Death threats and falsehoods among online abuse reported by land and climate defenders
Interviews and questionaires sent out to more than 200 environmental defenders across six continents by Global Witness found that nine in 10 activists reported receiving abuse over their work. Three in four defenders who said they had experienced offline harm believed that digital harassment contributed to it.
The findings come after Meta announced in January that it was axing factchecking, reducing 'censorship' and increasing political content, following similar moves by X since 2022.
Fatrisia Ain, a member of a collective of women fighting to regain land rights taken through Indonesia's palm oil plantation partnership programme in Sulawesi, told the Guardian about repeated intimidation attempts. 'Accounts have taken selfies from my personal Instagram and posted them on Facebook groups, spreading lies about me and 'red-tagging' – a very sensitive issue in Indonesia.' The posts remain visible in public groups with up to 40,000 members.
Almost two-thirds of defenders who had received abuse said it led them to fear for their safety, and Ain felt that being a woman made her 'even more vulnerable'. 'They falsely accused me of having an affair with a married man because I'm an unmarried woman activist,' she said, describing it as 'another serious allegation in Indonesia'. She said the online attacks had seriously worried her family, who had begged her to stop her activism.
Ain said Facebook refused to remove the posts about her after she reported them for hate speech. 'It said they're not dangerous – but I explained that it is in Indonesia,' she said, calling on platforms to exercise cultural sensitivity in their moderation practices. Just 12% of defenders who reported abuse said they were happy with platforms' responses, and Global Witness found evidence suggesting European defenders were more likely to receive responses when reporting harmful content.
In 2023, at least 196 land defenders were killed worldwide for their work, and Ain told the Guardian that she had been physically attacked last year. 'I was hit by another motorbike on our way to an assisted village surrounded by plantations,' she said, describing the attack as 'very intentional'.
'I just had a few scratches, but it was very terrifying. Now, for security, we use cars.' She said she had received WhatsApp messages condemning her activism before the attack.
Sign up to Down to Earth
The planet's most important stories. Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essential
after newsletter promotion
The poll, carried out by Survation, is a global first. Challenges with reaching land defenders en masse mean it may not be representative of all activists.
Ava Lee, Global Witness's campaign lead, said digital threats – and platforms' increasingly lacklustre responses to tackling them – harmed climate and environmental advocacy. 'We're definitely concerned that it will have a chilling effect on the movement. We know that there are lots of women that don't want to go into politics because of the abuse that they see female politicians getting online – the same can be said now for the climate movement,' she said.
While she called on social media companies to invest in content moderation, Lee also noted that 'these algorithms are designed to keep people online as much as possible and platforms have discovered that the best way of doing that is through division … That's also a choice.'
Global Witness contacted Google, Meta, TikTok and X with the report's findings. Meta pointed to its Safety Center and resources on bullying and harassment prevention, which include a 'hidden words' feature that allows users to filter offensive comments and direct messages. It said it had limits in place to prevent abuse of its features.
TikTok referenced its community guidelines on harassment and bullying and said it did not allow harassing, degrading or bullying statements and behaviour. The others declined to comment.
