Stuck in the muck: Panchkula's waste drive falters despite years of push
As per the latest Swachh Survekshan 2024-25, waste collection has failed to cover all households, leaving 39% of the areas underserved. Besides this, segregation at source has not met desired results, with only 20% of waste being segregated, says the survey.
Residents say that the data could differ from the 'worse' ground reality, despite the fact that they pay annual collection charges to the Panchkula municipal corporation and monthly charges to private door-to-door garbage collectors.
'Collectors mix segregated waste'
The president of the Federation of Residents Association (FORA), R P Malhotra, stated, "The ground reality is more worrisome. As far as wet and dry waste segregation at the source is concerned, even if the residents segregate it, the collectors mix it. They have not made separate waste containers in their carts. The failure of the municipal corporation is evident in the fact that garbage collection has still not reached every household.
The agency responsible for the task is earning quite well. However, it has not been held accountable. To top it all, we are paying double charges."
Echoing similar views, S K Nayar, president of the Citizens Welfare Association, commented, "We have stopped giving waste to MC's collectors as they were not segregating the waste and collection was irregular. We have now hired private collectors, who segregate the waste.
The real question is why residents are paying for waste collection and segregation at two levels when the system is still not functioning properly.
It's high time it is improved. Besides this, collectors or residents who are dumping the waste in the open in different parts of the city should be penalised."
Additionally, the absence of the city's own waste processing plant is a significant hindrance to effective waste management.
The city's solid waste is sent to Ambala for processing. There is neither a processing facility nor designated dumping areas for horticulture and construction and demolition waste. They too are found dumped here and there. Waste generation vs processing was given a 51 per cent score in the survey.
A silver lining
On a brighter side, the city got 99 per cent marks for the remediation of dumpsites. However, residents find the score higher when compared to the remaining legacy waste.
As per the MC, the high score is due to the clearing of the dump at Jhuriwala by remediation of the legacy waste. The remaining dump at Sector 23 is expected to be cleared soon as the work is in the final stages.
Mayor Kulbhushan Goyal told TOI, "We have recently distributed bins in Sector 15 to encourage segregation. We are also improving the system. As far as waste collection is concerned, it stands at 61 per cent because the garbage is not getting lifted from slums or colonies — which are with some HSVP and it is not possible to implement it there — and housing societies, where people have their own arrangements."
Box:
CLEANLINESS CHECK or DUMPS N DATA
State of solid waste management ((as per Swachh Survekshan 2024-25)
Category | Score
Source segregation | 20 per cent
Door-to-door collection of waste | 61 per cent
Waste generation vs processing | 51 per cent
Remediation of dumpsites | 99 per cent
MSID:: 122818563 413 |
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
14 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Mohali suffocating under garbage, but no sight of waste mgmt plant at Samgoli
Even as Mohali grapples with a growing solid waste crisis, the much-needed Solid Waste Management Project at Samgoli in Dera Bassi remains entangled in bureaucratic red tape. After years of delay, the municipal corporation (MC) has established two waste management facilities at Shahimajra and Jagatpura. (HT Photo) Land for the project was allotted in 2012. But 13 years later, the project remains hanging in balance, leaving the city choking under mounds of unprocessed garbage and denting its Swachh Survekshan score each year. Stinking heaps have become landmarks across neighbourhoods, drawing flies and stray animals, much to residents' dismay. Housing a population of 2.3 lakh, Mohali generates around 150 tonnes of waste daily. But shockingly, it still lacks a permanent mechanism for processing the garbage. After years of delay, the municipal corporation (MC) has established two waste management facilities at Shahimajra and Jagatpura. But despite sheds and machinery in place, both plants remain non-functional. The Shahimajra plant has a processing capacity of 40 tonnes per day, while the Jagatpura facility can handle 80 tonnes. Land acquisition hanging fire, no access road Records show that in 2012, the Punjab government planned to acquire 50 acres for the Samgoli project, as a solution to Mohali's garbage woes. However, only 39 acres were acquired by the local bodies department in 2013, with the remaining 11 acres are still pending with the revenue department. A boundary wall was constructed at a cost of ₹35 lakh, and the initial plan was for Mohali MC to build a Compressed Bio Gas (CBG) plant. When no private players submitted bids, the matter was handed over to the local bodies department. The department later involved HPCL and GAIL for technical inspection, with HPCL preparing an estimate of ₹27 crore for the CBG plant. The company also demanded road access and wrote to the tehsildar in May last year for land demarcation. A follow-up letter was sent to the department of rural development and panchayati raj in July 2024, which approved road construction at an estimated cost of ₹29 crore. However, the project, to be implemented under the Punjab Municipal Infrastructure Development Corporation (PMIDC), has been awaiting clearance from the head office since March 2025. City mayor Amarjit Singh Sidhu said, 'We have already written to the local bodies department to expedite the project. Mohali is overwhelmed by solid waste in the absence of proper processing mechanism. As a result, garbage piles are spreading across the city, posing serious health risks,' he said. 'There is no official dumping ground. Waste is being randomly dumped at RMC collection points. Residents are living in miserable, unhygienic conditions, while the government is dilly-dallying on the matter,' Sidhu added. Sucha Singh Kalaur, president of the Sector 76-80 Plot Allotment Welfare Committee, also criticised the state government: 'The city has gone to the dogs. Heaps of garbage and foul smells are everywhere. This is the so-called 'Future City' they promised?' The mounting crisis has been reflected in national cleanliness rankings as well. In the Swachh Survekshan results announced on July 17, Mohali slipped to 128th place among 903 cities (with populations between 50,000 and 3 lakh), down from 82nd last year. Within Punjab, the city dropped to 11th place among 35 cities, a stark fall from its first-place ranking last year among cities with populations over 1 lakh.
