
Brothers and sister of £18million health drinks tycoon win bid to battle his Maltese lover for a share of his fortune
The siblings of a multimillionaire British tycoon who made his fortune flogging health drinks have won the right to take his Maltese partner to court in a bitter battle over his £18million estate.
Alan Lorenz, a former London divorce lawyer who gave up his legal career in the 1980s to join controversial weight-loss brand Herbalife, died in 2021 aged 78, leaving his entire fortune to his much-younger partner Sheila Caruana.
But his brothers and sister – Robert Lorenz, 81, Anthony Lorenz, 77, and Vanessa Manasseh, 79 – insist he had promised them a share of the fortune and have now successfully appealed to have their claim reinstated after it was thrown out in the High Court.
The Court of Appeal ruling clears the way for a full trial, where the siblings will argue that Alan created a 'secret trust' shortly before his death, asking Sheila to 'do right' by his family and divide his fortune with them – something she now denies.
Charterhouse-educated Mr Lorenz built up an empire through Herbalife, the controversial US-founded direct-selling giant known for its nutritional shakes. He joined the firm in 1984, quickly climbing the ranks to become a senior member.
By the time of his death, Mr Lorenz had amassed a sprawling £18million estate, including a £4million Mayfair townhouse, a luxury £3.5million villa in Malta, £8.8million in cash and £2.1million in Herbalife-related assets.
He began his relationship with Sheila, now 59, around 2012. But with a 23-year age gap between them, the court heard that Mr Lorenz had been increasingly focused on tax planning in his later years.
Although earlier wills had left his siblings a share of his fortune, in 2020 he drew up a new one, leaving everything to Sheila.
The couple then entered a civil partnership shortly before his death, meaning she would not be liable for inheritance tax on his estate.
Robert, backed by his brother and sister, brought a claim to court arguing that Alan – who they said had 'a history of aggressive tax avoidance and indeed an abhorrence of paying tax' – had entered into the civil partnership and revised his will only as part of a scheme to shelter his wealth, with the understanding Sheila would later pass half on to his family.
They told judges he had assured them this would happen, and that he believed Sheila was '100 percent honourable' and would follow his wishes.
'Alan had a long-settled intention to benefit his siblings,' Robert said, claiming his brother was 'willing to enter into arrangements where the relevant authorities would or might be deceived as to the real purpose or effect of the transactions.'
A solicitors' note at the time reportedly stated that Sheila would 'sort out his family in due course', and that Alan had personally told each of his siblings that this was the plan.
Sheila, however, flatly denied any such understanding, saying: 'At no time did he say that there would be any restrictions on my use of the assets. Neither did he give me instructions to deal with the assets he was leaving in a particular way.'
The case was first brought to court in December 2023, when a judge refused Sheila's bid to have Robert's claim thrown out.
But it was dismissed last June in the High Court by Mrs Justice Joanna Smith, who ruled there was no realistic chance of proving a trust existed or of identifying which property it covered.
She described the siblings' claim as amounting to 'little more than submitting that something may turn up at trial.'
But last week, Lord Justice Zacaroli overturned the decision, ruling there was enough to warrant a full trial and allowing the siblings' claim to proceed.
He noted that the only evidence from Sheila so far was a 'short passage' in her statement claiming Alan had not given her any specific instructions about his wealth.
He continued: 'There has as yet been no disclosure from Sheila, there is scope for making requests for further information, and there may well be evidence from the authors of the attendance notes.
'If Sheila chooses to give no further evidence herself, then - while not underestimating the hurdle that Robert's case would need to overcome at trial - it may be possible to draw inferences from her failure to do so.
'If she does give evidence, then there is material in the contemporaneous documents which could realistically form the basis of cross-examination.'
He said there is a 'real prospect' that evidence at trial might 'fill the gaps' in the case as to what property the alleged trust was dealing with and who the beneficiaries are.
'The only person who can speak to what Alan actually said is Sheila, and there is at least a potential inconsistency between her current witness statement and the contemporaneous documents as to whether any instructions at all were given to her,' he said.
He overturned the decision to throw out Robert's claim, with Mr Justice Cobb and Lord Justice Stuart-Smith agreeing.
