University investigating student complaint over Palestinian fundraiser
Emails obtained by The Herald and Liberty Investigates reveal that the university also attempted to prevent the flag from being present at another bake sale fundraiser for a Palestinian charity, scheduled to be held by the University and College Union (UCU) 10 days later, in an 'attempt to avoid a similar issue.'
HWU eventually allowed the flag to be flown after a UCU member questioned whether prohibiting the Palestinian flag was discriminatory.
A HWU spokesperson said it would be investigating the 31 January bake sale event to 'establish a full set of circumstances' and that it would be 'inappropriate to comment' while this is ongoing.
Students lodged a formal complaint against university staff for the handling of controversy surrounding a fundraising event. (Image: Garrett Baylor Stell)
Ms Wood told The Herald she and her fellow students were left feeling 'targeted and uncomfortable' after staff allegedly threatened to use force to remove them if they did not comply with requests to remove their Palestinian flag and leaflets.
She provided documents showing that she had given the university nine days' notice when submitting a request to book a stall for a 'bake sale to raise donations for a Palestinian charity,' which was approved.
Yet on the day of the event, Ms Wood said two members of the university's Safeguarding team told them to remove the flag, allegedly saying it was 'university policy that no political messaging was allowed.'
Read more:
Ms Wood told the Herald: 'The Palestinian flag is not inherently political, any more than any other flag at any event would be. Attempting to remove the flag is discriminatory towards Palestinian students, as it implies their existence is inherently political and they are not welcome or safe on campus.'
"The members running the stall at the time asked why they were being told to remove the flag and leaflets, they were told that it was university policy that no political messaging was allowed, citing that the word "Genocide" on the leaflets was political, and so was the flag.
"The members were also informed that the safeguarding members had received 'numerous' complaints, including one asking for us to be removed, saying 'or there will be trouble.'
Ms Wood added: 'This was extremely concerning that we would receive a threat such as this, and that the safeguarding member took this to us instead of dealing with the student threatening our safety.
"This seems to show a great flaw in their approach to solving conflicts and harassment.'
Ms Wood said the students eventually decided to comply with the requests to remove the items in question so they could continue with their fundraiser.
'After continued attempts to reason, the safeguarding members threatened that if we did not comply, we would be 'removed by force.'
'We have been part of and have ran this same event before several times and have never faced this reaction. This is disappointing, and has made us feel targeted and uncomfortable within our university.'
They put away the flag, and handed out leaflets only to students who asked.
Heriot-Watt University is investigating whether Safeguarding staff ordered students to take down a Palestinian flag because it violated university policy. (Image: Garrett Baylor Stell)
Ms Wood said that she and her fellow students asked for the names of the Safeguarding staff in order to file a complaint, but staff allegedly refused to identify themselves.
A HWU spokesperson said: 'On Wednesday 16 July, we received a formal complaint relating to a bake sale event that took place at our Edinburgh campus on 31 January 2025.
"An investigation will now be carried out in line with our Complaints Handling Procedure (CHP) to establish the full set of circumstances. While the investigation is ongoing, it would be inappropriate to comment further at this time."
Emails disclosed under freedom of information laws reveal that university staff discussed the SPS bake sale 'incident' as they debated how to handle a similar event being held by the local branch of the UCU.
A staff member wrote, on 5 February 2025, that 'in an attempt to avoid a similar issue," they had contacted the UCU organisers to request that they 'didn't provide a flag and that any literature provided reflects University policies.'
According to the email, this 'inadvertently caused an issue.'
The email quotes a response from someone connected to the UCU fundraiser, who questioned the justification for banning the flag.
'I have never seen any literature stating that national flags are not permitted … If you could point me in the direction of any relevant literature, I would be grateful.
'I will also check with UCU as it is important not to have discriminatory situation where the Palestinian flag is the ONLY [sic] one that is not allowed on campus.'
People close to the event told The Herald the Palestinian flag was allowed at the UCU fundraiser.
The revelations come days after it was revealed that HWU agreed to a request from defence company Raytheon UK to monitor students for signs of potential protest activity targeting a career fair held last February.
Raytheon UK's requests – which HWU staff agreed to in an email – included monitoring students' online chats before the event, actively monitoring CCTV and carrying out 'enhanced patrols' during the fair in order to spot signs of students gathering and 'act as a deterrent' to help safeguard the Raytheon UK employees.
