&w=3840&q=100)
SIAC rules for Amazon in Future case, awards ₹23.7 crore damages
Amazon wins arbitration against Future Group at SIAC, but tribunal awards a fraction of claimed damages citing FRL's declining value and Covid-related business loss
New Delhi
The Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) has awarded ₹23.7 crore in damages, besides arbitration and litigation costs, to Amazon in its long-running dispute with the Kishore Biyani-led Future Group.
The three-member bench of the tribunal held that Future Group had breached the terms of its contract with Amazon by entering into a transaction with Reliance. It also told 11 promoters and parties of the Future Group, including Kishore Biyani, to pay the amount along with interest from March 9, 2022 till now.
The dispute pertains to a decision by the Future Group to sell its Big Bazaar retail business to Reliance Retail, a subsidiary of Reliance Industries.
Amazon had in 2022 argued before the Supreme Court of India that its ₹1,400-crore investment in the Future Group does not allow the latter to sell its assets to certain companies, which includes Reliance.
Amazon had, however, sought ₹1,436 crore damages, citing Future Retail Limited's (FRL) 'deteriorating value.'
SIAC ruled that Amazon was entitled to damages due to promoters' breaches of the Future Coupons Private Limited (FCPL) shareholders agreement, but rejected ₹1,436 crore damages sought by Amazon.
The tribunal reasoned that though all contractual obligations were fulfilled by Amazon, it would not have recovered its entire investment due to FRL'S deteriorating business value.
The tribunal said awarding Amazon damages in full would unfairly shield it from commercial loss it was bound to incur due to the Covid-19 pandemic and the deteriorating value of FRL.
Amazon was awarded ₹77.3 crore and Singapore dollars 68,550 as litigation cost.
In August 2020, Future Group, facing financial distress and debts of around ₹22,000 crore decided to sell its wholesale, logistics, and warehousing business to Reliance Industries for ₹24,713 crore. Amazon objected to this citing violation of their contractual obligations.
Amazon then started arbitration proceedings against Future Group in October 2020, obtaining an emergency arbitration award pausing the Future-Reliance deal.
Amazon and Future Group both took the matter to the Delhi High Court, Supreme Court of India, and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal to resolve the issue.
The Competition Commission of India (CCI) had also imposed a fine of ₹200 crore on Amazon for non-disclosure of information on combinations under the Competition Act 2002.
Amazon had then moved the Supreme Court against the CCI ruling suspending approval for the ecommerce giant's 2019 deal investment in Future Group on January 10, 2023.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
21 minutes ago
- Mint
Boeing-Spirit merger faces UK antitrust probe: Here's why the $4.7 billion deal is under lens
Boeing's proposed $4.7 billion deal to acquire Spirit AeroSystems Holdings will face an antitrust investigation in the United Kingdom, the country's antitrust watchdog said. The deal, valued at $8.3 billion including Spirit's net debt, was announced last year. It aims to reunite the aviation giants two decades after Spirit was spun off from Boeing in 2005 to trim costs, reported Bloomberg. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has initiated a probe to determine whether the transaction poses a risk of 'substantial lessening of competition' in the UK. This investigation is said to be a standard procedure for acquisitions of this magnitude. The inquiry 'was anticipated and is part of the normal process for acquisitions of this nature,' a Spirit spokesperson told the news agency. The UK antitrust watchdog is expected to make a decision on whether to close the investigation or launch a more in-depth probe by August 28 of this year, it said in a notice published on Monday. The Boeing-Spirit merger will bring a key supplier for the 737, 787 Dreamliner and other commercial jets back to Boeing. In July 2024, Boeing announced that it is acquiring Spirit, which will include substantially all Boeing-related commercial operations, as well as additional commercial, defence and aftermarket operations. The objective of the purchase is to streamline Boeing's operations and improve quality control, years after spinning off the key supplier, according to Reuters. In July, former Boeing CEO Dave Calhoun told the media at the time of the acquisition announcement that the deal 'is in the best interest of the flying public, our airline customers, the employees of Spirit and Boeing, our shareholders and the country more broadly'. As part of the transaction, Boeing was expected to work with Spirit to ensure the continuity of operations supporting Spirit's customers and programmes it acquires, including working with the US Department of Defense and Spirit's defence customers regarding defence and security missions, Boeing said in a statement.
