OpenAI urges Delhi court to dismiss book publishers' copyright plea
This story incorporates reporting fromLive Law, inc42 and EconoTimes.OpenAI has filed a motion in an Indian court to dismiss a lawsuit brought by a coalition of book publishers. The publishers accuse the artificial intelligence company of violating copyright laws through its AI service, ChatGPT. The Delhi High Court is handling the case, which involves claims that ChatGPT reproduces book summaries and extracts from unlicensed copies, consequently impacting publishers' business operations. OpenAI, however, argues that its use of data falls within the realm of fair use, utilizing publicly available information to generate responses.
According to recent court documents filed on Jan.26, OpenAI argues that the publishers have not substantiated claims that ChatGPT relies on or uses original literary works to produce content. Instead, OpenAI states that its technology draws from existing resources on the internet that are already in the public domain. The AI firm emphasizes its adherence to fair use principles, arguing that there is no infringement involved in the operations of ChatGPT.
The Federation of Indian Publishers, which includes major global players like Penguin Random House and Bloomsbury, is spearheading the legal challenge against OpenAI. The lawsuit is part of broader global tensions where various parties — including authors, media outlets, and musicians — are alleging that AI technology providers use their work without appropriate permissions or licensing agreements.
OpenAI's legal challenges extend beyond the book publishing industry. News agency Asian News International (ANI) has also brought a similar lawsuit against OpenAI, asserting that ChatGPT verbatim reproduces its original news content. The Delhi High Court in a separate adjudication urged restraint from media in reporting details of the submissions made by the parties involved in this case. OpenAI has presented that these cases revolve around similar issues concerning the use of public data and insists on a need for clarity on what is considered fair use in the context of AI technologies.
The Federation of Indian Publishers previously filed an intervention application to support the aforementioned cases. However, OpenAI's legal representative, Sibal, has opposed this intervention, pointing out procedural flaws, including the Federation's failure to provide the necessary authorization for filing. Despite these legal hurdles, the publishers remain adamant about pursuing their claims, underscoring the potential ramifications on their business models due to emerging AI technologies.
The broader context of these legal proceedings indicates a growing conflict between traditional content creators and digital technology firms over copyright interpretations. The debate has significant implications for how intellectual property laws would adapt to integrate advancements in AI and digital information dissemination.
As the Delhi High Court proceedings evolve, the outcomes could set precedents not only for similar future litigations in India but also for global discussions on the intersection of AI and copyright laws. The results of these cases may influence whether AI firms could continue using vast datasets available online under the pretext of fair use or if stricter regulations and licensing would need enforcement. The industry closely observes intelligence in the decision, awaiting direction on balancing innovation with intellectual property rights.
Quartz Intelligence Newsroom uses generative artificial intelligence to report on business trends. This is the first phase of an experimental new version of reporting. While we strive for accuracy and timeliness, due to the experimental nature of this technology we cannot guarantee that we'll always be successful in that regard. If you see errors in this article, please let us know at qi@qz.com.
