Cops who Tasered & pepper-sprayed amputee, 92, three weeks before his death are CLEARED of assault
Bodycam footage showed Donald Burgess
horror
at Park Beck Residential Care Home in St Leonards-on-Sea, East Sussex.
8
Donald Burgess was pepper sprayed and Tasered at a care home, jurors heard
Credit: SUSSEX NEWS AND PICTURES
8
He died in hospital three weeks later from Covid
Credit: PA
8
PC Stephen Smith and PC Rachel Comotto have been cleared of assault
Credit: PA
PC Rachel Comotto and PC Stephen Smith were called to the residence after Donald poked a worker in the stomach with a butter knife.
Smith claimed he did not know the one-legged pensioner was disabled - despite him sitting in a wheelchair - while Comotto denied she was "trigger-happy".
The pair have now been found cleared of assault occasioning actual bodily harm following a trial.
Southwark Crown
Court
heard one minute and 23 seconds elapsed between the cops arriving and Donald being Tasered.
Bodycam showed him clutching a specially adapted butter knife while sat in his wheelchair when Smith and Comotto entered his room.
PC Smith can be heard saying: 'Put it down mate. Come on, Donald, don't be silly.
"We can solve it without having to resort to this...Do as you're told."
He then "emptied all or almost all of his canister" of pepper spray in Donald's face, the court was told.
Most read in The Sun
The footage also showed Smith making his way towards the pensioner with his baton extended before striking him.
Comotto then deploys her 50,000-volt Taser as Donald screams out in pain before the officers took the knife from him.
After shooting him, PC Comotto asked Donald how he was feeling, leading him to reply: "I'm dying, I'm dying."
The officers were later seen joking about the shocking incident, jurors heard.
8
Donald was first pepper sprayed by Smith
Credit: SUSSEX NEWS AND PICTURES
8
Smith then got his baton out and struck Donald, who was still holding the knife
Credit: SUSSEX NEWS AND PICTURES
8
The butter knife had been specially adapted for the pensioner
In separate bodycam, Comotto is seen laughing and asking Smith: "Oh my God, is there any left in your can?"
Smith replies: "Probably not."
The court heard Donald suffered from multiple health conditions including diabetes and carotid artery disease.
He was taken to hospital after the incident and died 22 days later after contracting Covid.
The court was told the pair were "not responsible for his death".
Police had been called to the care home on June 21, 2022, after Donald was seen poking a care worker in the stomach with a knife after flicking food at her.
He threatened staff with the blade and told them he would take pleasure in murdering them.
Managers wheeled him back to his room and tried for 30 minutes to calm him down before calling 999.
The officers were dispatched under a grade one call, meaning it was treated as the highest level of emergency.
Jurors were told the care home specialised in support for people with dementia but Donald had not been diagnosed with the disease.
Prosecutor Paul Jarvis KC said it "ought to have been obvious by the fact he had one leg that this was a man who wasn't going to be mobile".
He added: "This was an elderly, vulnerable man who may not have understood what was going on.
"Rather than being met with understanding and sympathy, he was confronted by irritation and annoyance on the part of the defendants."
But in their defence, the officers claimed Donald was clutching the knife with a "tight grip".
Read more on the Irish Sun
Smith also said he only realised the pensioner was in a wheelchair after he was wheeled out following the incident.
He denied two counts of assault by using Pava spray and a baton, while Comotto denied one charge of assault by discharging her Taser.
