Gotcha! NYPD drones spot subway surfer and man at crime scene, but privacy an issue
One video shows a man riding a subway car; another a man collecting shell cases on a rooftop. Both videos, recorded by an NYPD drone, demonstrate they can be a boon to law enforcement. police say.
'The NYPD's use of drones as a strategic, emergency response saves lives on our subway system and streets,' the department said in a statement, 'allows for an immediate deployment to dangerous situations, and, ultimately, protects everyday New Yorkers.
Critics of the emerging technology, though, have been less than enthusiastic, calling drones more of a novelty than a way to improve public safety. They worry that the department does not care enough about the privacy concerns that have been publicly raised.
Albert Fox Cahn, who heads the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project (STOP), acknowledged drones can be effective in certain situations — such as water rescues. But he said there are already enough cameras to record subway surfers and that taxpayer money should be spent on other measures.
'Drones can respond to tragedies but they can't keep us safe,' Cahn said. 'Drones are gimmicks. Gimmicks can pay off on occasion but it's not a smart way to invest our tax dollars when you're talking about something that is helpful just sometimes and is ripe for abuse.'
The NYPD last month announced it was stepping up its use of drones with a five precinct pilot program in which the electronic devices would be sent out, along with patrol officers, on certain 911 calls, with the department noting a drone can often get to a scene before officers in a police cruiser.
The department also said that drones this year have helped nab 31 subway surfers through April. In a video obtained by the Daily News, a drone on the afternoon of April 2 spotted Isaiah Thompson, 29, as he rode outside the last car on the J train in Williamsburg.
The drone zooms in on Thompson, who does not appear to realize he is being watched. The video later shows him crossing the tracks at the Hewes St. station. When he gets to the other side of the tracks a plainclothes officer leads him onto the platform, where he is arrested and charged with reckless endangerment and trespass. Thompson's case is pending; his lawyer did not respond to request for comment.
In the other video, an NYPD drone on the evening of April 12 was dispatched to a ShotSpotter alert in the Bronx, by E. 18th St. near Marion Ave., police said. With officers on patrol not yet on scene, the drone zooms in on Lawrence Taylor, 23, atop an apartment building roof, pacing back and forth and picking items up off the ground.
The video shows Taylor a short time later leaving the building and, as he is about to cross the street, put his arms up at the sight of a police cruiser that is now on scene. Officers are seen getting out, moving Taylor to the ground and arresting him.
Taylor, no relation to the NFL Hall of Fame linebacker, was charged with tampering with evidence — eight 9mm shell casings he had hid in his right shoe, according to a court criminal complaint.
Police said any shell casings that are recovered are analyzed to see if they can be linked to any other shootings.
Cary (cq) London, Taylor's lawyer, predicted the case would be dismissed, saying 'there was no attempt to tamper or conceal evidence.'
London also said that while technology 'can be a helpful tooli n public safety we must ensure it doesn't come at the expense of privacy rights or lead to over-policing in communities already subject to disproportionate surveillance.'
The NYPD said it is aware of such concerns and that it 'has worked with good government groups to address privacy concerns and looks forward to our continued collaboration in keeping our city safe.'
Last May, the NYPD inspector general in a report said the police department was still not fully compliant with the terms of the Public Oversight of Surveillance Technology (POST) Act.
The NYPD said that two months ago it accepted all 10 of the recommendation made by monitor so that it could comply with the POST Act.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Cheer NYC's major-crime drop — but the city isn't out of the woods yet
Rejoice: The NYPD is scoring major success against violent crime. Yes, New Yorkers still have good reason to feel less safe than they did just a few years ago — but let's consider the good news first. Mayor Eric Adams and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced Tuesday that the city saw modern-history record lows in murders and shootings in the first five months of this year. Above all, credit the work of New York's Finest and Tisch's simple but highly effective approach to public safety: Enforce the law. Every law, all of the time. The NYPD is back to quality-of-life policing, not letting 'minor' infractions, like traffic violations and aggressive panhandling, slide — because major crime follows when cops stop sweating the small stuff. The department is also putting more cops in areas with high gun violence and nabbing more illegal firearms: Officers have yanked 2,200 guns off the streets so far this year. Lauding her officers' good work, Tisch said: 'Results like this never happen by accident, and certainly not at a time when the state's criminal-justice laws have made a revolving door out of our criminal-justice system.' Amen: The historic dip in shootings and homicides is a hard-won accomplishment. Full stop. But you're not alone in not feeling safer. For example, polling last month for Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg's reelection campaign found that 56% of likely Democratic primary voters described crime as out-of-control or a major problem. It's no small irony that Bragg is the messenger, but 'why' is plenty obvious: We are still less safe in important ways that are largely beyond cops' control. For one: Overall transit crime has slightly dipped, but the state's no-bail law and New York's failings on handling mentally illness are still wreaking havoc: Felony assaults on the subway are up 19%, with cops and MTA workers making up 36% of victims. And Tisch herself on Tuesday flagged another grim stat: Violent crime among kids has exploded since the state's Raise the Age law made it near-impossible to try under-18s in Criminal Court. From 2018 to 2024, the number of underage shooters spiked 192%, and the count of kids getting shot jumped 81%, while underage gun busts soared 136%. Other state 'reforms' brought a plague of retail theft that's closed countless stores and forced others to stick everyday necessities like toothpaste and deodorant behind locked plexiglass, while marijuana legalization has gifted New Yorkers with the ever-present reek of pot on the streets. Add the impact of tens of thousands of 'asylum seekers' coming to town, with their shelters serving as crime magnets and areas like the 'Market of Sweethearts' along Roosevelt Avenue in Queens plagued by open-air drug and prostitution markets. Tisch is a dedicated, no-nonsense, whip-smart leader — but she took over the NYPD after years of disastrous lefty policies wore law and order in New York down to the bone. She can't fix the city's out-of-control crime problem on her own. Her push for better enforcement is at odds with every far-left progressive in Albany and on the City Council, not to mention DAs and judges, who strive to protect perps from facing consequences for crime — which means victims suffer plenty. The NYPD alone can't fully restore your sense of safety: That requires fixing the laws that got New York into this mess and voting out the loons who oppose needed change.