I was given a five-star review by an Airbnb host... then came the biggest shock of my life a week later
Sydney nursing student Aleena Tiwari was given a five-star review by the owner of the Airbnb she recently rented for a single night.
Ms Tiwari said in a TikTok she and her friends had a 'great time' during their stay and made sure to clean up before leaving.
One week later, she said the owner accused her of damaging a reclining sofa at the property and demanded she fork out $2,000 for its replacement.
'Literally, we were in shock,' Ms Tiwari said.
'We didn't recline that sofa at all, and we didn't use that at all.'
While Ms Tiwari had the forethought to film a video of the property upon arrival, she regretted not documenting the sofa in more detail.
Unable to prove her claim, she now fears she will be forced to pay the hefty fine.
Social media users were left appalled, with many sharing similar horror stories, including one woman who claimed to have been asked to pay $1,500 to repair the blinds at a property.
'It was a horrible experience,' she said.
'After that, I realised that it's important to take photos of every corner of the house after checking in on Airbnb.'
Another woman said she had begun staying exclusively at hotels after suffering a similar experience with an Airbnb owner.
A third claimed to have stayed at the same Airbnb and being stuck with a damage bill.
'A week after returning, the host claimed $450 for carpet and rug stains we didn't cause,' they wrote.
'I explained this calmly to Airbnb support, but got no positive response. Out of frustration, I sent a strong message after receiving an email saying the amount would be charged to my card.
'Eventually, they cancelled my appeal.'
The nursing student ended the video with a warning to her followers to avoid falling prey to opportunistic hosts.
'Always make sure you always take a before-and-after video of the Airbnb,' Ms Tiwari said.
Ms Tiwari is not the first to accuse an Airbnb host of wrongfully requesting payment for damages.
Last December, a group of six high school graduates fired back at a Gold Coast host who accused them of causing $4,815 worth of damages during Schoolies.
As with Ms Tiwari, the request was all the more surprising given the positive review the girls received after their stay.
They had meticulously documented their stay and were able to refute many aspects of the host's claim, including pre-existing damages.
Airbnb ultimately cancelled the claim after a reporter from A Current Affair reached out to them on behalf of the girls.
According to Airbnb's website, guests have 24 hours to respond to a reimbursement request from a host.
If the guest does not pay the amount in full, the host may involve Airbnb or its insurer for review, and the guest will be given the opportunity to appeal any fines.
'Dealing with damage is never fun, but this process is designed to be as fair as possible,' it said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Bosses ordered prank call to Princess of Wales's hospital, claims radio DJ
The Australian radio DJ who made a hoax call to a hospital caring for the Princess of Wales, leading to the suicide of a nurse, has blamed his bosses for the prank. Michael Christian and Mel Greig were presenting on 2Day FM in December 2012 when they called the private King Edward VII hospital in London, pretending to be Elizabeth II and the then Prince Charles. Catherine, who was pregnant with Prince George at the time, was being treated for severe morning sickness. Jacintha Saldanha, the nurse who answered the phone and disclosed private medical information to the prank callers, later took her own life, prompting a backlash against the radio hosts and the broadcaster. Mr Christian has now alleged he was ordered by 2Day FM's production team to make the prank call and impersonate the late Queen and then Prince to gain access to the Duchess. He has sued the station's broadcaster, Southern Cross Austereo (SCA), in the Australian federal court, claiming that the company had promised to provide support if the content put out by its 'shock jocks' ever went too far. The broadcaster, who was made redundant in February, said he had been let down by the organisation, which had failed to 'step in' and instead let its presenters take the blame, impacting their careers. In court documents seen by the Australian media, Mr Christian's lawyers wrote: 'SCA did not immediately take public accountability for the incident, but rather allowed Mr Christian and Ms Greig to be left exposed to relentless public vitriol, harassment and abuse, including death threats. 'The radio presenters were left by SCA as the convenient fall guys and scapegoats for SCA management decisions and non-compliance.' Presenter 'gradually marginalised' at work Mr Christian reportedly alleged that his reputation had been severely damaged, leading to the loss of future earning capacity. He said he had started as a 2Day FM presenter two days before the prank call, which he alleges breached the Australian Communications and Media Authority code of practice. He added that he was told in early 2013 that SCA would help restore his reputation and rebuild his career, a promise which meant that he opted against pursuing legal action at that time. However, the court documents allege that the firm failed to provide meaningful health support, did not start a public relations campaign to rebuild his brand and failed to offer meaningful opportunities or pay rises to reward his loyalty. Instead, he claims he was 'gradually marginalised' within the organisation. Rhys Holleran, SCA's chief executive at the time of the incident, told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation in 2024 that he still suffered anxiety about the incident. 'I have always felt completely and utterly responsible for this,' he said. Ms Greig broke down at the conclusion of the inquest into the death of Saldanha, a mother-of-two, in 2014. She said: 'I really just wanted to say I am truly sorry, I've wanted to say that for so long. 'This tragedy will always stay with me and serve as a constant reminder. I was always concerned for the well-being of both nurses and I wish I had tried harder to stop the prank call from airing.' The Prince and Princess of Wales said at the time that they were 'deeply saddened' by the news.
