Failing to recognise Palestinian state 'rewards' Israel
Australia has begun co-ordinating with other nations on the issue as France, Canada and the UK prepare to recognise the state of Palestine at a United Nations meeting in September amid a humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Though the federal government has said recognition is a matter of "when, not if", it has been hesitant to commit to a deadline and the coalition has raised concerns such an action could be seen as a reward for designated terrorist organisation Hamas.
But Australia's former ambassador to Israel Peter Rodgers dismissed such arguments as "nonsensical", noting there were "nasty people" on both the Israeli and Palestinian sides.
"Not recognising a Palestinian state rewards Israel," he told ABC radio on Thursday.
"It rewards the government of Benjamin Netanyahu for ethnic cleansing and apartheid in the West Bank.
"We need to be very careful of pointing the finger in one direction and forgetting what's going on, on the other side."
A genocide case has been brought against Israel at the International Court of Justice, which is yet to rule on the matter, but Mr Netanyahu's office called the allegations "false and outrageous" and his government has repeatedly claimed it only targets Hamas and not civilians.
More than 50,000 children have been killed or injured by Israel since October 2023, UNICEF said.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has said the recognition of Palestine would need to guarantee Hamas played no role in the future nation, and Foreign Minister Penny Wong has repeatedly emphasised the Palestinian Authority has condemned and sought to distance themselves from the terrorist group.
Hamas has effectively governed Gaza since violently defeating the political party Fatah, which now controls the Palestinian Authority that exercises partial civil control in the West Bank.
The Palestinian Authority is currently "pretty useless", Mr Rodgers said, but recognition could provide an avenue for change.
"There is an opportunity to work with other Palestinians, to work towards reforming the Palestinian Authority ... giving it meaningful power," he said.
Mr Albanese spoke with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas on Tuesday, when he reiterated Australia's commitment to a two-state solution in the Middle East that would allow Palestine and Israel to co-exist, before discussing the two-state solution with French President Emmanuel Macron.
"The entire international community is distressed by what we're seeing happening in Gaza," he told reporters in Melbourne.
"We want to see commitments from the Palestinian Authority - commitments of their governance (and) reforms."
More than two million people in Gaza are now facing high levels of food insecurity, United Nations sources have found.
Israel denies there is starvation in the besieged strip despite international human rights groups decrying its offensive in Gaza and attributing deaths to starvation.
Mr Rodgers was one of many former Australian diplomats who signed an open letter to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, which is being circulated on social media, calling on Australia to urgently recognise a state of Palestine.
More than 140 of the 193 UN member states already recognise the state of Palestine, including European Union member states Spain and Ireland.
Violence in Gaza reignited after Hamas killed 1200 people in Israel and took about 250 hostages on October 7, 2023.
Israel's military response has since killed 60,000 people, according to local health authorities.
Opposition home affairs spokesman Andrew Hastie has taken issue with pro-Palestine protests.
Tens of thousands of Australians took part in pro-Palestine protests over the weekend, including at least 90,000 who rallied at the Sydney Harbour Bridge, and both Students for Palestine and the National Union of Students have called for students to walk out of class on Thursday as part of a demonstration.
Opposition home affairs spokesman Andrew Hastie has taken issue with domestic protests.
"This is Australia. Not the Middle East," he said in an interview with Sky News posted on his social media.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AU Financial Review
14 minutes ago
- AU Financial Review
Palestinian recognition possible without wiping out Hamas: Burke
The federal government could recognise a Palestinian state even with Hamas still operating in Gaza, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke has indicated, citing diplomatic relations continuing with Iraq and Syria when they were controlled by ISIS. Australia over the weekend joined Britain, New Zealand, Germany and Italy to 'strongly reject' the Israeli government's decision to launch a gradual military takeover of the full Gaza Strip.
