You might think a planning application for a windfarm is good news. You'd be wrong
planning application
to An Coimisúin Pleanála . It concerns a wind farm on Slieve Aughty in rural Co Galway, consisting of 70 major wind turbines with generating capacity to power 30,000 homes.
You might think that is good news, bearing in mind that
we are falling far behind our national targets
to build renewable wind generating capacity both on land and offshore. We have recently seen a number of setbacks for wind power projects.
A wind farm of that size and capacity would cost up to €200 million in today's prices.
But you would, alas, be very wrong about this being good news.
READ MORE
The planning application is, in fact, to dismantle the existing GWL wind farm and to remove the existing 70 turbines, to demolish the electricity substation to which they were connected and the compound in which the substation is connected, to remove the 110 kV overhead line connecting the facility to the national electricity network at a different substation, to deconstruct that substation and control building, to remove all other ancillary equipment, and to restore the Ennis-Shannonbridge 110 kV power line to its old condition.
The planning application will also entail establishment of three temporary compounds for execution of all that work and other work on the network of existing service roads for the 70 turbines, as well as improvements to existing access roads and forestry tracks at the site.
The application envisages that the site of the GWL wind farm will be abandoned, but with its network of 70 turbine foundations – large concrete cubes – left intact and useless on the mountain top.
The GWL wind farm was built at an unstated cost in 2003 but it would cost in the order of €200 million to construct today. GWL – a wholly owned subsidiary of the
ESB
– intended the wind farm to function until 2040. It had a lease on the land where the wind farm is situated.
So, all the undisclosed capital cost of building the wind farm, and its planned partial demolition and disconnection from the national grid, is laid at the feet of taxpaying citizens.
The taxpayer has, in addition, already incurred liability for EU fines in the order of €20 million arising out of this debacle.
How did this all happen?
It seems that
ESB/GWL did not carry out an appropriate environmental impact assessment (EIA) back at the beginning
. Nor did the county council require one.
No adequate consideration, it seems, was given to the potential impact of a peat slide risk occasioned by the construction works.
As a result, excavation material for the large concrete foundation plinth for Turbine 68 was deposited on adjoining blanket peat, apparently occasioning a peat slide down a small valley on the site. That resulted in 250,000 cubic metres (approximately the volume of 100 Olympic swimming pools) of
peat sliding downslope
and some of it polluting a small river, killing an estimated 50,000 brown trout, and causing temporary peat pollution to a small lake used as a local water source.
The European Commission then brought proceedings against Ireland for the inadequacy of our EIA regime enforcement and eventually started fining Ireland for failing to deal with the resultant damage caused by the peat slide.
[
The Irish Times view on Ireland's wind energy: opportunity must not slip past
Opens in new window
]
GWL applied to An Bord Pleanála for retrospective retention of the wind farm, and after an exhaustive process the board's inspector recommended that GWL be granted retrospective retention. His reasoning was impeccable in law and common sense.
Alas, somehow convinced that allowing GWL to retain the wind farm would be invalid in EU law because the environmental damage done was irreversible, the board
overruled its own inspector
, and went on to effectively decide that the entire wind farm was an unlawful development that needed demolition.
Imagine a similar decision had been arrived at on similar EIA grounds – say, in the case of a motorway toll bridge scheme in France – would the commission or the Court of Justice have demanded its demolition? Or would they be content to allow the bridge to stand provided the toll bridge developer did not thereby profit? It is hard to imagine that such a ridiculous demolition would be ordered.
But instead of punishing the ESB by depriving GWL of its wind farm, Ireland allowed the ESB to operate the wind farm until the planning board's wrong-headed refusal of retention. And now
the whole wind farm is to be demolished
, less the large foundations. We lose a vast amount of taxpayer money – and renewable energy for 30,000 homes.
Instead of accepting a legally sound
Seanad Bill to preserve the wind farm for the public
, while depriving the ESB of its ownership and investment, the last government chose to ensure that the Bill was voted down last year.
Why must we lose €200 million in today's value and the loss of alternative energy for 30,000 homes?
