Ganesha idols up to 6 feet must be immersed in artificial ponds, rules HC
The order came a day after the state government informed the court that it had already made immersion in artificial tanks compulsory for idols up to five feet tall. Expanding the mandate, the bench of chief justice Alok Aradhe and justice Sandeep Marne observed, 'We have to make an endeavour that the impact of immersion of idols is bare minimum on the environment. Therefore, idols up to 6 feet should compulsorily be immersed in artificial tanks provided by local bodies.'
The court also directed the state government to ensure its idol immersion policy is implemented 'in letter and spirit' and asked all civic authorities in Maharashtra to make appropriate arrangements to enforce the rule.
The aforesaid guidelines of the state government for immersion of idols shall apply to all festivals wherein practice of immersion of idols is followed which are to be celebrated till March 2026.
BMC flags scale of preparations, logistical challenges
During the hearing, senior advocate Milind Sathe, representing the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), told the court that 85,306 Ganesh idols measuring less than 5 feet were immersed in artificial ponds across Mumbai last year. With the new directive extending the rule to all idols up to six feet, the number of idols expected to be immersed in artificial tanks this year would rise to approximately 1,95,306—an increase of over 110,000.
Sathe added that in 2023, 3,865 idols between 5 and 10 feet in height and 3,998 idols above 10 feet—many of them made of PoP—were immersed in natural water bodies. He pointed out that arranging for the immersion of larger idols in artificial ponds had presented significant logistical challenges in the past, and the new policy would require substantial infrastructural and administrative planning.
Alongside the immersion mandate, the court asked the state to constitute an expert committee to explore eco-friendly methods to recycle PoP material. The committee will be expected to examine scientifically viable ways of dissolving PoP idols without harming the environment.
The legal tussle over PoP continues
The high court was hearing a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by Thane resident Rohit Joshi, seeking implementation of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)'s guidelines prohibiting both the manufacture and immersion of PoP idols. The PIL raised concerns about pollution in rivers, lakes, and other natural water bodies caused by immersion practices.
In contrast, Ganesha idol makers and artisans challenged the CPCB ban, arguing that it threatened their right to livelihood and impacted traditional practices. Taking a balanced view, the court allowed the continued manufacture and sale of PoP idols but barred their immersion in natural water bodies without specific court permission.
'It will be open to the petitioners and artisans to make PoP idols. However, the same shall not be immersed in natural water bodies without the leave of the court,' the bench clarified.
The question of whether PoP idols should be banned from natural water bodies has been under judicial scrutiny since 2003, when the NGO Janhit Manch filed a PIL on environmental grounds. This prompted the CPCB to issue guidelines in 2009, which were updated in 2020 to ban immersion of PoP idols in natural sources while stopping short of prohibiting their production.
A new scientific proposal adds nuance
In April this year, the Rajiv Gandhi Science and Technology Commission (RGSTC)—a statutory body under the Maharashtra government—submitted a report recommending the conditional use of PoP idols. Commissioned by Cultural Affairs Minister Ashish Shelar, the report proposed that PoP idols painted with eco-friendly paints be allowed for immersion in large water bodies such as the sea and major rivers—provided these sites are far from drinking water sources and animal habitats.
The report also recommended exploring 'retrievable immersion' methods that would allow PoP idols to be reused, thus minimising waste and damage to aquatic ecosystems.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
7 hours ago
- News18
‘Irony Died 1000 Times': Jain Temple Pigeon Nets Spark Backlash Amid The Kabutarkhana Row
Last Updated: The photo comes at a time when the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) has been actively shutting down pigeon-feeding spots across Mumbai. A photo from outside a Jain temple in Mumbai is gained widespread attention online as the city continues to clamp down on pigeon-feeding zones. The image, shows safety nets installed on temple windows to keep pigeons out. This has led to accusations of hypocrisy against the very community that has been protesting against the closure of public feeding spots. Many online users questioned how pigeons are welcomed in public spaces but kept out of religious ones. 'Hypocrisy At Its Best' The picture was reportedly taken near Dadar's Kabutarkhana which is one of the city's oldest and most prominent pigeon-feeding spots. The photo shows nets fixed on the temple's windows. The caption shared along with the photo reads, 'Guess what Dadar's Jain temple stands opposite Kabutarkhana. Nets are installed on the temple to keep pigeons out." Guess what Dadar's Jain temple stands opposite Kabutarkhana. Nets are installed on the temple to keep pigeons out. 