Teen born in prison learns fate after stealing €360 worth of clothes
The harrowing background was revealed when the now 18-year-old pleaded guilty to stealing €360 worth of clothes from a sportswear outlet in Tallaght, Dublin, on November 24 last.
He cannot be named because he was 17 at the time of the offence and a juvenile when charged.
At the Dublin Children's Court sentence hearing, Martin Dwan BL, defending, referred to the contents of a pre-sentence probation report and another from his guardian ad litem (GAL), a specialist appointed by a court to represent the best interests of a child in legal proceedings.
Counsel detailed the teen's background, telling Judge Brendan Toale that the youth had been born in prison because his mother had been in custody and had serious addiction issues. He was also born with foetal alcoholism, and Mr Dwan emphasised the youth's "tragic start in life", likening it to a "heavy millstone around his neck".
From infancy, he was in care, but at the age of six, he was placed in a foster home with a family, remaining there for a decade, where he had "stability and a good nurturing life".
However, the youth was "taken out" of that placement and later relocated to care homes around the country, lacking parental guidance.
The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
Mr Dwan quoted another judge, who dealt with one of the youth's earlier cases, that he was "absolutely failed by the State in that regard".
An eleventh-hour GAL report was drafted when he turned 18 and reached adulthood, as Tusla implemented an aftercare plan.
The youth listened intently but did not address the proceedings.
The court heard that due to his mother's drinking problems, the teen was predisposed to addiction. Mr Dwan elaborated about how the teen went on to attend child and adolescent mental health services with issues including PTSD.
The court heard that some problems coincided with the ending of his long-term foster placement; the teenager connected with his family and started to come to garda attention, while abusing alcohol and drugs, which he had a predisposition to from birth.
At one stage, the substance abuse induced psychosis, resulting in the teen being hospitalised.
Judge Toale noted the pre-sentence report assessed the young man as being at moderate risk of reoffending.
He also noted the contents of the GAL report and what he termed the "extraordinary background" to the case, and placed the teenager on supervised probation for six months. During that time, he must not reoffend and must comply with the directions of his probation officer to divert him from further offending; otherwise, the case could be reopened and a harsher penalty considered.
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Former bride weeps in court over failure to get back 'priceless' wedding flowers
A Co Louth woman has wept in court over not being able to get back her 'priceless' and 'irreplaceable' wedding flowers from a woman who was hired to preserve and frame the flowers. At the Small Claims Court at Ennis District Court, former bride, Michelle Markey became visibly upset after telling Judge Alec Gabbett of her failed efforts to obtain the return of her wedding flowers from Co Clare woman, Charlotte Roche. Ms Markey of Oriel Rd, Collon, Co Louth told Judge Gabbett: "My priceless flowers. I gave them away - I would have kept them if I had known I would never get my wedding flowers back." Judge Gabbett said that "wedding flowers hold sentimental value, some people put them on their mother's graves". He told Ms Markey: "I get that sentimentality aspect." The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Ms Markey told Judge Gabbett: "I gave away my - I'm sorry..." and momentarily began to cry before quickly recomposing herself. In response, Judge Gabbett said: "You are okay. It is fine. Take your time. You find the whole thing upsetting because the lack of communication is the biggest issue?" Ms Markey agreed. She said that the flowers are 'irreplaceable'. She said: "I do have evidence to show that this is not an isolated incident and reviews on a website show that this has happened to other brides." There was no appearance in court by Charlotte Roche of Laghtagoona, Corofin, Co Clare who agreed to provide the floral service to Ms Markey. Ms Markey was claiming €350 for the loss of her wedding flowers and Judge Gabbett granted her a decree of €200 for the replacement of the flowers against Ms Roche. He said: "That is the best I can do for you." Ms Markey told Judge Gabbett that she entered a service agreement on October 9, 2023 with Ms Roche when a €50 deposit was paid to Ms Roche for drying, preserving, artwork and framing of wedding day flowers. Ms Markey said that Ms Roche set up a new company, Lush Flower Art Ltd, in 2024. She said that the flowers were received by Ms Roche on November 7, 2023 and Ms Markey said that she was told that 16 weeks would be allowed for the completion of the artworks. She said that after multiple emails and texts between December 2023 and November 2024, including several requests to return the flowers, on November 23, 2024 she was informed via email by Ms Roche that she would not be progressing with the piece. She said: "I requested a return of deposit and flowers and neither was received at this time." Ms Markey said that Ms Roche cancelled the service over a review she had left on a weddings website. Ms Markey said that the deposit was returned on January 4 but no return of flowers and subsequent requests for return of flowers were ignored. Representing herself, Ms Markey told Judge Gabbett she travelled 200km to be in court in Ennis on a six-hour round trip from Co Louth "and had to organise childcare and take a day off work". After seeing that the next Small Claims case on the list was a Kerrie Horgan vs Charlotte Roche (Bradley), Judge Gabbett remarked 'Oh dear'. There was no appearance by either party in that case and Judge Gabbett adjourned that case to September. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Examiner