For the latest news, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Broadcom could blow past Nvidia, expert predicts
Broadcom could blow past Nvidia, expert predicts originally appeared on TheStreet. One of the tech sector's most dominant players just reported strong earnings for Q2 2025, beating Wall Street estimates. Broadcom () has performed well since the start of the year, recovering from some April volatility and demonstrating strong resilience. Now the multi-faceted tech company, known for producing custom silicon chips and infrastructure software products, looks well-positioned to continue rising. 💵💰💰💵 Despite all its success since the start of the artificial intelligence (AI) boom, Broadcom remains consistently overshadowed by Nvidia () , the chipmaking industry's undisputed leader. But as the company prepares to enter a new quarter, multiple investing experts have flagged it as a likely winner in the coming year. For months, AI investors have wondered when and if Broadcom can step out of its rival's shadow and establish itself as a market leader. Now, two financial experts believe that day may be approaching. Earlier this week, TheStreet's Charley Blaine predicted that Broadcom's earnings could produce shock and awe, urging investors not to dismiss the stock's year-to-date (YTD) performance. Now the company has posted them, coming in above Wall Street estimates on earnings-per-share (EPS) and issuing strong revenue shows progress from the chipmaker as it maneuvers to stay ahead in a highly volatile market and compete with other semiconductor producers. Many companies have found it difficult to hold their own against Nvidia, primarily due to the company's popularity among hyperscalers, firms that provide cloud services or large-scale data centers. Freedom Capital Markets Chief Global Strategist Jay Woods recently addressed Broadcom's prospects, though, noting that Nvidia hasn't been able to lead the industry in the way that investors need. As he sees it, this may create a key opportunity for Broadcom. 'The semiconductor company has grown mightily in Nvidia's shadows for years now,' he states. 'Shares have rallied just over 500% from its 2022 lows, which pales [in comparison] to the 1250+% rally in Nvidia. However, over the past 52 weeks, AVGO shares are leading up 84% compared to Nvidia's 15% gain.' Woods adds that Broadcom is 'basically Nvidia's baby brother,' with a slightly lower trillion-dollar market cap and a place in exchange-traded funds (ETFs) such as the VanEck Semiconductor ETF SMH and the Technology Sector ETF XLK, as well as the Nasdaq 100 index. He notes that following Nvidia's earnings, Broadcom has an opportunity to step out of the larger chipmaker's shadow and lead semiconductor stocks higher. However, the strategist adds that many large-cap tech stocks have struggled to reach new highs lately, citing Microsoft () as a key example. More Tech Stocks News: Veteran trader turns heads with Netflix comments Tempus AI hits back at scathing short report Salesforce makes a big bet on booming tech market While AVGO stock has dipped slightly since the recent earnings report, the company's leaders seem convinced that AI demand will help it continue growing. 'We continue to make excellent progress on the multiyear journey of enabling our three customers and four prospects to deploy custom AI accelerators,' states CEO Hock Tan. Following the Broadcom earnings, Wall Street sentiment toward AVGO stock has only improved. BofA Securities analyst Vivek Arya recently raised his price target to $300 per share, urging investors to focus on the company AI's surge rather than speculation based on quarterly results.'We rate Broadcom Buy due to its high-quality diversified exposure to secular product cycles in the smartphone, cloud data center, telecom, and enterprise storage markets,' Arya states. 'Additionally, with 45%+ EBITDA/FCF margins, Broadcom is among the most profitable semiconductor companies, which is likely to continue to drive strong cash returns.' His firm isn't the only one that remains bullish on Broadcom. Seaport Research reiterated a Buy rating on AVGO on June 4, citing the company's new Tomahawk 6 as a likely growth catalyst. The company describes this new AI chip as a 'turning point in AI infrastructure design,' highlighting unprecedented demand from both its customers and partners. Laffer Tengler Investments CEO Nancy Tengler also highlights this as a likely step forward, highlighting it as 'another example of staying on the forefront of innovation.' She adds that in her firm's opinion, AVGO stock's valuation is full but still fair, even after its recent could blow past Nvidia, expert predicts first appeared on TheStreet on Jun 7, 2025 This story was originally reported by TheStreet on Jun 7, 2025, where it first appeared. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Trump and Musk's AI Alliance Revealed in Shocking New Briefing