The university denied involvement in improper monitoring.
'Heriot-Watt University categorically denies any suggestion of improper monitoring of our community. These allegations completely misrepresent the way the University operates.
'For absolute clarity, our Safeguarding team does not have access to student chat rooms or online discussion forums, nor would they ever be expected or requested by the University to monitor them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Why the case for a 'Scottish visa' just got stronger
But how long can the current state of affairs continue? Starmer has so far resisted calls from the Scottish Government to introduce a "Scottish visa" to help the country deal with the labour shortages it faces, but the issue is simply not going away. Indeed, it seems to be very much uppermost in the minds of many Scottish business owners. As exclusively revealed by The Herald today, 70% of businesses in Scotland support the introduction a tailored 'Scottish visa', according to the latest Understanding Business Survey, conducted by 56° and Diffley Partnership. Such a scheme which would allow migrants to come to work in Scotland, as long as they live and maintain a tax code in the country, and presumably ease the pressure on the many companies which have struggled with skills shortages since the end of freedom of movement. But this would not be unrestrained immigration. Asked what their most important considerations would be if a Scottish visa were introduced, the top two responses from businesses surveyed both related to protecting Scottish workers, with 37% each saying 'maintaining a balance between migrant workers and upskilling local talent' and 'protecting job opportunities for Scottish workers and preventing wage suppression' were important. Business also wanted to ensure that any visa scheme would be easy to navigate for both employers and workers, selected as a top consideration by 35%. Clearly, immigration remains a hot political topic, and with feelings continuing to run high on the topic Starmer's reluctance to implement any big policy changes is perhaps understandable. Especially given that Labour's stance on Brexit was writ large in its election manifesto last year. But for a Government that has made economic growth its central mission, and has now presided over a second consecutive month of GDP decline, it must surely be looking to all the levers it has at its disposal to stem the tide. A Scottish visa, targeted at sectors and companies suffering the most acute skills shortages, would be a step in the right direction.
The National
14 hours ago
- The National
At least 73 Palestinians killed whilst accessing aid in Gaza
It was one of the deadliest days in over 21 months of Israel's genocide in Gaza, as civilians were targeted whilst trying to access food and medical relief. Reports from AP say the highest death toll came in northern Gaza, where 67 people were killed near the Zikim crossing with Israel as aid trucks had just arrived. READ MORE: 'Israel killed my brother. My boycott app in his memory now has 11 million users' According to the UN World Food Programme (WFP), 25 trucks carrying supplies for 'starving communities' entered the area but were met by large crowds that came under gunfire. The WFP condemned the violence as 'completely unacceptable.' Eyewitnesses accused the Israeli military of opening fire on the crowds. Ehab Al-Zei, who had been waiting for flour, told AP: 'Suddenly, tanks surrounded us and trapped us as gunshots and strikes rained down. We were trapped for around two hours.' 'I will never go back again,' he added. 'Let us die of hunger, it's better.' Another survivor, Nafiz Al-Najjar, said tanks and drones targeted civilians 'randomly,' and that he witnessed his cousin and others being shot dead. Israel's military claimed the crowd posed a threat and acknowledged some casualties, but dismissed the numbers reported by Palestinian officials as exaggerated. Medical teams said more than 150 people were injured, many of them in critical condition. READ MORE: 'Beyond shameful': Harvie urges SNP to explain secret talks with Israeli diplomat Elsewhere, seven Palestinians were killed while sheltering in tents in Khan Younis, including a five-year-old boy, according to the Kuwait Specialised Field Hospital. The killings in northern Gaza did not take place near aid points operated by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation – a US- and Israel-backed project. However, health workers and witnesses say hundreds have been killed trying to access aid from that same network. On the same day, Israel issued new evacuation orders in central Gaza, cutting off access between Deir al-Balah and the southern cities of Rafah and Khan Younis. The United Nations is seeking clarification on whether its facilities in the area are included in the order. An unnamed UN official noted that in past cases, UN facilities had been spared, but the scale of the current evacuation zone – which stretches to the Mediterranean coast – will severely limit humanitarian access. Israeli military spokesperson Avichay Adraee urged people to flee to the Muwasi area – a desolate tent camp with no basic infrastructure, now overcrowded with displaced families. The announcement came as ceasefire talks in Qatar failed to produce progress. READ MORE: When 'critical friends' fall out: Angus Robertson's Israel meeting details revealed Pope Leo has since renewed calls for an end to the violence. At the end of his Sunday Angelus prayer from a summer retreat in Castel Gandolfo, he said: 'I once again call for an immediate end to the barbarity of this war and for a peaceful resolution to the conflict.' He also expressed his 'deep sorrow' for the Israeli attack on the only Catholic church in the Gaza Strip on Thursday, which killed three people and wounded 10 others, including the parish priest. 