Best cotton bed sheets that feel like sleeping on a cloud, per our reviews

New York Post

28-05-2025

New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if you click or buy through our links. Featured pricing is subject to change.
Finding the best cotton sheets isn't just about picking the softest set off the shelf, it's about comfort, breathability, and how well they hold up after countless nights of sleep.
You know the thread count competition amongst friends, comparing thread counts, just like childhood competitions. But does it really matter?
The truth is, when it comes to cotton sheets, a higher thread count doesn't always mean better quality. In fact, extremely high numbers can be misleading and may even result in sheets that feel heavy and less breathable. So, what is a good thread count for cotton sheets?
Advertisement
Generally, the sweet spot is between 200 and 600, depending on the weave. Percale, for instance, feels crisp and cool at a lower count, while sateen can feel silky and smooth with a slightly higher one. And when you're deciding between options like bamboo vs. cotton sheets or whether to stick with jersey material, it's important to remember that there are more factors than just thread count.
Consider how the fabric feels, performs, and suits your sleep style. If you sleep hot, cotton or bamboo is likely your top choice due to their sweat-wicking properties and temperature-regulating fabrics. On the other hand, jersey cotton sheets offer a soft, stretchy feel that drapes like your boyfriend's sweatshirt, so it's really about all needs.
Best Cotton Sheets Overall: Boll & Branch Signature Hemmed Sheet Set
Boll & Branch
Pros: Offers a split King as well as all the other sizes from Twin to California King
Lots of colors and patterns to choose from
Very cooling and grows softer with each wash
Cons: The starting price is $229, which may be a bit of a stretch for some budgets
If you're looking for sheets that combine sustainability with luxury, the Boll & Branch Signature Hemmed Sheet Set delivers on every front. Made from the finest 100% organic cotton, these sheets are proof that high-end comfort doesn't have to compromise on ethics or performance.
New York Post Review: 'I've slept really well in this comfy cotton set, and I'm not typically a cotton girl. I usually reach for bamboo sheets for a silkier vibe, but I sleep very, very hot, and these sheets actually kept me from sweating last night.
I'm impressed by Boll & Branch's purpose-driven process, crafting fabrics from scratch, carefully managing every step of the supply chain, and upholding uncompromising standards in every detail. From the elegant unboxing, perfectly wrapped in tissue paper and ready for wedding season gifting, to the impeccable stitching and fabric quality, I highly recommend this brand. It makes a great choice for anyone seeking a reprieve from hot flashes or in need of breathable sheets.' – Emma Sutton-Williams, commerce reporter
Read more bed sheet reviews here.
Size: Twin to Split King | Depth: 17 inches | Color options: 26
Best Egyptian Cotton Sheets: Brooklinen Luxe Sateen Core Sheet Set
Brooklinen
Pros: Made from 100% long-staple cotton
480 thread count
Cons: No split sheet options
Egyptian cotton is renowned for its exceptionally long fibers, also referred to as long-staple cotton. These longer fibers can be spun into finer, stronger, and smoother yarns, resulting in a fabric that feels softer, resists pilling, and lasts longer than regular cotton.
While Egyptian cotton originally referred to cotton grown in Egypt's unique climate and Nile-fed soil, today, the term typically refers to the fiber quality, specifically long-staple cotton, regardless of where it's grown.
These sheets are made of 100% long-staple cotton, creating the Brooklinen Luxe Sateen Core Sheet Set, which customers highly rate, and we're sure you'll love it as well because of its super soft and silky texture.
New York Post Review: 'The Luxe Core Sheet Set looks clean and is so comfortable to sink into at night. For hot and cool sleepers alike, I would say the Luxe Core Sheet Set is a great, light, and airy option. I like to sleep with a million and one blankets and shorts, practically all year round, and Brooklinen delivers an exceptional, sound sleep. So much so, it's a struggle to leave bed some mornings.' – Victoria Giardina, content strategist and commerce journalist
For more cooling options, read our cooling sheet review.
Size: Twin to California King| Depth: 16 inches | Color options: 23
Best Value: Quince Classic Organic Percale Sheet Set
Quince
Pros: 100% long-staple cotton
270 thread count cotton percale
365-return window
Budget-friendly
Cons: Percale weave may not be preferred by those who like smoother, silkier textures
Percale is woven in a criss-cross pattern that helps regulate airflow but will have a rougher texture than viscose or standard cotton sheets. Many of our editors rave about the quality of Quince and how cost-effective it is, thanks to its direct-to-consumer approach that eliminates the middleman. Quince compares its sheets to Brooklinen, Parachute, and Coyuchi for the same quality but with much lower price tags than competitors. Plus, you can return these sheets 365 days after purchasing! For more budget options, check out Target's sheets.
Size: Twin to King | Depth: 16 inches | Color options: 12
Best Percale Cotton Sheets: L.L.Bean Pima Cotton Percale Sheet
L.L. Bean
Pros: Affordable pricing
Nine shades to choose from
Twin to California King
Free shipping with $75 purchase
Cons: Pocket depth only reaches 15 inches
Similar to Egyptian cotton, Pima cotton is a great option because its extra-long fibers create sheets that are exceptionally soft and smooth, offering a luxurious feel against the skin. The material resists pilling and holds up really well after washing. Available in a Twin Extra Long for those exceptionally tall college students and a California King for parents who want to spread out. If you need Twin XL options, check out these sets.
Size: Twin to California King | Depth: 15 inches | Color options: 9
