logo
Conservatives target $8 billion internet and phone subsidy. Supreme Court weighs in.

Conservatives target $8 billion internet and phone subsidy. Supreme Court weighs in.

USA Today25-03-2025
Conservatives target $8 billion internet and phone subsidy. Supreme Court weighs in. The case could also affect how much power Congress can delegate to federal agencies.
Show Caption
Hide Caption
SCOTUS hears case on Louisiana congressional maps
Lawyers from Louisiana argued that their new congressional maps are sound under "breathing room" promised by the Supreme Court.
WASHINGTON − When the pandemic prevented Arkansas River Valley residents from accessing the internet at their nearby local library, it didn't stop librarians from providing the critical service. They mounted antennas on rooftops to extend the signal.
'We still do it,' said Misty Hawkins, the regional library director.
The rural population with a median family income below $46,000 depends on the reliable internet connection that its seven libraries provide through a federal program.
'Lives are being changed through the distribution of a computer, through a connection, or a person being able to have resume assistance, or being able to get their GED,' Hawkins said. 'That's life changing and that's whether or not they're going to be able to put food on the table.'
The Supreme Court on Wednesday will hear a challenge to the $8 billion Universal Service Fund program that could jeopardize the availability and affordability of high-speed internet and phone service for millions of Americans, including those served by the Arkansas River Valley Regional Library System.
The case could also have broad repercussions for how much power Congress can delegate to federal agencies to make decisions about implementing legislation.
The Supreme Court's conservative super majority has in recent years curtailed the authority of executive agencies.
And the latest challenge is part of that larger conservative effort to curb the 'administrative state.'
Trump administration defends FCC's authority
But even though the Trump administration has been aggressively trying to shrink federal agencies, President Donald Trump has also been asserting broad executive authority.
And, in this case, the Justice Department argues Congress did not give away it's legislative power when, in 1996, lawmakers formalized a process that allowed telecommunications providers to impose higher rates in cities to subsidize the greater cost of serving rural areas.
Telecommunications companies are charged a Universal Service Fund fee - passed on to customers -that boosts phone and internet service to households and hospitals in rural areas, to low-income families across the country, and to public schools and libraries.
The fund is run through the Universal Service Administrative Company, a private, non-profit corporation overseen by the Federal Communications Commission.
The administrator distributes the funding, collects the fees and estimates how much needs to be raised each quarter. The FCC must approve the estimate before it's used to determine the fee for each carrier.
Program challenged as `open-ended scheme'
Consumers' Research, a conservative group, challenged this setup, as did a carrier and a group of consumers.
They argue it is Congress, not the FCC – and certainly not a private entity − that must determine the fee level.
The current 'open-ended scheme' is a 'bureaucrat's dream,' lawyers for the challengers told the court.
They compared it to Congress giving the IRS the power to set tax rates at whatever level the agency thinks is needed to run the government.
'The entire federal government could be funded with a single, vague delegation to the IRS, which could then hand over that power to a private group,' they wrote.
5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals sided with challengers
While appeals courts in Ohio and Georgia rejected those arguments, the Louisiana-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals declared the universal service fee unconstitutional.
'American telecommunications consumers are subject to a multibillion-dollar tax nobody voted for,' the appeals court said in a 9-7 decision last year. 'The size of that tax is de facto determined by a trade group staffed by industry insiders with no semblance of accountability to the public.'
The Justice Department says that's not what's happening.
'The FCC ultimately decides, within the limits and standards set by Congress, the amount of the fee,' the department's attorneys said in a filing.
Justice Department: Delegation similar to other laws
Tax statutes – particularly those allowing a president to impose tariffs – have historically not included the specificity the challengers say should be required under the Constitution, according to the administration.
The telecommunications law, they add, follows the same delegation framework Congress has used in a range of areas, including to prevent unfair competition, oversee the securities industry, ensure the safety of food and drugs, regulate labor relations and set air-quality standards.
But it was an air pollution case – a challenge to former President Joe Biden's effort to curb greenhouse gas emissions from power plants – that prompted the Supreme Court in 2022 to limit the authority of federal agencies.
The court said regulations that have a major impact on the economy or are a matter of great 'political significance' must be backed by clear congressional approval.
And last year, the court overturned a 40-year precedent that courts should defer to an agency as long as their interpretation of a law is 'reasonable.'
Tide turning on `non-delegation doctrine'?
But only twice – both times in 1935 in efforts to rein in President Franklin D. Roosevelt – has the court struck down a law for violating the 'non-delegation doctrine.'
The last time the Supreme Court weighed in on the issue, a divided court in 2019 declined to tighten the test, which requires Congress merely provide an 'intelligible principle' for agencies to follow.
That 5-3 decision came over the objections of Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas. Justice Samuel Alito sided with the liberals but said he would be open to reconsidering the issue in a future case. Justice Brett Kavanaugh did not vote because he joined the court after the case had been argued but before the decision was handed down.
Since that decision, another conservative – Justice Amy Coney Barrett – succeeded Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, one of the liberals who was in the 2019 majority.
Communities are at the other end of the funds
Hawkins, the regional library director in Arkansas, said she's worried that the court could strike down the program, leaving a big hole in her budget.
In the past ten years, her library system has received $381,395 from the program, which is nearly as much as her annual budget.
Without that funding, Hawkins said, the library wouldn't be able to pay for equipment like the antennas that boost internet service and might have to cut back on other services, such as databases that provide online tutoring, legal resources, contract guides for small businesses, genealogical research and access to newspapers.
'There's not a day that goes by that I don't look at our budgets, saying `What could go if it has to?'' she said of her already tight resources that are also facing local funding threats. 'There are real people, real families, real communities that are at the other end of these funds.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Blaming ‘the system,' Kamala Harris falls for the oldest temptation
Blaming ‘the system,' Kamala Harris falls for the oldest temptation

