AI porn victims see Hong Kong unprepared for threat
While the University of Hong Kong case has thrust AI-made porn into the spotlight, it is not the city's first.
HONG KONG - For Hong Kong law student 'C', AI-made pornography was a distant danger until a university classmate created graphic images of her and multiple other women.
'At first I was shocked, then it turned into panic,' said the 20-year-old, describing the ordeal as a 'wound that will leave a scar'.
C was one of three women who exposed an
AI porn scandal at Hong Kong's oldest university in July, sparking huge debate around what had largely been seen as an overseas phenomenon.
The victims, who spoke to AFP on condition of anonymity, and experts said the city was ill-prepared to counter the fast-growing threat.
In the University of Hong Kong (HKU) case, hundreds of images of at least 20 women were discovered on the student's laptop.
'B', another of those who spoke out, said she felt betrayed as she had considered the perpetrator a friend.
'I felt like my privacy was violated... like I couldn't trust the people around me,' she said.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore Train disruption on North East MRT line due to power fault, no service from Farrer Park to Punggol Coast
Business Singapore raises 2025 economic growth forecast but warns of uncertainty from US tariffs
Singapore Circle Line to close early most Fridays and Saturdays, start late most weekends from Sept 5-Dec 28
Business Goh Cheng Liang, Nippon Paint billionaire and richest Singaporean, dies aged 98
Business StarHub buys rest of MyRepublic's broadband business in $105m deal; comes after Simba buys M1
World After tariff truce extended, a Trump-Xi summit in China?
Asia Death of student in Sabah raises hurdle for Malaysian PM Anwar as he faces tough state polls soon
Opinion Sumiko at 61: Hearing loss is linked to dementia risk. Here's what you risk by ignoring it
The university's initial response was to give the student a warning letter and make him apologise.
The third woman, 'A', said she was told by staff the case could not be heard before a disciplinary committee.
'They were concerned but didn't know what they could do... We felt that was a bit ridiculous.'
HKU told AFP it 'has been in contact with the students involved' but cannot comment further with the case under active review.
Damage may 'never end'
While the HKU case has thrust AI-made porn into the spotlight, it is not the city's first.
Janice, a woman in her late 20s who also asked to use a pseudonym, told AFP she was devastated a few years ago when fake obscene images were sent to her friends.
She never found the culprit and worried that the damage might 'never end'.
'I tried skipping work and didn't dare to go out on the street,' she said, adding that she had suicidal thoughts and would suddenly burst into tears.
'I couldn't sleep because I was afraid I would wake up to see the whole internet filled with (pornographic) images of me.'
Hong Kong's Association Concerning Sexual Violence Against Women received 11 similar requests for help in 2024-25.
'We have observed an uptick... Some cases may be hidden if (victims) don't know how to seek help,' executive director Doris Chong said.
Janice doubted she had enough evidence to persuade police to help, adding that she felt society will 'never find a way' to punish canny offenders.
Type of 'sexual violence'
An estimated 90 per cent of AI-made porn victims are women, Professor Susanne Choi from the Chinese University of Hong Kong told AFP, 'suggesting that it is a form of gender-based sexual violence'.
Asked for the number of recent cases involving deepfake pornography, police said they did not maintain such figures.
Lawmakers and universities need to 'expand and revise existing laws and procedures to better cope with... technology-facilitated sexual harassment', Professor Choi argued.
Discussions in Britain and Singapore show a growing willingness to penalise its creation, though opinion is split on possession, according to Hong Kong barrister Stephen Keung.
Hong Kong currently criminalises the distribution of 'intimate images', including AI-made ones, but not their creation or possession.
That made legal action in the HKU case difficult as there was no evidence that the pictures were circulated.
After the women went public with the scandal, however, Hong Kong's
privacy watchdog launched a criminal investigation , and the Equal Opportunities Commission is handling a related complaint.
Dignity 'undermined'
The three students said they have had to deal with public backlash.
Once an avid social media user, C temporarily stopped posting, worried about who else 'would screengrab my photos for what purpose'.
'Many commenters said... 'You are ruining the guy's future, you should apologise to him',' she said, saying she endured periods of self-doubt.
The student has not been named and AFP was unable to reach him for comment.
B said the trio did not want to 'play judge' but believed offenders should face long-term consequences.
'The mere creation (of AI porn) is a problem... My bodily autonomy, my privacy, my dignity were undermined by it,' B said.