The case will now go forward for a full High Court trial unless settled beforehand.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Sun
21 minutes ago
- The Sun
The best jobs that allow you to retire early and how you could boost your pension pot to £345k
EVERYONE dreams of escaping the daily grind early and retiring - but what jobs will help you do that as quickly as possible? Here, we reveal the top roles to get the best paid pension and the employers offering more to make you richer in retirement. It might be tempting to choose a job based on salary alone, but it's important not to overlook how it will affect you when you retire. While private sector jobs tend to offer more flexibility and a higher salary, public sector jobs typically offer more generous "defined benefit" or "final salary" pension schemes. These schemes guarantee an income that rises with inflation, making them a "gold-plated" option rarely found in the private sector. In the private sector, you'll likely have a "defined contribution" scheme, where your retirement income depends on contributions and investment performance. Auto-enrolment requires at least 8% of your salary (5% from you, 3% from your employer) to go into a pension fund, and the government adds to this through tax relief. For basic-rate taxpayers, every £80 contributed becomes £100. Although defined contribution schemes may seem less appealing, starting early and maximising contributions can build a substantial retirement fund. According to the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association, a single person needs £13,400 per year for a basic retirement, while a couple requires £21,600. Craig Rickman, pensions expert at interactive investor (ii), said: "Don't overlook pensions when job hunting. "Even though it might not seem like extra cash in your pocket right now, an attractive workplace pension means you don't have to save as much personally every month to retire comfortably. "That's why it's vital to engage with your workplace pension at the earliest opportunity." Kings Speech 2024 reveals huge pensions shake-up that could add over £11,000 to retirement pots Below we reveal the best jobs in the public and private sector to help you build your pension pot and boost your chances of retiring early. Top jobs for solid pension pots Town planners have some of the most generous pension pots. For example, someone earning £30,000 a year from the age of 30 could retire with an annual pension of £41,400 through the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS), according to ii. The LGPS works by adding a small portion of your salary - 1/49th - into your pension pot each year. This amount grows over time in line with inflation, helping it keep its value. Boost your pot by £354,000 RETIREMENT expert Helen Morrissey, head of retirement analysis at Hargreaves Lansdown, shares how to maximise your pension savings. She said: "Small changes can make big differences to your pension." "And increasing your contributions beyond auto-enrolment minimums can make a huge impact over time. "The amount you contribute now will directly impact how much money you have when you decide to retire, typically around age 68. "For example, if someone starts saving at age 21 and continues until age 68, with a starting salary of £25,000 per year and an investment growth of 5% per year after fees, they could save around £236,000 by retirement. "This assumes they contribute 5% of their salary, and their employer adds an additional 3%." "If you increase your contribution to 10%, with your boss still adding 3%, you could boost your savings to roughly £384,000. "But what if your boss is feeling generous? "A more substantial contribution from your employer can significantly boost your retirement savings. "For example, If you save 5% of your salary and your boss matches that with another 5%, your pension could reach approximately £295,000 by the time you retire. "Even better, if both you and your boss contribute a hefty 10% of your salary each, you could be looking at a substantial pension pot of around £590,000. "It really pays to find out what your employer's policy is on pension contributions – it could make a massive difference to your future." Meanwhile, armed forces personnel don't have to pay into their pensions at all, as the Ministry of Defence contributes on their behalf, adding 1/47th of their salary each year and adjusting it for inflation. The standard pension age is 60, but those who serve for at least 20 years and leave after age 40 can benefit from the Early Departure Payment (EDP) scheme, which provides a tax-free lump sum and monthly income. For example, a sergeant retiring as a major could receive a pension of around £32,000 a year. Plus, teachers can build a pension of roughly £25,700 a year after 40 years of service on a £60,000 salary, plus a £170,000 if they tax a one-off tax-free lump sum, according to ii. Tax inspectors in the Civil Service Alpha scheme could receive £23,600 a year on a £36,100 salary. The Civil Service Alpha pension scheme is a 'career average' defined benefit scheme where you build up an annual pension based on 2.32% of your pensionable earnings each year, adjusted for inflation Police officers can retire after 30 years with about £22,000 annually. Firefighters retiring at 60 might get £20,000 to £29,000 a year, depending on service length. NHS workers build pensions based on 1/54th of their salary each year, offering strong retirement income. Museum curators in public roles could get £15,000 a year after 30 years, earning £30,000 annually. I tracked down lost pension and boosted my pot by £5,000 KATHERINE Brant was one of millions who lost track of an old pension pot – a common problem in the UK, where 4.8 million pots are "missing, Each time you start a new job you start a new pension, which can leave you with several pots of cash that are easily forgotten about. On average, employees lose sight of pots worth £10,000. As an assistant manager at a charity shop in Lincoln, Katherine, 32, realised she had no idea where her old pensions were, fearing that the savings from her previous jobs might be lost forever. Determined to take action, she decided to get on top of her pension planning during the pandemic. "I only had a very basic understanding of how pensions worked, but I knew I must have old pots knocking around somewhere that I'd completely lost," she said. Her search led her to Moneybox, an app designed to help people locate and consolidate their pension pots. Unsure of what to expect, Katherine signed up and provided her details. What followed was life-changing. The app helped her uncover a forgotten £2,000 pension pot, which has since grown to £5,000, significantly boosting her retirement savings. With decades left before retirement, Katherine now has plenty of time to grow her savings even further. "Finding this extra money feels life-changing—I had no idea it was even there," she said. If you're looking to track down a lost pension pot, you can also use the government's Pension Tracing Service by visiting Top jobs in the private sector Some private sector companies offer generous contribution rates to employees. The financial services industry tends to be a good place to start, with average employer contributions around 9.5%. For example, Unilever provides a benefits package equal to 25% of your salary. If you earn £40,000, this means £10,000. You can decide how to use it - put it all into your pension, take some as extra pay, or split it, such as £8,000 for your pension and £2,000 as cash. Shell follows with a total pension contribution of 20% (5% from employees and 15% from the employer), which can rise to 27.5%. Legal & General combines a basic contribution with a matching scheme, allowing employees to potentially reach a total of 20%. Kingfisher, owner of B&Q and Screwfix, offers a sliding scale where employees contributing 8% or more receive 14% from the employer. Phoenix Group boosts salary sacrifice contributions, enabling employees to receive 14.2% while contributing only 2%. A salary sacrifice scheme is where you agree to reduce your gross salary in exchange for a non-cash benefit, like increased pension contributions. This reduces your taxable income and National Insurance contributions, potentially saving you money while boosting your benefits. Royal Mail contributes 13.3% to its Collective Defined Contribution scheme, with employees adding 6%. Tesco matches pension contributions up to 7.5%. INDUSTRY trade body The Pension and Lifetime Savings Association calculates how much a single person and a couple need to afford different levels of comfort in retirement. They factor in all household bills, groceries, travel and car costs, going away on holiday, clothes, beauty treatments and more, into the amount of money you need per year. There are three lifestyle levels - minimum, moderate and comfortable. Here's how much you need per year to afford them all. Basic retirement: A single person needs £13,400 annually for a basic retirement lifestyle, while a couple needs £21,600. This covers essential needs plus a few extras like a small holiday and monthly cheap meal out. Moderate retirement: A single person needs £31,700, while a couple needs £43,900. This covers one holiday abroad a year, eating out once a week, and budget for two or three weekly activities like going to the cinema or swimming. Comfortable retirement: A single person needs £43,900, while a two-person household needs £60,600. This includes a foreign holiday and several mini breaks a year, as well as beauty treatments and hair appointments every six weeks.


Auto Express
28 minutes ago
- Auto Express
Car Deal of the Day: family-size Skoda Enyaq EV going cheap at under £280 a month
SE L trim; 268-mile range Plush interior; spacious and practical Only £276.71 a month Skoda has taken a lot of what owners love about the Enyaq SUV to create the Elroq, albeit in a smaller, cuter package. But what if we told you that you could have the bigger, more spacious car for less than £2 extra month on lease? That's exactly the case on the Auto Express Find a Car service. GB Vehicle Leasing is offering the Enyaq for just £1.81 extra a month over the smaller Elroq (through a different broker), after a £3,620.50 initial payment is put down first. Advertisement - Article continues below Then it's £276.71 for a total of 48 months with a 5,000-mile-a-year cap; a 8,000-mile limit can be arranged for just £6.07 extra a month, meaning this deal could be perfect for those who need to travel further. That extra £1.81 will get you a car that offers considerably more interior space, with greater levels of head and legroom. You'll be able to carry more luggage and shopping bags, too, thanks to the Enyaq's 115-litre-larger boot. The Enyaq and smaller Elroq both travel around the same distance on a charge, with around 268 miles possible from the same 58kWh battery, claims Skoda. In the real world, both will offer between 200 and 250 miles. There's no difference in terms of spec between the Enyaq in this deal and the cheapest Elroq on a lease (from another