New York Post

time28 minutes ago

  • New York Post

Blaming ‘the system,' Kamala Harris falls for the oldest temptation

August is usually downtime in Washington, DC: Congress is in recess, the heat and humidity contribute to the desire to escape town for cooler weather, the president is normally somewhere else and cable news is focused on shark attacks. Not this August. Cable news especially, along with some newspapers, seem to be fixated on the person Democrats will nominate for president in 2028. We are just eight months into President Donald Trump's second term — and we are being forced to listen and read speculation about an election a political lifetime away. Part of it can be blamed on former Vice President Kamala Harris, who received headlines for announcing she is not running for governor of California and will not seek the presidency again. Harris told Stephen Colbert on his soon-to-be canceled 'Late Show' the reason she will not run again: 'The system is broken,' she said Funny how Democrats claim the system is broken only when they lose. The larger part of the media's preoccupation with politics is that many 'can't stop thinking about tomorrow' instead of living in the present. For many, politics has become a false god. Like those ancient gods described in the Old Testament that could never deliver what the people claimed to want, the political 'gods' are worshiped no matter how many times they fail to keep their promises. If, as Harris claims, 'the system' is broken, much of the reason is that we have asked the government to do what it was never created to do. Every morning, the NY POSTcast offers a deep dive into the headlines with the Post's signature mix of politics, business, pop culture, true crime and everything in between. Subscribe here! Even as Trump, however imperfectly, is trying to fix it, too many voters still put too much faith where it doesn't belong. It is here that CS Lewis offers valuable insight. In his classic work 'The Screwtape Letters,' a demon-in-training named Wormwood is assigned by his Uncle Screwtape (aka Satan) to distract his 'patient' (aka us) from the plans of 'the enemy' (aka God). Kamala Harris would do well to read this excerpt, since she blames a broken system for her loss, and her decision not to run again. 'Be sure that the patient remains completely fixated on politics,' Lewis' Screwtape advises. Keep up with today's most important news Stay up on the very latest with Evening Update. Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters 'Arguments, political gossip, and obsessing on the faults of people they have never met serves as an excellent distraction from advancing in personal virtue, character, and the things the patient can control. 'Make sure to keep the patient in a constant state of angst, frustration, and general disdain towards the rest of the human race in order to avoid any kind of charity or inner peace from further developing. 'Ensure the patient continues to believe that the problem is 'out there' in the 'broken system' rather than recognizing there is a problem with himself.' William Shakespeare had his own analysis of the human condition. Students may remember this comment by Cassius in 'Julius Caesar': 'The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves, that we are underlings.' It means that fate and destiny do not control us, but rather the good or bad choices we make are the result of our own actions, determined by the worldview to which we cling and in which we believe. Imagine if politicians began speaking like Lewis and the Bard, telling voters, 'I can't do more for you than you can do for yourselves.' With so many addicted to politics and 'the system,' voters might quickly drive the career politicians from office — and the ratings on cable news would drop like a stone. Cal Thomas is a veteran political commentator, columnist and author.