8
Comotto pleaded not guilty to one charge of assault
Credit: PA
8
She and Smith both stood trial at Southwark Crown Court
Credit: PA
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
29 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'Do you want to die?' Man's chilling words before shooting Irish mum
An Irish woman who was shot by her ex-partner in an attempted murder-suicide was told to go to his home to collect their child's belongings following their break-up, an inquest in Australia has heard. Eileen Gibbons, from Mayo, was shot in the stomach by Ralph Donald, her ex-partner, who said to her 'Do you want to die?' in a domestic violence-related attack at a house in Millner in Darwin in October 2023. After shooting her, Ralph took his own life in the tragedy. The inquest into Mr Donald's death in Darwin, which opened on Monday, heard that on October 3, 2023, Mr Donald contacted Ms Gibbons and told her to collect their child's belongings at his home address in Millner. About 6pm, Ms Gibbons arrived with their young daughter in the back seat. Mr Donald's mother greeted the pair and took her granddaughter inside the home while Ms Gibbons had a conversation with Mr Donald's brother, Charles. During this time, Mr Donald carried and kissed his daughter for the last time. Without warning, Mr Donald then exited the house to look inside his vehicle before returning to his bedroom. From there, he collected his Marlin .30-30 rifle and some rounds from his gun safe. Moments later, he was face-to-face with Eileen in the backyard and said to her 'Do you want to die?' Ms Gibbons turned to run but was gunned down with a single round. When the rifle flashed, Charles ran to the scene and shouted 'What are you doing?' at his brother before attending to Ms Gibbons, who was bleeding from the abdomen. What followed was 'an act of enormous bravery', according to Peggy Dwyer SC. Placing himself between his brother and the wounded woman, Charles noticed Mr Donald had started to reload his weapon Fearing for Ms Gibbons, Charles grabbed the bleeding mother and dragged her out of sight. When Charles heard a second gunshot, he thought the round was meant for him or Ms Gibbons, but would find out it was not. Charles then took it upon himself to administer first aid to Ms Gibbons while he also dialled emergency services and his other brother, Angus, for help. In a bid to secure the site, he went to the body of his brother and threw the live weapon under a nearby car. Eileen Gibbons who was shot and seriously injured in Darwin, Australia pictured in her hospital bed with her daughter Silvia as she is visited by her mum Eileen and aunt Marian Langan from Castlebar. (Image: Supplied) Speaking from Ireland via video link at the inquest, Ms Gibbons recalled the early stages of her troubled relationship. '(Ralph and I) were in a relationship almost immediately and I noticed (he) could raise his voice and there would be some arguments – I let that go on a number of occasions,' she said. 'Over time it escalated, but I would say that from very early stages there were initial warning flags that his behaviour wasn't acceptable.' The inquest heard Mr Donald never physically assaulted Ms Gibbons, but the relationship grew more 'toxic', leading to their separation shortly after the birth of their child. Ms Gibbons told the inquest Mr Donald was under 'immense' stress, including financial, and struggled to get on top of his alcohol abuse. Eventually, Ms Gibbons and her daughter were constantly relocating to escape the environment. 'Were you effectively homeless?' NT Coroner Elisabeth Armitage asked her. 'Yes,' she replied. Set for five days, the inquest is expected to shed light on the circumstances leading up to the attempted murder-suicide and the measures which were taken to protect Ms Gibbons and her daughter. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
The Irish Sun
7 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Moment thug pulls out gun before shooting girl, 9, in head when she was caught in crossfire of botched gang hit
THIS is the moment a thug pulls out a gun before shooting an innocent nine-year-old girl in the head in a botched gang hit. The youngster was eating with her family inside the Turkish restaurant in Dalston, East London, when the horror unfolded. 5 A gunman opened fire on a restaurant - hitting a girl in the head Credit: PA 5 His getaway driver Javon Riley had a key role in the planning of the shooting Credit: PA Advertisement She was caught in the crossfire as six shots were fired in two seconds by a gunman on a Ducati Monster motorbike. The girl , who cannot be named, will be left with 'physical and cognitive difficulties throughout her life' after a bullet lodged in her brain. Javon Riley, 33, was today found guilty of attempting to murder three men and causing grievous bodily harm to the girl. The gunman has never been caught with cops offering a £15,000 reward for information that leads to his capture. Advertisement The Old Bailey heard the horror was a "planned assassination of members of a rival gang by Mr Riley and others'. A gruesome rivalry between two rival groups in London known as the Tottenham Turks and the Hackney Turks had been mounting for over a decade. In the months leading up to the shooting, Riley sat in the bar opposite Evin restaurant sipping on a pina colada as he studied traffic flow in the area. On May 29, 2024, he was captured driving from North London in a stolen car to pick up the gunman. Advertisement He then cruised past the restaurant several times to ensure his rivals from the Hackney Turks were inside. As the girl innocently tucked into some ice cream, the gunman was filmed approaching the building before pulling his gun out. He hit the girl in the head and blasted his enemies Mustafa Kiziltan, Kenan Aydogdu and Nasser Ali. The court heard while he did not fire the weapon, Riley