Tesla's robotaxi peppered with driving mistakes in Texas tests
(Reuters) -A first public test of robotaxis by Tesla in Austin, Texas led to multiple traffic problems and driving issues, videos from company-selected riders showed over the first few days.
Chief Executive Elon Musk has tied Tesla's financial future to self-driving technology, and with Tesla sales down, the stakes are high. He said Tesla would roll out the service to other U.S. cities later this year and predicted "millions of Teslas" operating "fully autonomously" by the second half of next year.
The Tesla fans invited to the trial were strongly supportive and posted videos of hours of trouble-free driving, but issues drew questions from federal road safety regulators and auto safety experts.
Issues included Tesla robotaxis entering the wrong lane, dropping passengers off in the middle of multiple-lane roads or at intersections, sudden braking, speeding and driving over a curb.
In one instance, a robotaxi drove into a lane meant for oncoming traffic for about 6 seconds. It had pulled into an intersection in its left-turn lane with its turn blinker on. Then the steering wheel wobbled momentarily, and instead of turning it proceeded straight into the lane meant for oncoming traffic, prompting a honk from a car behind it.
In another incident, the car suddenly brakedwith no obstruction apparent in the video. The passenger jerked forward and their belongings were thrown to the floor. In a third video, taken from another vehicle, a robotaxi abruptly stopped twice in the middle of the road while passing police vehicles with flashing lights.
Tesla is conducting the test with human safety monitors in the front passenger seat. A fourth video showed the safety monitor hitting a button to stop the robotaxi when a delivery truck in front of it started backing up.
"This is awfully early to have a bunch of videos of erratic and poor driving," said Philip Koopman, a Carnegie Mellon University computer-engineering professor and autonomous-technology expert. "I was not expecting as many videos of problematic driving on the very first day," he said. Tesla is testing about 10 to 20 robotaxis, which are standard Model Ys with advanced software, and has been giving rides since Sunday afternoon.
Reuters was able to independently verify the locations of at least 11 videos showing issues. Tesla did not respond to a request for comment.
A City of Austin spokesperson said officials are aware of the Tesla issues documented on social media and that "when a potential legal or safety concern is brought to our attention, we promptly share it with the company." The spokesperson added that the police department is "actively collaborating with Tesla" to ensure officers can safely interact with the robotaxis.
'CAUGHT ON CAMERA'
The incidents caught on camera did not involve accidents, and one expert said some reflected a decision to focus on safety.
"So far so good. It handled the situations very well and likely better than even good drivers," Alain Kornhauser, Princeton University professor of operations research and financial engineering, said by email. He added that it would be more dangerous to drive at less than the speed of prevailing traffic, for instance.
Tesla's experiment is unusually public. Other companies faced similar issues: Alphabet's Waymo and General Motors' Cruise had their own share of traffic mishaps after showing up on Austin streets. City officials logged dozens of instances over the past two years where residents and authorities reported that robotaxis blocked traffic by stopping in the middle of roads, failed to respond to police directions and could not deal with emergency vehicles and road closures.
A serious accident involving a pedestrian in 2023 led Cruise to shut down last year. Waymo is the only robotaxi service in the U.S. to ferry paying customers without a human backup driver or in-car safety monitor. It started offering rides to the general public through Uber in Austin earlier this year.
Musk for years has failed to deliver on promises that self-driving Teslas are just around the corner. Teslarolled out the service for a flat fee of $4.20 to a limited number of handpicked riders. The service is not available to the broader public and the robotaxis operate in a limited area, and avoid difficult intersections and bad weather.
Riders were rarely bothered much by driving issues. Farzad Mesbahi, a former Tesla program manager, and his co-passenger hit the "drop off early" option during a ride. The vehicle stopped in an intersection with a stoplight, his video showed. They exit quickly and walk to the sidewalk. "The car should have known to not stop there," Mesbahi is heard saying after the ride. "Opportunities for improvement," the co-passenger says.
That is an example "most companies would not be comfortable with," said Kara Kockelman, a professor of transportation engineering at the University of Texas at Austin, adding that she was surprised by the traffic mistakes.
"Dropping off people in the middle of a six-lane road or edge of a busy intersection when the traffic is going in the opposite direction is pretty dangerous. They definitely did not want to do this or be caught on camera," she said.
