Man convicted of 1994 Orkney restaurant murder is innocent, claims top lawyer
Leading criminal lawyer Aamer Anwar believes the case of a former soldier convicted of the murder 31 years ago of a restaurant waiter is a miscarriage of justice
Sheku Bayoh lawyer Aamer Anwar has called for the man convicted of the racially motivated murder of an Asian restaurant waiter to be set free.
The human rights campaigner believes that former Black Watch sergeant Michael Ross is the victim of a miscarriage of justice and wants his case referred back to the appeal courts and conviction and life sentence overturned.
Anwar says there is no evidence to show that he carried out a racially motivated killing. Michael Ross was found guilty in 2008 of shooting Bangladeshi waiter Shamsuddin Mahmood in the Mumutaz Indian Restaurant in Kirkwall, Orkney, in 1994. At the time of the murder Ross was only 15.
After a trial at the High Court in Glasgow Ross was told he must serve 25 years before he can be considered for parole. Suspicion first fell on the teenager after his policeman father, a firearms specialist, told senior officers that he possessed the same ammunition as was used in the killing. Ross, who was an army cadet at the time, was identified as a man seen wearing a balaclava in woods around two weeks before the murder.
Twelve years later new evidence came from local man William Grant who told police he had seen Ross on the evening of the murder wearing a balaclava and handling a gun in toilets near the crime scene. Mr Grant also claimed he witnessed the youth shouting racial abuse outside the restaurant weeks before the murder.
A campaign - Justice for Michael Ross - has been launched on Orkney which Anwar's Glasgow firm is backing.
In an exclusive interview with Criminal Record - our new weekly podcast - the lawyer said: "We have represented Michael for a few years now and need new evidence to get the keys to open the cell door and for a miscarriage of justice application. "It strikes me as incredible that a 15 year old boy could walk into a restaurant with a balaclava on, walk directly up to an individual, shoot them at point blank range and then walk out and leave nothing of themselves."
Anwar says there are also concerns that 15-year old Ross was interviewed in 1994 about the murder by police without a lawyer present. He also described the evidence of Mr Grant as "fanciful". The lawyer is appealing to anyone with information on the 31 year old murder to come forward.
He added: "There must be people on the island who know much more than they knew at the time and with the passage of time will feel guilt or have a conscience and will one day give that information which means we have a miscarriage of justice application. "There were always questions over whether it was someone outside the island or a gangland execution."
Anwar hopes to present any new evidence to the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission who have the power to refer convictions back to the appeal courts. The lawyer added: "There was evidence of people having turned up at the restaurant in the days before shouting abuse at Shamsuddin. "There is nothing to show that Michael Ross carried out a racially motivated murder."
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Following the murder of Shamsuddin Ross enlisted in the army and saw active combat in Iraq, becoming the sergeant of a sniper platoon.
Aamer Anwar is one of the country's most prominent criminal lawyers and has represented Abdelbaset Al-Megrahi, the Libyan convicted of the Lockerbie bombing, Surjit Singh Chhokar, the Lanarkshire waiter who was murdered in a racially motivated attack, and Sheku Bayoh, from Kirkcaldy, who died after being restrained by police officers in 2015.
He features in a new three part series of The Firm - about the workings of his legal practice - which began last night (Tuesday) on BBC Scotland.
The first episode shows him with Margaret Caldwell, the mother of murdered Glasgow sex worker, Emma Caldwell, as they successfully secure a public inquiry into police handling of her daughter's murder.
In 2024, Iain Packer was jailed for life with a minimum of 36 years for the murder of Emma in 2005. It emerged that Packer has been ignored as a suspect despite admitting to police that he was a client of Emma's and had previously taken her to the remote wooded spot where her body was found.
Anwar originally represented one of four Turkish men charged with Emma's murder and realised at that time they were not guilty. He added: "We need to know what went horribly wrong with the Emma Caldwell investigation. "There are still lessons to be learned. " Margaret Caldwell hopes to get to the truth but also wants a real and lasting legacy."
