Alligator Alcatraz leans on myth steeped in racism
Why it matters: Nothing about the portrayal is accurate, experts in alligator biology and history tell Axios.
What's more, the idea of the alligator lusting for human flesh is rooted in racism, dating back to Jim Crow, when tourists could buy postcards illustrating Black children as "gator bait."
"This idea that being around alligators is inherently dangerous is very problematic and misunderstood," said Mark V. Barrow Jr., a Virginia Tech history professor working on a book about the cultural history of American alligators.
The big picture: Florida's reptilian mascot isn't just in the nickname-turned-official name of the detention center. It's central to the premise.
"When people get out, there's not much waiting for them other than alligators and pythons," state Attorney General James Uthmeier said in a June 19 video introducing Alligator Alcatraz. "Nowhere to go, nowhere to hide."
AI-generated memes depicting alligators in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement hats, as well as merchandise, followed soon after.
During his visit to the facility this month, President Trump joked that the critters serve as "bodyguards" and "cops."
Reality check: "They're not on our side. It's silly to think that," Mark Teshera, a wildlife biologist who studies alligator behavior, told Axios.
Flashback: The idea of alligators as ferocious, human-eating beasts dates back to accounts from William Bartram, a naturalist from Philadelphia who in the late 18th century traveled to the Southeast, Barrow told Axios.
Bartram's widely read book chronicling the experience included over-the-top descriptions of the reptile and stories of seemingly unprovoked attacks.
The myth has persisted for centuries — including after Emancipation, when the false, racist belief that alligators liked the taste of Black flesh proliferated in the South.
It was "part of this broad campaign to dehumanize, oppress, suppress newly freed African Americans," Barrow said.
That history is why the University of Florida ceased its "gator bait" cheer and band performance in 2020.
The other side: Gov. Ron DeSantis' office did not respond to Axios' requests for comment.
Between the lines: Alligators don't consider humans prey and often react to them with fear, said Teshera, who authored a study that found that risky human behaviors caused most alligator attacks.
Those behaviors include swimming in waterways known to be inhabited by alligators, walking dogs near their habitats, and feeding them.
That also explains why, in Florida's scenic rivers and swamps, humans can observe alligators with little risk. Just be sure to practice situational awareness and give them space, Teshera said.
What they're saying:"Alligators get such a bad rep, but when you break it down … they're usually reacting to a situation," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
23 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Donald Trump's Approval Rating Jumps With Liberals
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. President Donald Trump's approval rating has increased among liberals in the past month. According to polling by I&I/TIPP released on August 4, the proportion of liberals who said they approved of Trump's job performance increased by 4 percentage points from 19 percent at the end of June to 23 percent in early August. Why It Matters Approval ratings are a good way of measuring the temperature of the nation and Trump's popularity has fluctuated in the first six-plus months of his term in the Oval Office. Liberals do not generally have a positive view of the president or his policies so an uptick in approval rating is noteworthy. It remains to be seen whether this will sustain and ultimately affect the 2026 midterm elections. President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before boarding Air Force One at Lehigh Valley International Airport, Sunday, Aug. 3, 2025, in Allentown, Pa. President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before boarding Air Force One at Lehigh Valley International Airport, Sunday, Aug. 3, 2025, in Allentown, Pa. AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson What To Know While the proportion of liberals who said they approved of Trump has increased, the majority of liberals (72 percent) still see him in an unfavorable light. The proportion of liberals with a favorable view of the president increased from 18 percent at the end of June to 23 percent in August—an increase of 5 percentage points. Overall, Trump's favorability rating among all voters was net -1 percent in July and net 0 percent in August. The June poll was conducted between June 25 and 27 had a sample size of 1,421 adults. In August, 1,362 adults were polled from July 30 to August 1. Both polls had a margin of error of +/- 2.7 percentage points. Polling elsewhere has been less positive. A survey conducted by Quantus Insights from July 21 to July 23 among 1,123 registered voters showed his rating stands at 47 percent, while 50 percent disapproved. According to the YouGov polling for British newspaper The Times, the proportion of people who disapprove of Trump's job performance has increased from 52 percent in April to 57 percent in July. What People Are Saying Speaking to Newsweek, Mark Shanahan, who teaches American politics at the University of Surrey in the U.K, previously said: "Trump's second term has been less of a honeymoon, but more of a divorce from half the country: one where he's got to keep the house, the kids and just about all of the assets. From day one of his rule by Executive Order he has never sought to bring the USA together and, indeed, has exploited differences to highlight how he's delivering on his campaign commitments, not least through DOGE [Department of Government Efficiency], through his clampdown on immigration and through his America First foreign policy." "Public services are already beginning to creak thanks to the actions of Musk and his cohort, and tariffs are driving up prices at home, while the economic benefits of the One Big Beautiful act have yet to be felt. And around all this, the whiff of Epstein is tainting the president's achievements." What Happens Next The midterms are scheduled to take place in November 2026 where Trump's popularity will be tested in earnest.