played a key role in orchestrating and implementing a plan intended to end the lives of his rival gangsters. The girl was rushed to hospital where she underwent several intensive operations. Advertisement Several parts of her skull had to be removed to ease swelling to her brain and replaced with a titanium plate. She had to stay in hospital for three months before being allowed to return home. While the youngster has made "a relatively good recovery", she will struggle physically and mentally for the rest of her life. Her mum said: "In a single moment, the future we had imagined for our daughter was torn away. She was once an energetic, adventurous child — everything that celebrated movement, energy, and life. "Now, weakness on her left side means she can only watch from the sidelines, living with a titanium plate in her skull and a bullet still in her brain. Advertisement "As parents, we are shattered — emotionally, physically, mentally, and financially. Each day brings new challenges, from her slower growth on one side to the emotional and mental scars that cannot be seen. "The world we once believed was safe for our child now feels frightening and uncertain. This was not just an accident — even if our daughter was not the intended target, those responsible were still attempting to take lives, It is brutal and inhumane. "We live with this pain every day, knowing nothing will ever be the same for our family." Riley will be sentenced on September 12. 5 Riley picked up his accomplice in a stolen car Credit: PA Advertisement 5 The girl was shot as she ate with her family Credit: Paul Edwards
Irish Independent
8 hours ago
- Irish Independent
‘Intoxicated' rugby player in England banned for 28 weeks after telling female referee to ‘get your baps out'
Casey Johnson, an Ossett player since the Covid pandemic, admitted the incident, which took place during a match this year, with a Rugby Football Union panel finding him guilty of conduct prejudicial to the interests of the union and the game in a hearing in June. The panel found that the severity of the incident − 'the phrase was abhorrent and highly offensive' − made it a 'top end' offence and initially imposed a ban of 42 weeks on Johnson, who said that he was 'intoxicated' at the time and 'had no real explanation for why he shouted the phrase at the match official'. The referee, whose identity is kept anonymous in the written verdict, described how she had been 'shocked' at the verbal tirade and how her parents, who were among the crowd and heard the remarks, were 'heartbroken and angry'. Johnson's subsequent remorse and his acceptance of the charge 'at the earliest opportunity', with a clean disciplinary record, meant that the panel reduced the suspension to 28 weeks. The panel noted how Johnson 'appreciated at the time that what he had said was inappropriate and had intended to apologise to the match official at the end of the game but was advised by friends not to do so given his intoxicated state'. Johnson, who was described as a 'positive influence' by a committee member at Ossett, was also forced to pay £125 in costs. Although Johnson admitted shouting 'get your baps out, ref' from the touchline during the set-up of a line-out, he denied adding 'show us your boobs'. However, the panel were content that 'made no difference to the appropriate sanction'. The panel added: 'It goes without saying that such a phrase shouted to a woman has no place in society, including rugby, and it plainly goes against rugby's core values. It has the very real potential to impact on the participation of women in rugby (whether as match official, player, coach or spectator) and cannot and must not be tolerated.' Johnson received a suspension 'from playing, coaching and spectating from 1st August 2025 to 13th March 2026', which does not include midweek training. The panel added how the referee 'handled the situation impeccably' and how 'her ability to continue to referee the game and deal with the aftermath of the incident [has been] hugely impressive'. In her written testimony, the referee praised the response of both clubs in identifying Johnson and taking swift action. 'I was approached by the Ossett coach after the game who told me that he had been made aware by my dad during the game of the nature of the comments that were being made,' she wrote. 'The coach profusely apologised and informed me that they had sent someone over during the game to speak to the spectators. After the game as I was walking to the changing rooms I was approached by the spectators' friends who apologised on his behalf... and also apologised to both of my parents at the end of the match. 'Once changed, I entered the clubhouse and approached the Ossett coach to get the name of the spectator. The coach returned two minutes later with their head coach, who had been watching the game, and the spectator's name. The head coach apologised on behalf of the spectator and the club and condemned the spectator's behaviour and called it unacceptable, 'disgusting', and assured me it did not represent the values of the club. 'Whilst I don't condone what happened, and I wouldn't wish it upon any match official, I am glad that what started off as an uncomfortable and negative experience was made significantly better with the reactions and support that I've received both post-match and from people within the refereeing community.' In conclusion, the panel also acknowledged and commended the approach taken by both clubs. 'Female participation in rugby (whether playing, coaching, refereeing or spectating) is fundamental to the values of rugby union and a vital element of the game,' the panel wrote. 'That participation is put at risk by actions such as those of [Johnson] here and it is the responsibility of everyone involved in rugby to take whatever steps are necessary to ensure that such actions are removed from the game.'