Hindustan Times
3 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Mohali MC to rope in private hand to drive waste segregation
Stung by a dismal performance in the 2024 Swachhta Survekshan rankings, the Mohali Municipal Corporation (MC) is ramping up efforts to ensure proper waste segregation at source, one of its weakest waste management areas, by roping in a private player for door-to-door garbage collection for the first time. Garbage strewn around on roadsides across the city points to the long road ahead for Mohali in managing its daily waste effectively. (Sanjeev Sharma/HT) Currently, garbage collection in the city remains disorganised, with both sanitation workers and residents failing to segregate waste at source. In the rankings announced on July 17, Mohali fell to the 128th spot among 903 cities with population between 50,000 and 3 lakh — a sharp drop from 82nd last year. Within Punjab, it slipped to the 11th spot among 35 cities, compared to first place last year among cities with over 1 lakh population. Mohali scored 69.93% — earning 8,742 out of 12,500 marks — compared to last year's 82.72% (6,204.20 out of 7,500). Officials attributed the poor performance largely to non-segregation of waste at source and poor processing of waste generated —two key parameters in the central government's cleanliness survey. Tech-enabled monitoring MC commissioner Parminder Pal Singh said, 'For the first time, we are privatising door-to-door garbage collection and will float tenders next week. Our aim is to implement an end-to-end, tech-enabled, efficient waste management system in compliance with the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016.' As part of the plan, sanitation workers will sensitise households about waste segregation. Each household will be assigned a QR code, and violations, such as mixing wet and dry waste, will be logged in real-time via a mobile app with time and date. Repeat violations will be escalated to MC sanitary inspectors. Collection vehicles will be required to have separate compartments for wet and dry waste and deliver it to Material Recovery Facilities without mixing. Any violation, including mixing of waste post-collection, will attract strict penalties as per the Service Level Agreement. Three plants set up for waste processing To improve processing, MC has also set up two waste management facilities at Shahimajra and Jagatpura villages, where shed construction and machinery installation is complete. A Panchkula-based agency has been hired to install waste sorting equipment at both sites. While dry waste will be processed here, wet waste will be sent to another shed in Phase 3A. The Shahimajra plant has a daily processing capacity of 40 tonnes and the Jagatpura facility can handle 80 tonnes per day. These steps come in the wake of the Punjab and Haryana high court ordering closure of the Phase 8-B dumping ground, leaving the city with no designated dump. CSR-funded park upkeep Meanwhile, in a bid to improve park maintenance and reduce financial strain, MC has also decided to hand over five major city parks to private companies under the Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) model. Mohali currently has 798 parks, including 39 designated as 'Special Parks' and 194 maintained by Residents' Welfare Associations (RWAs). The plan is to bring 604 parks, including all 39 Special Parks and 565 others, under CSR to enhance upkeep and transparency.
Hans India
4 days ago
- Hans India
Puttur shines in Swachh Survekshan rankings
Puttur: Puttur City Municipal Council has achieved the 8th rank in Karnataka in the Swachh Survekshan 2024–25, a nationwide cleanliness survey conducted by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. The city earned recognition for its comprehensive and sustainable waste management strategy, including 100% door-to-door waste collection and an efficient solid waste processing system. Its proactive, community-based approach sets an example for urban areas striving for cleanliness and hygiene. Among the initiatives that drew national appreciation were a biogas plant and an electronic waste collection centre, both implemented through public-private partnerships. These innovative efforts were specially acknowledged in the assessment.