The Hill
24 minutes ago
- The Hill
Greene talks about her ‘genocide' comment and being an ‘early indicator' of GOP discontent
The Movement is a weekly newsletter tracking the influence and debates steering politics on the right. Sign up here or in the box below. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) says that Republicans should take her vocal criticisms of the GOP — which she insists are not criticisms of President Trump — as a warning about coming troubles with their base. 'I'm an early indicator, and my complaints are felt and being said far and wide among your average American people who voted for the President and Republicans in 2024,' Greene told me in a phone interview on Monday. 'The Republican Party is the one drifting away from what we campaigned on.' Greene also expanded to me on being the only Republican in Congress to call Israel's actions in Gaza a 'genocide.' Far from backing away from the term, Greene said: 'It's easy to call it a genocide.' More on that in a moment. I had reached out to the firebrand Georgia congresswoman in wake of her comments to the Daily Mail that the GOP had 'turned its back on America First' and that she was unsure of whether 'the Republican Party is leaving me, or if I'm kind of not relating to Republican Party as much anymore.' The comments surprised some, given Greene's ardent support of Trump, who is the leader of the GOP. She told me it is 'ridiculous' to suggest she does not support the president. But they are part of a pattern of Greene breaking with leaders in the GOP, including Trump. In recent weeks, she called the crisis in Gaza a genocide; raised the alarm about U.S. strikes in Iran; critiqued the U.S. continuing to sell weapons to help Ukraine; and pushed for more Jeffrey Epstein disclosures despite resistance from Trump, among other gripes. Just on Monday, Greene in a post lamented that there have been zero arrests in a number of MAGA-amplified scandals like the 'Russian Collusion Hoax,' 'COVID,' 'Mar-A-Lago Raid,' and 'Epstein Pedophile Arrest,' among others. She posted: 'Don't talk about it if you aren't going to do it.' Who was she talking about in that post, and who needs to change? Greene declined to name specific names. 'That criticism is to everyone, literally everyone, and no one's left out of that,' Greene said. 'If you're going to go on television — and this is for everybody — and point their fingers at all these people and call them criminals, say they committed treason, then do something about it,' Greene said. 'If they make these accusations, but yet hold no one accountable, they're going to lose everybody. They're going to lose a vast majority of people who really were told they had to care about this, and they cared about it, but yet nothing got done.' After Greene and I spoke on Monday, CNN reported that Attorney General Pam Bondi was directing federal prosecutors to start a grand jury probe into Obama administration officials over their role in the 2016 Russia election interference investigation. The question is whether Greene is a canary in the MAGA coal mine, or whether her criticisms just put her on an island. She is a giant figure in terms of followers and attention, but some could dismiss her concerns as representing only a minor faction on the right. Greene said she is reflecting what she is hearing in her deep-red Georgia district. But there is clearly some annoyance with the criticism from Greene. Asked about Greene's comments in the Daily Mail and on X, a White House official told me: 'President Trump campaigned on securing the border, signing tax cuts, and ending the genital mutilation of minors. He's accomplished all three within the first 200 days. Those are all promises MTG campaigned for and should be happy about.' Greene in response told me that she had posted over the weekend praising zero crossings in the past three months, and noted that she voted for Trump's 'One Big, Beautiful Bill' that locked in tax cuts. But she pushed back by saying Trump has not had the opportunity to sign her bill, the Protect Children's Innocence Act, to codify Trump's executive order to ban gender-affirming care for minors because it hasn't yet gotten a vote in the House or Senate. 'I'm not criticizing the President on this. I'm criticizing everyone around him. They're actually working against the president by making his executive orders, his accomplishments only temporary,' Greene said. Greene's 'America First' critique of U.S. foreign policy — going as far as to call the crisis and conflict in Gaza a 'genocide' — is perhaps the most notable break. Greene said she dubbed the situation a 'genocide' by 'simply looking at the truth and being willing to speak,' saying that there are 'many others' who agree but 'they're afraid to say it.' 