Cops who Tasered & pepper-sprayed amputee, 92, three weeks before his death are CLEARED of assault
TWO cops who pepper-sprayed and Tasered a 92-year-old amputee just weeks before his death have been cleared of assault.
Bodycam footage showed Donald Burgess
horror
at Park Beck Residential Care Home in St Leonards-on-Sea, East Sussex.
8
Donald Burgess was pepper sprayed and Tasered at a care home, jurors heard
Credit: SUSSEX NEWS AND PICTURES
8
He died in hospital three weeks later from Covid
Credit: PA
8
PC Stephen Smith and PC Rachel Comotto have been cleared of assault
Credit: PA
PC Rachel Comotto and PC Stephen Smith were called to the residence after Donald poked a worker in the stomach with a butter knife.
Smith claimed he did not know the one-legged pensioner was disabled - despite him sitting in a wheelchair - while Comotto denied she was "trigger-happy".
The pair have now been found cleared of assault occasioning actual bodily harm following a trial.
Southwark Crown
Court
heard one minute and 23 seconds elapsed between the cops arriving and Donald being Tasered.
Bodycam showed him clutching a specially adapted butter knife while sat in his wheelchair when Smith and Comotto entered his room.
PC Smith can be heard saying: 'Put it down mate. Come on, Donald, don't be silly.
"We can solve it without having to resort to this...Do as you're told."
He then "emptied all or almost all of his canister" of pepper spray in Donald's face, the court was told.
Most read in The Sun
The footage also showed Smith making his way towards the pensioner with his baton extended before striking him.
Comotto then deploys her 50,000-volt Taser as Donald screams out in pain before the officers took the knife from him.
After shooting him, PC Comotto asked Donald how he was feeling, leading him to reply: "I'm dying, I'm dying."
The officers were later seen joking about the shocking incident, jurors heard.
8
Donald was first pepper sprayed by Smith
Credit: SUSSEX NEWS AND PICTURES
8
Smith then got his baton out and struck Donald, who was still holding the knife
Credit: SUSSEX NEWS AND PICTURES
8
The butter knife had been specially adapted for the pensioner
In separate bodycam, Comotto is seen laughing and asking Smith: "Oh my God, is there any left in your can?"
Smith replies: "Probably not."
The court heard Donald suffered from multiple health conditions including diabetes and carotid artery disease.
He was taken to hospital after the incident and died 22 days later after contracting Covid.
The court was told the pair were "not responsible for his death".
Police had been called to the care home on June 21, 2022, after Donald was seen poking a care worker in the stomach with a knife after flicking food at her.
He threatened staff with the blade and told them he would take pleasure in murdering them.
Managers wheeled him back to his room and tried for 30 minutes to calm him down before calling 999.
The officers were dispatched under a grade one call, meaning it was treated as the highest level of emergency.
Jurors were told the care home specialised in support for people with dementia but Donald had not been diagnosed with the disease.
Prosecutor Paul Jarvis KC said it "ought to have been obvious by the fact he had one leg that this was a man who wasn't going to be mobile".
He added: "This was an elderly, vulnerable man who may not have understood what was going on.
"Rather than being met with understanding and sympathy, he was confronted by irritation and annoyance on the part of the defendants."
But in their defence, the officers claimed Donald was clutching the knife with a "tight grip".
Read more on the Irish Sun
Smith also said he only realised the pensioner was in a wheelchair after he was wheeled out following the incident.
He denied two counts of assault by using Pava spray and a baton, while Comotto denied one charge of assault by discharging her Taser.
