Hamas and Israel respond to former Biden official who said Israel 'without a doubt' committed war crimes in Gaza
Hamas and the Israeli government have responded to an interview on Sky News in which a former official in the Biden White House said Israel had "without a doubt" committed war crimes in Gaza.
A statement from Hamas said comments by Matt Miller, who as State Department Spokesman articulated the views of the US government, amounted to a "significant admission that condemns the occupation and exposes its crimes".
On the Trump 100 podcast, Mr Miller was asked if he agreed with the view that actions in amounted to genocide.
"I don't think it's a genocide, but I think, I think it is without a doubt true that Israel has committed war crimes," Mr Miller said.
In a written statement, Hamas said Mr Miller's words reveal that he was, quote, "not allowed to speak the truth while in office and was forced to adhere to the US government's official narrative regarding the occupation's practices".
"This exposes the deep political complicity of US administrations with the occupation and their criminal cover-up of its brutal violations," it added.
And the proscribed terror group said his words "reveal attempts by successive US administrations to obscure the truth about this brutal war against innocent civilians in the Gaza Strip".
A Hamas spokesperson said: "This admission does not only condemn the occupation but also holds Washington directly responsible as an active partner in the war crimes and genocide committed against our Palestinian people in Gaza, through funding, arming, providing political and diplomatic protection, along with spreading misleading media coverage."
Sky News challenged Mr Miller on why he didn't speak up while in government, to which he said: "When you're at the podium, you're not expressing your personal opinion.
"You're expressing the conclusions of the United States government. The United States government had not concluded that they committed war crimes, still have not concluded [that]."
Pressed further on why he didn't offer such views while serving as State Department spokesman, Mr Miller told Trump100: "The State Department did release a report in the spring of last year where, look, there was a bunch of bureaucratic legalese language as the government always [uses] where they did say it's reasonable to assess that Israel has at times acted in violation of the laws of war, or something similar."
He continued: "So the State department itself had concluded - they didn't phrase it in these terms - but I think I did it at the podium, a few times, conclude that it was likely that Israel had committed war crimes, but I do think it's almost certain that they have."
Mr Miller offered a qualifying distinction between state-sanctioned war crimes and individual illegal acts by soldiers.
"There are two ways to think about the commission of war crimes: One is if the state has pursued a policy to deliberately commit war crimes or is acting reckless in a way that aids and abets war crimes.
"Is the [Israeli] state committing war crimes? That, I think, is an open question. I think what is almost certainly not an open question is that there have been individual incidents that have been war crimes where Israeli soldiers, members of the Israeli military, have committed war crimes."
Sky News put Mr Miller's accusations to Israeli government spokesman David Mencer.
"Of course, when there are claims like that, they need to be fairly investigated, but I can tell you that Israel upholds the highest levels of international law that is key in the strategy of releasing our hostages and destroying this terrorist organisation," he said.
Read more:
But to that, Mr Miller, out of office, now echoes a point repeatedly put to him by journalists while he was in office, at the podium: that Israeli investigations so often go nowhere.
At the podium, he repeated phrases like "...we are asking the Israelis to investigate...", "...we are concerned by what we have seen...", "...we are waiting for the results of the Israeli investigation...".
Now, Mr Miller says: "We do know that Israel has opened investigations, but look, we are many months into those investigations and we're not seeing Israeli soldiers held accountable.
