People 'will suffer' under new waiting list scheme, doctor warns
People who cannot afford to pay for medical procedures upfront are going to suffer under a new reimbursement scheme, a senior medic has said.
The scheme was announced on Tuesday as part of a £215M plan outlined by Health Minister Mike Nesbitt to tackle spiralling hospital waiting lists.
From next month, patients waiting longer than two years for an operation will be able to claim back money if they pay for a procedure in the Republic of Ireland.
But the deputy chair of the British Medical Association in Northern Ireland, Dr Clodagh Corrigan, said that is going to make current problems worse.
"We know there is an enormous gap in health access and in poverty in Northern Ireland," she told BBC's Sunday Politics programme.
"If we are now in a position where we are providing a better health service to those who can afford it, we are going to see that disparity become even greater and people who cannot afford to pay for their healthcare up front really suffering."
Full details of the plan have yet to be outlined and the full range of eligible procedures covered by the cross-border scheme are not yet known.
The Department of Health said patients would require prior approval before accessing the scheme.
Other measures include using NI's private healthcare providers to target anyone waiting longer than four years on a hip or knee replacement, colonoscopy, hernia or gallbladder surgery.
Nesbitt said initially £10m will be invested in the waiting list reimbursement scheme, which will begin in June 2025.
Dr Corrigan also questioned where Nesbitt will find the money that is needed.
"We are already in a situation in our health service where we are being propped up by staff good will, by and large," she said.
"They money has to be saved from somewhere so what are we going to lose and what services are we going to have to cut?
"How much worse is the care that we are providing our patients on a day to day basis going to have to get to fund these savings that the minister is looking for to invest in the waiting lists?"
Alliance MLA Nuala McAllister said Northern Ireland is now "lawing in the phase of a two-tier health system".
"There has to be some equity in [the health service] if it is going to relieve the pressure elsewhere.
"If it is not going to relieve the pressure then we need to look again at other options.
"We need to use all levers and that is just the reality of it."
Following the announcement, the People Before Profit MLA Gerry Carroll said the reimbursement scheme was "nothing more than stealth privatisation".
"The for-profit healthcare sector has the Department over a barrel," he said in a statement.
"The more the Minister depends on private healthcare to solve this crisis, the weaker our NHS becomes."
Cross-border surgery reimbursement to tackle waiting lists
£135m a year to fix waiting lists, say health officials
NI hospital consultant waiting lists at all-time high
Urgent funds needed to clear waiting lists - report
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
25 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Novo Nordisk to Expand Access to Wegovy with WeightWatchers Partnership
Novo Nordisk NOVO.B -0.99%decrease; red down pointing triangle plans to expand access to Wegovy through a collaboration with WeightWatchers, days after ending a partnership with telehealth firm Hims & Hers to sell the weight-loss drug. The pharmaceutical giant said Thursday WeightWatchers will work with CenterWell Pharmacy to fulfill and deliver Wegovy prescriptions. WeightWatchers aims to streamline the patient experience with convenient access to medication approved by the Food and Drug Administration as well as lifestyle support, Novo Nordisk said.