BALTIMORE, June 07, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- James Altucher uncovers secret AI facility that could cement U.S. dominance — and it all began with Trump's first move back in office. In a recent public briefing, bestselling author and tech entrepreneur James Altucher exposed what he describes as the real story behind President Trump's first executive reversal — and its direct link to a classified AI superproject now underway in Tennessee. According to Altucher, Trump's repeal of Biden's executive AI order didn't just lift regulations — it cleared the way for Elon Musk to quietly launch Project Colossus, a private supercomputer that now rivals anything built by Big Tech or the Pentagon. Trump's First Move — Musk's Fastest Machine 'In one of his FIRST acts as President… Donald Trump overturned Executive Order #14110.' Altucher says this maneuver gave developers like Musk 'full speed ahead' to build without delay — and Musk wasted no time. 'Right here, inside this warehouse in Memphis, Tennessee… lies a massive supercomputer Musk calls 'Project Colossus.'' The system, according to Altucher, is now operational and powered by over 200,000 AI chips — with more upgrades on the way before July 1. A New Tech Doctrine Altucher argues that Trump's return marks more than a change in leadership — it marks a shift in philosophy: from AI safety to AI supremacy. 'Trump also announced the LARGEST AI investment in history… Stargate… a massive, AI data center and infrastructure project with an estimated $500 billion price tag.' He believes this signals a strategic effort to make America the global leader in next-generation technology — not through bureaucracies, but through Musk-led private innovation. Musk Builds the Machine, Trump Clears the Way Altucher refers to the pairing as 'the most powerful alliance in tech history' — and warns that what they're building isn't just software. 'This second wave of ARTIFICIAL SUPERINTELLIGENCE… Will rival all of the great innovations of the past. Electricity… the wheel… even the discovery of fire.' He says what happens next could reshape the balance of power — both at home and abroad. About James Altucher James Altucher is a computer scientist, author, and entrepreneur. He studied AI at Cornell and Carnegie Mellon, worked on IBM's Deep Blue supercomputer, and pioneered AI-powered market systems. His latest work tracks the hidden forces shaping the next generation of American technology and policy. Media Contact:Derek WarrenPublic Relations ManagerParadigm Press GroupEmail: dwarren@ in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Godfather of AI Alarmed as Advanced Systems Quickly Learning to Lie, Deceive, Blackmail and Hack
A key artificial intelligence pioneer is concerned by the technology's growing propensity to lie and deceive — and he's founding his own nonprofit to curb such behavior. In a blog post announcing LawZero, the new nonprofit venture, "AI godfather" Yoshua Bengio said that he has grown "deeply concerned" as AI models become ever more powerful and deceptive. "This organization has been created in response to evidence that today's frontier AI models have growing dangerous capabilities and [behaviors]," the world's most-cited computer scientist wrote, "including deception, cheating, lying, hacking, self-preservation, and more generally, goal misalignment." Of all people, Bengio would know. In 2018, the founder of the Montreal Institute for Learning Algorithms (MILA) was presented with a Turing Award alongside fellow AI pioneers Yann LeCun and Geoffrey Hinton for their formative roles in machine learning research, and he was listed as one of Time magazine's "100 Most Influential People" in 2024 thanks to his outsize impact on the ever-accelerating technology. Despite the accolades, Bengio has repeatedly expressed regret over his role in bringing advanced AI technology — and its Silicon Valley hype cycle — to fruition. This latest missive seems to be his most stark to date. "I'm deeply concerned," the AI pioneer wrote in his blog post, "by the behaviors that unrestrained agentic AI systems are already beginning to exhibit." Bengio pointed to recent red-teaming experiments, or tests that push AI models to their limits to see how they'll act, showing that advanced systems have developed an uncanny tendency to keep themselves "alive" by any means necessary. Among his examples was a recent report from Anthropic detailing how its Claude 4 model, when told it would be shut down, threatened to blackmail an engineer with incriminating emails if they followed through. "These incidents," the decorated researcher wrote, "are early warning signs of the kinds of unintended and potentially dangerous strategies AI may pursue if left unchecked." To put such behavior in check, Bengio said that his new nonprofit is building a so-called "trustworthy" model, which he calls "Scientist AI," that is "trained to understand, explain and predict, like a selfless idealized and platonic scientist." "Instead of an actor trained to imitate or please people (including sociopaths), imagine an AI that is trained like a psychologist — more generally a scientist — who tries to understand us, including what can harm us," he explained. "The psychologist can study a sociopath without acting like one." A pre-peer-review paper Bengio and his colleagues published earlier this year explains it a bit more simply. "This system is designed to explain the world from observations," the paper reads, "as opposed to taking actions in it to imitate or please humans." The concept of building "safe" AI is far from new, of course — it's quite literally why several OpenAI researchers left OpenAI and founded Anthropic as a rival research lab. This one seems to be different because, unlike Anthropic, OpenAI, or any other companies that pay lip service to AI safety while still bringing in gobs of cash, Bengio's is a nonprofit — though that hasn't stopped him from raising $30 million from the likes of ex-Google CEO Eric Schmidt, among others. More on creepy AI: Advanced OpenAI Model Caught Sabotaging Code Intended to Shut It Down
