NY pols push IRS to probe nonprofit ‘sanctuary' groups helping defy Trump, federal immigration laws
Reps. Nicole Malliotakis (R-Staten Island) and Claudia Tenney (R-Watertown) questioned the four groups' nonprofit status in a letter to the IRS after an expose by The Post that revealed the groups took in more than $600 million in public funds while simultaneously pushing New York's sanctuary policies.
'We are concerned that these organizations may be using tax-exempt resources to provide goods, services or legal advice that (1) encourages, (2), induce, or (3) aid and abet an alien in unlawfully entering, remaining in, or evading detection within the United States,' the lawmakers said in a Tuesday letter to IRS Commissioner William Hollis Long.
5 Reps. Nicole Malliotakis (R-Staten Island) and Claudia Tenney (R-Watertown) have pleaded with the IRS to probe four nonprofit migrant advocacy groups that have been taking taxpayer funding.
Michael McWeeney
The pro-sanctuary groups — the Bronx Defenders, the NY Immigration Coalition, Make the Road NY and NY Lawyer for the Public Interest — provide legal services to poor New Yorkers, including criminal defendants and migrants.
They said based on prior IRS enforcement of rules for charitable groups the groups' sanctuary activities 'constitutes grounds for revocation of tax-exempt status.'
The Bronx Defenders alone has received more than $500 million in city and state contracts since fiscal year 2018, according to The Post review.
Make the Road NY was awarded $56 million, the NY Immigration Coalition $46 Million and NY Lawyers for the Public Interest, $19 million over the years.
The groups pushed for a statewide sanctuary bill — the New York for All Act — that would bar state and local law enforcement from cooperating with US Immigrations and Customs Enforcement agents.
The Bronx Defenders has fought to block ICE from operating at the Rikers Island jail complex and state courthouses.
5 The lawmakers sent a letter to IRS Commissioner William Hollis Long stating that the organizations are using the tax-exempt resources to possibly aid aliens who are staying in the United States unlawfully.
Tomas E. Gaston
5 The four pro-sanctuary groups mentioned are Bronx Defenders, NY Immigration Coalition, Make the Road NY, and NY Lawyer for the Public Interest.
X / @thenyic
The other groups similarly encourage clients or the public not to cooperate with ICE, said the letter from Malliotakis and Tenney, who are members of the House Ways and Means Committee.
They said IRS rules that grant groups tax-exempt status are for charitable, religious or educational purposes, 'not for groups that leverage taxpayer subsidized benefits to obstruct federal law.'
'Combined with federal tax-exempt benefits, these public subsidies shift the financial burden onto taxpayers who may oppose the recipients' efforts to shield removable aliens from enforcement,' the House members said.
5 The organizations all provide legal services to low-income New Yorkers, including migrants and criminal defendants.
X / @MaketheRoadNY
5 The majority of the migrant-advocacy groups have also encouraged their clients not to cooperate with ICE.
AP
They also noted President Trump's April 28, 2025, executive order that directs agencies to withhold funds from sanctuary jurisdictions such as New York City that restrict or refuse to cooperate with federal immigration authorities.
The IRS, lawmakers said, should examine whether the pro-sanctuary groups' actions 'obstruct' federal immigration enforcement' or engage in 'unlawful advocacy.'
The lawmakers said 'we respectfully request that their tax-exempt status be revoked' if the IRS concludes they violated the rules.
The IRS declined to comment, citing privacy laws for tax-exempt organizations.
Representatives of the groups didn't respond to requests for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
29 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump doubles down on call for Senate nominees before breaking for August recess
President Trump on Thursday doubled down on his call for the Senate to stay in session and confirm his nominees before breaking for their annual August recess. 'The Senate must stay in Session, taking no recess, until the entire Executive Calendar is CLEAR!!! We have to save our Country from the Lunatic Left,' Trump wrote Thursday night on Truth Social. 'Republicans, for the health and safety of the USA, DO YOUR JOB, and confirm All Nominees. They should NOT BE FORCED TO WAIT. Thank you for your attention to this matter!' Trump's demand has been a consistent rallying cry in the past few weeks, as the Senate gears up for its extended break, with several key nominations remaining in limbo. He notably pressed Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) to keep Senate Republicans in town, with Thune saying last week he could consider the move. 'We're thinking about it. We want to get as many [nominations] through the pipeline as we can,' Thune said. On Wednesday, Thune told reporters that there is an expanding interest within the Senate GOP conference for a potential rule change that would accelerate the confirmation process amid the Democrats' effort to slow-walk progress. 'There's certainly interest in looking at options that might enable us to break the logjam and expedite consideration of nominees in a way that, in the end, would benefit both parties when their party has the presidency,' Thune said, according to CBS News. GOP lawmakers have argued that Democrats' strategy is a break from tradition from how Republicans acted toward nominees of then-President Biden. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer's (D-N.Y.) office disagreed, with the spokesperson saying in a statement that 'Historically bad nominees deserve historic levels of scrutiny.'
