logo
Why India Needs to Update Its Own Poverty Line

Why India Needs to Update Its Own Poverty Line

The Wire3 days ago

Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Economy
Why India Needs to Update Its Own Poverty Line
Dipa Sinha
4 minutes ago
It is important to remember that poverty ratios derived from consumption-expenditure-based poverty lines represent only one dimension of well-being.
Illustration: Pariplab Chakraborty
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Contribute now
India's poverty numbers are once again making headlines, ironically even though our official poverty lines have not been updated in over a decade.
The World Bank has revised the International Poverty Line (IPL) from $2.15/day (2017 purchasing power parity or PPP) to $3.00/day (2021 PPP). Based on this new line, the poverty ratio in India is estimated to be 5.25% compared to 27.12% in 2011-12. While it could be true that the poverty ratio has declined in the last decade, there are a number of questions related to the data and methodology which put a cloud over both the extent of decline as well as the level of poverty currently.
A longstanding criticism that these poverty lines of the World Bank are extremely low and do not reflect what most would accept as absolute poverty still holds. Based on the latest data from the International Comparison Program (ICP) based on which these new estimates have been released, one PPP$ is roughly equivalent to Rs 20. Therefore, this new poverty line of $3 a day reflecting extreme poverty is equivalent to only Rs 60 per day of consumption expenditure per person. On the basis of the higher IPL of $4.2 PPP (i.e. Rs 84) per day, 23.89% Indians are estimated to be poor. We don't need to be experts to imagine what living on less than Rs 84 a day means (this is to account for all expenses of a person including rent, travel, food, education, health and other consumption).
It is common practice for poverty lines to be revised at regular intervals to reflect the change in living standards and consumption patterns. The last time India's official poverty line was changed was in 2009 based on the Tendulkar committee recommendations. In 2015, the Rangarajan committee made recommendations updating the poverty lines but it is not clear what their official status is. In fact, India stopped estimating consumption-based poverty after 2011-12 and has been relying in recent times on these World Bank and IMF estimates.
India not in consideration
As mentioned in the official press release of the Union government, the new IPL reflects (a) revised national poverty lines in low income countries (b) improved measurement of consumption, particularly food and non-food items and (c) the integration of 2021 PPP estimates. In fact, this press note quotes the World Bank saying, 'Most of this upward revision is explained by revisions in the underlying national poverty lines rather than a change in prices'.
But the issue is that India is not one of the countries that has made this upward revision to its poverty line! And therefore, the IPL does not include the Indian national poverty line in its consideration at all.
While the verdict is out on whether the new methodology of collecting data that was adopted in Household Consumption Expenditure Surveys (HCES) of 2022 and 2023 captures consumption better, what is not in doubt is that this data are now not comparable with the previous rounds of consumption expenditure. While the World Bank has considered the change in the recall period and adjusted for that while comparing with 2011-12 (from URP to MMRP), the HCES changed not just the recall period but the entire way in which data were collected – with multiple visits to each household and changes in the questionnaire. While there have been some validation exercises to understand what the impact of these changes are in comparing trends, no official national estimates have been released so far on what the poverty rates are based on these new surveys. PPP estimates of the ICP are also known to have their methodological issues which are too complex to discuss here.
Limitations
What is important, however, is to understand the limitations of these global poverty estimates and to be cautious not to assign them more weight than they merit. The World Bank factsheet on the new poverty estimates include FAQs which also clearly explain the limited use of these international poverty ratios by stating: 'A country's national poverty line continues to be far more appropriate for underpinning policy dialogue or targeting programs to reach the poorest within that specific context.'
Further, it also states that, 'when analyzing trends for a single country, the national poverty line is the appropriate standard to use. It captures the definition of poverty that is most relevant for this context, as well as how it should be updated over time to reflect changes in survey methodologies and evolving needs.'
What is required therefore in India is an urgent exercise at updating our own poverty line – this was something that was under the remit of the erstwhile Planning Commission. The NITI Aayog must now take this on. The expert committee must develop a methodology that robustly measures poverty, grounded in a normative understanding of the basic minimum standards we, as a country, believe every citizen should have access to. In the absence of such an exercise, the old poverty ratios are still being used for making crucial allocations to states for programmes such as the National Social Assistance Programme (NSAP) through which social security pensions for the elderly, single women and disabled are disbursed.
Further, it is important to remember that poverty ratios derived from consumption-expenditure-based poverty lines represent only one dimension of well-being. To gain a comprehensive understanding of the realities of people's lives, a broader set of indicators must be considered. These include employment status, real wage trends, health and education outcomes, food security and nutritional status, as well as income and wealth inequality, among others. Taken together, these dimensions provide a more holistic picture of well-being – and on many of these fronts, both national and international estimates indicate that India still has a significant distance to cover.
Dipa Sinha is a development economist.
The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
Reality Check: Beyond Statistics, is Poverty Actually Reducing in India?
Lessons From the BluSmart Case: Why the RBI Must Act Now on Digital Wallets
The State of the Economy: India Inc's Profit Dips, Rupee Is Asia's Worst Performer
US Cites National Security Grounds, Procedural Errors to Reject India's Notice at WTO
World Bank Report on India's Incredible Poverty Reduction Isn't Credible
What Happens to the 2026 Football World Cup Under Trump's Travel Ban?
Here's to the Humble Bicycle
Is RBI's New Plan for Bad Loans Just Another Quick Fix?
Sharp Rise in Loan Write-Offs This Fiscal
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Punjab governor honours outstanding students, launches new educational initiatives
Punjab governor honours outstanding students, launches new educational initiatives

