James Staley's capital murder conviction reversed on appeal
WICHITA FALLS (KFDX/KJTL) — The Second Court of Appeals has reversed the capital murder conviction of James Irvin Staley, III, for the 2018 death of 2-year-old Jason Wilder McDaniel.
Staley was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole by a Tarrant County jury on March 13, 2023, following a three-week trial in Fort Worth.
According to Wichita County officials, the Fort Worth appellate court informed them of the decision to reverse the conviction and remand the case for a new trial on Thursday, March 6, 2025.
OTHER COVERAGE: James Staley appeal submitted after oral arguments
John Gillespie, Wichita County District Attorney, said he doesn't agree with the Second Court of Appeals' decision.
'I'm extremely disappointed with the Second Court of Appeals' decision to reverse James Staley's conviction, and I disagree with the decision,' Gillespie said.
Despite the reversal of Staley's conviction for Wilder's death, Gillespie said he will use every resource at his disposal to ensure justice is served.
'The fight isn't over, this is only the beginning,' Gillespie said. 'We will exhaust every appellate option available, including petitioning the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to reinstate the conviction. If we cannot get the conviction reinstated, then we'll try the case again and get him a second time. I've only begun to fight.'
Staley has been serving his sentence in the Bill Clemens Unit in Amarillo while awaiting the result of his appeal, which was submitted nearly a year ago on March 13, 2024.
According to Keith Hampton, Staley's appellate attorney, his case for an appeal of his conviction stems from a failure by the Wichita Falls Police Department to produce an adequate search warrant or affidavit to obtain such.
Staley's defense alleged that key evidence taken from a Mac Mini and Staley's cell phone was unconstitutional because the specific devices were not named in the affidavit or warrant, and therefore, it should not have been admitted into evidence during Staley's trial.
Gillespie's main counterpoint to Hampton's argument was that specific details actually were contained within the affidavit that led to the warrant to search Staley's devices.
'This was far from boilerplate,' Gillespie said. 'These ample facts implicated a key Texas law, Article 3836, which authorizes prosecutors to provide relationship and state-of-mind evidence in murder trials.'Further details regarding the reasoning for the appellate court's decision are unavailable at this time.
The memorandum opinion has not been publicly released by the Second Court of Appeals as of the publication of this story.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
12 hours ago
- New York Post
Locals say bizarre ‘massacre' of mother goose and her six tiny goslings in Kansas street was no accident
The shocking discovery of the smooshed and mangled bodies of a mother goose and her six tiny goslings on a Kansas street has ignited local residents who believe the mysterious mass deaths were no accident — and possibly a violation of federal law. 'It was just a massacre of goslings in the street,' Wichita resident Cylie Gillespie told KAKE after she came across the grisly scene Monday morning that left her physically ill. The family of Canada geese was likely struck by a car and Gillespie believes a cruel driver deliberately ran them over. Advertisement 'There was seven of them in a row. There was one hit, one hit, one hit, one hit, like it was over, a good amount of space,' she said. 'It didn't look like they hit one, and then, you know, swerved to miss the rest of them. They hit one, and then continued to hit the remainder of the flock.' It looked like the car made no effort to avoid the geese, Gillespie added. Residents in Wichita hope the killer of a mother goose and six goslings is found and arrested. FOX NEWS KANSAS Advertisement 'If you hit one, whatever, I guess accidents happen,' she told the local news station. 'But to me, it was deliberate due to the fact of how they were all lined up.' The Wichita local is one of several residents who look forward to this time of year when the geese make a stop in town as they migrate south, she said. But what she saw Monday, caused her to have an overwhelming physical response. Canada geese are a common sight in Kansas this time of year. FOX NEWS KANSAS Advertisement 'I threw up a little bit. I cried, I needed a hug,' Gillespie said. 'I was hurt, I was upset, I was very angry.' 'I was just disgusted with humanity,' she added. Canada geese are federally protected, thanks to the Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918, according to the Kansas Department of Wildlife and Parks. Without a permit, it's a crime to intentionally harm or kill the animal. Advertisement Gillespie hopes police get involved to find and arrest the waterfowl killer. 'It's just sickening,' she said. 'I'm at a loss for words. I want action. I want something to be done,' she told KAKE.
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
Former Bellefontaine sergeant in court on OVI, firearm charges
DAYTON, Ohio (WDTN) – A former Bellefontaine officer was in a Logan County court Wednesday on firearm and OVI charges. Bellefontaine Police Sgt. Bradley Staley faces charges of improper handling of a firearm in a motor vehicle, a felony of the fifth degree, and operating a motor vehicle under the influence (OVI), a misdemeanor of the first degree. Staley appeared before Judge Kevin P. Braig in the Logan County Court of Common Pleas. The judge granted Staley recognizance bond, ordered him to keep in contact with lawyer Madison Mackay and submit to pre-trial drug/alcohol testing. Staley pleaded not guilty to the charges. He moved the court for admission to the intervention instead of the conviction program. He was ordered by the court to appear for a pre-sentence investigation interview. A hearing is scheduled on the motion and to accept a change of plea on the OVI charge for July 11 at 2 p.m. 2 NEWS will follow this case as it develops. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
Paxton Calls For New Law To Protect Texas Elections From Local Corruption
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has called for the State House of Representatives to pass legislation that would allow him to prosecute voter fraud when local officials refuse to do so. Paxton cited a 2021 decision by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to overturn a law that allowed the attorney general to unilaterally prosecute election cases, instead ruling that a district or county attorney must invite him to work on the case. The attorney general has taken a strong stance against this decision while calling for the legislature, with his office writing in a news release that it 'opened the door for abuse throughout the state.' Paxton also released a statement, writing that 'the system is broken' if the attorney general is not permitted to prosecute voter fraud when local district and county attorneys choose not to. 'We're talking about one of the most fundamental rights we have as Americans—the right to vote. This legislation gives Texas the legal tools to protect the ballot box,' he added. 'Secure elections are the foundation of our system of government, but if a rogue district or county attorney ignores clear evidence of voter fraud, there's nothing we can do about it.' This news release continued by pointing out the issues preventing Paxton from prosecuting voter fraud, noting that one corrupt official could allow voter fraud to persist within a county. Additionally, Paxton noted how local officials could be involved in deep schemes to plan voter fraud, noting that attorney general resources could be required to truly uncover the full depth of the alleged crimes. 'Concurring with the Senate Substitute for HB 5138 is the best opportunity to provide meaningful reform so that Texans can have full confidence in the integrity of their elections,' concluded the release. This information from Paxton's office comes as the Lone Star State continues to evaluate ways to improve voter integrity, including the potential for allowing only U.S. citizens to vote in state elections, as previously reported by The Dallas Express. These concerts have also spilled into Dallas within recent months, with Former Texas House of Representatives candidate Barry Wernick filing a complaint against the Dallas County Elections Department. Wenrick alleged that Dallas County's 'sample ballots' were not actually samples but the real ballots being used in the election, which included both candidate names and Dallas Elections Administrator Heider Garcia's signature, as reported by DX.
