anger and shame in growing up with parents struggling with addiction, Ms Todd said she never lost the love for her family. 'I was ten, 11, 12 years old and there were moments of real shame, moments of real anger,' she said. 'Throughout this, I loved my parents; they were really loving. 'I don't want anyone to get the wrong impression. 'One of the reasons that I'm so sorted is because the only thing my parents got wrong was the drinking.' Despite being in the public eye for almost a decade, Ms Todd has not spoken about her parents' struggles. She said her father is happy with her discussing it now, because they both hope his four decades of sobriety will inspire others. 'One of the reasons I'm so keen to talk about it is because I want people who read your work or come across your work to understand that change can happen,' she said. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Woman jailed for leaving eight starving dogs to eat each other in hellhole flat
Stacey Harris, 39, was jailed for eight months and banned from ever owning dogs again after seven dogs died when they were starved and left in a filthy abandoned flat Seven dogs horrifically died after they were left in a filthy hellhole flat as a woman has been jailed over the shocking cruelty. Stacey Harris, 39, left eight dogs to die in disgusting conditions inside an abandoned flat in Dundee. The 39-year-old had starved the animals for at least two months and failed to provide food or seek treatment for painful eye and ear infections. Only one dog managed to survive the appalling conditions the suffering animals had been kept in. Harris appeared in Dundee Sheriff Court on Tuesday and was handed an eight month jail sentence and a lifetime ban from owning or keeping dogs. It comes after a dad died in a scalding hot bath as his family slam a hotel's management for 'ignoring warnings'. She was found guilty of seven charges - six of causing unnecessary suffering and one of failing to meet basic welfare needs, according to the Daily Record. A probe was launched by the SSPCA after a tip-off was made about suspected dog abandonment in October 2024. A Scottish SPCA inspector said "We received a complaint that a property had been abandoned and the dogs inside had not been attended to for over a week." When officers arrived at the property, they could see an emaciated Sharpei-type dog with visibly infected eyes. The flat was said to have an overwhelming smell of faeces and urine, with the entire property being was littered with dog excrement, rubbish, and debris. A tan and white American Bulldog - the sole survivor - was so malnourished it could not walk and had to be carried out. A vet later said the dog had recently given birth and was suffering from dehydration, skin, and ear infections that had gone untreated for weeks. She was also extremely underweight, with ribs, spine, and hip bones visible. The SSPCA have not seen any report of the pregnancy or about the puppies of the surviving bulldog. After walking upstairs, inspectors found the remains of a dead Sharpie dog stuck in a bedroom doorway. The second dead dog, a Sharpei cross, was found lying on the floor of the second bedroom surrounded by dog faeces, empty dog food bags and rubbish. The bodies of a 12-year-old chihuahua and year old Sharpei were never found and were presumed eaten. Three other one year and four months old Sharpei-type dogs, who were all emaciated, were removed from the property using specialist equipment. They were later euthanised on welfare grounds due to the severity of their untreated conditions. The bodies of the two dead Sharpei dogs were taken for postmortem which confirmed both had died from prolonged starvation. An inspector added: "This was an extremely distressing case where multiple animals suffered unnecessarily for a prolonged period which could have been easily avoided by contacting an animal welfare organisation for help if needed. "It is hard to comprehend how any individual cannot attend to their own pets knowing they were locked up in a property. As a result, the Scottish SPCA and the Inspector involved are very pleased with Harris's sentencing and hope it acts as a deterrent to others."
