Urgent calls for KZN Cogta MEC to restore order in troubled KwaDukuza municipality
The north coast-based municipality has been plagued by reports of instability and a potential collapse since the ANC removed Lindile Nhaca as mayor in a no-confidence vote in December 2024. Nhaca's removal came after her fallout with the party's then-provincial secretary Bheki Mtolo.
She was replaced by Muzi Ngidi, who didn't last long either, before being forced out of the mayoral office by the party earlier this month, along with deputy mayor Njabulo Cele.
Ngidi had only been in office for eight months when the ANC's provincial task team (PTT) co-ordinator Mike Mabuyakhulu announced he had also been recalled after a controversial tenure that had included allegations of corruption, misuse of municipal vehicles and excessive security expenses.
The PTT announced that the two would also be liable to pay a portion of the money that the municipality spent on Ngidi's vehicle hire during their tenure.
The two were retained in their respective positions until the party and its coalition partners elected their replacements to ensure 'continuity'.
The DA and ActionSA in the council have since highlighted the impact that those actions and internal disputes in the ANC have had on the municipality.
Privi Makhan, DA caucus leader, pointed to Ngidi's continued spell in office -despite his official recall — while his party looks for a replacement as the cause of the leadership uncertainty within the municipality, which has led to last-minute cancellations of portfolio committee and EXCO meetings. That has undermined the legislative functions of the council and is affecting service delivery, he said.
'Caretaker mayor Ngidi however appears exceedingly content to play the role of ceremonial figurehead, attending public events and persevering with his handshaking exercises, while refusing to take political responsibility for the legislative crisis unfolding under his watch. It has become increasingly clear that between him and his cabal, he remains hell-bent on collapsing the municipality, which is reminiscent of his eight-month tenure in office,' said Makhan.
'KwaDukuza is not a pawn in the ANC's internal political games. Communities are being denied basic services, as a result of Ngidi's disdain for a decision made by his own movement.
'This political circus, created and sustained by the ANC, must come to an end. KwaDukuza needs stable, accountable leadership, not more chaos driven by internal ANC dysfunction.'
He called on Buthelezi to intervene to ensure stability in the municipality.
ActionSA councillor Halalisani Ndlovu expressed similar sentiments. Ndlovu wrote a letter to the department requesting an urgent intervention in the 'ongoing collapse of governance and oversight' in KwaDukuza.
She said her main cause for concern was the collapse of the financial and local public administration and human resources (FLPA) committee, which oversees critical functions like expenditure monitoring, procurement and budget implementation as per the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA).
'The committee last met on June 4 . Since then, no meetings have been convened to consider matters for June or July. The July 25 meeting was abruptly postponed with no explanation or alternative date provided. The next scheduled sitting is only on August 20, meaning three consecutive months of oversight will be lost,' she said.
'This is a dereliction of duty that threatens the very integrity of the municipality's governance and financial accountability.'
She added that executive directors had also missed committee meetings, often without formal apologies or explanations, which have added to the crisis within the committee.
'This reflects a blatant disregard for institutional responsibilities and the accountability obligations of senior officials.
'As a result, oversight over the municipality's finances has collapsed. Our fiduciary duty as councillors and members of the finance committee to monitor procurement and performance processes has ground to a halt, and the public interest is being severely undermined.'
Ndlovu said Ngidi served as a chairperson for the FLPA committee, and the uncertainty around him and the mayoral position was at the centre of this crisis.
