Bill aims to minimize treatment delays for North Dakota patients
The first thing that came to people's minds about Shanna was her smile. It was warm, inviting and just the right amount of mischievous.
Her family didn't think much of her fall in September; maybe she missed a step off the deck. She had a headache but nothing so bad that it needed medical treatment.
That changed on Sept. 19 when Shanna was life-flighted from Carrington to Fargo with stroke symptoms. After imaging, a neurosurgeon performed an emergency craniotomy, removing part of a tumor applying pressure to the brain. They saw three more inoperable spots. Initial reports determined it was likely lymphoma, but her care team was optimistic.
She was a healthy 40-year-old mother, and lymphoma is treatable. I finished my own cancer treatment a year prior. It was breast cancer spread to lymph nodes, so not the same certainly, but I became fiercely protective of my cousin. I was ready to be involved however she needed me to be.
We lost my cousin Shanna Barone on Feb. 6, less than five months after the first sign of trouble. It was grueling and heartbreaking and perhaps there was nothing that could have been done to save her life, but dealing with the insurance company's prior authorization requirements certainly cost us time in a process where – aside from cancer — time was perhaps our greatest adversary.
Prior authorization is a practice in which physicians must obtain approval from insurers before prescribing medication or moving forward with treatment for their patients. Insurers use this, in part, to contain costs. Physicians report the process can lead to significant delays in care, contributing to negative outcomes in patients, including abandoned treatment. The process was once used sparingly to determine whether costly medical procedures or medications were needed but now providers often must get approval to prescribe even the most routine medications and procedures.
This is why I have testified in support of North Dakota Senate Bill 2280, which will place limits on the amount of time insurers can take to make prior authorization decisions. Such limits could have curtailed at least some of the delays faced by Shanna.
Senate Bill 2280 has a hearing at 2:30 p.m. Monday in Room 327C of the Capitol. Testimony can be submitted online until 1:30 p.m. Monday.
Her team of oncologists submitted prior authorization requests for aggressive chemotherapy and a PET scan upon admittance. She didn't get approval and receive those services until Oct. 3 – an 11-day wait. The PET scan determined a mass in her abdomen, so a prior authorization request was sent for another chemotherapy regimen that would address that as well. She wasn't approved until Oct. 11 – eight days.
Her oncologists remained vigilant and switched the plan on Nov. 18. They wanted a better response, so they switched to R-ICE, a combination of four chemotherapy drugs given over several days. They would follow with CAR-T cell therapy, a process that usually takes between three and four weeks to complete.
On Jan. 2, Shanna's oncologists submitted the prior authorization request for CAR-T because they knew she would need it sooner than later. Her symptoms increased daily. She lost vision in her left eye, then movement and feeling on that side, then her speech. Her skull skin was so tight around the growing tumor it was shiny.
Radiation began then also to buy time waiting for approval. By Jan. 5, she was admitted to the hospital and would never leave.
On Jan. 10 – two weeks after the initial physician request — Shanna got 'soft approval' for CAR-T from the insurance company, but they 'couldn't' sign off by the end of the business day and told us to wait until the next week. Formal approval was received on Jan. 14 and the lab processes were completed by Jan. 29.
By then, she had declined, so she had to undergo another surgery to place a shunt in her skull to relieve pressure. We were so encouraged by her response — she was responsive and spoke clearly for the first time in weeks. But two days later she declined again. Additional cancer cells had been allowed to grow during the period she waited for approval.
Shanna passed away Feb. 7, 11 days after her 41st birthday.
Shanna knew her battle would be hard, but she went into it with fiery determination, an intelligent, compassionate care team and family support.
Her life depended on decisions she didn't get to make, ones that increased suffering and anxiety in the interim. If a simple set of laws can prevent this situation from happening to another North Dakotan, the decision to pass this bill is an easy one.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
11 hours ago
- USA Today
Question of the Week: How concerned are you about dengue fever?