😂😂😂 — Zoro (@wildcardgyan_) August 6, 2025 In the comment section, people pointed to what they saw as a contradiction in the community's actions as they were defending the right to feed pigeons in public while preventing them from entering temple premises. 'Someone file a petition to get that removed. Poor pigeons need to rest in the shade of the Jain temple," a person said. 'Hypocrisy, if they really love animals they should let the pigeons in along with the stray dogs around," someone else wrote while an individual remarked, 'The drama writes itself." The Court Order And Its Fallout The photo comes at a time when the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) has been actively shutting down pigeon-feeding spots across Mumbai following a Bombay High Court ruling on July 31. The order directed the closure of all kabutarkhanas, citing health risks caused by bird droppings including respiratory issues like 'pigeon lung," damage to heritage sites and nuisance complaints. Soon after, the BMC barricaded many of these sites using tarpaulin covers and bamboo fencing. Warning notices were put up and feeding in public was banned. FIRs were ordered to be filed against violators. Faith And Tradition For many in the Jain and Gujarati communities, feeding pigeons is seen as a religious duty and part of their ancestral traditions. It is closely tied to the idea of jeeva-daya which means compassion towards all living beings and is often considered a way to earn good blessings. Since the ban, several Jain trusts and local groups have voiced strong opposition. At Dadar Kabutarkhana, organisers claimed that nearly 980 pigeons have died due to lack of food. Animal welfare groups have also stepped. They questioned the medical evidence behind the health claims and demanded humane alternatives rather than outright bans. Protests On Thursday morning, hundreds of people, mostly from the Jain community, gathered at Dadar Kabutarkhana in open defiance of the court's order. Protesters tore down tarpaulin covers, climbed over barricades and scattered grains to feed the birds. Police were called in to manage the situation and disperse the crowd. According to BMC data, fines worth Rs 68,700 have been collected from 142 people across various kabutarkhanas between July 13 and August 3. Of these, 61 fines were issued at Dadar alone. About the Author Buzz Staff A team of writers at bring you stories on what's creating the buzz on the Internet while exploring science, cricket, tech, gender, Bollywood, and culture. News18's viral page features trending stories, videos, and memes, covering quirky incidents, social media buzz from india and around the world, Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : mumbai pigeon viral news view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
11 hours ago
- Business Standard
Explained: Why feeding pigeons has become a political flashpoint in Mumbai
A seemingly routine action of covering up a public pigeon feeding area has turned into a full-blown controversy in Mumbai. It has brought to light a complex issue involving religious traditions, public health concerns, and politicians ahead of the city's municipal elections. According to a report by The Economic Times on Thursday, members of the Jain and Gujarati communities allegedly tore down tarpaulin sheets placed over the iconic Dadar Kabutarkhana (pigeon feeding area) by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC). This defied a Bombay High Court ban on pigeon feeding in public spaces. Visuals of the incident have since gone viral, sparking political backlash and reigniting the 'native versus outsider' debate in Mumbai, cultural tension centred around who belongs to the city. These forms of debate centre around identity-linked issues like language, employment, and culture, often arising during elections. Pigeon feeding ban On July 30, 2025, the Bombay High Court ruled that feeding pigeons in public areas such as 'kabutarkhanas' (pigeon feeding spots) posed a serious health hazard and amounted to public nuisance. The court directed the BMC to file FIRs against anyone continuing to feed pigeons in defiance of the order. Rising complaints of respiratory illnesses from pigeon droppings. Environmental and sanitation concerns due to large gatherings of birds in densely populated areas. The order followed complaints from residents, health officials, and environmentalists who argued that unchecked pigeon feeding was harming public health and the urban ecosystem. What is a kabutarkhana? Why is it significant in Mumbai? Kabutarkhanas are traditional public pigeon feeding spots. The most famous among them is the Dadar Kabutarkhana, a Grade II heritage structure located at a key intersection near a Jain temple. For many members of the Jain community, feeding pigeons is a religious and moral act — a form of non-violence and compassion towards living beings. It is seen not just as charity, but as a sacred duty. How did this turn into a protest? Following the High Court's order, the BMC began taking enforcement actions: 142 people were fined between July 13 and August 3, including 51 at Dadar Kabutarkhana. On August 3, the BMC covered the Kabutarkhana with tarpaulin sheets to prevent access. Despite this, on August 6 and 7, groups of Jain