On no sane view – even of EU law – could demolition of the Derrybrien wind farm be justified.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
How to cope with the loneliness of being a CEO
It's lonely at the top. The burden of responsibility, complexity of leadership and the speed of decision-making weighs heavily on chief executives. Although little research exists on this topic, a small recent Canadian survey of 106 chief executives (46 of whom were interviewed in depth) found that 25 per cent reported frequent loneliness and 55 per cent had experience of moderate yet significant periods of loneliness. You'd think the skills that help people ascend and excel at work – strong social bonds, political acumen and quick intelligence – would mean they feel less alone, but it doesn't. They're just as human and needy as we are. This week I spoke to top leaders in Ireland about their advice to fellow executives on how to ward off loneliness in leadership. When are loneliness levels the highest? Perhaps unsurprisingly it's during periods of organisational upheaval: financial issues; regulatory or supply chain changes; political and economic crises; lay-offs; reputational issues; and during natural or man-made disasters. Decisions need to be well informed and made quickly. Despite the backing they may feel from their senior executive team, board, shareholders and others, the buck ultimately stops with them. That's not easy. READ MORE Chief executives can listen and consult all they want, but final decisions – both the popular and the unwelcome – generally fall to them alone. Sometimes they can share the reasons and reasoning behind the decision, but confidentiality and market sensitivity mean they may be unable to disclose information to even their closest associates. They are also keenly aware of the impact their decisions have on others' careers and finances. One leader who has worked in both the public and private sector told me: 'It can be lonely because you feel the pressure of responsibility, but ultimately, that responsibility is part of the job.' Thankfully there are ways for chief executives and senior management teams to relieve that burden. 'There are two primary strategies for alleviating loneliness among CEOs: self-oriented strategies, which focus on looking after your emotional wellbeing; and network-orientated strategies, which help build support from your team. So be kind to yourself and encourage your team to do the same so they have the energy to support you,' states the research by Prof Alaric Bourgoin of HEC Montreal and Saouré Kouamé of the University of Ottawa Build a trusted tribe Leadership is not a solitary task, despite the prevalence of the outdated 'great man' model, and leaders do not need to know all the answers. That's a good thing, as effective modern leadership involves an appreciation of the collective intelligence of the team. Good leaders know how to ask great questions and to listen to everyone attentively. Building a culture where your leadership team can disagree with you and each other is important — Multi-sector leader 'One of the easiest ways for a leader to fail is to forget that her power is limited in isolation and nearly endless if amplified throughout the collective intelligence and resources of the community,' says John Coleman, author of Harvard Business Review's Guide to Crafting Your Purpose. Too often, leaders think it is their job alone to research and map out solutions. Then they just expect others to follow along blindly. That's a way of thinking that belongs in the rubbish bin of history. You are not burdening others, or failing as a leader, by asking them what they think or how they might go about solving a particular problem. Projects tend to have better outcomes when they're shared and solved collectively. Why hesitate to use all the intelligence and experience available to you in your team? Leaders need to rely on their boards, their executive teams and their staff, and to remember to build networks of leaders outside their industry too. Chief executives who intentionally build these connections and seek out support are more likely to be more energised and focused. There's no doubt that when leaders put themselves out there, help suddenly appears and complex problems are more easily solved. Chief executives need to find and build a trusted tribe. Look for people outside the formal leadership team who have the respect, influence and ability to move things forward in line with company strategy. They must be willing to be honest with you and to challenge your thinking. Make sure they're a diverse group, including strategists and operational experts who can work to help you clear obstacles. 'I have found it helpful having board members or other CEOs with whom I can have a less formal, yet still relatively private discussion, in addition to being able to consult with the team,' one multi-sector leader told me. [ Ireland fined €1.54m for delay in writing EU work-life balance directive into law Opens in new window ] The journey is certainly more exciting when you're sharing it with people along the way. 'Building a culture where your leadership team can disagree with you and each other is important (the principle of healthy discussion being that you can 'disagree without being disagreeable'), as well as being happy to build on each other's ideas,' she said. It's also important to stay connected to all levels of the organisation. A technology leader told me, 'Through insisting on one-to-ones with people, I manage to sustain a sense of connection and togetherness.' Take time back When everyone wants your time, self-care and periods away from the pressures of work are essential. One veteran retail leader told me to 'ruthlessly protect your calendar'. You need time blocked out for thinking, not just doing. Look at your week and track how much of the time is spent leading as against responding. Ensure you have regular time – hours, not minutes – for strategy and focused work so you don't get lost in constant meetings, requests and emails. The best leaders are self-aware leaders. They know who they are, both good and bad, and use that knowledge to effectively lead themselves and their team. If you're terrible at blocking out time for strategy, analysing the finances in detail or developing talking points for the board, admit it and get someone in to help teach you these skills or to do it for you. There's no shame in that. When delegating work or sharing your work challenges, don't think of it as just dumping the work on someone else: use it as a way for them to develop new skills and ways of thinking. [ Can we just have one day when no one mentions AI? Opens in new window ] You are more than just a leader of the business. It's important to have a life outside of work that sustains and fulfils you. The tech leader says she feels less lonely when she connects to her feelings through music, through the words of her team and through her own spoken word. 