Lee said: 'It doesn't have to be this way. We're talking about some of the most wealthy companies that hold so much power. [The climate] is the biggest crisis of our lifetimes – if they put their resources into making sure their platforms are safe, we'd have a much better chance of meeting it head-on.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Two tourists dead and another missing in Bali boat horror as tourist ferry with 80 people on board capsizes
A boat carrying 80 passengers has capsized in Bali leaving two tourists dead and a third missing. The speed boast capsized about 5pm AEST after being caught in large surf off Sanur in southeast Bali. At least five Australians, three men and two women, had boarded the vessel, though local authorities have yet to provide information on their condition. Denpasar Search and Rescue Agency said 77 passengers survived the incident while two Chinese nationals died and a 23-year-old Indonesian remained missing. Footage captured the aftermath, where sodden passengers were carried to shore after being rescued from the upturned vessel. In a particularly troubling scene, an apparently unconscious woman was seen being rushed to shore as the screams of onlookers filled the air. The boat, named Fast Boat Dolphin II, capsized and ran aground near its destination port in Sanur, on the Bali mainland, after crossing from Nusa Penida. The search agency said fifteen people were receiving treatment at Bali Mandara Hospital. Pictured is the upturned vessel, which ran aground near Sanur Port on the mainland Investigations into the number of passengers on board and their condition remain ongoing. 'We received the initial report to the Bali Province Disaster Management Operations Center (Pusdalops PB) at 4.25 pm,' the search agency's Bali head I Nyoman Sidakarya said, according to the National News Network. 'We are continuing to gather information regarding the number of passengers and their current condition.' Travel authorities have raised concerns with the safety of Bali's boats in recent months, following the death of Australian woman Anna Blight, 39, in March. The Melbourne accountant was among the 13 passengers on the Sea Dragon snorkelling boat thrown overboard in rough surf on its way to Nusa Penida. Last month, at least 19 people died after a ferry sank while crossing from from an eastern Java island to Bali.
Daily Mail
7 hours ago
- Daily Mail
We came to Bali for a dream getaway - but a drunk Australian ruined everything for us
Two British mates on holiday in Bali have claimed they were run down in the street by a tattooed Aussie who police alleged had been on a drunken carjacking rampage. North Londoner Jesse Green, 27, travelled to the holiday island for a relaxing break and had met up with his brother and also his friend Luke Ellis, 25, of Birmingham. Mr Green, who runs a sales agency back in the UK, claimed he and Mr Ellis were departing another friend's house in Canggu on a motorcycle just after midnight Sunday when a black Toyota Avanza mowed them down. He said the pair were sober and sharing a single bike when they were 'rammed from behind' by the car, which the police had accused the Australian, known only as WRJ, of having carjacked earlier that night. 'It was completely unprovoked. We'd never seen him before,' Mr Ellis told Daily Mail. Mr Green bore the brunt of the impact and was thrown from the back of the bike, while Mr Ellis went sliding along the bitumen with the machine. Fuelled by adrenaline, Mr Ellis managed to shove the bike off himself before collapsing just moments later. 'We were both just lying in the road in shock, like ''what the hell happened?'',' Mr Green said. As the pair were getting their bearings on the road, they looked for what had hit them. 'And we can see in the distance, the SUV is just driving off, hit and run style. 'We were there in shock physically, mentally, everything you can imagine,' Mr Green said. Witnesses called an ambulance to take them to hospital where they discovered the extent of their injuries. The pair's helmets had spared them head trauma, but both men suffered serious injuries to their lower bodies. Doctors discovered Mr Green suffered a fractured pelvis, confirmed by CT scans of his hips and spine taken at 4am on Sunday. His medical bills are already more than $1,000. He also fears it could cost him crucial clients at work by delaying his return to the UK. Mr Ellis sustained deep abrasions and burns from the bike and the road surface, with his treatment medical bills already at $500. His gleaming sport bike was also badly damaged on the body work and frame with repairs expected to exceed $2,000. Both have paid the bills out of their own pocket. Balinese police arrested an Australian man (pictured speaking with police in his underwear) after a burned-out car was found nearby, allegedly stolen from a villa security worker Mr Ellis remains bed ridden while Mr Green is recovering with limited mobility. Their ordeal didn't end there. As the men received treatment in hospital, Mr Green's brother approached local police and claimed he was told by the accused's lawyer not to file a police report. The pair then contracted a local lawyer and told him they wanted to file a police report for the alleged hit-and-run through a translator. The lawyer informed them foreigners could not make police reports under Indonesian law but promised to help them seek a reimbursement for their medical fees and the bike. He assured them it was a standard process under the government and told the men he would speak to the lawyer representing the alleged carjacker. 