'I appeal to the international community to observe humanitarian law and respect the obligation to protect civilians as well as the prohibition of collective punishment, the indiscriminate use of force, and the forced displacement of populations,' the Pope added. Earlier this month, the Israeli military claimed it had taken control of more than 65% of Gaza. More than 58,800 Palestinians have been killed since the genocide began. Gaza's 2.3 million residents are now facing full-scale famine, displacement, and relentless bombardment, with aid barely trickling in
Powys County Times
17 hours ago
- Powys County Times
More than 70 killed trying to reach aid in Gaza, health ministry says
At least 73 people have been killed while attempting to access aid at locations across Gaza, the health ministry in the Palestinian territory has said. The largest toll was in the northern part of the territory, where 67 Palestinians were killed while trying to reach aid entering through the Zikim crossing with Israel. More than 150 people were injured, with some of them in a critical condition, hospitals said. Seven Palestinians were also killed while sheltering in tents in Khan Younis, including a five-year-old boy, according to the Kuwait Specialised Field Hospital, which received the casualties. It was not immediately clear whether they were killed by the Israeli army or armed gangs, or both. But some witnesses said the Israeli military shot at the crowd. The Israeli military said soldiers had shot at a gathering of thousands of Palestinians in northern Gaza who posed a threat, and that it was aware of some casualties. But it said the numbers being reported by teams in Gaza were far higher than the military's initial investigation found. The military added it is attempting to facilitate the entry of aid, and blamed Hamas militants for fomenting chaos and endangering civilians. The killings in northern Gaza did not take place near aid distribution points associated with the Gaza Humanitarian Fund, or GHF, a US and Israel-backed group that hands out food packages to Palestinians. Witnesses and health workers say hundreds of people have been killed by Israeli fire while trying to access the group's distribution sites. It came as the military published new evacuation warnings for parts of central Gaza, in one of the few areas the military has rarely operated with ground troops. The evacuation cuts access between the city of Deir al-Balah and the southern cities of Rafah and Khan Younis in the narrow enclave. The announcement comes as Israel and Hamas have been holding ceasefire talks in Qatar, but international mediators say there have been no breakthroughs. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly stressed that expanding military operations in Gaza will pressure Hamas to negotiate, though negotiations have been stalled for months. Earlier this month, the Israeli military said it controlled more than 65% of the Gaza Strip. The area of Gaza under the evacuation order is where many international organisations attempting to distribute aid are located. The United Nations has been in contact with Israeli authorities to clarify whether its facilities in south-western Deir al-Balah are included in the evacuation order, an official said. They said that in previous instances, UN facilities were spared from evacuation orders. The evacuation announcement covers an area stretching from a previously evacuated area all the way to the coast and will severely hamper movement for aid groups and civilians in Gaza, they added. On Sunday morning, ambulances in front of three major hospitals in Gaza sounded their alarms simultaneously in an urgent appeal to shed light on the hunger crisis in the territory. The health ministry posted pictures on social media of doctors holding paper signs about malnourished children and the lack of medication. Zaher al-Wahidi, one of the spokesmen at the health ministry, said at least nine children under five have died of malnutrition as of Sunday since Israel imposed the aid entry blockade in March. He explained that tracking the number of people dying of starvation is hard because some could be suffering from other medical conditions that could be worsened when compounded with severe hunger. In northern Gaza, Shifa Hospital director Abu Selmiyah said the facility recorded 79 people who died of malnutrition in the past month. On the new evacuation order, Israeli military spokesman Avichay Adraee warned the military will attack 'with intensity' against militants. He called for residents, including those sheltering in tents, to head to the Muwasi area, a desolate tent camp on Gaza's southern shore that the Israeli military has designated a humanitarian zone. Gaza's population of more than two million Palestinians are in a catastrophic humanitarian crisis.