'I find the moments to re-anchor and reconnect through live gigs when possible,' she said. She also keeps a percentage of her salary aside for a career coach and therapists 'so I think out loud and don't leave things unsaid, no matter how hard'. 'Having a private life – family, hobbies, time out – is good. You can feel 'on' 100 per cent of the time, but that's not necessarily healthy in the long run, so time to detach when possible is a positive,' said the multi-sector leader. Margaret E Ward is chief executive of Clear Eye, a leadership consultancy. margaret@
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Irish web design firm Granite Digital buys Rupert Murdoch's Zesty
The deal is expected to boost Granite's annual revenues to about €20m this year. Last November, Granite had expected to generate turnover of more than €18m in 2025. One of the companies behind Granite Digital posted a €433,000 profit in 2023, the last year for which accounts are publicly available. News UK publishes titles including The Times, The Sun and The Sunday Times, and also owns Virgin Radio in the UK. Scott Taunton, executive vice-president of News UK's broadcasting division, said the sale of Zesty to Granite will help the agency achieve its long-term growth potential. Zesty's staff will join Granite's team of digital specialists in its offices in Dublin, Cork, Galway, Belfast, New York and Dubai. Granite Digital was founded in 2009. It provides services including web design and development, digital marketing and search engine optimisation. Audi, Intel, Red Bull, Dalata Hotel Group, Lidl and Pepsi are among its clients. Zesty provides web design and development services. It was founded in 1996. Its clients include Bank of Ireland, Belfast City Council, Power NI, Rentokil and Phoenix Natural Gas. Granite said the acquisition of Zesty reinforces the firm's position as Ireland's largest independent digital agency, and expands its geographic footprint. The combined group has 170 employees and more than 1,200 clients. Conor Buckley, the CEO of Granite Digital, said the acquisition of Zesty is another 'transformative milestone' for the company. 'This deal strengthens our ability to deliver end-to-end digital solutions while expanding our technical expertise and geographic reach,' he said. Granite Digital has made a number of acquisitions in the past. Last year, it bought Limerick-based data science and digital marketing firm Coalface, and Dublin-based digital design agency Wondr. That added companies including An Post and the ESB to Granite's client list. In 2023, Granite bought Galway-based digital design firm Armour, and acquired a majority stake in New York-based creative agency LCM247. In June 2024, the company announced plans to create 50 jobs in New York by 2027 as it expands its business there.
Irish Times
14 hours ago
- Irish Times
Jewellery chain Claire's appoints administrators to business in Ireland and Britain
The Irish and British businesses of struggling jewellery chain Claire's has fallen into administration, putting 2,150 jobs at risk. The retailer formally appointed insolvency practitioners from Interpath Advisory on Wednesday, a week after the chain's parent group filed for bankruptcy protection in the US. Interpath had been recently tasked by the US parent company to find a buyer for the European operation but, according to reports from the UK, the company struggled to find a financial backer. One industry source said that as many as one-third of its shops might be closed under a restructuring programme. Claire's, known for selling colourful necklaces and bracelets and offering ear piercing services, has 306 stores in Ireland and Britain aimed at the teen and preteen market, and 2,150 staff. That includes 20 stores in Ireland. READ MORE It recorded a pretax loss of £4 million on sales of £137 million according to its most recent results for the year to February 3rd, 2024. Administrators at Interpath, which had been trying to sell the business, said shops will remain open for now as they assess options for the chain, including 'exploring the possibility of a sale which would secure a future for this well-loved brand' shorn of its liabilities. Customers will no longer be able to buy goods online. The update comes after the wider Claire's group, which operates 2,750 stores in 17 countries, applied for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in a Delaware court. The company last week said that it was in discussions with vendors and landlords about the future of its North American stores. Claire's previously filed for bankruptcy in 2018, exiting Chapter 11 in 2022. The Illinois-based group is owned by a group of investment firms, including Elliott Management and Monarch Alternative Capital. It has also had two failed attempts at a stock market IPO. Last week, the group blamed 'increased competition, consumer spending trends and the ongoing shift away from brick-and-mortar retail' for the bankruptcy, as well as 'debt obligations'. The retailer's trading difficulties are understood to have been exacerbated by uncertainty surrounding tariffs imposed on China by the US administration, which is likely to have seen its overheads increase substantially in recent months. The parent company said it has between 25,001 and 50,000 creditors. Claire's Irish and British business is the second high-street brand to battle to maintain a presence on the high street in as many weeks. Fashion retailer River Island managed to avert administration after a court approved a restructuring plan last week that includes the closure of 33 of its 230 stores. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