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
34 minutes ago
- The Herald
Bay acting electricity boss dragged out of office by staff
Nelson Mandela Bay's acting executive director of electricity and energy, Tholi Biyela, was forcibly removed from his office at the Munelek building on Tuesday by disgruntled officials who accused him of undermining them and ruling with an iron fist. A large group of officials, accompanied by leaders of the South African Municipal Workers Union (Samwu), stormed Biyela's office, demanding his resignation from the position. His removal was preceded by a union meeting. During the meeting, officials voiced their dissatisfaction with Biyela, and a resolution was passed to remove him from office. Acting city manager Ted Pillay has since called a top-level management meeting for Wednesday to discuss the issue and workers' grievances. Samwu shop steward Ayanda Solani said Biyela allegedly undermined engineers who had worked in the city for years by starting a process to appoint Eskom as an independent contractor. 'On top of this, Eskom will also bring its service providers to work on the municipal infrastructure,' Solani said. 'It is as if we are not capable of doing the work we studied for and have been doing all our professional lives. 'This partnership means that Eskom will be procuring material on behalf of the municipality and will attend to electricity faults at a cost. 'This will cost the municipality twice for the same job.' Solani said Biyela wrote a memorandum and prepared a service level agreement that just needed Pillay's approval. 'The turnaround strategy [for the electricity directorate] has not been presented and agreed with the unions, but Biyela is ready to present it at the next standing committee.' Solani said they were unhappy with Biyela calling a meeting to address workers without Samwu, in which he bashed the union. Biyela has been at odds with some officials in the directorate who have previously accused him of threatening their lives when he said in a meeting that 'lives will be shed'. On the other hand, Biyela opened a case with the police in July after receiving an anonymous phone call from a stranger who said 'You won't see the sun rise tomorrow'. Working relations between Biyela and staff have created unfavourable conditions for all parties involved. Biyela did not respond to a request for comment. Electricity and energy political head Ziyanda Mnqokoyi said, based on information they had received, the only concern raised with Biyela was that staff did not want him in the post. 'The Eskom issue is new to me. 'However, if this concern was raised by the workers regarding the involvement of Eskom in certain technical operations, it has been noted. 'It is important to clarify that the municipality, like many others across the country, occasionally engages with Eskom or other entities when specialised or high-risk technical assistance is required, particularly in instances where the stability of the local grid or resident safety may be at stake. 'This is not a reflection on the competency of our internal teams but rather a strategic step to augment capacity and ensure service continuity.' Regarding allegations about Biyela's management style, Mnqokoyi said they would be investigated through the proper channels. 'I will work closely with the city manager and labour representatives to restore calm, address underlying concerns and ensure that the interests of the residents remain the top priority.' When the reporter arrived at Munelek, one of the workers who spoke at the gathering said Biyela made their work harder and would confront subordinates over office gossip. 'Biyela is entertaining gossip and threatening to suspend people,' the worker said. 'He has a bullying kind of leadership style. 'His appointment as acting executive director with only five months in the metro was a huge disaster. 'He comes from a small local municipality in Knysna and has no experience of running a metro department. 'To add to that, he doesn't have experience and is not mature.' A second worker said Biyela, by bringing Eskom in, was saying they could not do their jobs. 'Many of our colleagues are on leave because they can't deal with his leadership style of threatening people. 'We can't continue like this. 'He must go and we will continue doing our jobs as we have been all along.' Municipal spokesperson Sithembiso Soyaya condemned Biyela's removal. He said such conduct undermined the law, workplace discipline and institutional processes to resolve disputes. 'We can confirm that an unlawful incident involving the forceful removal of Biyela occurred this morning,' Soyaya said. 'This is being investigated and dealt with through the appropriate legal and disciplinary channels. 'Security and legal measures are being put in place to ensure Biyela's safety and to prevent any recurrence of such incidents. 'Leadership appointments follow formal governance processes and decisions cannot be made through unlawful or coercive means. 'Biyela's acting contract remains valid until further notice or formal review by the city manager, who has the delegated authority in this regard.'
Mail & Guardian
4 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Kenny Kenene ordered to say sorry for calling Julius Malema a cockroach
Suspended Patriotic Allianc deputy president Kenny Kunene. (X) The high court in Johannesburg has ruled that suspended Patriotic Alliance (PA) deputy leader On Tuesday, the court ordered that Kunene issue an unconditional written and oral public apology to Malema, adding that the apology must unequivocally retract the use of the word 'cockroach' to describe the Red Berets leader. It said the apologies must be published within one month of the date of the order and also ordered Kunene to pay the costs for Malema's legal team. The high court upheld an earlier ruling by the eNCA . Judge Motsamai Makume ruled that Kunene's remarks constituted hate speech under the Equality Act. Kunene's comments in the eNCA interview followed Malema's reference to the PA as a party led by 'mapantiti', which loosely translates to 'convicts', after the party decided to work with the ANC in several municipalities across the country. Both Kunene and PA leader Gayton McKenzie are convicted criminals. Last month, Kunene Mail & Guardian that Malema would not get a cent from him as compensation for calling him a cockroach. 'There's not a cent he's going to get from me. I've never ever apologised. I can't apologise to this young boy. He insults people all the time, then just runs to court,' a defiant Kunene said at the time. He said that he found it strange that calling the EFF leader a cockroach was deemed hate speech, while Malema's continued use of the 'Kill the Boer, Kill the Farmer' chant at rallies has been ruled not to be so. In a statement on Tuesday, EFF spokesperson Thambo said the pair's inability to discern the difference between political language and discourse, and blatant hateful rhetoric rooted in historical instances of genocide, was a reflection of that. Kunene had argued in court that the term 'cockroach' was valid if read in response to Malema's remarks regarding the inclusion of ex-convicts in government in the form Kunene and the PA, however the court dismissed his claims. 'The court rightly referred to these [Malema's] comments as having been made in good faith and interpretable as a reflection of concern for public interest, as it is a fact that Kunene and his party leader are indeed ex-convicts,' Thambo said. 'To state this objective fact in reflection of a political agreement which includes ex-convicts in government is acceptable in political discourse.'