You can hear more from Aamer Anwar in our Criminal Record podcast where he talks about death threats, online abuse, and his most memorable campaigns and cases.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
3 hours ago
- Spectator
Foreign nationals convicted of a quarter of sex assaults on women
Britain's grooming gangs scandal has dominated the news this week, after the publication of Baroness Casey's review on Monday. Now data from the Ministry of Justice has emerged showing that over a quarter of sex assaults on women – that have been successfully prosecuted in the UK – were committed by foreign nationals. It's quite the stat… The data, which came to light through Freedom of Information requests, revealed that of the 1,453 sex assault convictions on women in 2024, 26 per cent were foreign nationals. There are suggestions that the real total could be higher, given that those 8 per cent recorded as having perpetrators of 'unknown' nationalities could also include foreign nationals. Casey's review revealed, as Home Secretary Yvette Cooper told the Commons on Monday afternoon, that disproportionate numbers of Asian and Pakistani men were responsible for grooming gang abuse – while consecutive governments and authorities failed to act due to concerns about racism. More than that, the audit found that both foreign nationals and asylum seekers were involved in a 'significant proportion' of 12 active and ongoing police investigations into grooming gangs. The Centre for Migration Control think tank got hold of the data on sex crimes – which also found that foreign nationals for over 20 per cent of all rape convictions last year. Good heavens… Baroness Casey did say, however, that while the report found an overrepresentation of Pakistani men in cases of child sexual exploitation, white men were more commonly suspects in cases of child abuse. The crossbench peer has also taken aim this week at the authorities who failed victims, the police and their ability to only 'half-collect' race data, and at politicians for the 'politicisation' of the issue. On that note, Prime Minister Keir Starmer has taken a pop at Tory leader Kemi Badenoch – claiming when her party was in power she did not raise the issue of grooming gangs 'not once', while he was 'calling even then for mandatory reporting' – while the Conservatives have claimed the issue is one of 'borders, beyond criminal justice'. The Labour lot certainly has their work cut out…
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Mailman admits brutally stabbing, beheading and dismembering girlfriend, blaming it on drugs blackout
A man has admitted brutally murdering and decapitating his 21-year-old girlfriend before texting her mother pretending to be her. Ewan Methven killed Phoenix Spencer-Horn at their home in East Kilbride, Lanarkshire, Scotland, last November. The mailman, 27, later called emergency services insisting he had a drug-induced blackout and could not remember what he had done. It emerged he had also mutilated her body and pretended to her mother she was still alive while trawling the Internet for porn for hours. Methven admitted the gruesome murder as he appeared in the dock at the High Court in Glasgow. His lawyer said those close to Spencer-Horn will regard him as 'the personification of evil'. The first offender now faces a life sentence when he is back in court next month. The couple had dated for two years before the killing having met at a party and had recently moved into the top floor, one-bedroom flat together. He worked as a mailman while she held part-time jobs at both the Strathaven Hotel and a local coffee shop. She had been working on Saturday, November 16, and was described as having been in 'good spirits'. Methven had texted her during her shift complaining of feeling 'lonely' due to her hours. She apologized to her boyfriend. The couple ate a takeout when Spencer-Horn came back from work that night and she contacted her mother, Alison Spencer, to say she was at home having dinner. It was the last time she heard from her daughter. At around midnight a downstairs neighbor heard 'loud noise and hurried footsteps'. Prosecutor Chris McKenna said: 'At that time, around or shortly after midnight on November 16 through to November 17, Methven attacked Phoenix by compressing her neck and repeatedly stabbing her to the head and body.' Following the attack he repeatedly arranged to buy drugs via a contact on his phone. When Spencer tried to contact her daughter on the Sunday morning, Methven claimed she was not up yet and that he would get her to message when she was. The sick killer then later pretended to be his girlfriend and sent a text to her mother saying: 'Hey sorry I've just woken up xxx.' Another claimed she was 'all good'. The court heard that minutes after this Methven logged on to the adult websites accessing a 'pornographic video site 170 times'. He was also captured on CCTV driving his partner's car. Concerns were raised when Spencer-Horn did not turn up for work after the weekend, on November 18. Methven called emergency services that afternoon stating he had had 'a drug induced psychotic break' and that he had 'killed' his girlfriend. He told the operator she remained in the hall with a knife beside her and said he'd been taking steroids and cocaine which he believed had been spiked. Methven claimed he'd 'totally blacked out' but mentioned having 'stabbed' and 'choked' her adding: 'It was f****** horrible.' When asked if she could still be alive, he replied: 'I know she is dead, mate - she is dead.' Mr McKenna told the court: 'Phoenix's naked and mutilated body with her head decapitated was discovered by police covered up within the hall of their home. 'An attempt had also been made by him to sever her torso, right wrist and ankle from her body. 'There were two bloodstained knives lying next to the mutilated body. A further bloodstained knife was found discarded in the bedroom.' McKenna said her head had been placed upright next to her body under her left arm. Methven was described as 'calm'. Among the remarks Methven made on his arrest were: 'I could not stay here with her like that. I tried to dismember her. I moved her from the bath and put her there.' After he was put in a police cell, he said: 'I guess this is what my next 25 years look like.' Spencer-Horn had suffered a total of 20 stab wounds - the fatal one to the chest. Methven also pleaded guilty to a charge of attempting to defeat the ends of justice including the mutilation of her body and lying to her mother. His lawyer Tony Graham said: 'Those related to Phoenix and those who are friends are likely to regard Ewan Methven as the personification of evil. 'While of little moment, he wishes to express publicly how truly sorry he is for the death. 'He recognizes the relatives and friends will never be able to forgive him. He will not be able to forgive himself. 'He understands the bereaved will seek an explanation, but he cannot provide an explanation.' The judge said: 'You have pleaded guilty to an appalling and horrible crime.' Methven will learn the minimum he will spend behind bars next month. Following his guilty plea, Detective Chief Inspector Susie Cairns said: 'My thoughts remain with Phoenix's family and friends as they continue to try to come to terms with what happened. 'Methven now faces the consequences of his actions.