'After he went to meet with the lawyer, whatever happened… everything changed. His whole tune changed,' Mr Green said. 'We don't know what has happened, but… he changed his tune. To the point where now this morning he said, ''I can't represent you guys. I can't represent you guys''.' The Australian reached a peace agreement with the car's owner (pictured together) on Tuesday, police said The pair said they are struggling to understand the local legal system, and are unsure whether the accused will be brought to justice. They fear they could be left without financial compensation if authorities do no cooperate with them. Law consultants at Legal Indonesia previously stated foreigners may encounter challenges dealing with local police. 'Foreigners in Bali often find themselves at a disadvantage. Police do not always readily accept reports and may even avoid engagement due to language barriers or reluctance to handle cases they see as difficult to resolve,' they said. Police alleged the Australian had intimidated security officials at the Seminyak villa in which he was staying, choking one and stealing a car from another. The man allegedly drove off in the Toyota Avanza while drunk, as the owner and his colleague gave chase. It was found engulfed in flames early on Sunday morning with the interior completely incinerated and the windows smashed outward by the blaze. Police said they returned to the man's villa in Eden the Residence by the Sea and arrested him. Management at the villa complex told police their suspect had been involved in other disturbances before the alleged incident on Sunday. The Australian was arrested and taken to North Kuta Police Station and was questioned by police on Monday. However, after he was detained and the case was transferred to police and seen by immigrations officials, the Australian was released on Tuesday. North Kuta Police Chief Pasek Sudina said he reached a peace agreement with the security guard who owned the vehicle. 'The victim I Ketut Wijaya Kusuma decided to not lodge a police report as the perpetrator has agreed to give him compensation over his loss,' he said. He is due to sign a separate agreement over a case of alleged phone theft with a manager of The Club Bali. '(He) has also agreed to cover the medical cost for another foreigner that has been hit by the car driven by him during the escape,' Police Chief Sudina said.
Reuters
11 hours ago
- Reuters
Taiwanese authorities detain three over alleged theft of TSMC chip secrets
Aug 5 (Reuters) - Taiwanese authorities have detained three people for allegedly stealing technology trade secrets from Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) ( opens new tab, the world's largest chip foundry, Taiwanese prosecutors said on Tuesday. The three were detained late last month after TSMC reported that an internal investigation had shown that former and current employees had illegally obtained information from the company, the Taiwan High Prosecutors Office said in a statement. The prosecutors office said another two people had been released on bail, and one more had been released. The three who have been detained - two current staff and one former employee - are suspected of violating Taiwan's national security law, it added. It did not disclose their identities apart from saying that the former staffer was surnamed Chen. Earlier on Tuesday, TSMC said it had launched legal proceedings and taken disciplinary action against employees involved in potential trade secret leaks after detecting unauthorised activities during routine monitoring. It said its "comprehensive and robust monitoring mechanisms" enabled early identification of the issue, leading to internal investigations and measures against the personnel involved. TSMC said the legal case, which is now under judicial review, prevented it from providing further details. Nikkei Asia earlier reported that the breach involved several former employees suspected of attempting to obtain critical proprietary information on TSMC's 2-nanometer chip technology. There were no immediate details on the suspected motives or whether any information had been passed on, and investigations are ongoing to determine the scope of the leak and whether any others were involved, the Nikkei report said. Taiwanese media outlet United Daily News said prosecutors and investigators had also searched the offices of Tokyo Electron, without citing where they had obtained the information. Tokyo Electron and the prosecutors' office declined to comment. TSMC's 2-nanometer chip technology is the most advanced technology in the semiconductor industry in terms of both density and energy efficiency, according to the company's website. The contract manufacturer, which counts AI industry darling Nvidia (NVDA.O), opens new tab, iPhone maker Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab, and Qualcomm (QCOM.O), opens new tab among its customers, highlighted its zero-tolerance policy for trade secret violations, and said it would pursue offenders to the full extent of the law.
