Bill 106 will not boost productivity of doctors: health policy expert
There is scant evidence that the Quebec government's proposed bill to tie doctors' pay to their performance will lead to more patients being treated, argues a prominent health policy expert.
Damien Contandriopoulos, a professor of public health at the University of Victoria who had previously taught at the Université de Montréal, is highly critical of Bill 106, which proposes linking up to 25 per cent of a doctor's pay to performance targets as an incentive for them to take on more patients.
'It's a government that likes the notion of direct control, top-down, all the way from the ministry to the worker,' Contandriopoulos said in an interview Wednesday after he testified on Bill 106 at a National Assembly hearing.
'Centralized systems, data collection, heavy monitoring, and this kind of top-down, direct-control approach is generally not a great fit for super complex, extremely large systems like the health-care system,' he added.
Bill 106 has sparked an intense backlash in the medical community, with physicians charging that the legislation would drive some doctors away from the profession or the province — and worsen patient care. The bill follows Health Minister Christian Dubé's creation of Santé Québec in December to run the province's $65.5-billion-a-year public system. Despite opposition to Bill 106, Premier François Legault has said the Coalition Avenir Québec government intends to have the legislation adopted.
Dubé tabled the bill on May 8 amid contract negotiations with two Quebec federations representing physicians. The 25-per-cent pay figure tied to performance targets was calculated in a mathematical formula that Contandriopoulos described as 'complete nonsense.' Even if the performance targets aren't met, doctors would still receive 10 per cent, according to the formula written in the bill.
In Contandriopoulos's report on Bill 106, he wrote similar past incentives in Quebec have not notably increased doctors' capitation — which is the term used for the number of patients a physician has on their roster, and the new rules would only make it harder for them to do their jobs.
He illustrates that financial incentive systems are prone to 'gaming,' meaning doctors will try to exploit the system's flaws to their advantage.
He cited a recent initiative in Quebec, the 'Guichet d'accès pour la clientele orpheline,' which tied a payment incentive to the registration of new patients. Because of a flaw in the system, he suggested many doctors retroactively enrolled patients who had already been treated. This gave physicians the financial benefit despite the fact they didn't take on additional patients.
He also suggested that with Bill 106, doctors may be less motivated to take on complex cases that require extra attention and expertise if their remuneration were based largely on the number of patients they see. As a result, doctors may flood their schedules with patients who could be treated by nurses, social workers or other health professionals on their team as a way to maximize their patient load and increase their remuneration, Contandriopoulos said.
If a doctor delegated their straightforward patients to nurses and social workers, 'then they would be stuck with demanding, challenging, long visits,' he explained, adding that this approach would be effectively penalized under Bill 106.
'They would go bankrupt because the system doesn't reward them to do so. So if we want physicians to really focus on the work that they are the best trained to do and where the benefit for society is the highest, we need to incentivize them to really focus on (these complex cases), which we do not.'
Dubé said during a scrum Tuesday afternoon that Bill 106 won't be adopted this session of the National Assembly and he would like for discussions to continue.
Amid the hearings on Bill 106, Dubé reiterated he wants 100 per cent of Quebecers to have access to a health professional by the summer of 2026.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
4 days ago
- CTV News
EXCLUSIVE: B.C. paid private nursing agencies $508 million in just two years
British Columbia's health authorities have cut cheques to private staffing agencies totalling a little more than half a billion dollars in just the last two years, in order to have enough nurses to keep the province's hospitals, operating rooms and care homes open to patients. CTV News spent months trying to update the figures, which show the province has been spending more and more every year since the pandemic, despite trying to scale back reliance on the short-term contractors. Read more: Explosion in reliance on for-profit health-care staffing agencies in B.C. For example, Vancouver Coastal Health spent $5.7 million in the 2019/20 fiscal year and $43 million in 2024/25. Northern Health spent the most of any health authority, going from $12.6 million in 2019/20 and soaring to $92.2 million last year, with 19 per cent of their nursing costs paid to agencies. B.C. health care agency spending 'It's a trap for the healthcare system,' said University of Victoria nursing professor Damien Contandriopoulos, who described it as a vicious cycle with more staff opting to leave full-time work and the inability to refuse overtime for higher hourly pay and the ability to dictate their own schedules. Read more: Outcry and pushback against B.C.'s 'outrageous' spending on health-care temp agencies 'There is no easy way out because when you look at the workforce, we have more nurses per person in B.C. now than we had pre-COVID,' he said. 'The only reason (this is happening) is dysfunction, but that dysfunction is not going to be miraculously solved by agency nurses.' B.C. health care agency spending Unionized travel growing, but not enough The BC Nurses' Union has been encouraged to see members who are interested in working in communities across the province doing so through the GoHealth program, but isn't surprised the reliance on the temp agencies continues to grow. 'If health authorities and government are willing to spend this kind of money on for-profit, private nursing services, then why wouldn't we want to invest in the nurses that are already here in British Columbia?' said BCNU president, Adrian Gear. 