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Five things to know before you board a Silversea ship
When Silversea launched in 1994, it brought unprecedented luxury and a true all-inclusive offering to cruise passengers. It was the first to include alcohol in the fare, introduce suite butlers and offer a complimentary in-room mini-bar. Three decades on, the line continues to meet the exacting standards demanded by its loyal clientele. The brand doesn't try to 'be' anything other than a luxurious hotel at sea offering grade-A service. Carpets bounce, décor is quietly elegant and easy-on-the-eye, and guest rooms have pillow menus, marble bathrooms, rain showers and walk-in wardrobes. Newer ships have ushered in a contemporary feel, with relaxed al-fresco dining areas and lots of exterior glass designed to let the ocean in. It's an 'all-suite' line, which means every guest room has a window-facing lounge area that can be partitioned off from the bedroom. Although it typically attracts an older demographic, Silversea doesn't rest on its laurels, and is constantly reinventing its shore experiences, dining offerings and destination portfolio. In the 2026-7 season, passengers can choose from 230 new cruises. Last year, the line announced plans to build a 150-room hotel in the Chilean city of Puerto Williams to accommodate guests transiting to Antarctica. Rooms will have views across the Beagle Channel to the snow-capped Patagonian mountains. A focus on quality ingredients and non-buffet dining has been a mainstay for the line. Foodies will appreciate the well-executed Salt (sea and land taste) food programme that explores a destination through food-focused excursions and interactive open-kitchen dinners on board. These are sometimes led by an accomplished local chef. The cruise fare includes 24-hour butler-in-tux service for every guest; round-the-clock in-suite dining; premium drinks in suite and throughout the ship; and private transfers and flights. There is a supplement for certain restaurants. Beyond that are three fare types: door to door (everything is included and transport organised from the minute you close the front door); port to port (transfers and air fare aren't included), and essential (transfers, air fare and excursions aren't included). Silversea's fleet consists of 12 ships, six of which have joined since 2020. Four are expedition vessels, including a ship that sails solely in the Galapagos. Headquartered in Miami, Silversea is one of five brands owned by the Royal Caribbean Group. 1. Where does Silversea cruise? Worldwide, including all seven continents. The 2026/2027 cruise portfolio features 131 expedition voyages, while ocean ships will visit more than 85 countries. A handful of cruises sail the British Isles from Portsmouth and Southampton in the spring, and there are cruises from Southampton and Belfast to Copenhagen in June. Expedition cruises visit some of the world's most remote regions, including the Arctic and Greenland, the Antarctic, South America, French Polynesia and the Pacific, the Galapagos and the Kimberley in north-west Australia. Each January, passengers can join a world cruise – which can be taken in its entirety or in sections. In 2028, a 132-day cruise from Miami to Nice will visit 58 destinations on five continents. For those who prefer to cross the Atlantic by ship, rather than plane, Silversea has 'transoceanic' crossings from Southampton and Belfast to New York, and from Lisbon to Barbados. Itineraries often dovetail with festivals, high-profile sporting events and seasonal highlights such as cherry blossom season in Japan, Carnival in Rio de Janeiro and the F1 Grand Prix in Monaco. 2. Who does Silversea appeal to? With a high proportion of longer cruises and the inclusion of big-ticket events, Silversea appeals to a well-heeled, largely American crowd that favours 'enrichment' (learning experiences) – and that wants to travel in comfort. Every effort goes into ensuring that passengers get the best experience from the destinations they're visiting – whether that's at a fine-dining experience onboard or during a shore experience. Although the demographic is generally older, and there are no children's clubs on board, families are welcome too. The minimum age for children on ocean-going ships is six months. The following age limits also apply: 12 months on Silver Cloud; five years on Silver Origin. Children younger than five cannot board zodiacs on Silver Endeavour, Silver Cloud and Silver Wind. Under-18s must be accompanied in the same or connecting suite by a parent or responsible adult aged 21-plus. Solo travellers pay 25 per cent of the full fare on selected voyages. An October cruise to Antarctica costs £11,150 instead of £12,900, and a Bridgetown to Lisbon cruise costs £3,150, down from £4,900. 3. Silversea's fleet Ocean Silver Ray (728 passengers) Launched in 2024, Ray is the identical sister ship to Silver Nova. The 13 room categories include new, corner master suites with 270-degree views. There are eight restaurants, four bars and lounges, an Otium Spa, plus a sea-facing gym and beauty salon. Powered by LNG (liquefied natural gas), Silver Ray is the most energy-efficient ship in the fleet. She has plug-in capability and is hydrogen fuel-cell ready. Silver Nova (728 passengers) Launched in 2023, Nova introduced the 'Nova' class of ship, featuring an asymmetrical design aimed at connecting guests with the water, wherever they are on board. It also introduced a buzzing all-day dining hangout, The Marquee. The deck 10 pool has 'floating' cabanas and a decent swimming length. Corner Otium Suites feature a private Jacuzzi and 270-degree views. Silver Dawn (596 passengers) Silver Dawn launched in 2022 and was the first to feature the brand's top-tier Otium spa. Otium wellness services are also available in-suite – that could be a massage, butler-drawn