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
RFK Jr.'s vaccine committee votes on new RSV immunization, flu shots
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's influential panel of vaccine advisers Thursday approved updated recommendations for a new shot for respiratory syncytial virus, or RSV. It is also set to vote on recommendations for this year's influenza vaccine. Their votes mark the panel's first official move after Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. fired the committee's experts and replaced them with his own picks earlier this month. Votes by the panel are closely watched by health authorities because they are tied to federal policies and programs that enable access to vaccines, including requirements for insurance coverage and funding to provide shots for uninsured children. Other vaccines are also being discussed by the panel, but not voted on, including those for COVID-19, chikungunya and anthrax. Kennedy's new committee also announced Wednesday that it would start a renewed review of all recommended pediatric vaccines, over fears about the "cumulative effect" that the shots could be having on children. That includes weighing changes to recommendations for hepatitis B and measles vaccines given early in life. The American Academy of Pediatrics denounced the move as sowing distrust in safe and effective immunizations, and warned Wednesday against curbing hepatitis B recommendations. "Secretary Kennedy has given this committee a clear mandate to use evidence-based medicine when making vaccine recommendations, and that is what we will do. Vaccines are not all good or bad," Dr. Martin Kulldorff, the panel's chair, said Wednesday. RSV shot An RSV vaccine during pregnancy and another antibody shot called clesrovimab that can be given to newborns have previously been approved by the Food and Drug Administration and recommended by the CDC to prevent the disease. The committee Thursday voted by a majority — five in favor, two against — to recommend a shot for newborns, branded as Enflonsia by Merck, adding another option to the already approved immunizations. Two of the panel's new members — Retsef Levi, an operations management professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and Vicki Pebsworth, the research director of a group focused on preventing vaccine injuries and deaths — voted against recommendations for the shot. Pebsworth said she worried about coadministration of the shot with other childhood vaccines, despite data presented by the CDC's Vaccine Safety Datalink showing that RSV antibody shots being given alongside other vaccines are not resulting in a safety risk. Levi said that he was uncomfortable with clinical trial data he claimed suggested that deaths could be more frequent after use of the shots. He cited his experience as a parent, saying that "as a father, I can feel that I would be concerned." "I don't feel this is ready to be administered to all healthy babies. I think we should take a more precautionary approach to this," Levi said. That was at odds with reviews by the CDC and FDA, which did not turn up evidence of this risk. An FDA official told the panel that the death rates — 0.3% versus 0.2% — were not significant, and that careful reviews of the deaths concluded that their causes were not related to the drug. Another panel member, Dr. Cody Meissner of Dartmouth University, disagreed with Levi, warning that 80% of children hospitalized with RSV are healthy with no underlying conditions. Meissner had previously participated in the deliberations of the committee's work group as an outside adviser, before Kennedy purged its voting members. "The work group has spent an enormous amount of time, the FDA has spent an enormous effort looking at safety and efficacy, and it is simply not an issue here," he said. Flu vaccines The panel is also expected to vote on updated recommendations for influenza vaccines for the coming season, usually a routine annual affair for the committee before Kennedy's purge. This year is different also because Kennedy's committee is now scheduled to vote on vaccines that use thimerosal, a preservative used in a small handful of shots that has been the subject of debunked claims about risks for autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders. Thursday's vote on thimerosal is scheduled to follow a presentation from Lyn Redwood, the former head of a group founded by Kennedy that has lobbied against vaccine authorizations and requirements. The group has been hired to work in the agency's vaccine safety office. Young Cuban girl asks Trump to lift travel ban stopping her from joining mom in U.S. Supreme Court allows South Carolina to block Medicaid funds from Planned Parenthood Hegseth gets defensive over initial assessments about Trump's Iran nuclear sites strikes
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The best wrist braces for carpal tunnel syndrome of 2025, according to hand specialists and health experts
Pain, discomfort and numbness in your fingers can make everyday tasks like pushing a shopping cart or pulling the garbage can to the curb incredibly painful. And while hand and wrist pain can arise from any number of causes, a common culprit is carpal tunnel syndrome. CTS is a neurological condition that occurs when there's compression of the median nerve — one of the three major nerves of the forearm and hand. Pressure on that nerve often results in a tingling sensation, pain and numbness that can make living everyday life more challenging. While it's important to see a health care provider for wrist pain or numbness, one of the most common treatments for mild-to-moderate CTS is bracing. Dr. Raymond Hwang, vice president and medical director at Lantern, says, "Braces help keep the wrist in a neutral, slightly extended position, which relieves pressure on the median nerve as it travels through the carpal tunnel in the wrist. This can reduce numbness, tingling and pain."Certified hand therapist Brenda Cummings says, "Wrist braces for carpal tunnel work by keeping your wrist in a neutral position to alleviate pressure