U.S. federal appeals court backs Florida gun age law
The 8-4 ruling by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals came after seven years of legal wrangling in the National Rifle Association's challenge to a 2018 law passed after a mass shooting at Parkland's Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School that killed 17 students and faculty members.
Nikolas Cruz, who was 19 at the time, used a semiautomatic rifle to gun down the victims at his former school. The NRA filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the gun-age restriction shortly after the law passed.
Friday's ruling by the full Atlanta-based appeals court upheld a three-judge panel's decision and outlined the history of the nation's gun laws, from its founding to recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions setting guidelines for determining how to apply the Second Amendment. While the law barred people under 21 from buying rifles and long guns, they still can receive them, for example, as gifts from family members.
'From this history emerges a straightforward conclusion: the Florida law is consistent with our regulatory tradition in why and how it burdens the right of minors to keep and bear arms,' Chief Judge William Pryor wrote. 'Because minors have yet to reach the age of reason, the Florida law prohibits them from purchasing firearms, yet it allows them to receive firearms from their parents or another responsible adult.'
Judges Adalberto Jordan, Robin Rosenbaum, Jill Pryor, Kevin Newsom, Britt Grant, Nancy Abudu and Charles Wilson joined the majority opinion. Judge Andrew Brasher wrote a dissenting opinion, which was joined by Judges Elizabeth Branch, Barbara Lagoa and Robert Luck.
The majority ruling relied heavily on U.S. Supreme Court standards, established in recent cases, saying that Second Amendment restrictions must be rooted in the 'prevailing understanding' of gun rights from the nation's founding era.
'The founders' generation shared the view that minors lacked the reason and judgment necessary to be trusted with legal rights,' William Pryor wrote.
The chief judge noted that, at the time of the founding, minors generally could not purchase guns because they were deemed to lack the judgment and discretion to enter contracts and that minors were subject to the power of their parents.
The opinion noted that the Florida law also is consistent with the country's regulatory tradition because it allows minors to possess rifles and long guns although they are prohibited from purchasing them.
The 2018 law 'burdens the right no more than … historical restrictions because it prohibits purchase but preserves access to firearms with parental consent,' William Pryor wrote.
'From the founding to the late-19th century, our law limited the purchase of firearms by minors in different ways. The Florida law also limits the purchase of firearms by minors. And it does so for the same reason: to stop immature and impulsive individuals, like Nikolas Cruz, from harming themselves and others with deadly weapons. Those similarities are sufficient to confirm the constitutionality of the Florida law,' the majority ruling said.
But Brasher, in a dissent, disputed the historical roots of the age restriction.
'There were no age-based limitations' on the 'right to keep and bear arms either before, during, or immediately after the adoption of the Bill of Rights,' Brasher wrote. 'This is where the majority opinion loses its bearings. Simply put, there is nothing in our nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation that resembles Florida's complete prohibition on an adult's ability to purchase a firearm based only on that adult's age. Nothing in the founding-era legal landscape is analogous to the challenged law. To the extent the history says anything about age and firearms, it says that the states and federal government expected all men over the age of 18 to be armed.'
But William Pryor called the dissent's characterization of people between the ages of 18 and 21 as adults as 'unavailing,' arguing that it 'discounts the key fact that, at the founding and until the late 20th century, the age of majority was 21.'
The majority opinion also questioned whether the dissenting judges would support any age restriction for firearm sales as constitutional.
'If they do not, their position would require enjoining the enforcement of numerous federal and state laws, including a federal law that prohibits licensed sellers from selling 'any firearm or ammunition' to an individual under the age of 18,' the majority opinion said.
The full appeals court decided to take up the issue after the three-judge panel's ruling. Chief U.S. District Judge Mark Walker also upheld the law.
But Friday's decision likely will not end debate about the law, which could go to the U.S. Supreme Court.
After the ruling, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, who took office last month, said he would not defend the law. Gov. Ron DeSantis tapped Uthmeier to replace former Attorney General Ashley Moody after DeSantis appointed her to the U.S. Senate.
'Men and women old enough to fight and die for our country should be able to purchase firearms to defend themselves and their families,' Uthmeier posted on social media.
Also, a state House panel on Wednesday approved a measure (HB 759) that would repeal the age restriction. The House passed such bills in 2023 and 2024, but the Senate refused to support the proposals.