Mail & Guardian
6 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
How Trump's tariffs exposed South Africa's strategic trade failures
The Trump' administration's trade tariffs have shaken the rand. Photo: File The United States' 30% tariff on South Africa — set to take effect on 1 August 2025 but pushed back seven days — is a grave blow for those diligently modelling costs, yet a distant abstraction for many South Africans who are yet to grasp its economic gravity. Regrettably, in South Africa global economic shocks typically register as background noise, their causes unexamined, their consequences only recognised when unavoidable. Before dissecting our strategic missteps, let's make these abstract forces tangible. Consider first how US President Donald Trump's threats of tariffs shook the rand's foundations in July alone. The currency exhibited heightened volatility, opening at R17.59 before plunging 2.6% to R18.04 by month-end, as markets priced in the impending tariffs. Three distinct phases can be identified: the initial 7 July drop to R17.74 (-1%) on Trump's Brics surcharge threat, a mid-month slump to R17.89 as exemption hopes faded and the final 1.5% 24 to 31 July drop when tariff implementation became certain. Let's also appreciate trade and industry in this context. The South African Revenue Service's Cumulative Trade Report for January to June 2025 revealed that SA exported R68.8 billion worth of goods to the US. Trump's tariffs will probably disproportionately target critical sectors like vehicles and transport equipment (R11.4 billion); machinery (R3.8 billion); iron and steel products (R10.9 billion); chemicals (R4.8 billion) and plastics (R644 million). Despite exempt categories, such as precious metals and iron ores, several mineral categories will suffer, including processed steel, machinery components and industrial chemicals, risking R31.5 billion in vulnerable exports. If these impacts remain abstract, consider the tangible consequences — currency depreciation and trade disruptions will send prices of basic goods soaring, devastate jobs in the auto and mining industries, deepen inequality, shutter factories at an alarming rate, fuel inflationary fires and ignite political instability as economic hardship erodes public trust. Clearly, these repercussions span economic, political and social spheres, raising pressing questions about whether the state could have taken stronger measures to mitigate the coming storm. The evidence suggests decisive action was both possible and necessary. While competent trade negotiation reflects able governance, truly strategic trade diplomacy remains an elusive art — one whose absence we feel acutely in these turbulent economic waters. A few months back, while Washington's theatrics over South Africa's land reform policies dominated headlines, the real tragedy unfolded quietly – that is, the country's mineral baiting approach to trade talks which ultimately ought to have been seen by our government as doomed from inception. Why so? Because Trump's global trade warfare primarily stems from geopolitical anxiety over dwindling US hegemony, not sound economic logic. In such a context, no mineral concessions could sway Washington. Rather than this futile approach, we should have been aggressively pursuing market diversification, accelerating regional industrial partnerships and building shock-absorbent trade architectures. Far from wishful thinking, this has been a deliberate strategic pivot by pragmatic emerging economies. For example, shortly after Trump announced reciprocal tariffs, Southeast Asian states like Cambodia aggressively diversified trade partners through South-South cooperation and the 'China+1' strategy, transforming tariff threats into opportunities. These nations retain their edge as export manufacturing hubs, where labour cost advantages outweigh protectionist headwinds. Regrettably, this was a storm we might have weathered — had we possessed the strategic foresight to act early. Instead, we'll spend the coming quarters, perhaps years, paying for missed opportunities, while our trade and diplomatic machinery scrambles merely to recover lost ground. Siseko Maposa is the director of Surgetower Associates Management Consultancy. The views expressed are his own.