bath or a 'food and chill' evening. Silver Muse and Silver Moon (596 passengers) Built in 2020, Moon introduced Silversea's immersive culinary programme, Salt. Three dedicated venues include the Salt Kitchen, Salt Lab and Salt Bar, where dinners, demonstrations and drinks are tailored to regionally inspired menus. A signature French restaurant, the Japanese Kaiseki and Asian-inspired Indochine are among the eight restaurants. Built in 2017, Silver Muse shares the same restaurants as Moon, and both ships have the Zagara spa and beauty salon and a casino. Shows and films are held in the Venetian Lounge. Silver Shadow and Silver Whisper (392 passengers) The décor and layout of these two ships is classic rather than stylish. However, both offer a more intimate atmosphere and the same attention to detail when it comes to dining and service. Both ships have four restaurants, a show lounge, a card room, a library and a spa. Whisper was built in 2001 and last refurbished in 2024; Shadow was built in 2000 and last refurbished in 2019. Silver Spirit (608 passengers) Silver Spirit made headlines in 2018 when she was 'stretched' at a shipyard in Palermo. She left the yard 49ft longer, following a complex lengthening and extensive refurbishment. The result was roomier public areas and suites, an enlarged pool deck and a refreshed dining offering. The ship has an Arts Café, Observation Library, Zagara Spa and the chic Dolce Vita lounge. Expedition Silver Endeavour (220 passengers) Purpose-built for the polar regions, Silver Endeavour launched in 2022. She carries kayaks, zodiacs and a remote camera system that can capture high-quality images from over three miles away. Spread over eight decks, the all-suite ship has multiple restaurants, bars and lounges; a spa; a two-storey solarium with a pool and whirlpool; and several indoor and outdoor observation areas. Silver Wind (274 passengers) Refurbished in 2021 with an ice-strengthened hull, Silver Wind is a crossover ship, visiting polar and non-polar destinations. The nine-deck ship carries 24 zodiacs and has a show lounge, fitness centre and spa, observation library and jogging track. Her décor is more traditional. Silver Cloud (254 passengers on non-polar cruises; 200 in polar regions) Silver Cloud underwent a $40 million refurbishment and conversion to an ice-class ship in 2017. She carries 20 zodiacs and 10 kayaks and sails with a large team of expedition experts. The ship has four restaurants and a photo studio, and photography masterclasses are offered. Silver Origin (100 passengers) A stylish ship with sleek yacht lines, Origin was built for the Galápagos. Passengers travel with a team of Ecuadorian guides and a fleet of eight zodiacs. All suites have balconies and butler service, and an in-suite water purification system. The meeting point for zodiacs, the 'Basecamp', doubles as an information source for the islands. 4. Loyalty scheme Membership of the Venetian Society commences with the first voyage. Members accumulate Venetian Society Days on each voyage (one VS day per day sailed). 5. Access for guests with disabilities Suites can accommodate wheelchairs, scooters and other equipment. Dining and bar venues and other public areas offer wheelchair seating. Wheelchair accessible excursions are offered mainly in Europe and the US, and low-activity tours are available at almost every port. The 'View Deck Plan' tab on each ship page indicates accessible suites (
Edinburgh Reporter
2 hours ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
East Lothian Airbnb ‘too popular' to escape change of use rules
An Airbnb owner has been told their flat is 'too popular' to qualify for automatic approval to carry on operating. The owner of the ground floor flat in Musselburgh had applied for a Certificate of Lawfulness to keep renting out the short term holiday home which was first advertised on the website in January this year. The certificate, which avoids the need to apply for a change of use for short term holiday lets, was applied for on the grounds there had been no material change of use of the flat. However planners said the fact the two bedroom flat , in Kilwinning Terrace, has been occupied for 99% of the time it has been available, with stays lasting between two to five days, meant there had been a change of use and it was not 'lawful'. Refusing an application for the certificate planners said: 'The property is advertised on Airbnb and is let out continuously throughout the year, with the applicant stating an occupancy rate of 99% in their supporting statement. 'The use of the applicants' flat as a unit of short-term holiday let accommodation by a maximum of four guests would not be too dissimilar to the number of residents that could occupy the property in a residential use. 'However, as the flat is advertised on a holiday rental platform, coupled with the frequency of the arrival and departures of guests and the movements associated with the changeovers and cleaning between guest stays, this would lead to a different movement pattern which is incomparable with long-term residential use. 'Based on this information, it is considered that, the use of the applicants' ground floor flat for short term holiday let accommodation constitutes a material change of use, requiring planning permission, where a lawful use cannot otherwise be demonstrated.' Certificates of Lawfulness can be issued if it can be proven a property has been used continually for ten years or more or there is no material change of use. In this case the applicant had argued that as the ground floor flat has its own main door and private front garden and did not share any communal area with neighbours the coming and goings of visitors did not have any more impact than if it was being used by long term tenants. By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter Like this: Like Related