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Punjab governor honours outstanding students, launches new educational initiatives

1 2 Chandigarh: Punjab governor Gulab Chand Kataria honoured 237 outstanding students from Chandigarh who achieved above 90% marks in Class XII examinations at the Post Graduate Govt College for Girls, Sector 42, Chandigarh, on Wednesday. Students received certificates and cash incentives of Rs 5,000 each from the UT education department. The ceremony also recognised principals and teachers from four govt schools that achieved 100% results. Also, the UT administration introduced three new educational initiatives during the event to enhance the city's educational framework. Adopt-a-School Mentorship Initiative: It will encompass 42 govt schools, benefiting approximately 60,000 students. Administration officials, professionals, and experts will guide students on health, hygiene, moral values, cyber awareness, and life skills, providing practical knowledge beyond academics. Udaan Project: The education department's MoU with prestigious coaching institutes will provide free coaching to 700 talented students for competitive examinations like JEE, NEET, IAS, PCS, and NDA, supporting academically capable students with limited resources. Cashless Campus: The initiative aims to ensure secure and transparent financial transactions whilst promoting digital literacy, supporting the vision of Developed India 2047. The governor acknowledged that the students' achievements resulted from their efforts combined with teachers' and parents' support. He said, "The real credit for this success goes to the teachers. The respect for a teacher is the same today as it was earlier. Time has changed, technology has changed, but the contribution and importance of the one who imparts education is still steadfast." Kataria also emphasised that education extends beyond examinations, serving as an instrument for societal change. He noted that "we should not only have knowledge, but also the qualities of humanity." Discussing Developed India 2047, the governor expressed his vision for Chandigarh: "Our dream is that Chandigarh should not only become a smart city but also a visionary city – where we show direction to the country on all parameters of education, innovation, cleanliness, digital progress, and good governance."