'I support Israel, and we want to see every single hostage released …. It was horrific what happened on October 7,' Greene said. 'But it's also horrific what's happening in Gaza and many innocent people are being killed, have been killed. Christians have been killed, and children have been killed and are being starved.' 'It's easy to call it a genocide. And I think Israel has made clear what they want to do. They really want to, basically, move all the Palestinians out of Gaza, and that's what they're in the process of systematically doing,' Greene said. I noted that even many progressive Democrats critical of Israel have not used the term 'genocide' to describe what's happening in Gaza, since the term implies targeted destruction of an ethnic group based on their identity. American Jewish groups, not to mention Israel itself, strongly reject accusations of 'genocide.' 'I think it's pretty easy to understand. It's targeted at who they are, so that's their identity,' Greene said. 'I mean, they've bombed it to the point where it's unlivable … They are in talks of trying to get other countries to take Palestinian refugees. So I don't think it can be any more clear.' Welcome to The Movement, a weekly newsletter looking at the influences and debates on the right in Washington. I'm Emily Brooks, House leadership reporter at The Hill. Tell me what's on your radar: ebrooks@ STRANGE BEDFELLOWS FOR 'ORGASMIC MEDITATION' CONVICTS Can the right-wing outrage over 'weaponized' prosecution give a boost to those involved with a salacious case? Those defending the sexual wellness company OneTaste are finding strange bedfellows on the right as they fight convictions of the group's founder and former CEO Nicole Daedone and its former head of sales Rachel Cherwitz. Daedone and Cherwitz were convicted in June for 'forced labor conspiracy in connection with their coercive scheme to obtain the labor and services of certain OneTaste employees.' The company, which taught 'orgasmic meditation,' turned from a start-up celebrated for its focus on female sexuality to being criticized for alleged abuse of employees. It was the subject of a controversial 2022 Lena Dunham -produced Netflix documentary, 'Orgasm Inc.' It's not the type of case that immediately invites a conservative defense, but defenders of Daedone and Cherwitz see an opening with those skeptical of overzealous prosecutors — like those in the MAGA movement supportive of Trump and outraged about his prosecutions, as well as those of Jan. 6 rioters. 'The bulk of the support has come from the conservative movement,' said Juda Engelmayer, the crisis publicist for Daedone and Cherwitz. Getting others to take a deep look at the underlying legal issues, he said, requires 'getting your head around that concept is an ick factor.' The libertarian magazine Reason's senior editor Elizabeth Nolan Brown in February outlined a key argument of those defending OneTaste heads: 'The two face a single count of conspiracy to commit forced labor … Neither woman is charged with actually forcing labor or engaging in other criminal acts.' Former Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.), who was once investigated by the DOJ for alleged sex trafficking but never charged, has criticized the case on his One America News show. Trump adviser Roger Stone has critiqued the FBI over the case, as well. And it doesn't end in the conservative media space. There are people privately pressing the DOJ to look into the case. One member of Congress wrote to FBI Director Kash Patel with concerns about the case earlier this year, the Daily Mail reported. The Daily Mail censored the name of the member of Congress who wrote to Patel about the case — identified only as being a House Judiciary Committee member who has a law enforcement background. But Rep. Troy Nehls (R-Texas), who fits that bill, confirmed to me that he was the one who sent the OneTaste letter to the FBI. The 'ick factor' could be a limiting factor for the defendants as they hope for more support on the right — given social conservative values opposed to the sex-positive OneTaste ethos. Daedone and Cherwitz are scheduled to be sentenced on Sept. 23, and plan to appeal the conviction. GAMBLING TAX DIVIDE EMERGING ON THE RIGHT A divide is emerging on the right over whether gamblers should be able to deduct their losses on their taxes, pitting social conservatives against top Republicans who hope to reverse the recent change. At issue is a last-minute provision in the 'One Big, Beautiful Bill' that lowered the gambling loss deduction from 100 percent to 90 percent, set to kick in in 2026. That means if a gambler broke even one year, winning $1 million and losing $1 million, the gambler would still be taxed on $100,000 worth of income on winnings. House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Jason Smith (R-Mo.) said in a 'field hearing' in Las Vegas, Nev. last month that he was open to nixing that change. 