"We have not yet seen them hold sufficient numbers of the military accountable and I think it's an open question whether they are going to."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Bodies of 2 hostages recovered from Gaza in Israeli military operation
June 5 (UPI) -- Israel said Thursday it had recovered the remains of two Israeli-American hostages in a military operation overnight in the Khan Yunis area of southern Gaza. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in a post on X that the bodies of Gadi Haggai, 72, and Judy Weinstein-Haggai, 70, had been returned to their families in Israel 20 months after they were killed in the Oct. 7, 2023, attack on southern Israel and taken back to Gaza. He said the married couple were recovered in a special operation mounted by the Israeli Security Agency and Israel Defense Forces. "I would like to thank, and express appreciation to, the fighters and commanders for this determined and successful operation. We will not rest, nor will we be silent, until we return home all of our hostages -- the living and the deceased," Netanyahu said. The couple, who held U.S. citizenship, were out for a morning walk near their home in Kibbutz Nir Oz when they were gunned down by Mujahideen Brigades fighters who joined the Hamas-led attacks on Oct. 7 in which around 1,200 Israelis were killed and hundreds abducted. "We welcome the closure and their return to a proper burial at home, in Israel," a statement from the families of Haggai and Weinstein said. Judy Weinstein-Haggai was born in New York but moved to Toronto, Canada, with her family at the age of 3. She married Gadi Haggai after meeting him while working as a volunteer on a kibbutz in the 1970s, according to a bio posted on social media. Gadi Haggai was described as a retired chef, a passionate jazz musician, and a devoted father and grandfather. Israeli President Isaac Herzog said it was a painful time but also a moment of solace. "We will continue to do everything in our power to bring our sisters and brothers back from hell -- the living, for healing and rehabilitation, and the fallen, to be laid to rest in dignity. Every last one of them!" Herzog said on X. The couple's recovery means 54 out of the 251 people originally taken hostage remain in Gaza, of whom about 20 are believed to be still alive. As of Wednesday, Gaza's health ministry, which is run by Hamas, put the number of Palestinians killed since Israel launched its military response a day after the Oct. 7 attacks at 54,607 and 125,341 injured. The "Bring Them Home Now" Hostages and Missing Families Forum said it wanted to stress that a grave was a basic human right and called for authorities to do whatever was necessary to reach an agreement that will see the return of the rest of the hostages, "the living for rehabilitation and the murdered for burial." "There is no need to wait another 608 agonizing days for this. The mission can be completed as early as tomorrow morning. This is what the majority of the Israeli people want." Thursday's rescue came hours after the United States vetoed a draft U.N. Security Council resolution for an "immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire" in Gaza. The Slovenia-sponsored resolution, which also called for the unconditional release of all the hostages held by Hamas and other groups and the immediate lifting of all restrictions on aid going into Gaza, was defeated in a 14-1 vote on Wednesday evening in New York, the U.N. said in a news release. Slovenia's representative to the U.N. expressed disappointment at the vetoing of a measure motivated by humanitarian intentions, saying "starving civilians and inflicting immense suffering" was inhumane, in breach of international law and unwarranted by any war objective. U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Dorothy Shea said Washington could not support rewarding Hamas with a permanent cease-fire that would leave it with the ability to carry out further attacks and criticized the "false equivalence" drawn between Hamas and Israel in the text of the draft resolution. She also argued that the draft did not make any mention of the failings of the system used operated by the U.N. and aid charities to distribute humanitarian assistance in Gaza, which she said had been exploited by Hamas for its own benefit. "Performative actions designed to draw a veto" would only serve to undermine efforts to resolve matters through quiet diplomacy currently underway between the parties, said Shea.
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
US vetoes UN ceasefire resolution in Gaza
The US vetoed a United Nations Security Council resolution calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza. All 14 other members backed the measure, but the US voted against, saying that the wording did not condemn Hamas. US-Israel relations have cooled in recent months — President Donald Trump did not visit the country during his recent Middle East tour, and his relationship with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is tense, with disagreements including over the best way to deal with Iran. But Washington remains firmly behind Israel on the war, to the frustration of the UN: Its humanitarian chief said the scenes of people being 'shot, wounded or killed in Gaza while simply trying to eat' were 'horrifying.'
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
U.S.-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation says it will open two aid distribution centers on Thursday
DUBAI (Reuters) -U.S-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) said it will open two aid distribution centers on Thursday. GHF had said earlier that its sites would not open at their usual time due to maintenance and repair work. It did not say when aid distribution would resume. The group, which has been fiercely criticised by humanitarian organisations, including the United Nations, began distributing aid last week. The U.N. has warned that most of Gaza's 2.3 million population is at risk of famine after an 11-week Israeli blockade of the enclave.