17 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man accused of €550k arson attack on Cork house further remanded in custody
A 40-year-old man charged in relation to an attack at a house in Cork where there was €550,000 fire damage was remanded in custody for another fortnight. Paul McCarthy of 40 Dowth Avenue, Cabra, Dublin, was remanded in custody by Judge Mary Dorgan until then on a charge of arson at Fernbrook, Ballincrokig, County Cork, on April 24. Nicholas Hall, barrister, complained of delay and applied to have the matter made peremptory against the State – an application refused by Judge Dorgan. Det. Garda Brian Murphy objected to bail when the matter first came before Cork District Court, saying: 'It is alleged that Paul McCarthy drove from Dublin, passing the Watergrasshill toll at 8.30pm. "At 9pm the car arrives at the house and three people exit. Two enter the curtilage of the property and ignited two glass petrol bombs with a blowtorch. They smashed a bedroom window and threw in these petrol bombs. 'The third person – believed to be Paul McCarthy – stands close to the vehicle and allegedly films the incident on his mobile phone.. The Skoda Octavia enters the Plaza filling station in Portlaoise just before midnight and Paul McCarthy is identified, filling the car with €30 diesel and leaving without paying.' A man aged 87 and his 86-year-old wife were watching television in the house at the time. It was quickly engulfed in flames but they were unharmed. Paul McCarthy's next court appearance will be by video link from prison on August 6.
Irish Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Grieving mum of drowning victim Freya Tobin thanks community for their support
The grieving mum and nanny of Freya Tobin, who died after getting into difficulty in the River Suir two weeks ago, have thanked the local community who 'rallied around' them in the 'darkest time of our lives.' Freya, from Newcastle, Co Tipperary, drowned after she got into difficulty while swimming in the River Suir on Friday, July 11 at around 4.20pm. It is understood that Freya along with another friend both got into difficulty swimming around the same time. Freya's friend managed to swim to safety and raise the alarm. A number of local boys heard the screams of the girls and dived into the water to help. In a multi-agency response Gardaí, National Ambulance Service personnel and firefighters from Clonmel Fire Station's swift water rescue team attended the scene. Floral tributes to Freya Tobin in Newcastle, Tipperary Freya was transferred to Cork University Hospital (CUH) by the Irish Coast Guard Air and Sea Rescue 117 helicopter after being recovered from the water at around 4.45pm. The former sixth class student of Scoil Mhuire Caisleán Nua National School sadly died a short time later. Now, in a post on social media, Freya's mum Shannen and nanny Caitriona O'Mahoney have thanked the whole community of Newcastle "from the start of this nightmare you helped us on this journey of life without Freya.' 'It would be impossible to name everyone individually because there's just too many. You helped to make the task of planning and organising our little angel's funeral and rallied around us in the darkest time of our lives. 'We felt the love you had for Freya and the compassion you showed towards us was out of this world. 'This gave us light in the darkness of days and gave us comfort knowing that Freya had a massive impact on our community. 'From the bottom of our hearts we sincerely thank you all and we will be eternally grateful.' The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Earlier, at her funeral mass at Our Lady of the Assumption Church, Newcastle, an emotional tribute was read out on behalf of Freya's mam Shannen: 'Twelve years ago, a precious little angel was sent to me. A beautiful, dark haired little baby with the most beautiful, piercing blue eyes. I named her Freya, after the Goddess of love and beauty, and by God, did she honour that name. 'She instantly filled mine and my family's life with so much love. Her funny, happy and caring personality only grew stronger as each year passed. She was not only my daughter, but my best friend and my life. 'She shone a light even on the darkest of days,' Freya's mam's tribute continued. 'I was so proud of how much love she brought to everyone, no matter where she was, and I'll never forget the way that Freya would light up her room just by entering it, the brightness she brought would never fade.' Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