8
Comotto pleaded not guilty to one charge of assault
Credit: PA
8
She and Smith both stood trial at Southwark Crown Court
Credit: PA
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
I'm terrified Maddie suspect Christian Brueckner will hunt me down after he's freed from prison, says rape survivor
RAPE survivor Hazel Behan fears Madeleine McCann suspect Christian Brueckner will 'hunt me down' after his prison release. Brueckner, 47, is due to be 4 Rape survivor Hazel Behan tells her story Credit: Dan Charity 4 Convicted paedophile Christian Brueckner is due to be freed from a German jail in September Credit: Paul Edwards 4 Officers travelled to Germany for a search of derelict farms in Praia da Luz Credit: Dan Charity And Hazel, who has waived her right to anonymity, said: 'His sentence may be ending but mine never did. I have lived with fear every day for 21 years. "Fear that I'll see him. Fear that he'll find out where I live and hunt me down. I also have fear that he'll do to someone else what he did to me. 'I've called him out in a public forum and I have genuine concern he could confront me. "I wouldn't put anything past a person like him. If he is released, I will worry for every woman and child who, like me, believes the justice system is protecting them. "A leopard doesn't change his spots.' His expected release from his current conviction comes a month before Hazel will discover the outcome of her High Court appeal in Although Judge Uta Engemann described the Dublin woman as a 'credible witness' and said 'we have no doubt something bad happened to her', she added there was not enough evidence to Hazel went on: 'I am a survivor of sexual assault and rape — a title I never asked for, but one I have carried with me every day for almost 21 years. "If he is released in September, he can go anywhere he wants. The police can only get involved in protecting me if he comes into my garden. Madeleine McCann cops call off search as trawl of Brueckner's 'rat run' turns up nothing 'I think of every survivor who never got to speak, and every woman who might become the next me. "The system may be ready to let him go, but I'm not. And neither is the wider society that deserves to feel safe.' The 41-year-old added: 'I have no doubt this predator is capable of anything "Age doesn't matter to him. It is about power and control for him and this won't have changed once he is out of prison. 'He has drifted across many countries over the years and targeted women and children of all ages. What's to stop him coming to Ireland and coming after me again? 'There have been reports he had plastic surgery and although his appearance is known, he could easily live underground and adapt a new identity and appearance. 'He is part of a world where people know how to stay hidden before they commit horrific levels of violence against women and kids.' Authorities in 4 Three-year-old Madeleine McCann disappeared in 2007 Credit: PA Last week, officers travelled to Germany for a Despite his denial of any involvement, cops carried out the extensive hunt in the hope of finding a shred of evidence to link him to Madeleine — and to keep him behind bars. Hazel hopes if And she said: 'It took the German BKA to restore my faith in the police as my experience with the Portuguese was horrendous, to put it mildly. 'I believe the BKA are doing a stellar job and working very hard to bring justice to those believed to be victims of Christian B.' Former holiday rep Hazel also spoke of her ongoing trauma, adding: 'On the 16th of June 2004, 21 years ago, my life changed forever. Face behind the mask 'The man who raped me took more than my sense of safety — he murdered my spirit and crushed my soul. He destroyed all the little parts of me that made me, me. 'He took my trust, my voice, and for a long time, my ability to live freely in the world. 'Since then, I have worked tirelessly to reclaim those pieces of myself. But no matter how much therapy I go through, how much time passes, some scars don't fade.' Hazel also expressed her sympathy and support for the Leicestershire-based family of Madeleine. She said: ' As a parent, I cannot begin to imagine what they have gone through and continue to go through every day for the past 18 years.' On her fight for justice, she said: 'On the 3rd of June 2020, following 16 years of getting to know this 'new me', I was once again thrown back to 2004 — only this time, I was made aware of the face behind the mask. Facing the man I believed completely destroyed my life in court is one of the most difficult things I have willingly ever had to do. Hazel Behan "I grappled with whether I had the mental strength to highlight myself to the relevant authorities as a potential victim, but I knew, deep down, if I didn't, I would always regret it. 'The following four years were unimaginably tough for me and my family and nothing could have prepared me for what lay ahead. "Facing the man I believed completely destroyed my life in court is one of the most difficult things I have willingly ever had to do.' She has also taken a case to the European Court of Human Rights over what her lawyer called the 'systematic and inexcusable failings by the Portuguese authorities that has denied her, and others, justice'. FIEND 'CASH-IN' SEX beast Christian Brueckner is said to be preparing to 'cash in' on his infamy by signing up for TV and book deals when he is released. The rapist and paedophile is set to be released from jail in September. Sources in Germany claim he will be desperate for money once out — and will face no shortage of offers to make money from his notoriety. One said: 'Brueckner is awaited by many members of the media and could be paid well for going onto talk shows, which will offer him a platform to tell his version of the 'injustice' done to him.' He has already maintained his innocence in interviews from jail, also telling German broadcaster RTL of his cravings for steak and beer.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Notts knife attack victim's mum slams ‘shameful' BBC for failing to apologise for chat with killer's family