How concerned are you about dengue fever? Editor's note: It's vacation time. That means you'll have two weeks to make your voice heard on today's topic. Question of the Week will return on Sunday, Aug. 31. I live beachside and have for 20 years. This is literally the first year I've had to buy citronella candles to ward off mosquitos in my backyard. Actually, my front porch rockers have seen little use this year because of those blood-sucking pests as well. Other than the annoying buzzing in the ear and pinches of pain, I never really gave the loathsome insect much thought. Until now, that is. As reported by my colleague, Jim Waymer, experts are puzzled at why a disease ― spread by mosquitoes ― that typically affects the tropics has made its way to Brevard County for the first I'm talking about dengue fever. The Florida Health Department has confirmed eight cases of the illness here on the Space Coast, a number that might be higher by the time you read this. Dengue fever? Sounds like something from a Tarzan movie. What's next, malaria? According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, dengue fever can cause flu-like symptoms ―including severe muscle aches and joint pain, fever, and maybe even a rash-- ranging from mild to potentially fatal if left untreated. It takes about two weeks for symptoms to start showing up. Great. Another thing to worry about. This dengue fever news came out a few days before World Mosquito Day on Aug. 20. No, it's not a celebration of the deadly insect, but rather a day to recognize the deadly impact on global health this insect has. Mosquito expert Gordon Patterson wrote a column this week about the simple things we can do to minimize risk of getting a mosquito-borne disease. The main thing is to eliminate standing water on your property, like open trash bins that have collected rain. This is where mosquitoes breed, lay eggs. I'm not gonna lie, I'm concerned about the number of mosquitoes I'm seeing lately and this tropical illness that has come to our county. I'm curious to know what you think about it. And that brings us to the Question of the Week: Are you concerned about mosquito-borne illnesses, like dengue fever? Why or why not? You can scan the QR code that is on the print edition page or go to Please leave a comment telling us why you voted the way you did. In order for your comment or email to be published on our website and in next week's print edition, you must include your first and last name. You can also shoot me an email with "mosquito" in the subject line. I look forward to reading your responses. Last Sunday I asked: Is the Department of Homeland Security out of line in trying to recruit local officers assisting them during immigration sweeps? Why or why not? Results: Your comments: I don't have a problem with ICE recruiting from other law enforcement agencies, a standard practice.I do have a problem with ICE's massive, disproportional budget that puts local understaffed LEO's at a major disadvantage as they're unable to compete with lucrative offers. ICE funding allocations have also contributed to increasing the federal debt despite GOP legislators reducing funding to vital programs that serve We The People. -- Kathy Ojeda The only way to recruit is to offer incentives. Umfortimately for local authorities their departments act as a stepping stone for the officers to better themselves. Competition for employees will always result in higher wages. -- Gregory Sanders Terrible that ICE will use the good intentions of Florida Sheriffs like our Wayne Ivey. It's truly a stab in the back:. No good deed goes unpunished! But wait, the sheriffs should by now know Trump will deceive and toss anyone under his bus to get his way. Sorry sheriffs, when you sleep with the devil you get no good end. Be careful in the future what you quickly agree to. -- H.L. Singer Why not? If DHS has this much excess funding to use in recruiting, why not recruit existing LEOs? Makes sense to me. Another source for DHS would be soon to separate Military Police. I won't say this of BCSD, but usually when the term poaching is used, the 'poacher' is usually offering better working conditions, or better pay, or better benefits. -- Greg Pierce 80,000 have already applied, no need to poach. -- John Weller It's called competition. As an exteme example, a few AI techno-nerds are the beneficiaries of NBA-like salaries. Yes, ICE recruiting creates problems on the local level but for now it's good to be a cop for a change! Disclaimer: I am neither a cop nor even related to one. -- John Pare This is still, at least for now, a free country. Everyone