Renovated information centre opened at Chamundi Vana
Renovated information centre opened at Chamundi Vana

Time of India

time3 hours ago

  • Time of India

Renovated information centre opened at Chamundi Vana

Mysuru: The renovated Environmental Information Centre at Chamundi Vana was inaugurated by district minister HC Mahadevappa on Wednesday. On the occasion, a sapling planting programme was organised as part of the celebrations. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The information centre has been developed to raise awareness about forestry, environment, and wildlife conservation, incorporating various schemes and programmes of the forest department, such as agroforestry promotion, distribution of saplings at subsidised rates, human-wildlife conflict management, sandalwood cultivation, and providing cooking gas connections to reduce forest pressure. It also includes information about forest martyrs, e-services, and e-initiatives. A proposal of Rs 100 lakh has been submitted to develop Chamundi Vana as a model park, enhancing it into a prime tourist destination for the millions of devotees visiting Chamundi Hills temple to enjoy its natural beauty. In the current financial year, other works like a children's park, Pavithra Vana, Nakshatra Vana, Rashi Vana, and pergola will be undertaken. MLA GT Devegowda, Nagamma, president, Chamundi Hill gram panchayat; M Malathipriya, conservation officer, Mysuru Circle, and Basavaraj KN, deputy forest conservation officer, Mysuru Territorial Division, were present. Chamundi Vana is being taken care of by Mysuru Forest Division's Urban Greening Zone. The information centre was started in 2003, but due to legal hurdles, it was temporarily shut in 2011. Then the forest department appealed in the high court in 2011, and the state archives provided documentation of govt orders in the 1940s for 2 acres and 28 guntas, and in 1947, for 18 acres, totalling 20 acres acquired by the forest department. In 2024, these records were submitted to the high court, which ruled in favour of the forest department in July 2024, stating that "Once a forest, always a forest. " Now, the department has started a renovated information centre.

From fruit chaat seller to assistant professor: Tej Kushwaha's inspiring journey
From fruit chaat seller to assistant professor: Tej Kushwaha's inspiring journey

Time of India

time3 hours ago

  • Time of India

From fruit chaat seller to assistant professor: Tej Kushwaha's inspiring journey

Indore: In a testament to perseverance and determination, 31-year-old Tej Prakash Kushwaha, a native of a small village in Rewa district, achieved his dream of becoming an assistant professor in geography. His name figures among the successful candidates in the recently announced interview results of the MPPSC Assistant Professor Recruitment Exam 2022. Kushwaha hails from Bausadwa village in Jawa tehsil where his parents are engaged in farming. He completed his early education at a govt school in his village that went up only to Class 5, after which he moved to another town to continue his studies. Despite facing academic setbacks — he once failed Class 8—Tej went on to earn a BA and MA in geography from Allahabad University. His journey into competitive exams began with the UPSC, for which he prepared while living in Delhi for three years. After multiple attempts, he shifted his focus to the Madhya Pradesh Public Service Commission (MPPSC) and moved to Indore in 2019. Though he cleared the prelims four times and appeared for mains, the interview round remained elusive. Faced with financial difficulties while preparing, Tej and three friends—Shubham Thakur, Suraj, and Pradeep—started a small venture named PSC Falahaar, selling fruit chaat near Bhola Ram Ustad Marg in Indore. "Expenses in Indore were rising, so we decided to serve fresh fruits to students and residents for just Rs.20," Tej told TOI. The group would visit the fruit mandi at 5am, prepare the servings, and take turns running the stall to balance work and studies. While their aim was to make Rs 200 each per day for their expenses, the venture became a success and expanded to multiple locations in Indore, eventually being replicated in 14 other states by students. In early 2025, Tej and his friends handed over the initiative to another group in need. Meanwhile, he cleared the UGC-NET and qualified for a Junior Research Fellowship in 2023, which allowed him to pursue a PhD at Devi Ahilya Vishwavidyalaya with financial support from the central govt. Determined to crack the MPPSC interview, he joined a coaching group for mock interviews and personality development. "We critiqued each other's communication and body language, which boosted my confidence," he said. His interview panel asked questions about his startup, the Rewa region, and Prayagraj—his place of higher education. "For questions I didn't know, I admitted it honestly and promised to learn." Tej scored 80 in the interview and was selected. "I come from a humble background. My father once worked as a labourer in Pune while my mother managed the farm. Today, I'm happy to make them proud." Now being in the field of education, Tej aims to attain the top positions. "I want to grow in academia and one day serve as a vice-chancellor," he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store