(Reporting by Abhirup Roy in San Francisco, Rachael Levy in Washington and Chris Kirkham in Los Angeles; Additional reporting Inaki Malvido, Fernando Robles and Richa Singh; by Editing by Peter Henderson and Nick Zieminski)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
9 hours ago
- The Star
As megacities slow, China's smaller counties lead as new consumer hotspots
As widespread economic gloom in China's megacities sees high-end restaurants close their doors one after another, Starbucks is accelerating its expansion into the country's far-flung counties, where a growing number of residents are embracing a petit-bourgeois lifestyle. While county shopping centres might not stock Dyson vacuum cleaners and hairdryers, they have already become part of daily life in households in urban counties thanks to China's ubiquitous e-commerce networks. Driving Teslas and eating expensive cherries imported from South America, the expanding middle class in smaller cities and towns is fuelling China's next wave of consumption. As the world's second-largest economy grows more slowly, residents of major cities have reined in their spending. But the consumption upgrade in China's more numerous lower-tier markets is far from complete, experts said. With lighter economic burdens, faster income growth and greater confidence in the future, consumers in such areas have stronger purchasing power and a greater willingness to spend, becoming a new engine for consumption growth as China seeks to shift its economy towards a consumption-driven model and away from one relying on exports and investment. 'Lower-tier cities have been overlooked in the past, with their consumption potential untapped, while the disposable consumption capacity of first-tier city residents is more affected by the slowing economy,' said Professor Liu Xuexin, who heads a consumer data research institute at Capital University of Economics and Business in Beijing. In China's governance hierarchy, county-level cities sit below prefecture-level ones, covering smaller urban and rural areas, including townships and villages, and serving as regional hubs for commerce, education, healthcare and local government. Classified by their economic strength and population, such cities are usually – and informally – referred to as being third-tier or lower, lacking the scale and influence of first- or second-tier cities such as Beijing, Shanghai and the provincial capitals. A typical third-tier city is Yiwu, in east China's Zhejiang province, which is known for its globally focused wholesale markets. According to the 2020 census, about 509 million people lived in China's first- and second-tier cities, meaning around 903 million lived outside them. A nationwide survey conducted by management consultancy McKinsey & Company at the end of last year found that nearly 80 per cent of Chinese consumers in third- and fourth-tier cities expressed optimism about the economy, compared with 70 per cent in second-tier cities and 67 per cent in first-tier ones. However, the rates for all were down compared with 2023, it said in a report released in May. In terms of retail sales, about 97 per cent of the 171 non-first-tier cities across China that publish such data reported positive year-on-year growth last year, with third- and fourth-tier cities outperforming, according to statistics compiled by Chinese news app in March. Yuxi, a fourth-tier city in Yunnan province, reported the highest growth rate at 8.8 per cent. In contrast, official figures showed that Shanghai's total retail sales of consumer goods fell 3.1 per cent last year, while those in Beijing declined 2.7 per cent. Lily Huang, a housewife who moved from Beijing to Haiyan, a county-level city in Zhejiang, several years ago with her family, said she now buys the same kinds of products she used to buy in Beijing, despite the bad macroeconomic environment in recent years and its effects on incomes. 'We don't feel a lot of pressure, most probably because we don't have a large loan to repay since home prices are much cheaper here,' she said. A lower housing price-to-income ratio than in high-tier cities is one reason lower-tier cities are experiencing faster consumption growth, according to a research note issued by China International Capital Corporation in June. Higher proportions of handed-down properties, greater family financial support for home purchases and lower overall debt burdens have also contributed, it said. Besides, market penetration rates in many consumer sectors in high-tier cities have nearly reached saturation point, leaving little room for further expansion. Using ready-to-drink coffee as an example, the frequency of consumption among consumers in China's first- and second-tier cities is approaching that of Japan, South Korea and Western countries, analysts from Puyin International said in a note issued in June. However, the overall penetration rate in China remained significantly lower than in high-tier cities, they said. Consumers in higher-tier cities, who are generally wealthier, are less sensitive to policy stimuli Well aware of this trend, Starbucks entered 166 new county-level markets in China in the 2024 financial year. In its second-quarter business update this year, Starbucks China said there were Starbucks stores in more than 1,000 county-level markets. A series of government policies has also boosted consumption confidence in such regions, according to the Puyin International note. 