Best Organic Cotton Sheets: Frette Naturalismo Sheet Set
Frette
Pros: 100% organic cotton
Sustainable dyeing process
Italian craftsmanship
No chemical agents used
Eco-luxury designer
Cons: Limited colors available
Only made in Queen or King
Very expensive
For those willing to invest in exceptional craftsmanship and sustainable luxury, the Naturalismo Sheet Set by Frette is a standout choice. At nearly $5,000, it's not just bedding; it's an heirloom-quality piece, woven from 100% organic cotton and dyed with dried organic poppy petals in a process as refined as the brand's Italian heritage. So obviously, it might be best not to get freaky in the sheets if you want to keep these looking crisp and pristine, because light colors in any price range can stain.
Size: Queen or King| Depth: 15 inches | Color options: 1
Best Sateen Cotton Sheets: Ralph Lauren Organic Cotton Sateen Sheeting
Ralph Lauren
Pros: 624-thread count
Can be personalized
Cons: The sateen weave can feel warmer, which may not be ideal for hot sleepers
Ralph Lauren's sheet set stands out for its exceptional quality, featuring a strong 624-thread count made from 312 two-plied yarns that create a smoother feel against your skin. This updated collection elevates the brand's iconic sateen sheets by incorporating organic cotton and refined design elements, such as French seams and delicate hemstitching, to combine sustainability with timeless elegance for a truly sophisticated bedding experience.
Size: Twin to King | Depth: n/a | Color options: 7
Best Flannel Cotton Sheets: Cosy House Collection Flannel Bed Sheet Set
Macy's
Pros: Best for tight budgets
Great for warmth
Cons: Only sells Queen or King
Potential for pilling
These flannel sheets are incredibly soft, double-brushed for warmth, and stay securely in place thanks to deep pockets and sturdy corner straps. Available in a range of calming colors, they offer comfort and a tailored fit for thick mattresses. Sadly, they are only available in Queen or King.
Size: Queen or King | Depth: 17 inches | Color options: 5
How we tested
To find the best cotton sheets, we tested over 30 sets across various materials, weaves, and price points. Each sheet set was evaluated over multiple nights and washes to simulate real-life use and wear. We looked closely at comfort, breathability, durability, softness, and overall value. Because sheet preferences vary by sleep style and climate, we also considered special use cases like hot sleepers, people with sensitive skin, and women experiencing menopause who may need cooler, moisture-wicking options.
We tested a wide range of cotton types and compared cotton to popular alternatives like microfiber and bamboo to help you understand how each material performs.
Our testing process involved:
Hands-on evaluation of texture, weight, and stitching quality right out of the package
of texture, weight, and stitching quality right out of the package Wash tests to see how each sheet set held up after laundering
to see how each sheet set held up after laundering Sleep trials to evaluate real-time breathability, temperature regulation, and comfort
to evaluate real-time breathability, temperature regulation, and comfort Thread count and weave analysis to determine how construction impacts feel and durability
FAQ
What kind of sheets do 5-star hotels use?
One size does not fit all, except when it comes to quality — the sheets are always well-made. Generally, we'd say cotton because of how easy to wash and how breathable they are, especially because it only gets softer after washing.
Popular options include Egyptian cotton sheets, Pima cotton sheets, and Supima cotton sheets, all known for their high-quality fibers and luxurious feel. Cotton percale sheets offer a crisp, hotel-like texture, while cotton sateen sheets provide a smoother, more lustrous finish. Some luxury hotels also incorporate organic cotton sheets for eco-conscious guests. While less common, certain properties may use linen, wrinkle-free cotton blends, or bamboo sheets for specific aesthetics or guest preferences.
Microfiber is a derivative of polyester, so microfiber sheets are rarely used in upscale settings due to their tendency to trap heat and moisture, making for an uncomfortable night's sleep.
What thread count is best for 100% cotton sheets?
For 100% cotton sheets, a thread count between 200 and 400 is acceptable. Cotton percale sheets feel crisp and breathable, typically around 200 to 400 threads per inch, while cotton sateen sheets benefit from a slightly higher count, usually 300 to 600 threads per inch, for a silkier touch.
Premium types like Egyptian cotton, Pima, and Supima cotton sheets perform best within this range, offering the perfect mix of softness and strength. Beware of extremely high thread counts, which can reduce airflow and are often more marketing than a meaningful indicator of quality.
For cold weather, cotton flannel sheets focus more on fabric weight and texture than thread count, providing cozy warmth instead of cool crispness. Since we're rolling into warmer months, linen sheets are also worth considering because both keep you cool; however, keep in mind linen wrinkles way more.
Again, it's all about what you are looking for in sheets and it's not always about the thread count. That's pure marketing!
Polyester VS. Cotton Sheets: Which is better?
When comparing polyester to cotton sheets, we found that cotton was almost always the more breathable and cooling option. Unlike natural fibers, polyester's weave is much tighter, and it traps heat and moisture, making summer heat unbearable. So, if you want to avoid tossing and turning, consider one of these highly ranked cotton sheets.
For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America's go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We're not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren't already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we're known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.
Looking for a headline-worthy haul? Keep shopping Post Wanted.