has the right to offer, receive, and consider job opportunities. There are too many politicians that want to control everything. And why wouldn't we want individuals to advance their careers and improve their financial situation? It seems personal rights and free speech matter only when things go your way. I also want our best to stay local, but they have free will. -- Jennifer A. Roberts Not only is ICE out of line recruiting, but offering the incentives of money, power and weapons surely attract the wrong individuals for the job. It seems they are following orders that defy our Constitution, enabled by a President who has chosen to ignore that document. -- Linda Moore A secret police force should not exist in the United States. This mirrors the beginning of the Nazi takeover of Germany. It continues with the assault on freedom of the press, the universities, and voting rights. All of this is the Nazi playbook. Wake up! -- Catherine Kornek ICE recruitment efforts are part of the free market. While viewed as bad taste by Sheriff Ivey, I view it as opportunity to help the country while promoting excellent Sheriff deputies and opening up opportunities for more local and regional recruitment by Sheriff Ivey. This means he will have to be more competitive and the County will pay more which overall will lift the Police community through higher pay, bonuses and benefits. -- Brian Wilkins Our Governor and most County and City law enforcement agencies and some State agencies such as FWC, have proudly helped detain and deport illegals including those with not even a speeding ticket. They also likely supported ICE's expansion. How could these patriotic action backfire? Well this support for ICE will weaken most law enforcement agencies as they raid lower paying law enforcement agencies. Local law enforcement wages are low and constrained by an unwillingness to raise property taxes. Now there will be more pressure to raise those wages and more property taxes to pay for them. Meanwhile our Governor wants to eliminate property taxes and raise other taxes which would be controlled by the State. This will make our counties go to the State to beg for tax money that will apparently come from a substantial increase in sales taxes. Meanwhile the State DOGE will cut funding for all counties. Instead of complaining, Sheriffs like Ivey should be proud that ICE values their employees. Local law enforcement will just have to do more with less. Because we deserve quick response by our law enforcement officials. -- Anthony Carrollo Contact Torres at jtorres@ You can follow him on X @johnalbertorres Multimedia editor Rob Landers contributed to this report. Support local journalism and become a subscriber. Visit
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
Tennessee Hiker killed by venomous snake bite in state park after picking up the deadly reptile
A hiker was killed from a rare but venomous rattlesnake bite after he made the mistake of picking up the reptile. The unidentified male hiker, who was in Tennessee's Savage Gulf State Park on Aug. 8, picked up what was likely a Timber rattlesnake, which has 'venom potent enough to kill a human,' but whose 'bites are rare,' according to the National Zoo. 'According to witnesses, the hiker had picked the Rattlesnake up resulting in a bite to his hand,' Matthew Griffith of the Grundy County Emergency Management Agency said in a statement to Fox News Digital. The hike was believed to have suffered an allergic reaction, although his actual cause of death has not been made public, Griffith said. Multiple agencies, including fire and rescue workers, EMS members and park rangers, arrived at the park, around a half-mile down the trail, at around 12:30 p.m., according to CBS. Timber rattlesnake bites are rare, according to the National Zoo. Getty Images Multiple agencies, including fire and rescue workers, EMS members and park rangers, reported to the scene. Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images CPR was then performed on the hiker, who was taken to a hospital where he 'later succumbed to his injuries.' Griffith warned of the precautionary measures hikers should take when outdoors and in proximity to poisonous animals. 'As always it's strongly recommended to have some kind of first aid supplies while enjoying outdoor recreational activities and be mindful of wildlife and the dangers that some wildlife may pose,' he told the outlet. 'If you encounter a snake, simply remain calm and do not attempt to handle it. If bitten, seek immediate medical attention.' It is still unclear why the hiker picked up the animal.