DeSantis this month signaled that he would support revising state gun laws, including the gun-age restriction.
But state House Minority Leader Fentrice Driskell, D-Tampa, praised Friday's ruling.
'I am thrilled the 11th Circuit confirmed what we've been saying for years, that reasonable, responsible gun laws are both constitutional and appropriate to help keep us safe. We can, and should, limit someone from being able to purchase an AR 15 until they are at least 21 years old,' Driskell, D-Tampa, said in an email. 'Any question about constitutionality has now been clearly settled. The Marjory Stoneman Douglas Act is lawful and should continue to protect our communities as it has since 2018. Florida is safer for it.'
Click here to download our free news, weather and smart TV apps. And click here to stream Channel 9 Eyewitness News live.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
18 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Indian Oil and Bharat Petroleum resume Russian oil purchases
India-based refiners Indian Oil and Bharat Petroleum have resumed their purchases of Russian oil for delivery in September and October, with widening discounts in place, as reported by Reuters, citing two officials familiar with the matter. This move could potentially impact the supply to key China buyers, which had increased its intake during the Indian refiners' hiatus. However, with discounts on Russian flagship Urals crude reaching approximately $3 per barrel, the economics have swung back in favour of the Indian companies. Despite geopolitical tensions and previous criticism from the US, Russia anticipates maintaining its oil exports to India. Officials at the Russian embassy in New Delhi have expressed hope for upcoming trilateral discussions involving India and China. The decision to restart imports follows a temporary halt in July when Indian refiners faced slimmer discounts and international scrutiny. The US criticised India's continued purchases of Russian oil, which have surged from a marginal 0.2% to 35% of India's total oil imports since the Ukraine conflict began. Furthermore, US President Donald Trump had threatened to impose a 25% tariff on Indian goods from 27 August to penalise the country for its dealings with Russia. Despite the geopolitical backdrop, Indian Oil, the nation's key refiner, communicated to analysts its intent to continue sourcing Russian oil, based on favourable economics. The company's strategy includes diversifying its crude basket with other Russian grades such as Varandey and Siberian Light. While Indian companies typically do not disclose details of their crude imports, the market has taken note of China's recent acquisition of 15 cargoes of Russian oil for delivery in October and November. "Indian Oil and Bharat Petroleum resume Russian oil purchases" was originally created and published by Offshore Technology, a GlobalData owned brand. The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data


Fox News
26 minutes ago
- Fox News
Ex-Adams aide allegedly tried to give reporter a wad of cash hidden in a potato chip bag
A New York City reporter was allegedly the target of an apparent bribery attempt by a former aide to Mayor Eric Adams, who is currently seeking reelection. Winnie Greco, a longtime Adams ally, is accused of trying to give a reporter from THE CITY, a New York City-based publication, a wad of cash hidden in a bag of Herr's Sour Cream & Onion ripple potato chips. The publication said the incident occurred after a campaign event in Harlem on Wednesday. According to THE CITY's account of the events, City Hall reporter Katie Honan spotted Greco near the opening of Adams' new Harlem campaign office. The former Adams aide later texted the reporter and asked to meet across the street from the campaign office. The two then walked to a Whole Foods next door, where Greco handed Honan the bag. Honan, according to THE CITY, believed Greco was offering a snack and initially refused, but the former aide insisted she keep it. Honan reportedly opened the bag while on her way to the subway and saw a red envelope containing at least one $100 bill and several $20 bills. THE CITY reports that Honan called Greco, who said she had left the area. When Honan said she had to return the money, Greco suggested they meet in Chinatown. According to THE CITY, Honan texted Greco asking when she could return the cash but did not receive a response. THE CITY interviewed Greco later that same day, and she reportedly tried to apologize multiple times, saying she had made "a mistake." Greco reportedly told the publication that it was "a culture thing" and that she "just wanted to be her friend." The publication said that it contacted the Department of Investigation (DOI) after the incident. Greco's attorney, Steven Brill, denied the act was "nefarious," saying that it was a Chinese custom to give money to others as a sign of "gratitude and friendship." Though he did not explain why it was hidden in a bag of chips. "This was no payoff. This was no handing over a bag of cash. This is nothing more than a gesture of kindness blown out of a Chinese tradition of handing money to others as a form of gratitude and friendship. She knows this reporter and was fond of her. It may appear strange, but there was nothing nefarious about it," Brill told Fox News Digital. When Honan returned to her office, she gave the bag to her editors, at which point the publication contacted New York City's Department of Investigation. THE CITY said it did not open the envelope or count the money inside. Reports indicate that the Adams campaign has since prohibited Greco from participating in volunteer campaign-related activities. Greco is no stranger to law enforcement and has been under federal investigation for some time. The FBI raided her Bronx home in February 2024 amid reports that Adams' 2021 mayoral campaign conspired with the Turkish government to raise funds. She later resigned from her position as the city's director of Asian American affairs. According to Fox 5, the DOI is also investigating claims that Greco pressured a campaign volunteer to do personal tasks in exchange for a City Hall job. Fox News Digital reached out to Greco and Adams' campaign for comment but did not get a response in time for publication.

