Quebec's failed SAAQclic project could cost $500M, inquiry hears
A public inquiry examining a failed digital shift by Quebec's automobile insurance board heard Monday it could end up costing the province nearly half a billion dollars more than initially planned.
Alain Fortin, Quebec's interim auditor general, testified that cost overruns could mean the final tally for the so-called SAAQclic project will come in at $1.1 billion by 2027, nearly $500 million more than was budgeted.
The project was expected to cost $638 million over 10 years when launched in 2017. Fortin noted that the board no longer tracks operating costs, and the assumption by the auditor was that operating costs would be at least what was initially budgeted in 2017.
The projected total includes costs for services that are already implemented and others that haven't been completed. However, several phases are on hold without firm deadlines for completion.
'The $1.1 billion includes future costs, actual costs, all costs combined. It could be more …. If they want to get what they wanted at the beginning, it could be more,' Mr. Fortin told the inquiry.
Story continues below advertisement
Earlier this month, Premier François Legault questioned the auditor general's calculations at the national assembly, arguing that 'the cost of the program' and 'the cost of maintenance' should be calculated separately.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Fortin insisted that it was necessary to 'compare apples with apples.' He noted that the board no longer tracks operating costs and the auditor general report estimated the operation cost will come to at least what was initially budgeted in 2017.
The digital transformation was supposed to provide a one-stop platform for renewing licences, scheduling driving tests and performing other tasks without needing an in-person meeting.
It ended up creating headaches for the provincial government in 2023 as frustrated citizens were stuck waiting in massive lineups at branches attempting to get services that should have been available online.
Much of Fortin's testimony was based on the auditor's report published in February 2025, which found SAAQclic was a failure and the board, the Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec, blew through its budgets with little to show.
Some of the problems were known in 2022 before the system became operational, but management claimed the system was proceeding according to plan.
'In fact, the implementation of the new computer system caused significant problems and has not yet generated the expected benefits,' the auditor general wrote. 'Two years after its implementation, problems persist.'
Story continues below advertisement
The inquiry, headed by Denis Gallant, a Montreal municipal court judge, must submit its report by Sept. 30.
After the auditor's report, Éric Caire was forced to resign as minister of cybersecurity and digital technology. Legault's government established the public inquiry to shed light on what went wrong with the implementation of the software for the board.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
28 minutes ago
- Global News
New report shows Regina manufacturing sector feeling tariff pressure
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook Economic Development Regina (EDR) has released its second quarterly report of the Regina Prosperity Matrix. The report shows the standing of Regina's economy through collected data that focuses on employment, manufacturing, housing, retail/consumerism and household affordability. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy In EDR's latest report, it shows strength and growth in many of Regina's sectors but manufacturing industry in the city is seeing some difficulty. Industry officials say the ongoing talks and uncertainty around the U.S. tariffs and trade policy are putting a big strain on manufacturing companies. Katherine Ludwig has the full details in the video above.
Global News
28 minutes ago
- Global News
Canada Post's latest offer set to go to a vote by union members
Canada Post workers will soon be asked to cast their votes on whether to ratify the employer's final offer in the ongoing labour dispute, despite union opposition. 'Canada Post has received notice that the Minister of Jobs and Families has approved its request for a vote to take place on the company's final offers to the Canadian Union of Postal Workers (CUPW), using her authority under section 108.1 of the Canada Labour Code,' Canada Post said in a statement Thursday. 'The vote will be administered by the Canada Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) as soon as possible and will give employees in the Urban and RSMC (Rural and Suburban Mail Carriers) bargaining units the opportunity to have their say on Canada Post's final offers. 'We stand ready to work with the CIRB to prepare for the vote and will share details as soon as they are available.' Story continues below advertisement Jobs and Families Minister Patty Hajdu said she made the decision because 'it is in the public interest that the membership of the Canadian Union of Postal Workers has the opportunity to vote on Canada Post's last offers.' 1:45 Chickening out on snail mail: Man airlifts 1K chicks to Penticton amid Canada Post strike fears The vote will be focused on the latest and final offers made to employees in both the Urban and Rural and Suburban Mail Carriers bargaining units presented on May 28, and the decision comes just days after Canada Post rejected the union's binding arbitration proposal on Monday. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy If the majority approves, this could be the beginning of the end of off-and-on labour disruptions at Canada Post after 18 months of negotiations. The Canadian Union of Postal Workers said in a statement that 'Canada Post and the Government are colluding to take away the rights of workers to freely and fairly bargain collective agreements.' Story continues below advertisement 'CUPW leadership and its negotiating committees will be recommending to members to vote no on these offers,' the union said, adding that the overtime ban remains in effect.