The Hindu
21 minutes ago
- The Hindu
India to fast-track 52 military satellites for better surveillance at borders
After defence forces realised the need for more precision surveillance during Operation Sindoor, the Union government has ordered the fast-tracking of the launch of 52 dedicated surveillance satellites, enhancing round-the-clock monitoring of coastline and land borders. In October last year, the Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led Cabinet Committee approved $3.2 billion for the SBS-III programme to develop next-generation satellites over the next decade. Under the programme, ISRO will manufacture and launch the first 21 satellites, while private companies will handle the remaining 31. The Defence Space Agency (DSA) will oversee the operation of the newly launched satellite system. 'We have asked the private companies and ISRO for early launch of satellites. These new satellites will add a next-generation radar imaging capability that will help in all-weather and day-night surveillance. We are expecting first set of satellites to be launched by 2026,' said a senior official. The official added that the new satellites will be using artificial intelligence (AI) to make smarter decisions and improve overall performance and efficiency in space. During Operation Sindoor, satellite-based surveillance helped Indian defence forces to act swiftly by offering accurate intelligence, including the trajectory and movement of drones and missiles. After the successful implementation of SBS-III, India will become more self-reliant and reduce its dependence on other countries. It will help focus more clearly and accurately on the Pakistan and China border and the Indian Ocean Region. During the Operation Sindoor, it was claimed that China provided satellite support to Pakistan. India's satellites, like the Cartosat and RISAT, helped defence forces to track enemy mobilisation, confirm strike impact, and maintain real-time situational awareness, which prevented any major damage to the country's military assets.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Trump wants America to make iPhones. Here's how India is doing it
By Alex Travelli and Hari Kumar DEVANAHALLI: A new iPhone factory in an out-of-the-way corner of India looks like a spaceship from another planet. Foxconn , the Taiwanese company that assembles most of the world's iPhones for Apple , has landed amid the boulders and millet fields of Devanahalli. The sleek buildings rising on the 300-acre site, operational but still growing, are emerging evidence of an estimated $2.5 billion investment. This is what President Donald Trump wants Apple to do in the United States. What is happening in this part of India shows both why that sounds attractive and why it will probably not happen. In India, Apple is doubling down on a bet it placed after the COVID-19 pandemic began and before Trump's reelection. Many countries, starting with the United States, were eager to reduce their reliance on factories in China. Apple, profoundly dependent on Chinese production, was quick to act. Analysts at Counterpoint Research calculated that India had succeeded in satisfying 18% of the global demand for iPhones by early this year, two years after Foxconn started making iPhones in India. By the end of 2025, with the Devanahalli plant fully online, Foxconn is expected to be assembling between 25% and 30% of iPhones in India. This newest factory is the largest of several making Apple products in India. Its full frame is still rising from red dust. Cranes are at work above the skeletons of high-rise dormitories for female workers. But about 8,000 people are already at work on two factory floors. Soon there should be 40,000. The effects on the region are transformative. It's a field day for job seekers and landowners. And the kind of crazy-quilt supply chain of smaller industries that feeds Apple's factory towns in China is coalescing in India's heartland. Businesses are selling Foxconn the goods and services it needs to make iPhones, including tiny parts, assembly-line equipment and worker recruitment. Some of the firms are Indian; others are Taiwanese, South Korean or American. Some were already in the area, while others are setting up in India for the first time. The changes spurred by Foxconn are rippling broadly through Bengaluru, a city of 8 million people that had a start in the 20th century as home to India's first aerospace centers. But its manufacturing base was pushed aside, first by call centers and then by flashier work in microchip design and outsourced professional services. Going back to the factory floor, as they're doing in Devanahalli, is what Trump wants American workers to do. To see the changes afoot here is to understand the allure of bringing back manufacturing. Wages are rising 10% to 15% around the Foxconn plant. Businesses are quietly making deals to supply Foxconn and Apple's other contractors. A factory that makes plastic parts for bank cash machines hosted a team from Foxconn for a tour. A foundry that makes yarn-spinning machinery