'In contrast, consumers in higher-tier cities, who are generally wealthier, are less sensitive to policy stimuli, and meanwhile they face greater employment pressures, more severe asset depreciation due to falling housing prices, and a higher potential impact from tariff wars,' it said. A nationwide consumer goods trade-in programme has been in place in China since March last year as the authorities work to drive spending and boost the economy. Fu Longcheng, vice-president of the China General Chamber of Commerce, told a news conference in January that the consumption structure in county-level markets is being optimised and upgraded, with increased spending on developmental and experiential consumption, as well as service-oriented consumption, and clear trends towards more consumption for personal gratification. 'Entertainment formats such as cinemas, along with new tea drinks, fast fashion and maternity chains are continuously entering county markets, while new consumption models like live-streaming e-commerce and instant retail are rapidly integrating, boosting the momentum for quality enhancement and expansion of county-level consumption,' Fu said. Products in hot demand not only include trendy milk tea and artisanal baked goods, once exclusively found in first- and second-tier cities, but also Boston lobsters and Sam's Club speciality products on dining tables and tickets for music festivals and concerts. More spending by affluent rural residents is also contributing as the country's top leadership pushes forward with an urbanisation drive, reiterating its determination over the past few years to make it easier for farmers to settle in urban areas. Data from the National Bureau of Statistics said that rural retail sales of consumer goods grew by 4.3 per cent last year, outpacing urban growth by 0.9 of a percentage point. In line with that, the McKinsey survey found that the proportion of rural consumers who were optimistic rose by 6 percentage points last year to 73 per cent. Members of Gen Z – those born between 1996 and 2010 – from high-income families in rural areas stood out as the most confident, with 88 per cent having an optimistic outlook, 11 percentage points higher than in 2023. Meanwhile, county tourism is emerging as a vital contributor to efforts to increase consumption's role in the Chinese economy, attracting young people from first-tier cities seeking cost-effective, experiential getaways and at the same time fostering sustainable growth in lower-tier regions. Reports from several travel platforms have highlighted it as a hot trend this year, with posts on RedNote, China's leading lifestyle app, touting the middle-class appeal and affordability of horse riding and tennis lessons in county-level cities. The ITB China Travel Trends Report 2024/25 noted that rural counties are increasingly popular destinations among younger travellers drawn to authentic experiences such as ecotourism and cultural festivals. Huang said she had welcomed several batches of friends from Beijing who had visited Haiyan for sightseeing in the past couple of years. 'They really enjoyed the stay here as it is cheap and relaxing,' she said. In a plan aimed at revitalising rural areas during the period from 2024 to 2027, the State Council, China's cabinet, outlined measures to 'fully promote rural consumption', including the development of county-level commercial systems, providing a key focus for unleashing rural consumption potential. But researchers remain cautious about whether the rise of consumption in lower-tier markets is sufficient to revitalise overall consumer activity. Liu, the Beijing professor, noted that compared to big cities, lower-tier cities lag behind in infrastructure and the overall consumption environment, including consumer rights protection, limiting their consumption potential. 'Whether the consumption boom in these regions can sustain China's shift to a consumption-driven economy is hard to answer, but it is undoubtedly a crucial supplement,' he said. Fudan University economist Shi Lei said that while growth is evident, county-level consumption still faces constraints, primarily due to insufficient local financial resources, with many areas, including regions mainly populated by ethnic minorities, relying on fiscal transfer payments from higher-level governments to sustain development. 'In the long term, the potential arising from underdevelopment should be recognised,' he said. 'But short-term performance should not be overestimated.' -- SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST
The Star
13 hours ago
- The Star
US-India trade talks scheduled for August called off, source says