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
Iran to open new enrichment facility after censure by UN nuclear watchdog
The U.N. nuclear watchdog's board of governors on Thursday formally found that Iran isn't complying with its nuclear obligations for the first time in 20 years, a move that could lead to further tensions and set in motion an effort to restore United Nations sanctions on Tehran later this year. Iran reacted immediately, saying it will establish a new enrichment facility 'in a secure location' and that 'other measures are also being planned.' 'The Islamic Republic of Iran has no choice but to respond to this political resolution,' the Iranian Foreign Ministry and the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran said in a joint statement. U.S. President Donald Trump previously warned that Israel or America could carry out airstrikes targeting Iranian nuclear facilities if negotiations failed — and some American personnel and their families have begun leaving the region over the tensions, which come ahead of a new round of Iran-U.S. talks Sunday in Oman. In Israel, the U.S. Embassy ordered American government employees and their families to remain in the Tel Aviv area over security concerns. Story continues below advertisement 7:41 Iran and U.S. hold second round of nuclear talks in Rome Nineteen countries on the International Atomic Energy Agency's board, which represents the agency's member nations, voted for the resolution, according to diplomats who spoke on condition of anonymity to describe the outcome of the closed-doors vote. Russia, China and Burkina Faso opposed it, 11 abstained and two did not vote. In the draft resolution seen by The Associated Press, the board of governors renews a call on Iran to provide answers 'without delay' in a long-running investigation into uranium traces found at several locations that Tehran has failed to declare as nuclear sites. Western officials suspect that the uranium traces could provide further evidence that Iran had a secret nuclear weapons program until 2003. The resolution was put forward by France, the United Kingdom, Germany and the United States. Story continues below advertisement Iran lists steps in retaliation for the IAEA vote Speaking to Iranian state television after the vote, the spokesman for the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran said that his agency immediately informed the IAEA of 'specific and effective' actions Tehran would take. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'One is the launch of a third secure site' for enrichment, spokesman Behrouz Kamalvandi said. He did not elaborate on the location, but the organization's chief Mohammad Eslami later described the site as 'already built, prepared, and located in a secure and invulnerable place.' Iran has two underground sites at Fordo and Natanz and has been building tunnels in the mountains near Natanz since suspected Israeli sabotage attacks targeted that facility. The other step would be replacing old centrifuges for advanced ones at Fordo. 'The implication of this is that our production of enriched materials will significantly increase,' Kamalvandi said. Story continues below advertisement According to the draft resolution, 'Iran's many failures to uphold its obligations since 2019 to provide the Agency with full and timely cooperation regarding undeclared nuclear material and activities at multiple undeclared locations in Iran … constitutes non-compliance with its obligations under its Safeguards Agreement.' 1:48 Trump 'not in a rush' to attack Iran over nuclear program Under those obligations, which are part of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, Iran is legally bound to declare all nuclear material and activities and allow IAEA inspectors to verify that none of it is being diverted from peaceful uses. The draft resolution also finds that the IAEA's 'inability … to provide assurance that Iran's nuclear program is exclusively peaceful gives rise to questions that are within the competence of the United Nations Security Council, as the organ bearing the main responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security.' The draft resolution made a direct reference to the U.S.-Iran talks, stressing its 'support for a diplomatic solution to the problems posed by the Iranian nuclear program, including the talks between the United States and Iran, leading to an agreement that addresses all international concerns related to Iran's nuclear activities, encouraging all parties to constructively engage in diplomacy.' Story continues below advertisement Still a chance for Iran to cooperate with IAEA A senior Western diplomat last week described the resolution as a 'serious step,' but added that Western nations are 'not closing the door to diplomacy on this issue.' However, if Iran fails to cooperate, an extraordinary IAEA board meeting will likely be held in the summer, during which another resolution could get passed that will refer the issue to the Security Council, the diplomat said on condition of anonymity because he wasn't authorized to discuss the issue with the media. The three European nations have repeatedly threatened in the past to reinstate, or 'snapback,' sanctions that have been lifted under the original 2015 Iran nuclear deal if Iran does not provide 'technically credible' answers to the U.N. nuclear watchdog's questions. In a joint statement to the IAEA board of governors, the three European nations said that they would 'spare no efforts to work towards a diplomatic solution' but added that without a satisfying deal, they would 'consider triggering the snapback mechanism to address threats to international peace and security arising from Iran's nuclear program.' Story continues below advertisement 1:20 Trump says U.S. to have 'direct talks' with Iran at 'very high level' The authority to reestablish those sanctions by the complaint of any member of the original 2015 nuclear deal expires in October, putting the West on a clock to exert pressure on Tehran over its program before losing that power. The resolution comes on heels of the IAEA's so-called 'comprehensive report' that was circulated among member states last weekend. In the report, the U.N. nuclear watchdog said that Iran's cooperation with the agency has 'been less than satisfactory' when it comes to uranium traces discovered by agency inspectors at several locations in Iran. One of the sites became known publicly in 2018, after Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu revealed it at the United Nations and called it a clandestine nuclear warehouse hidden at a rug-cleaning plant. Iran denied this, but in 2019, IAEA inspectors detected the presence of uranium traces there as well as at two other sites. Story continues below advertisement —Gambrell reported from Dubai, United Arab Emirates. Associated Press writer Amir Vahdat in Tehran, Iran, contributed to this report.