A NOTTINGHAM knife victim's mum says it is 'shameful' BBC's Panorama has still not apologised ten months after airing interviews with the killer's family. 5 Emma Webber, mother of Barnaby Webber, has still not relieved an apology from the BBC Credit: The Times 5 Barney Webber was murdered by Valdo Calocane in Nottingham in June 2023 Credit: PA The BBC's complaints unit later said it would get a response within 35 days. But six months on, the families have had nothing — so have gone to boss Tim Davie. Emma said: 'It's exhausting, draining and shameful we have to escalate our concerns to the very top to get a response.' read more on bbc The families complained that Panorama's The Nottingham Attacks: A Search for Answers contained 'serious inaccuracies and omissions'. They also said the report — about The BBC yesterday apologised for the delay. Calocane killed Emma's student son Most read in The Sun The schizophrenic got The 11 deadly blunders that left Valdo Calocane free to kill as Nottingham victims' parents say cops have blood on hands 5 Calocane's family were interviewed for Panorama's The Nottingham Attacks: A Search for Answers Credit: PA 5 Grace O'Malley- Kumar was killed by Calocane while out with Webber Credit: PA 5 Caretaker Ian Coates was killed by Calocane during his horrific rampage Credit: PA
Sunday World
5 hours ago
- Sunday World
Judge tells man whose partner died after festival drug use it is ‘one of the saddest cases'
The court heard that Mr Carroll and his girlfriend had attended the Forbidden Fruit festival on June 2, 2024, where they both consumed drugs A 24-year-old man whose partner died after they both took drugs following a music festival has avoided a conviction for simple possession, in what a judge described as "one of the saddest cases" to come before his court. The District Court was told that the defendant Brian Carroll has now made a commitment to living a "drug-free life". Mr Carroll, of Cedarmount Road, Mount Merrion, Co Dublin pleaded guilty to possession of MDMA and cannabis and appeared before Judge Conor Fottrell at Dún Laoghaire District Court on Wednesday. Stock image News in 90 Seconds - 7th June The court heard that Mr Carroll and his girlfriend had attended the Forbidden Fruit festival on June 2, 2024, where they both consumed drugs, while further substances were taken later at a house in south Dublin. The woman was found unresponsive later that night and died as a result. Mr Carroll had been in a relationship with the deceased for two and a half years. Gardaí who carried out a search of the house recovered cannabis worth €44, €16 of MDMA and a small quantity of cocaine. Garda Harry Poole told the court that the drugs were for personal use and were at the lower end of the scale. The court heard that Mr Carroll later voluntarily attended a garda station, gave a full account of what occurred and has not come to garda attention since. Judge Fottrell initially questioned whether the District Court had jurisdiction to hear the case, given the serious background circumstances. 'I appreciate the plea before the court today, but this is a serious matter,' he said. 'I'm not sure it's a District Court matter.' Defence solicitor Mark O'Sullivan said it was a tragic accident and argued that the case before the court concerned a minor possession matter. 'That's all the court is being asked to hear today,' he said. After considering the details, Judge Fottrell accepted jurisdiction. 'On the basis of what's before me, the circumstances are tragic. I'll accept jurisdiction.' Mr O'Sullivan told the court that Mr Carroll and the deceased had bought the drugs together, but the woman had taken more than his client. He said his client was fully cooperative, had no previous convictions, and had voluntarily presented himself to Gardaí. Letters were handed into court from Kilmacud Medical Centre and the Community Addiction Response Programme. The court heard Mr Carroll had engaged in trauma counselling following the incident, tested negative for drugs in recent months and remained in full-time employment. He had also volunteered with Little Flower Penny Dinners during the Covid-19 pandemic. The woman's father and sister were present in court. 'On behalf of my client, I extend our sympathies to the family,' Mr O'Sullivan said. 'Relations remain good between them. This was an absolute tragedy.' In a personal letter to the court, the man expressed remorse and a commitment to living a drug-free life. Judge Fottrell acknowledged the man's remorse, the steps he had taken since and the tragic nature of the case. 'This is a tragic case,' he said. 'The consequences were anything but minor. However, the value of the drugs involved is low, and there are no previous convictions". 'You've pleaded guilty, made full admissions, and taken meaningful steps since. I don't propose to impose a conviction. "This is one of the most unusual and saddest cases to come before the court. I hope you continue your recovery," the judge said, addressing the defendant. Judge Fottrell concluded the matter without a conviction, following a €1,000 charitable donation. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.