Trade talks between New Delhi and Washington collapsed after five rounds of negotiations. - Photo: AFP NEW DELHI: A planned visit by US trade negotiators to New Delhi from August 25-29 has been called off, a source said, delaying talks on a proposed trade agreement and dashing hopes of relief from additional US tariffs on Indian goods from Aug 27. The current round of negotiations for the proposed bilateral trade agreement is now likely to be deferred to another date that has yet to be decided, the source with direct knowledge of the matter said. The US embassy in New Delhi said it has no additional information on the trade and tariff talks, which are being handled by the United States Trade Representative (USTR). India's trade ministry did not immediately reply to a Reuters email seeking comments. Earlier this month, US President Donald Trump imposed an additional 25% tariff on Indian goods, citing New Delhi's continued imports of Russian oil in a move that sharply escalated tensions between the two nations. The new import tax, which will come into effect from Aug 27, will raise duties on some Indian exports to as high as 50% - among the highest levied on any US trading partner. Trade talks between New Delhi and Washington collapsed after five rounds of negotiations over disagreement on opening India's vast farm and dairy sectors and stopping Russian oil purchases. India's Foreign Ministry has said the country is being unfairly singled out for buying Russian oil while the United States and European Union continue to purchase goods from Russia. - Reuters
The Star
14 hours ago
- The Star
Bolivia votes as support for left wanes and inflation is top of mind
LA PAZ (Reuters) -Voters in Bolivia are gearing up for a general election on Sunday that has been overshadowed by inflation at a four-decade high and the absence of former leftist President Evo Morales, who is barred from running. Leading the race are opposition conservative contenders Samuel Doria Medina, a business magnate, and Jorge "Tuto" Quiroga, a former president, but neither commands more than 30% support, opinion polls show, with around a quarter of Bolivians undecided. The August race marks the first time in almost two decades that polling indicates Bolivia's incumbent Movement for Socialism, or MAS, could face defeat. Support for MAS-affiliated and other left-leaning candidates trails the opposition, totaling around 10%, according to the latest August Ipsos CEISMORI survey. If no presidential candidate wins more than 40% support with a 10 percentage point lead, the election will head to a runoff on October 19. Morales, who co-founded MAS and governed the country from 2006 to 2019 under its banner, has been barred from running for another term as president. Ballot stations open on Sunday at 8 a.m. local time (1200 GMT) and close at 4 p.m., with initial results expected after 9 p.m. Full officialresults are due within seven will also elect all 26 senators and 130 deputies, and officials assume office on November 8. With a crowded field and no dominant MAS party candidate, the election marks a "crossroads moment" for Bolivia, said Southern Andes analyst Glaeldys Gonzalez Calanche of the International Crisis Group. Bolivia's fragile economy is top-of-mind for voters. Price-rises have surged past other Latin American countries this year, and fuel and dollars have run scarce. Annual inflation doubled to 23% in June, up from 12% in January, with some Bolivians turning to cryptocurrencies as a hedge. Many Bolivians, especially those who work in the informal economy, were now struggling to make ends meet, said economist Roger Lopez. "Prices of the basic food basket are going up fast," said Lopez. "Suddenly the math doesn't add up anymore." They may choose to punish MAS on Sunday, creating a window of opportunity for centrists, the right, or a leftist faction led by Senate President Andronico Rodriguez. "Every year the situation has got worse under this government," said Silvia Morales, 30, from La Paz, who works in retail. A former MAS voter, she said this time she would cast her vote for the center-right. Carlos Blanco Casas, 60, a teacher in La Paz, said he intended to vote for change. "This election feels hopeful. We need a change of direction," he said. Quiroga has promised "radical change" to reverse what he calls "20 lost years" under MAS rule. He supports deep public spending cuts and a shift away from alliances with Venezuela, Cuba and Nicaragua. Quiroga was president for a year in 2001-2002 after the then-leader resigned. Doria Medina, meanwhile, offers a more moderate approach, pledging to stabilize the economy within 100 days. On the left, the vote is split between the official MAS party candidate Eduardo del Castillo, who is backed by outgoing President Luis Arce, and Rodriguez, who has distanced himself from the party and is running on his own ticket. Morales, 69, has called for a boycott of the election, but analysts said his influence is waning. "There is widespread support for these elections," said Calanche. "Most Bolivians see them as key to leading the country towards economic recovery." (Reporting by Lucinda Elliott in Montevideo and Monica Machicao in La Paz, additional reporting by Camille Ayral in Mexico CityEditing by Daina Beth Solomon and Rosalba O'Brien)