GOP senators place holds over tax credit guidance
GOP senators place holds over tax credit guidance

The Hill

time28 minutes ago

  • The Hill

GOP senators place holds over tax credit guidance

Grassley, who recently engaged in a heated back-and-forth with Trump over the handling of judicial picks, announced his move to place the holds in the congressional record Friday. 'Today, I placed a hold on three Department of the Treasury nominees,' he said in the record, specifically naming Trump's picks for the department's general counsel, assistant secretary and undersecretary. The Iowa Republican added that while the 'big, beautiful, bill' recently passed by Congress allowed for wind and solar companies to continue to get tax credits if they begin construction of their projects in the next year, the Treasury Department 'is expected to issue rules and regulations implementing the agreed upon phase-out of the wind and solar credits by August 18, 2025.' 'Until I can be certain that such rules and regulations adhere to the law and congressional intent, I intend to continue to object to the consideration of these Treasury nominees,' Grassley said. Sen. John Curtis (R-Utah) is also placing a hold on the same nominees — Brian Morrissey Jr., Francis Brooke and Jonathan McKernan — for the same reason, a source familiar told The Hill. After legislation to terminate the tax credits was passed, Trump signed an executive order that directed the Treasury to take a strict approach to limit which projects are eligible while they're still active.

Trump plans White House task force on security for the 2028 L.A. Olympics
Trump plans White House task force on security for the 2028 L.A. Olympics

Los Angeles Times

time28 minutes ago

  • Los Angeles Times

Trump plans White House task force on security for the 2028 L.A. Olympics

WASHINGTON — President Trump will order the establishment of a White House task force on Tuesday focused on security for the Olympics Games in Los Angeles in 2028. Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, said the president plans on creating the task force by executive order on Tuesday, telling The Times that Trump 'considers it a great honor to oversee this global sporting spectacle.' 'During his first term, President Trump was instrumental in securing America's bid to host the 2028 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles,' Leavitt said. 'Sports is one of President Trump's greatest passions, and his athletic expertise, combined with his unmatched hospitality experience will make these Olympic events the most exciting and memorable in history.' The executive order follows on Trump's signature legislation, referred to by the president as the 'big beautiful bill,' securing $1 billion for security, planning and other costs for the L.A. Games. Planning for the games is being led by the Los Angeles Organizing Committee for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games, or LA28, a privately funded non-profit organization. Casey Wasserman, chairperson and president of LA28, thanked the Trump administration in a statement 'for their leadership and unwavering support as we prepare to deliver the largest and most ambitious Olympic and Paralympic Games ever hosted in the United States.' 'Since we secured this historic opportunity in 2017, President Trump has consistently recognized the magnitude of our responsibility in welcoming the world to Los Angeles,' Wasserman said. 'The creation of this task force marks an important step forward in our planning efforts and reflects our shared commitment to delivering not just the biggest, but the greatest Games the world has ever seen in the summer of 2028.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store