'If a line must be drawn, it should be drawn at creation.' AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Ukrainian troops doubt quick ceasefire, reject territorial concessions
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Service members of the 58th Separate Motorized Infantry Brigade of the Ukrainian Armed Forces use an RPG-7 grenade launcher during military exercises at a training ground, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in Kharkiv region, Ukraine August 11, 2025. REUTERS/Sofiia Gatilova/File Photo KHARKIV REGION, Ukraine - Ukrainian soldiers preparing for battle say they have little faith in prospects for a quick ceasefire, and many reject suggestions that Kyiv should give up any of its hard-fought territory to Russia. Reuters interviewed troops at two training bases in the northeastern Kharkiv region this week, days ahead of a planned meeting in Alaska between U.S. President Donald Trump and his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin. Ukraine fears the two leaders could use their summit on Friday to dictate terms of peace and force Kyiv to abandon territory, a move Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has flatly rejected. "Give it away to whom? Give it away for what?" asked the commander of a training base for Ukraine's 58th Motorised Brigade, whose call sign is Chef. Trump said on Monday that both Kyiv and Moscow would need to cede land to end the war, now in its fourth year. European Union leaders rallied to Ukraine's defence on Tuesday, saying it must have the freedom to decide its own future. The joint statement came as Russian forces made a sudden thrust into eastern Ukraine in a bid to break a key defensive line, likely aimed at boosting pressure on Kyiv to give up land. The rapid battlefield push by Russia's larger and better-equipped army followed months of deadly air strikes on Ukrainian towns and cities. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Luxury items seized in $3b money laundering case handed over to Deloitte for liquidation Singapore MyRepublic customers air concerns over broadband speed after sale to StarHub Singapore Power switchboard failure led to disruption in NEL, Sengkang-Punggol LRT services: SBS Transit Singapore NEL and Sengkang-Punggol LRT resume service after hours-long power fault Business Ninja Van cuts 12% of Singapore workforce after 2 rounds of layoffs in 2024 Singapore Hyflux investigator 'took advantage' of Olivia Lum's inability to recall events: Davinder Singh Singapore Man who stabbed son-in-law to death in Boon Tat Street in 2017 dies of heart attack, says daughter Singapore Man who stalked woman blasted by judge on appeal for asking scandalous questions in court A Gallup poll released last week found that 69% of Ukrainians favor a negotiated end to the war as soon as possible. However, around the same number believe fighting won't end soon. "Every path to peace is built through negotiations," said another 58th Brigade soldier, call sign Champion, sitting inside an armoured vehicle. "But I cannot say that tomorrow there will be peace just like that... Because the enemy continues to creep in." Trump said his talks with Putin would be "a feel-out meeting" and that he would tell the Russian leader to "end this war". But he also hinted that he may walk away and let the two sides continue fighting. Other Ukrainian troops training in the Kharkiv region also welcomed a ceasefire, but said the Kremlin would need to be forced into making peace. "Until Russia suffers losses big enough to give up the idea of military pressure on us, (fighting) will continue," said an instructor from the 43rd Separate Mechanised Brigade, whose call sign is Snail. "We will not be able to stop this otherwise." REUTERS
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
What deal might emerge from Trump-Putin summit and could it hold?
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Russian traditional nesting dolls, known as Matryoshkas, with images of Russian President Vladimir Putin and U.S. President Donald Trump are placed on a shelf during a demonstration at a gift shop in central Moscow, Russia, August 12, 2025. REUTERS/Yulia Morozova U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin will discuss a possible deal to end the war in Ukraine when they meet on Friday in Alaska for a summit that is also likely to affect wider European security. European leaders and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy plan to speak with Trump on Wednesday amid fears that Washington, hitherto Ukraine's leading arms supplier, may seek to dictate unfavourable peace terms to Kyiv. WHAT KIND OF DEAL COULD EMERGE FROM SUMMIT? Trump said last Friday that there would be "some swapping of territories to the betterment of both". This prompted consternation in Kyiv and European capitals that Russia could be rewarded for 11 years of efforts - the last three in full-blown war - to seize Ukrainian land. It occupies about 19% of Ukraine. Ukraine controls no Russian territory. "It's a reasonable concern to think that Trump will be bamboozled by Putin and cut a terrible deal at Ukraine's expense," said Daniel Fried, a former senior U.S. diplomat now with the Atlantic Council think-tank. But "better outcomes" for Ukraine were possible if Trump and his team "wake up to the fact that Putin is still playing them". Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Luxury items seized in $3b money laundering case handed over to Deloitte for liquidation Singapore MyRepublic customers air concerns over broadband speed after sale to StarHub Singapore Power switchboard failure led to disruption in NEL, Sengkang-Punggol LRT services: SBS Transit Singapore NEL and Sengkang-Punggol LRT resume service after hours-long power fault Business Ninja Van cuts 12% of Singapore workforce after 2 rounds of layoffs in 2024 Singapore Hyflux investigator 'took advantage' of Olivia Lum's inability to recall events: Davinder Singh Singapore Man who stabbed son-in-law to death in Boon Tat Street in 2017 dies of heart attack, says daughter Singapore Man who stalked woman blasted by judge on appeal for asking scandalous questions in court One could entail agreeing an "armistice line" instead of a transfer of territory, with only de facto - not legal - recognition of Russia's current gains. Any sustainable peace deal would also have to tackle such issues as future security guarantees for Ukraine, its aspirations to join NATO, the restrictions demanded by Moscow on the size of its military, and the future of Western sanctions on Russia. Trump has not commented on those issues since announcing the summit with Putin, though his administration has said Ukraine cannot join NATO. Diplomats say there is an outside possibility that Trump might instead strike a unilateral deal with Putin, prioritising lucrative energy contracts and potential arms control accords. Trump himself has said he might conclude in Alaska that a Ukraine peace deal cannot be done. The White House did not respond to a request for comment on the possibility of Trump clinching a unilateral deal with Putin. WHAT IF UKRAINE OBJECTS TO ANY TRUMP-PUTIN DEAL? Trump would face strong resistance from Zelenskiy and his European allies if any deal expected Ukraine to cede territory. Zelenskiy says Ukraine's constitution prohibits such an outcome unless there is a referendum to change it. Trump could try to coerce Kyiv to accept such a deal by threatening to stop arms supplies and intelligence sharing. But analysts say there is more chance Ukraine might accept a freezing of battlelines and an unstable, legally non-binding partition. One European official told Reuters that, even if Trump did renege on recent promises to resume arms supplies to Ukraine, he was likely to continue allowing Europe to buy U.S. weapons on Ukraine's behalf. "The loss of U.S. intelligence capabilities would be the hardest element to replace. Europe can't even come close to providing that support," said the official, speaking on condition of anonymity. HOW MIGHT A DEAL AFFECT TRUMP'S SUPPORT AT HOME? There would be big political risks in the U.S. for Trump in abandoning Ukraine, said John Herbst, a former U.S. ambassador to Kyiv, now with the Atlantic Council. This would portray him as "an accomplice in Putin's rape of Ukraine ... I don't think Trump wants to be seen that way, for sure", he said. Despite his strong political position at home, Trump would also come under fire even from parts of the American right if he were to be seen as caving in to Russia. "To reward Putin ... would be to send the exact opposite message that we must be sending to dictators, and would-be-dictators, across the globe," Brian Fitzpatrick, a Republican lawmaker and former FBI agent, said on X last week. HOW MIGHT UKRAINE'S EUROPEAN ALLIES RESPOND? EU member states said on Tuesday that Ukraine must be free to decide its own future and that they were ready to contribute further to security guarantees for Kyiv. Oana Lungescu, a former NATO spokesperson now with the RUSI think-tank, said European states must move much faster to arm Ukraine, and start EU accession talks in September. Jana Kobzova, senior policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said that "... if an unacceptable deal emerges from Alaska, European capitals will go into yet another diplomatic and charm offensive vis-a-vis Trump". "European leaders are increasingly aware that the future of Ukraine's security is inseparable from that of the rest of Europe - and they can't let Putin alone decide its future shape and form." REUTERS
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Ukraine says fighting ‘difficult' after reports of Russia's rapid gains
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Residents are evacuated by bus from the front-line town of Dobropillia, in Ukraine's eastern Donetsk region, on Aug 10. KYIV - Ukraine said on Aug 12 it was engaged in 'difficult' battles with Russian forces after Moscow had made rapid advances in a narrow but important section of the front line in the country's east. The gains came just days before US President Donald Trump was to meet Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in Alaska for talks on the war, the first meeting between a sitting US and Russian leader since 2021. The Ukrainian army said it was engaged in 'heavy' battles with Russian forces attempting to penetrate its defences. 'The situation is difficult and dynamic,' it said in a statement. A map published by Ukrainian battlefield monitor DeepState, which has close ties with Ukraine's military, showed Russia had advanced around 10km over around two days, deep into a narrow section of the eastern front line. The corridor – now apparently under Russian control – threatens the town of Dobropillia, a mining hub that civilians are fleeing and that has come under Russian drone attacks. It also further isolates the destroyed town of Kostiantynivka, one of the last large urban areas in the Donetsk region still held by Ukraine. 'New offensive operations' The Institute for the Study of War, a US-based observatory, said Russia was sending small sabotage groups forwards. It said it was 'premature' to call the Russian advances in around Dobropillia 'an operational-level breakthrough'. The military's Operational-Tactical Group Donetsk, which oversees parts of the front in the industrial region, also said Russia was probing Ukrainian lines with small sabotage groups, describing battles as 'complex, unpleasant and dynamic'. Mr Trump has described his summit with Mr Putin on Aug 15 as a chance to check the Russian leader's ideas for ending the war. Ukrainian leader Volodymyr Zelensky warned ahead of the talks that Moscow was laying the groundwork for further attacks, after Mr Trump said on Aug 11 that both sides would have to swop territory for peace. European leaders have, meanwhile, sought to ensure respect for Kyiv's interests. 'We see that the Russian army is not preparing to end the war. On the contrary, they are making movements that indicate preparations for new offensive operations,' Mr Zelensky said in a statement on social media. Russia, which invaded Ukraine in 2022, has made costly but incremental gains across the sprawling front in recent months and claims to have annexed four Ukrainian regions while still fighting to control them. Ukrainian police, meanwhile, said that Russian attacks in the past hours had killed three people and wounded 12 others, including a child. AFP