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Youth violence has skyrocketed in NYC, top cop Jessica Tisch reveals as she blames contentious ‘Raise the Age' law
Youth violence has skyrocketed in the Big Apple over the last few years, Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said Tuesday — as she placed the blame on the state's contentious 'Raise the Age' law. The number of kids under the age of 18 busted with a gun increased by a whopping 136% between 2018 and 2024, the top cop said alongside Mayor Eric Adams at a crime stats briefing held at City Hall. Over the same period, Tisch said the number of underage shooters soared 192%, while the number of juvenile victims of gun violence spiked by 81%. Advertisement 5 The number of kids under the age of 18 busted with a gun increased by a whopping 136% between 2018 and 2024. LP Media 'I have seen enough,' Tisch said of the surging youth crime, while pointing the finger at Albany's soft-on-crime law that raised the age of criminal responsibility to 18. The NYPD couldn't immediately provide the exact numbers tied to the percentage increases cited by the commissioner. Advertisement But so far in 2025, 36 — or 14% — of suspected shooters in the five boroughs have been under the age of 18, she said. And 44 shooting victims — also 14% — were under the age of 18 so far this year, according to Tisch. She said the spike was a result of Raise the Age, which was signed by then-governor – and now mayoral candidate – Andrew Cuomo on April 10, 2017, and took effect in October 2019. 5 Authorities at the scene where a person was reportedly set on fire inside of Penn Station near the NYC subway entrance in New York, NY around 7:55 p.m. on December 27, 2024. Christopher Sadowski Advertisement The law upped the age for a teen to face adult charges to 18, from the previous 16- and 17-year-old threshold. 'The idea behind this was one that we could all agree on: children should not be treated like adults in our criminal justice system,' Tisch said. 'But when the age of criminal responsibility went up, the age of criminal suspects went down.' Gangs and crews are now recruiting ever-younger members – who 'carry the guns and commit the shootings, the robberies and the assaults' – in order to evade serious consequences, according to the commissioner. Advertisement 5 The law upped the age for a teen to face adult charges to 18, from the previous 16- and 17-year-old threshold. LP Media 'Seriously bad things come from a consequence-free environment, and right now juveniles who commit crimes in New York City are living in a virtually consequence-free environment,' she said. Tisch's comments came a week after a 13-year-old boy was busted in the murder of an innocent 28-year-old plumber's apprentice from Yonkers who was simply meeting his out-of-town friend in the Bronx when he was shot dead. The teen turned himself in on May 27 to face charges of second-degree murder, first-degree manslaughter and criminal use of a firearm in the broad-daylight April 23 shooting death of bystander Daoud Marji, police said. It was part of the troubling trend outlined by Tisch that increasingly shows youngsters becoming both the perpetrators — and victims — of gun violence. 5 Tisch's comments came a week after a 13-year-old boy was busted in the murder of an innocent 28-year-old plumber's apprentice from Yonkers. LP Media Earlier in May, Evette Jeffrey, a 16-year-old girl riding her scooter near a schoolyard was shot in the head and killed by a stray bullet — which was fired by a 14-year-old who was handed a gun by a 13-year-old, according to cops. The tragic May 12 shooting stemmed from a beef between rival street gangs — Forest Over Everything and the upstart crew Kreep On Davidson — based at the Davidson Houses housing project in Morrisania, according to NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny. Advertisement 'She was an innocent bystander who was simply trying to take cover behind the brick wall and was struck in the head by one of the rounds,' Kenny said at the time about the young victim. 5 LP Media 'The victim, Evette Jeffrey, was not involved in this dispute.' Tisch's startling comments came as she and Adams announced a more promising crime trend — a dip in shooting and murders so far this year. Advertisement From January through May, the Big Apple saw the lowest number of shootings and murders in recorded history, statistics show. The city also set a record for the lowest number of shootings and murders in the month of May, the officials said. The mayor and top cop also touted the NYPD's seizure of more than 2,200 illegal firearms from the streets since the beginning of 2025.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Man killed in hit-and-run on Robert F. Kennedy Bridge exit ramp: NYPD
MANHATTAN, N.Y. (PIX11) — The search continues for a driver after a man was struck and killed by a motor vehicle on Monday afternoon. The incident happened around 12:49 p.m. near East 125th Street and 2nd Avenue. More Local News Police say the victim, an unidentified man, was standing in the roadway on the Manhattan-bound exit ramp of the Robert F. Kennedy Bridge when he was hit by a vehicle. The driver fled the scene, according to the NYPD. EMS transported the man to an area hospital, where he was pronounced dead. The victim's identity is pending. No arrests have been made, and investigations remain ongoing. Submit tips to police by calling Crime Stoppers at 1-800-577-TIPS (8477), visiting downloading the NYPD Crime Stoppers mobile app, or texting 274637 (CRIMES) then entering TIP577. Spanish-speaking callers are asked to dial 1-888-57-PISTA (74782). Ben Mitchell is a digital content producer from Vermont who has covered both local and international news since 2021. He joined PIX11 in 2024. See more of his work here. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