broker) either, as both are in SE L trim. This nets you heated front seats and steering wheel, sat-nav, and that all-important umbrella in the driver's door. The Car Deal of the Day selections we make are taken from our own Auto Express Find A Car deals service, which includes the best current offers from car dealers and leasing companies around the UK. Terms and conditions apply, while prices and offers are subject to change and limited availability. If this deal expires, you can find more top Skoda Enyaq leasing offers from leading providers on our Skoda Enyaq hub page. Check out the Skoda Enyaq deal or take a look at our previous Car Deal of the Day selection here… Find a car with the experts Car Deal of the Day: A Volkswagen Golf R Estate for less than a GTI Car Deal of the Day: A Volkswagen Golf R Estate for less than a GTI The Golf R Estate is one of the best performance estates around – and right now it's criminally cheap. It's our Deal of the Day for 9 June. Should Citroen make a new 2CV? Some say oui, others say non Should Citroen make a new 2CV? Some say oui, others say non A new Citroen 2CV could be inbound, but would this be a French fancy or a financial flop? Avoid using car finance claim firms, says financial watchdog Avoid using car finance claim firms, says financial watchdog FCA warns that using a claim firm could see consumers lose up to 30 per cent of their winnings if car finance redress scheme is implemented


Telegraph
34 minutes ago
- Telegraph
BT plots TalkTalk takeover as cash crisis escalates
BT is plotting a rescue of TalkTalk as an escalating cash crisis threatens disruption in the broadband market. The former state monopoly is in the early stages of exploring a takeover of TalkTalk and its 3.2m customers, according to City sources. BT is considering a bid for Britain's fourth-largest broadband provider amid fears that its own business could be damaged by the tightening squeeze on TalkTalk's finances. TalkTalk, which is led by Sir Charles Dunstone, its founder, narrowly avoided collapse last year. Sir Charles and other shareholders were forced to pump £235m into the company to stave off the threat of insolvency. That deal provided some breathing space but TalkTalk remained saddled with £1.2bn of costly debt. The further deterioration of its business, as customers defect to rival broadband providers, has put it back under pressure within months. TalkTalk lost 400,000 customers last year. It ranked bottom of Ofcom's latest customer service rankings last month with a satisfaction score of 77pc. One of its listed bonds is now trading at 44p, suggesting uncertainty in the market over whether the company will be able to repay its debts. It was trading at 78p in the pound in late April. Customer exodus TalkTalk's challenges have begun to take a toll on BT's Openreach network division, which hosts the vast majority of TalkTalk's customers. Many of the customers switching away are opting for new challenger networks which have invested in their own fibre-optic networks rather than rented capacity from Openreach. Openreach lost almost a quarter of a million broadband customers in the first three months of the year, in part as a result of TalkTalk's decline. TalkTalk has also fallen behind on payments in recent months and Openreach has reportedly threatened to block the company from putting new customers on its network. Insiders stressed that internal discussions at BT were at an early stage and that a takeover bid had not yet been discussed with TalkTalk. The combined company would hold a market share of roughly 36pc, strengthening its hand against the fibre-optic challenger and expanding its Plusnet brand, which competes with TalkTalk at the value end of the market. However it would be likely to attract protests from rivals and scrutiny from competition regulators given BT already holds a dominant position in the broadband market. CityFibre, the largest of the fibre-optic challengers, hosts around 150,000 TalkTalk customers on its network. A lengthy investigation by the Competition and Markets Authority would raise the risk of further customer losses at TalkTalk that would dilute the appeal of a merger, City sources cautioned. BT executives are said to be hopeful of receiving support from Ofcom, which would be closely involved in a competition investigation. The telecoms regulator has been monitoring TalkTalk closely amid concern that a collapse could leave millions of customers in the lurch. Virgin Media O2 has also previously weighed up an approach for TalkTalk as it looks to build up its own wholesale broadband business. James Ratzer, an analyst at New Street Research, said BT was now a 'more likely acquirer' of TalkTalk than its competitors given the slowdown at Openreach and the potential benefits of a tie-up. He added: 'It would be an understatement to say that TalkTalk faces a difficult and uncertain future ... This is clearly an extremely high risk investment, but we now believe BT could enter the fray in some potential form increasing the chance of a potential deal.' TalkTalk, which has been seeking a solution to its financial problems since splitting itself into three divisions in 2023, has been focusing on cost-cutting and asset sales to shore up its balance sheet. The Salford-based company cut 350 jobs last year as part of a wider plan to strip £120m out of the business. Further job losses are expected in the year ahead. It has also pared back marketing budgets. But the moves risk fuelling subscriber losses further and discontent over poor customer service.