Sky News AU
4 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Tony Burke says Hamas sympathiser who had visa cancelled after praising October 7 attacks applied for entertainment visa
Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke has confirmed that Mona Zahed, a Palestinian woman who praised Hamas' October 7 attacks against Israel was initially given an entertainment visa as opposed to a humanitarian visa. A Palestinian woman who showered Hamas with praise for their brutal October 7 attacks on Israel had her visa cancelled by the Home Affairs Department on Friday. Following the Coalition's call for Tony Burke to step down over the visa's approval, a Home Affairs spokesperson said on Friday afternoon "The department has advised ... that the visa was cancelled today - the reasons have been communicated directly to the applicant." Ms Zahed also posted a photo on Instagram of Israeli festival goers fleeing for their lives on October 7 with the caption 'Praise be to Allah who has kept us alive to see this day'. In a bizarre twist to the disturbing saga, Mr Burke told Sky News Australia's Political Editor Andrew Clenell on Sunday that the woman had initially been granted an entertainment visa by DFAT authorities, bypassing routine character checks as a result. 'This was someone from Gaza who was not going through the humanitarian visa process that we've got in place, or even for a visitor visa for that matter, but who'd applied on the entertainment stream,' Mr Burke said. Mr Burke said the woman was not eligible to receive the visa, and that as a result her application was not immediately cancelled on character grounds. 'The presumption of that visa is you are coming for a fixed tour, where the tickets are being sold, the dates are all in place, and your intention is then to return to the country you came from,' Mr Burke said. 'This was a very unusual visa application and it was a visa she was not eligible for. Entertainment and humanitarian visas are designed for entirely different purposes, with the entrainment visa requiring proof of skills in the entertainment industry while the humanitarian visa states for applicants to show that they are at risk of serious harm or persecution. The entertainment visa is typically a temporary visa and valid for the duration of the specific entertainment event while the humanitarian visa usually results in permanent settlement in Australia. Mr Burke reiterated that as soon as senior officials at Home Affairs were made aware the woman had made an 'entertainment' visa application her submission was cancelled on the spot. 'As soon as it was brought to the attention of people more senior in the department, they looked at it and thought hang on, this individual is not eligible for this particular visa,' Mr Burke said. He said her visa was cancelled before the department could progress to the character grounds stage. 'So had we got to eligibility and then we got the character stage, there's a few things that would have had to be unpacked and worked through.' Although about 3,000 visas across a broad stream have so far been granted to Palestinians fleeing the ongoing conflict in Gaza Mr Burke said, 'about half the people for whom visas had been issued ended up getting here.' Mr Burke said this was due to a myriad of factors including people deciding that they did not want to flee to Australia, some people being trapped in Gaza and some of the visa recipients no longer being live. 'We're still in a situation where they are not able to leave, the borders are closed and some of them have very close family in Australia, they face real challenges and have very direct family connections,' he said. 'At least one person is longer in Australia who was brought here and the work of our security agencies in making sure we are keeping Australia safe couldn't be stronger.
Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
Key detail revealed in Hamas sympathiser visa debacle
A Hamas sympathiser in Gaza was given an Australian visa she was ineligible for, Anthony Albanese's border tsar has revealed. Palestinian woman Mona Zahed applied to come to Australia on a visa typically used for speaking tours rather than humanitarian options. Senior immigration officials noticed the error after they were alerted to social media posts Ms Zahed made celebrating Hamas' October 7 attacks on Israel in 2023. Due to the wrong visa type, Home Affairs and Immigration Minister Tony Burke said on Sunday that Ms Zahed's application was cancelled 'before we even got to character grounds'. Mr Burke has said NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia 'Before we even got to the character grounds issue, she wasn't eligible for the visa that had been issued and the department administratively cancelled the visa,' Mr Burke told Sky News, calling the application 'unusual'. 'This was someone from Gaza who was not going through the humanitarian visa process that we've got in place, or even for a visitor visa for that matter, but who'd applied on the entertainment stream, where the presumption of that visa is you are coming for a fixed tour, where the tickets are being sold, the dates are all in place, and your intention is then to return to the country you came from. 'Now, you can see a few reasons there why as soon as it was brought to … the attention of people more senior in the department, they looked at it and thought, 'Hang on, this individual is not eligible for this particular visa.'' As for the thousands of Palestinians who have been granted visas since the start of the war in Gaza, Mr Burke insisted all approved had been double-checked. He also said only 'about half the people … for whom visas had been issued ended up actually getting here' because of border closures. The figure is unclear, but human rights groups have put it at about 1300. 'We would have had something in the order of close to 1000 visas where people were trapped in Gaza,' Mr Burke said, adding that those stuck in Gaza had dropped to 'not too much more' than half of that. 'Now some of that will be that people decided they didn't want to come to Australia, some of it will be people (who) found another pathway out of Gaza, some of it will be that those people are no longer alive. 'There's a few different reasons for the reduction in numbers. 'Overwhelmingly now the people who are in that visa group, they had the initial check against the movement alert list. 'We've had (the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation) go through everybody on the list twice now, and so they are in fact the most highly checked cohort that we've ever had.' Though, he pointed out they 'are still in a situation though, where overwhelmingly, they're not able to leave'. Ms Zahed has been living in tents with her young family for much of the 22-month war in Gaza – a conflict triggered by Hamas' October 7 attacks. The militant group killed more than 1200 in the unprecedented assault, including whole families. Fighters took hundreds more hostage as they retreated into Gaza, where dozens remain captive. The Herald Sun revealed on Friday that Ms Zahed praised the attack on social media at the time. 'We woke up and got God's kingdom,' she wrote of the worst loss of Jewish life since the Holocaust. She made her visa application with the support of Melbourne artist Matt Chun, who claims to have raised tens of thousands of dollars to help Ms Zahed, her husband and four children make their way to Australia. Hamas is a listed terrorist organisation in Australia and the Albanese government has repeatedly condemned the October 7 attacks.