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
The ‘Nordic diet' can help you lose weight and prevent heart attacks — stock up on these foods
Forget the Mediterranean — the land of snow and salmon is serving up a fresh way to eat that gives your heart a healthy boost. A growing body of research suggests the Nordic diet can help trim your waist, tame your cholesterol levels and keep your blood pressure in check. That could be a game-changer in the fight against cardiovascular disease, which kills an American every 34 seconds. 4 The Nordic diet is packed with fiber, fatty fish and cold-weather produce. Getty Images This northern European way of eating leans heavily on whole foods that retain their natural nutrients, in sharp contrast to the US food supply, where up to 70% is ultraprocessed. It revolves around seasonal, locally sourced ingredients found across Nordic nations like Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden. '[The Vikings] were limited to the foods available to them at the time,' Lauren Harris-Pincus, a registered dietitian, told Fox News. 'Their diet focused on clean, sustainable foods, which is why we are discussing its health benefits today.' Like the Mediterranean diet — long hailed for its heart-healthy power — the Nordic style is plant-forward, high in fiber and packed with seafood. 4 Fatty fish are excellent sources of omega-3 fatty acids, which are linked to reduced risk of heart disease. artemidovna – But while the Greeks rely on olive oil, the northern approach leans on rapeseed (or canola) oil, another heart-friendly monounsaturated fat, according to Harvard Health. Rapeseed oil is also a source of alpha-linolenic acid, a plant-based omega-3 fatty acid similar to the kind found in fatty fish like salmon, mackerel, sardines and herring — all staples of the Nordic kitchen. Followers typically eat two to three servings of these fish each week. The omega-3s delivered by both the oil and fish have been shown to reduce the risk of heart rhythm issues, slow plaque buildup in arteries and lower fat levels in the blood, key factors in protecting cardiovascular health. The Nordic diet also emphasizes low-fat dairy, such as yogurt, and incorporates eggs and poultry in moderation. Red and processed meats, on the other hand, rarely make it onto the plate. 4 Root vegetables are loaded with vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and fiber. Viktor Iden – Whole grains such as oats, barley and rye are another cornerstone in this eating pattern. These fiber-rich 'complex' carbs digest slowly, helping to curb cravings and keep blood sugar steady — unlike refined grains in processed staples like white bread. Cold-weather veggies like turnips, carrots, parsnips, cabbage and cauliflower are also featured prominently. They're packed with fiber and nutrients that have been shown to help lower cholesterol and blood pressure. Berries like blueberries, strawberries, cranberries and lingonberries play a starring role, too. Rich in antioxidants called anthocyanins, these fruits help keep arteries flexible and may also lower blood pressure. Unlike many American eating habits, the Nordic diet also goes easy on alcohol and avoids foods high in added sugar and sodium. By avoiding processed junk, saturated fats and high-cholesterol meats while loading up on fiber-rich whole foods, studies suggest the Nordic diet can lead to significant weight loss — a major win for heart health. 4 Every year, about 805,000 people in the US have a heart attack. Pixel-Shot – In one study, people who followed the Nordic diet for just six weeks lost 4% of their body weight — significantly more than those eating a standard western diet. In another trial, people with obesity who stuck to it for six months dropped about 10 pounds — roughly triple the weight loss seen in a typical diet group. And it's not just about the scale. In a 2022 analysis, researchers found that the Nordic diet helped lower cholesterol and blood sugar levels independent of weight loss. 'The group that had been on the Nordic diet for six months became significantly healthier, with lower cholesterol levels, lower overall levels of both saturated and unsaturated fat in the blood, and better regulation of glucose, compared to the control group,' study author Lars Ove Dragsted said in a statement. Other studies have found that the Nordic diet can have a positive impact on blood pressure and inflammation. Taken together, and experts say this cold-climate cuisine could be just what the doctor ordered for your heart. A 2023 review even found that the Nordic diet might reduce the risk of death from cardiovascular disease, the leading cause of death in the US. However, more research is needed to nail down exactly how much. Still, experts say Americans could learn a thing or two from their northern neighbors — especially when it comes to cutting processed meats and sugar-laden snacks. 'People who really like berries, rye bread, and canola oil should go ahead and enjoy a Nordic-style diet rather than waiting 10 years to get more evidence,' advised Dr. Frank Hu, professor of nutrition at the Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health.