'They have been holding up the system for a number of years.' So-called 'agency nurses' used to be a valuable resource in rural and remote communities to cover vacations or medical leave, but have become the norm in every health authority in the province. They have the same licensing and qualifications as unionized, publicly-employed staff but make more per hour to plug scheduling holes in various acute and long-term care facilities. Gear urged the government to follow through on their promises to establish reasonable nurse-patient ratios and to understand 'nurses require (better) working conditions and could be treated better,' in order to stay in the public system. The ministry responds It's always been difficult to obtain the numbers on how many public dollars are going towards private staffing agencies, and when CTV News first started reporting on this issue in 2022, the health authorities insisted that contact tracing and vaccination clinics required during the COVID-19 pandemic were driving the numbers. But now that nurses have experienced the hefty paycheques and ability to determine days off, it's hard to go back on that kind of flexibility and cash in hand. Last year, then-health minister Adrian Dix acknowledged they'd need to rely on the agency staff to keep hospitals and other facilities open while they tried to ramp up recruitment for permanent, union positions. Current health minister, Josie Osborne, was unavailable to speak to the issue on Tuesday, and a ministry spokesperson sent an email statement pointing out the rate of increase has slowed and that agency staff are only used as a last resort. The ministry said contracts have been standardized and they're working on making disclosure of agency expenditures more transparent, but they made the same claim last year and the payments are just as opaque and difficult to obtain as they've always been. With mounting pressure to control costs as they already face a record deficit, the B.C. NDP has been looking for areas to scale back spending. At first blush, it might seem that slashing agency expenses could be one area, but then they'd essentially have to choose between balancing the books and shutting down even more emergency departments or making for longer waits for care. Gear is urging them to cut out the middlemen and 'to invest in the people that are delivering the care, not investing in for-profit, businesspeople that are, frankly, exploiting the situation.'
Vancouver Sun
6 days ago
- Vancouver Sun
New to B.C.'s school curriculum this fall: CPR, naloxone, cardiac arrest devices
All Grade 10 students will learn first aid in gym class starting in September, and every B.C. school will be required to have medical kits to treat cardiac arrests and reverse overdoses. These significant Ministry of Education policy changes are the direct result of persistent advocacy by a group of Vancouver high schools students who watched their friend die from cardiac arrest , as well as from the parents of a University of Victoria student who didn't get the help she needed after being poisoned by toxic drugs. 'That's cool to hear. That's really great,' Tobias Zhang, who is going into Grade 12 at Point Grey Secondary, said Monday when told about the changes. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. 'It makes me feel like I can rest a little bit easier now. It's nice to know that this device will be in schools, and we'll all be a little bit safer in school.' Zhang and several of his classmates began lobbying last year for automated external defibrillators, or AEDs, for their school after his best friend collapsed during a Grade 9 basketball tryout in 2022. The 911 operator told the students to find an AED, but the school didn't have one. The ministry confirmed that performing CPR and using AEDs will now be part of the Grade 10 physical education curriculum at public and private schools when classes resume this fall, so 'every student will have the opportunity to gain these life-saving skills.' A ministry email said a ministerial order covering support services in schools was amended last month to make having AEDs and overdose-reversing naloxone kits mandatory. The two medical devices must be in all secondary schools before the end of 2025, and in elementary and middle schools by September 2026, the ministry says. The jury at a coroner's inquest into last year's preventable overdose death of UVic student Sidney McIntyre-Starko recommended in May that secondary schools should teach CPR and administering naloxone. Sidney's parents, Ken Starko and emergency room physician Dr. Caroline McIntyre, have created a public campaign to push for similar changes. On Monday, McIntyre applauded the policy adjustments. But she wishes information about the lethal drug supply and how to reverse overdoses would also be taught in classrooms, since toxic drugs are the leading cause of death for British Columbians ages 10 to 59. 'We are grateful that CPR and AED training will be part of the curriculum. Every child deserves to learn these basic, life-saving skills,' she said. 'I hope they include education about the toxic drug crisis, how to respond to an overdose, as well as naloxone training.' Melanie Cheng, president of the Vancouver District Parent Advisory Council, said the changes were long overdue. 'It's become an industry standard to have an AED at a recreation facility. Why not a school site,' she asked. 'It shouldn't be an option for districts. It should be mandatory. These are critical life skills that students need.' Vancouver school trustee Christopher Richardson backs the CPR, AED and naloxone requirements, but wonders why the province didn't institute them earlier. 'Let's not wait until a coroner's inquest demands this,' said Richardson, who supported the students' AED efforts. Last year, the Vancouver school board rebuffed the students' AED requests, based on advice from Vancouver Coastal Health that the devices were only necessary in schools with children with existing health conditions. The board made this call despite the fact many other districts already had AEDs in their buildings. In January, though, the board reversed course and asked the province for $250,000 to buy AEDs for all 107 schools . The new provincial directives, though, do not come with funding, so the Vancouver district will have to find the money for the AEDs, Richardson said. 