protestors forcibly tore down the covers and began feeding pigeons, claiming the birds were starving. Police attempted to intervene, leading to scuffles. Visuals of the protest quickly went viral. What the state government says Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis initially supported enforcement but changed course as tensions rose. On August 5, he said 'abrupt closure' of kabutarkhanas was not advisable. Then he called for 'controlled feeding' under civic supervision to protect both public health and animal welfare. Fadnavis also asked the BMC to set up a formal policy regulating pigeon feeding, explore dedicated aviaries, and conduct scientific studies on health impacts and cleaning methods. Political reactions Shiv Sena (part of ruling coalition) Party MLC Manisha Kayande condemned the protest and said pigeon feeding must be addressed scientifically, not emotionally. Kayande said, "When the kite festival kills birds, where are the animal lovers then?" Bharatiya Janata Party Minister Mangal Prabhat Lodha called the protest 'unfortunate', but emphasised the CM's balanced approach. He suggested police may act against those who broke the law. Congress Leader Vijay Wadettiwar accused the ruling Sena-BJP-NCP government of flip-flopping and trying to 'appease' minority voters ahead of elections. Maharashtra Navnirman Sena Firmly supports the ban and has called for similar measures in Thane. Why is feeding pigeons harmful? Medical experts and civic leaders point to several risks: Respiratory illnesses are caused by inhaling dust and droppings. For example, pigeon droppings can lead to hypersensitivity pneumonitis Spread of fungal infections and zoonotic diseases Overpopulation of pigeons, reliant on human feeding which disrupts urban ecology Shiv Sena's Manisha Kayande said, 'Pigeons become dependent. Feeding them in public spaces has long-term ecological and health impacts.' What happens next? A report will be submitted to the Bombay High Court. The BMC may file FIRs against those who defied the ban. The bottom line What began as a court-ordered public health measure has escalated into a debate over faith, governance, and electoral strategy. The fate of Mumbai's kabutarkhanas now lies at the intersection of religion, law, and public opinion. [With agency inputs]
Time of India
11 hours ago
- Time of India
Vantara offers to build rehab centre in Kolhapur for elephant Madhuri after court-ordered relocation amid backlash
The internet has been roaring, and not in celebration, after elephant Madhuri, also called Mahadevi, was moved from her long-time home at Kolhapur's Nandani Math to Vantara's Jamnagar-based sanctuary. The shift, triggered by a Bombay High Court order following a PETA petition, sent shockwaves across religious and animal welfare circles. But now, in a dramatic twist, Vantara has spoken up, and offered a potential solution. Vantara breaks their silence after uproar over Madhuri's relocation In a statement released Wednesday, the Anant Ambani-led Vantara said it was fully behind bringing Madhuri back to Kolhapur. The centre proposed setting up a satellite rehabilitation facility right in the Nandani area. And this is not just any rehab, it is the elephant equivalent of a five-star spa. After 33 years alone and in chains, Mahadevi (Madhuri) is finally receiving the care she deserves thanks to @petaindia's action! Mahadevi was controlled with weapons and forced into chaotic ceremonies. Now, she's starting a new life with other elephants at @Vantara_RF 🐘💙 A plush rehab plan for elephant Madhuri in Kolhapur The plan includes 24/7 medical care, hydrotherapy pools for joint and muscle relief, a dedicated swimming waterbody for natural movement, laser therapy zones, and a vet clinic. Add to that sand pits for play, soft rubber flooring, and chain-free open spaces for Madhuri to roam in peace. According to insiders, the land for the facility will be finalised in consultation with the Math's spiritual leaders and state authorities. वनतारा व्यवस्थापनाच्या वरिष्ठ अधिकार्यांसोबत मी आज मुंबईत सविस्तर चर्चा केली.महादेवी हत्तीण (माधुरी) पुन्हा सुखरुप नांदणी मठाकडे परत देण्यासाठी महाराष्ट्र सरकारने जी याचिका करण्याचे ठरविले, त्यात सहभागी होण्याचा निर्णय वनताराने घेतला असल्याचे त्यांनी मला आश्वस्त केले आहे.या… 'We never wanted to relocate her,' Vantara clarifies Amid accusations of religious interference, Vantara clarified its role, saying the relocation was purely a court-mandated decision. A spokesperson from the centre confirmed that they were only providing veterinary support and housing as per orders from the Supreme Court and Bombay High Court. At no point, they said, did Vantara request the move or push for it. Their involvement was described as 'strictly procedural.' Supporters believe she belongs with her spiritual family in Kolhapur As protests continue over Madhuri's removal, Vantara has offered full cooperation for any court application seeking her return to Kolhapur. If approved, the shelter is promising not just technical and medical assistance, but a safe, dignified journey back home for the beloved elephant. While Madhuri is reportedly recovering from years of abuse under expert care at Jamnagar, her supporters believe she belongs with her spiritual family in Kolhapur. Vantara's latest announcement could be the compromise everyone has been waiting for.