Daily Record
9 hours ago
- Daily Record
Man convicted of 1994 Orkney restaurant murder is innocent, claims top lawyer
Leading criminal lawyer Aamer Anwar believes the case of a former soldier convicted of the murder 31 years ago of a restaurant waiter is a miscarriage of justice Sheku Bayoh lawyer Aamer Anwar has called for the man convicted of the racially motivated murder of an Asian restaurant waiter to be set free. The human rights campaigner believes that former Black Watch sergeant Michael Ross is the victim of a miscarriage of justice and wants his case referred back to the appeal courts and conviction and life sentence overturned. Anwar says there is no evidence to show that he carried out a racially motivated killing. Michael Ross was found guilty in 2008 of shooting Bangladeshi waiter Shamsuddin Mahmood in the Mumutaz Indian Restaurant in Kirkwall, Orkney, in 1994. At the time of the murder Ross was only 15. After a trial at the High Court in Glasgow Ross was told he must serve 25 years before he can be considered for parole. Suspicion first fell on the teenager after his policeman father, a firearms specialist, told senior officers that he possessed the same ammunition as was used in the killing. Ross, who was an army cadet at the time, was identified as a man seen wearing a balaclava in woods around two weeks before the murder. Twelve years later new evidence came from local man William Grant who told police he had seen Ross on the evening of the murder wearing a balaclava and handling a gun in toilets near the crime scene. Mr Grant also claimed he witnessed the youth shouting racial abuse outside the restaurant weeks before the murder. A campaign - Justice for Michael Ross - has been launched on Orkney which Anwar's Glasgow firm is backing. In an exclusive interview with Criminal Record - our new weekly podcast - the lawyer said: "We have represented Michael for a few years now and need new evidence to get the keys to open the cell door and for a miscarriage of justice application. "It strikes me as incredible that a 15 year old boy could walk into a restaurant with a balaclava on, walk directly up to an individual, shoot them at point blank range and then walk out and leave nothing of themselves." Anwar says there are also concerns that 15-year old Ross was interviewed in 1994 about the murder by police without a lawyer present. He also described the evidence of Mr Grant as "fanciful". The lawyer is appealing to anyone with information on the 31 year old murder to come forward. He added: "There must be people on the island who know much more than they knew at the time and with the passage of time will feel guilt or have a conscience and will one day give that information which means we have a miscarriage of justice application. "There were always questions over whether it was someone outside the island or a gangland execution." Anwar hopes to present any new evidence to the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission who have the power to refer convictions back to the appeal courts. The lawyer added: "There was evidence of people having turned up at the restaurant in the days before shouting abuse at Shamsuddin. "There is nothing to show that Michael Ross carried out a racially motivated murder." Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Following the murder of Shamsuddin Ross enlisted in the army and saw active combat in Iraq, becoming the sergeant of a sniper platoon. Aamer Anwar is one of the country's most prominent criminal lawyers and has represented Abdelbaset Al-Megrahi, the Libyan convicted of the Lockerbie bombing, Surjit Singh Chhokar, the Lanarkshire waiter who was murdered in a racially motivated attack, and Sheku Bayoh, from Kirkcaldy, who died after being restrained by police officers in 2015. He features in a new three part series of The Firm - about the workings of his legal practice - which began last night (Tuesday) on BBC Scotland. The first episode shows him with Margaret Caldwell, the mother of murdered Glasgow sex worker, Emma Caldwell, as they successfully secure a public inquiry into police handling of her daughter's murder. In 2024, Iain Packer was jailed for life with a minimum of 36 years for the murder of Emma in 2005. It emerged that Packer has been ignored as a suspect despite admitting to police that he was a client of Emma's and had previously taken her to the remote wooded spot where her body was found. Anwar originally represented one of four Turkish men charged with Emma's murder and realised at that time they were not guilty. He added: "We need to know what went horribly wrong with the Emma Caldwell investigation. "There are still lessons to be learned. " Margaret Caldwell hopes to get to the truth but also wants a real and lasting legacy." You can hear more from Aamer Anwar in our Criminal Record podcast where he talks about death threats, online abuse, and his most memorable campaigns and cases.