36 minutes ago
China races to build world's largest solar farm to meet emissions targets
TALATAN, China -- Chinese government officials last month showed off what they say will be the world's largest solar farm when completed high on a Tibetan plateau. It will cover 610 square kilometers (235 square miles), which is the size of Chicago. China has been installing solar panels far faster than anywhere else in the world, and the investment is starting to pay off. A study released Thursday found that the country's carbon emissions edged down 1% in the first six months of 2025 compared to a year earlier, extending a trend that began in March 2024. The good news is China's carbon emissions may have peaked well ahead of a government target of doing so before 2030. But China, the world's biggest emitter of greenhouse gases, will need to bring them down much more sharply to play its part in slowing global climate change. For China to reach its declared goal of carbon neutrality by 2060, emissions would need to fall 3% on average over the next 35 years, said Lauri Myllyvirta, the Finland-based author of the study and lead analyst at the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air. 'China needs to get to that 3% territory as soon as possible,' he said. China's emissions have fallen before during economic slowdowns. What's different this time is electricity demand is growing — up 3.7% in the first half of this year — but the increase in power from solar, wind and nuclear has easily outpaced that, according to Myllyvirta, who analyzes the most recent data in a study published on the U.K.-based Carbon Brief website. 'We're talking really for the first time about a structural declining trend in China's emissions,' he said. China installed 212 gigawatts of solar capacity in the first six months of the year, more than America's entire capacity of 178 gigawatts as of the end of 2024, the study said. Electricity from solar has overtaken hydropower in China and is poised to surpass wind this year to become the country's largest source of clean energy. Some 51 gigawatts of wind power was added from January to June. Li Shuo, the director of the China Climate Hub at the Asia Society Policy Institute in Washington, described the plateauing of China's carbon emissions as a turning point in the effort to combat climate change. 'This is a moment of global significance, offering a rare glimmer of hope in an otherwise bleak climate landscape,' he wrote in an email response. It also shows that a country can cut emissions while still growing economically, he said. But Li cautioned that China's heavy reliance on coal remains a serious threat to progress on climate and said the economy needs to shift to less resource-intensive sectors. 'There's still a long road ahead,' he said. A seemingly endless expanse of solar panels stretches toward the horizon on the Tibetan plateau. White two-story buildings rise above them at regular intervals. Sheep graze on the scrubby vegetation that grows under them. Solar panels have been installed on about two-thirds of the land, with power already flowing from completed phases. When fully complete, the project will have more than 7 million panels and be capable of generating enough power for 5 million households. Like many of China's solar and wind farms, it was built in the relatively sparsely populated west. A major challenge is getting electricity to the population centers and factories in China's east. 'The distribution of green energy resources is perfectly misaligned with the current industrial distribution of our country,' Zhang Jinming, the vice governor of Qinghai province, told journalists on a government-organized tour. Part of the solution is building transmission lines traversing the country. One connects Qinghai to Henan province. Two more are planned, including one to Guangdong province in the southeast, almost at the opposite corner of the country. Making full use of the power is hindered by the relatively inflexible way that China's electricity grid is managed, tailored to the steady output of coal plants rather than more variable and less predictable wind and solar, Myllyvirta said. 'This is an issue that the policymakers have recognized and are trying to manage, but it does require big changes to the way coal-fired power plants operate and big changes to the way the transmission network operates,' he said. 'So it's no small task.' ___