'I was gravely disappointed,' he said. 'When they mandated (these changes), there was no funding. And they made that very clear.' Zhang and his friends have raised nearly $14,000 to help Vancouver school buy AEDs. Zhang said being part of the solution made him feel like he and his friends accomplished something important. While CPR and AED training are meaningful skills, what is more relevant to young people is giving them naloxone kits and training to use them, added Richardson, who is a special constable with the Vancouver police. 'Having free and easy access to nasal naloxone would improve intervention outcomes even more,' agreed Starko, Sidney's father. 'And we hope for increased government action against import of unregulated drugs and their component chemicals.' B.C.'s toxic drug crisis has claimed more than 16,000 lives since it was declared a provincial health emergency in 2016. When Sidney overdosed in a UVic residence, student witnesses immediately called 911 and campus security, who have first aid training. But she died of oxygen deprivation after not getting naloxone for 13 minutes and CPR for 15 minutes. lculbert@ For more health news and content around diseases, conditions, wellness, healthy living, drugs, treatments and more, head to – a member of the Postmedia Network.
CBC
01-08-2025
- CBC
N.S. given mixed review on overhaul of housing for people with disabilities
An independent monitor says Nova Scotia is making gradual progress in some aspects of its five-year plan to move people with disabilities out of institutions and off waitlists for community housing. However, Michael Prince also notes in his second annual report that the government is "heading in the wrong direction" on other portions of its response to a legally binding human rights decision. In his conclusion to the 55-page report, Prince wrote the province is "gaining traction," and moving toward meeting the program's 2028 deadlines on 24 of the 90 legally required steps, but added it is "not yet advancing consistently and comprehensively toward the outcomes." The province's five-year plan — referred to by the Disability Rights Coalition and the province as "the remedy" — is the result of a 2021 Appeal Court decision that identified systemic discrimination against people with disabilities seeking housing and supports in the community. A human rights board of inquiry subsequently provided the list of reforms required to address the province's shortcomings. Prince, a professor of social policy at the University of Victoria, was appointed in 2023 to provide annual reports on the province's progress. 2028 goal Under the provincial plan, 400 people are expected to be moved into new housing and care programs in the communities of their choice by 2028, when all of the institutions would be closed. Last year, Prince's report found the province made only "slight progress" — defined as "minimal" and "marginal in result" — on almost half of the 90 legally required steps to improve housing and support of people with disabilities. The latest report says the number of people living in institutions dropped by 189 — about three-quarters of the original plan's goal for this year. In addition, the number of people on a waitlist to receive some form of service from the disability supports program has fallen by 293, exceeding the target for this year. In 2022, the list had about 1,800 people on it. However, Prince also notes that in some areas the figures are going in the opposite direction. One example is a program called "homeshare" — where community members share their home and provide support to individuals with disabilities who choose to live with them. 'A case of inaction' The monitor called this "a case of inaction," in that none of the planned 240 homeshare places planned for by now are yet in place. Prince said in his report this poses a risk to the successful transition of about 400 residents in large facilities to community housing. In addition, the number of people with disabilities who are under 65 still living in nursing homes rose, and there was a sharp increase in people placed in emergency, temporary housing arrangements. "The increase amounted to 52 more young people admitted to long-term care facilities or 12 per cent growth. It is hard to square these results with the province's assessment of this requirement as complete. This appears to be unnecessary institutionalization, imposing disadvantages on the individuals concerned," wrote Prince. Prince also noted that only about a third of new staff — 26 of the 65 expected by Year 2 — slated to provide "intensive" support to help people move were in place. In addition, only about half of the 50 staff slated to provide support in communities by Year 2 were in place. However, the monitor saw improvements in this area from the last year, and noted that by the spring of 2026, the province anticipates a "targeted recruitment campaign" over this summer will yield results. The province has pointed to labour shortages in the health-care sector as being among the key reasons for the delays in hiring. Co-operation needed The annual report emphasized the need for the province to heighten a focus on co-operation among various departments and programs to provide support for people moving from facilities into the community. That co-operation will be crucial in setting up mental health support programs in the community, along with rapid response teams for issues that may arise for people who are living in new forms of housing, says the report. Prince wrote that he believes the premier's office and key cabinet ministers should be more involved in ensuring that various, multidisciplinary support teams start being set up. "Making the remedy a major policy priority requires sustained strategic involvement by key cabinet ministers and the premier's office," he wrote.