Politico
an hour ago
- Politico
Trump goes after Susan Collins for her voting record
The simmering dispute over the FBI's future headquarters derailed Senate efforts Thursday night to launch floor debate on the legislation that funds the agency, as well as the departments of Commerce and Justice, NASA and science programs. Sen. Chris Van Hollen objected Thursday night to including the bill in a larger package of funding measures. The Maryland Democrat demanded that the Senate agree to adopt language that would require the FBI to meet a specific security threshold for its headquarters, as the Trump administration keeps the agency in downtown Washington instead of relocating it to the suburban Maryland campus previously selected after a yearslong competition. But Sen. Jerry Moran (R-Kansas), who chairs the funding panel that handles the bill, shot down that request on the Senate floor Thursday night, after the dispute over the FBI headquarters already snagged committee action on the bill. Tearing up as he spoke on the floor, Moran said he knows 'no path forward' that would allow Van Hollen's amendment. 'Our appropriations process is fragile,' he said. If Van Hollen, who serves as the ranking member on the Commerce-Justice-Science Subcommittee, hadn't objected, his amendment would have been teed up for a vote. But Van Hollen didn't want to take the risk that the language would not have been adopted. 'That is a simple request that I would have thought all of us could stand behind,' Van Hollen said, 'making sure that the new headquarters of the men and women of the FBI meets the security requirements that we and they have set out.' Senate appropriators already killed another amendment Van Hollen proposed in committee, which would have barred the Trump administration from dipping into a $1.4 billion construction account for anything besides relocating the FBI to the previously selected site. After the proposal was initially adopted, the committee later voted to strike the language because so many Republicans were threatening to tank the underlying bill if it rebuked Trump on the headquarters decision. 'We did it because the president of the United States was going to throw a fit if that provision stayed on, that's why people reversed the position,' Van Hollen said on the Senate floor Thursday night. 'And we shouldn't make our decisions out of fear about what somebody in the White House is going to do, because that distorts the entire process here in the United States Senate.' Moran's Thursday evening request was to tie together four bills to fund the government for the fiscal year that begins Oct. 1. Those bills would collectively fund the departments of Veterans Affairs and Agriculture, as well as military construction projects, the operations of Congress and the FDA. The Kansas Republican touted that those four measures had made it through the full Senate Appropriations Committee with bipartisan support and 'in some instances, unanimously.'
Fox Sports
2 hours ago
- Fox Sports
NFL Kicks Off Preseason With Moment of Silence After Fatal NYC Shooting
The NFL season kicked off at the annual Hall of Fame game Thursday night with a moment of silence for the four people killed earlier this week by a shooter who was targeting league headquarters in New York. The gunman also wounded a league employee in the shooting Monday night. NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell told NBC he visited the employee for an hour on Wednesday and said the man was improving. "It's just heartbreaking for all of us," Goodell said. "It's devastating. An amazing young man, and so we're optimistic about his recovery and I think that's good news for all of us in the NFL and obviously our hearts continue to be in support with the family. I think it is something that is really hard for all of us to understand and to deal with." Goodell stayed in New York to attend the funeral for police officer Didarul Islam, who was killed in the shooting. "It hits home — the loss, the unnecessary and unexplainable loss — and it's something all of us, you know, as New Yorkers feel great pride in the NYPD and what they do, and all the first responders," Goodell said. "So it was a difficult, emotional afternoon, but also a tremendous, heartwarming service." There was increased security around Tom Benson Stadium, where Eric Allen, Jared Allen, Antonio Gates and Sterling Sharpe will be inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame on Saturday. "That's real life and it's unfortunate that we live in a space right now that's a possibility, and it's becoming a situation where if you're a parent, that's the first thing you think about is workplace safety for your child or for your loved ones," Eric Allen told The Associated Press. "And for it to specifically be the National Football League, the opening week is tonight, Hall of Fame is Saturday, and the game has made so many great strides, but it's just an example of there's still work to be done." The league held a virtual town hall on Wednesday, giving employees an opportunity to connect and share resources. Goodell told employees on Tuesday they could work remotely at least through the end of next week because league offices would be closed. Investigators believe Shane Tamura, 27, of Las Vegas, was trying to get to the NFL offices after shooting several people in the building's lobby, then another in a 33rd-floor office on Monday, before he killed himself, authorities said. Police said Tamura had a history of mental illness, and a rambling note found on his body suggested that he had a grievance against the NFL over a claim that he suffered from chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a degenerative brain disease that can be diagnosed only by examining the brain after a person dies. Tamura played high school football in California a decade ago but never in the NFL. "It is a difficult thing, particularly when you are dealing with senseless acts like this," Goodell said. "They're hard for all of us to understand, when it inflicts pain on people you know and people you care about and people that we deal with on a daily basis, that's particularly hard. "As you know, these acts of senseless violence and hatred are happening around our country and our world, far too often in schools and churches and synagogues and other places. This should just not be happening, but we all have to continue to be vigilant and do what we can to protect ourselves and the NFL's going to do that with our employees and our people." Reporting by The Associated Press. recommended Item 1 of 3 Get more from the National Football League Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more in this topic