from the median nerve." To be effective, Cummings says, a brace should prevent you from being able to bend your wrist more than 15 degrees in any help find the best wrist braces for CTS, we spoke with orthopedic experts to learn what to look for in carpal tunnel-specific braces, and what to avoid. We learned that a rigid insert or stay (typically made of metal) is key to stabilizing the wrist. These stays may be found on the back of the wrist, the palm of the hand or on both sides. A dorsal support brace (those with stays on the back of the wrist) is often best for CTS since it prevents flexion, but depending on your level of pain or discomfort, a simple wrist brace or wrist wrap worn while sleeping may be the better our experts' feedback, we evaluated more than 20 wrist braces for CTS, rating each based on construction, materials used, breathability, brand reputation, user and in-house tester reviews, cost, comfort and efficacy. These are the eight wrist braces for carpal tunnel that made our cut. Update, June 25, 2025: We checked all product prices and availability. Our No. 1 pick for the best wrist brace for carpal tunnel remains unchanged. Three stages categorize the symptoms and level of severity of carpal tunnel syndrome. Stage 1: Frequently waking in the night with a sensation of a swollen, numb hand or severe pain that radiates from the wrist to the shoulder. There is also tingling in the hand and fingers. After waking, hand stiffness usually persists. Stage 2: The symptoms are present during the day, especially if you stay in the same position for prolonged periods or perform repeated movements or tasks with the hand and wrist. This is the stage where you may have lost so much feeling in your hands and fingers that you frequently drop things. Stage 3: This is the final stage where atrophy can set in and the median nerve may respond poorly even to more advanced treatments like surgical decompression. In this phase, sensory symptoms decline. Comfortable fit: Carpal tunnel braces keep your wrist in a neutral position. Immobilization is important because wrist flexion puts pressure on the median nerve; bracing prevents this pressure. However, in order for the brace to work, it needs to fit correctly. It should be snug enough to provide adequate support, but not so tight that it restricts circulation or causes skin irritation. Material: A big part of comfort has to do with quality materials. Neoprene is one of the best material choices since it offers compression, warmth, elasticity and breathability. Mesh fabric can also add to a brace's overall breathability. Softer materials, like memory foam, can provide padding for additional comfort. Some braces use copper-infused fabrics, which can help deodorize the brace. Most of these wrist braces are not machine-washable, but you can hand-wash some of them. Structure and design: Most braces have a rigid insert on either the dorsal side (i.e., the back of the wrist), the palmar side, or both. Small studies indicate a dorsal support brace may be best for carpal tunnel since it prevents flexion without adding more pressure to the median nerve. Palmar support can be beneficial, too; just make sure that the rigid stays don't press in on the median nerve or that they're removable. Length is also important. "A wrist brace that is too short may apply more pressure to the median nerve," says Cummings. Look for a wrist brace that doesn't stop directly at the wrist and instead extends about halfway up the forearm. Cost: Finally, cost is something to consider. The best wrist brace for you is one that is comfortable and effective, but more expensive doesn't necessarily mean better. To determine the best carpal tunnel braces, our team looked at over 20 different wrist braces and evaluated each based on their efficacy. The truth is, there are many wrist braces on the market, but not all of them work well to alleviate the specific symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome. We considered factors like the overall structure and design of the brace, the amount of stability it provides and how comfortable it is to wear. Finally, we consulted two orthopedic experts, including a hand pain specialist and an orthopedic surgeon to get their input on which braces are the best options for CTS. Dr. John Thomas, a board-certified hand surgeon, says that wrist braces can be extremely beneficial for mild to moderate carpal tunnel, especially when used overnight. "Most people like to curl up and fully flex their wrists at night," he says. "This places pressure upon the median nerve in the carpal tunnel and increases symptoms." In addition to bracing, treatments for CTS include oral anti-inflammatory medication, steroid injections and, in severe cases, surgery to decompress the carpal tunnel and increase space for the median nerve. You shouldn't consider wrist braces as a permanent fixture in your life. Instead, Thomas says, they're best worn for a few weeks. If symptoms don't improve, it's a sign you might need to try a more intensive form of treatment. Dr. Melissa Boyette, an orthopedic surgeon, says, "I would caution against wearing a brace longer than a few weeks if a physician has not evaluated you." She warns that prolonged bracing can lead to stiffness and weakness in the forearms and wrists. Hwang recommends taking frequent hand/wrist stretching breaks, especially for those with repetitive hand motions at work. He also says, "Prevention through ergonomic workstations, exercises, and avoiding excessive wrist bending is important for those at risk." You can also try oral anti-inflammatory medication or a pain-relieving cream for immediate relief. Dr. Melissa Boyette, orthopedic surgeon; hand and wrist specialist, Bradenton, Fla. Brenda Cummings, OTD, OTR, CHT, certified hand therapist, Fort Collins, Colo. Dr. Raymond Hwang, orthopedic surgeon and medical director at Hinge Health Dr. John Thomas, orthopedic hand surgeon, New York City Our health content is for informational purposes only and is not intended as professional medical advice. Consult a medical professional on questions about your health.