'I know that many members on both sides of the aisle are open to working to address it before it goes into effect on January 1st,' Smith said. But social conservatives are starting to pipe up encouraging the opposite direction. Advancing American Freedom, the group founded by former Vice President Mike Pence, is circulating a memo opposing that reversal and encouraging to lower the deduction even more: 'Gambling losses should not be deductible at all.' 'Nearly all gamblers lose money, leading to further financial, health, and family problems. Congress should encourage a pro-growth tax code by declining to reinstate full expensing for gambling losses,' the memo said. ON MY CALENDAR It's a quiet August here in Washington. Send me your interesting upcoming seminars, Capitol Hill forums, and galas to be featured in this section: ebrooks@ Monday, August 25 to Thursday, August 28: State Policy Network annual meeting in New Orleans, La. THREE MORE THINGS The Trump administration is not planning to mandate coverage for in vitro fertilization, contrary to the president's campaign pledge, the Washington Post reported. The Young Republicans honored four leaders at its national convention in Nashville, Tenn., over the weekend, inducting them into the 1856 Society: Deputy Assistant to the President and Director of the Office of Political Affairs Matt Brasseaux; former National Director of Election Integrity for the Trump Campaign and RNC Christina Norton; The Washington Reporter Editor-in-Chief Matthew Foldi; and Trump 2024 National Delegate Selection Director John Findlay. Douglass Mackey, whose conviction over posting memes about the 2016 race was overturned by an appeals court this year, was celebrated at a bash at MAGA Capitol Hill hangout Butterworth's on Friday. Napkins at the event featured the meme telling voters to text to vote that Mackey posted under an anonymous Twitter account that was the center of the conviction of conspiracy to suppress voters. WHAT I'M READING
The Hill
24 minutes ago
- The Hill
Texas Republican: GOP ‘will never have the White House again' if state lost to Democrats
Texas State Rep. Brian Harrison (R) claimed on Monday that the Republican Party will 'never have the White House again' if Democrats overtake the majority in the Lone Star State. 'I'm here to speak for myself. And what I care about is working to make sure that the will, the interests, the desires and quite frankly, what the voters of Texas deserve to have happen, which is their elected Republican legislature, stand up and do what they want, which is make sure the state of Texas — where the line in the sand for the future of the country,' Harrison said during his Monday night appearance on CNN's 'The Source,' when asked why the redistricting push in Texas, which was approved by President Trump, is taking place. 'There's no doubt about that. As goes Texas, so goes the nation,' he told host Kaitlan Collins. 'If we ever lose Texas to the Democrats, the Republicans will never have the White House again. So, it's incumbent upon us, people like me, in the legislative branch.' Harrison added, 'If you want to ask the governor a question about what motivated him to do something, feel free to ask him. I mean, he called the special session as a member of the legislature.' Trump won Texas, which carries 40 Electoral College votes, in the 2024 presidential election by nearly 14 points against former Vice President Harris. The redistricting push kicked into higher gear on Monday as Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) ordered that Texas Democrats, who fled the state, be arrested by the Texas Department of Public Safety. Dozens of state-level Democrats have left the Lone Star State, breaking the state House quorum and looking to remain outside of Texas until the special legislative session, which gaveled last month, ends. The lawmakers are hoping to slow down the GOP's effort to pass a mid-decade redistricting plan, as Trump has said he would like the Republican Party to gain five House seats in the state during next year's midterms. Democratic governors in other states, including New York, have warned that they might fire back by altering the congressional lines in their states to make them more favorable for their party's candidates. State Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) said the Democrats that fled Texas should be 'swiftly arrested, punished, and face the full force of the law for turning their backs on the people' of Texas. State House Texas Democrats have argued their action was necessary, accusing the GOP of rigging the forthcoming midterm election.