was hoping it might start making the metal bits Foxconn might need in its new factory. Neither Foxconn nor Apple replied to requests for comment about their operations in India. India has been working toward a breakthrough like this for a long time. Its first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, called hydroelectric dams, steel plants and research institutes the "temples of modern India." In 2015, Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced a "Make in India" policy. Since 2020, his government has committed $26 billion to subsidising strategic manufacturing goals. India's most urgent reason for developing industry is to create jobs. Unlike the United States, it does not have enough: not in services, manufacturing or anything else. Nearly half its workers are involved in farming. With India's population peaking, it needs about 10 million new jobs a year just to keep up. It also wants to achieve the kind of financial power and technological autonomy that China found as it became the factory to the world. One problem is that India's electronics factories still import the most valuable of the 1,000 components that go into a finished iPhone, like chips and camera modules. Skeptics disparage India's success with the final assembly of iPhones as "screwdriver work," complaining that too little of the devices' value is made in India. But the government, dangling subsidies, is persuading companies like Apple to source more of those parts locally. It is already getting casings, specialised glass and paints from Indian firms. Apple, which opened its first Indian stores two years ago, is required by the Indian government to source 30% of its products' value from India by 2028. Indo-MIM, an Indian company with an American-born boss, is the kind that contributes to the neighborhood forming around Apple's production and also benefits from it. At a plant near Devanahalli, in southern Karnataka state, Indo-MIM's engineers perform metal-injection moulding for hundreds of companies around the world. It makes parts for airplanes, luxury goods, medical devices and more. The company is already making jigs or brackets for use in the Foxconn plant. In addition, a "critical mass" of specialty firms means that Indo-MIM no longer needs to make many of the tools it uses to make its products, said Krishna Chivukula, its CEO. "You don't want to have to make everything yourself," he said, adding it means Indo-MIM can concentrate on what it does best. Chivukula said the workforce made Devanahalli fertile ground for factories. "The people here are very hungry," he said. "They're looking for opportunity, and then on top of that millions of them are engineers." Still, despite the surplus of engineers, companies are bringing in talent from East Asia. Prachir Singh, an analyst for Counterpoint, said it had taken 15 years to figure out what would work in China and five years to import this much of it to India. Centum is an Indian-origin contract manufacturer, like Foxconn is to Apple. Centum makes circuit boards that go into products like air-to-air missiles, forklifts and fertility scanners. Nikhil Mallavarapu, its executive director, said the company was in talks to customise testing equipment for the Foxconn factory. Newly hired engineers and other professionals are pouring into the area. Many moved hundreds of miles while others must commute hours a day to get to work. Some rise at 3:30 a.m. to make the 8 a.m. shift. But India is thick with people. A five-minute walk away, a village called Doddagollahalli looks the same as it did before Foxconn landed. Nearly all the houses clustered around a sacred grove belong to farming families growing millet, grapes and vegetables. Some villagers are renting rooms to Foxconn workers. Many more are trying to sell their land. But Sneha, who goes by a single name, has found a job on the Foxconn factory's day shift. She holds a master's degree in mathematics. She can walk home for lunch every day, a corporate lanyard swinging from her neck. It is people like Sneha, and the thousands of her new colleagues piling into her ancestral place, who make Foxconn's ambitions for India possible. Trump wants to revive the fortunes of left-behind American factory towns, but the pipeline of qualified young graduates is not there. Josh Foulger has recruited lots of motivated Indian workers like Sneha. He heads the electronics division of Zetwerk, an Indian contract manufacturer with factories in Devanahalli that sees itself as a smaller competitor to Foxconn. He said he routinely got 700 job applications a year from local tech schools. It is a matter of scale: Karnataka state alone, he pointed out, has a population half the size of Vietnam's. All of India's "states are very keen on getting manufacturing," said Foulger, who grew up in southern India and made his home in Texas before moving back to India, where he set up shop for Foxconn. India has jobs for engineers and managers and all the way down the ladder. "Manufacturing does a very democratic job" of meeting the demand for good jobs, he said.
