Pahalgam Attack Was On Country, Not Government: Javed Akhtar On Op Sindoor Delegations
Members of the opposition being part of the outreach delegations to various countries following Operation Sindoor is a welcome step because the Pahalgam terror attack was not carried out on the government, but India as a whole, noted lyricist and scriptwriter Javed Akhtar has said.
In an over 30-minute discussion at NDTV's Creators' Manch on Friday, Mr Akhtar also spoke about where the real power centre in Pakistan lies and the row over the casting of Pakistani actor Hania Amir in Diljit Dosanjh's film 'Sardaar Ji 3'.
Asked if including leaders like the Congress' Shashi Tharoor and AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi in the outreach delegations was a calculated move by the government, the lyricist said in Hindi, "The Pahalgam terror attack was not on the government, it was an attack on the country. So everyone in the country will go. Among the people (who were part of the delegations) are some who keep attacking the government. But when it comes to the country, we are all one... the other issues are internal ones and we will keep talking about them internally," the lyricist said.
Mr Akhtar said Mr Tharoor is very articulate and he was happy the Congress leader led one of the delegations, because he has diplomatic experience at the United Nations. "This is an issue that concerns the country, and that's when everyone is one. That is how it should be. This is not about a political party," he said.
On the relationship between India and Pakistan, Mr Akhtar said it feels like this is the worst phase because it is a fresh wound, but pointed out that the 1965 war and the Kargil war had also happened.
"Each time, the government in Pakistan tries to wash its hands of what's happening and claims it wasn't involved. In 1948, they said tribals had entered Kashmir; during the Kargil war, they said they did not know who had gone there. Similarly, in Pahalgam, they said they did not know anything about the attack. This is nothing new, it's what they do," he said.
'Not A Monolith'
The lyricist stressed, however, that no country is a monolith and crores of people in Pakistan want friendship with India, but this does not suit the country's government, army and right wing.
"It suits the common people there, and why won't it? India is such a big market, it has great universities, a rich culture... so young people from there will want to come here and work... in the entertainment industry and the corporate sphere. Businessmen would also want to collaborate with Indian businesses, how are all of them benefiting from strained ties? They only lose because of this," he said.
Mr Akhtar said even the US knows where the real power centre in Pakistan lies and that democracy in the country is a sham.
"Those who benefit are the right wing in Pakistan, because their existence depends on hatred for India and the country's army, because it'll have to stay in the barracks if there is no confrontation with India. Even when the American president wanted to talk to Pakistan, he could have spoken to the president or prime minister, but he knew where the real power lies, so he called their army chief Asim Munir. This made it clear that their democracy is a sham and the army rules the country. So, how will good relations with India suit them?" he pointed out.
The lyricist repeated that it would not be in India's interest to treat Pakistan as a monolith. Indians, he said, should encourage people in Pakistan who admire and love India.
Diljit Row
On the row over the casting of Pakistani actor Hania Amir in Diljit Dosanjh's 'Sardaar Ji 3', Mr Akhtar said it was pointless because the movie had been shot earlier. "How was he to know? Pakistan will not lose money (because of this), our countryman will... Laws can't be applied retrospectively... The Censor Board and the government should look at this sympathetically. They can say it shouldn't happen again," he suggested.
One way of bettering the relationship between the countries when things weren't as bad as they are now, the scriptwriter said, would have been for artistes from both sides to make movies with the involvement of the governments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
18 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Digambar Kamat and Ramesh Tawadkar — whose careers saw them in, out of, and back in BJP — sworn in as new Goa ministers
Former Goa chief minister Digambar Kamat and former Assembly Speaker Ramesh Tawadkar were sworn in Thursday as ministers in the Goa Cabinet. Governor Pusapati Ashok Gajapathi Raju administered the oath of office and secrecy to the BJP legislators at Raj Bhavan in the presence of Chief Minister Pramod Sawant. The Cabinet berth marks a political resurrection for Kamat, who was first elected as an MLA on a BJP ticket more than three decades ago in 1994. He later joined the Congress and was among the group of eight 'turncoat' MLAs who switched over to the BJP from the Congress in September 2022. He served as the chief minister of Goa from 2007 to 2012, the last Congress government in the state. Kamat said he got an opportunity to become a minister after a gap of 13 years. 'I am returning to the Cabinet after 13 years. I am happy that I will get the strength to work for the common man. This will allow me to work for the people and help strengthen the party. God, the central leadership, the chief minister and party colleagues…have given me this opportunity,' Kamat said. The seven-time MLA from Margao has oscillated between the Congress and the BJP in his political career. Kamat started his journey with the Congress. He joined the BJP in 1994 and won two elections as the party's candidate from the party and first became a minister in the Manohar Parrikar-led Cabinet in 2000. He returned to the Congress in 2005 and was instrumental in bringing down the Parrikar-led BJP government in 2005. In 2007, with opinion divided on whether to choose Ravi Naik or Pratapsingh Rane, the party finally named Kamat as the chief minister in the Congress-led coalition government. He remains the only chief minister in Goa to have completed a full five-year term. Along with then PWD minister Churchill Alemao, Kamat was booked under the Prevention of Corruption Act in a bribery case. Alemao was PWD minister from 2007 to 2012 when officials of the US-based company, Louis Berger, allegedly paid bribes to win a consultancy bid for water augmentation and a sewerage pipeline project in Goa under the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA). Kamat, who served as mining minister of the state for 10 years, was indicted by a judicial commission in 2012 for reportedly allowing illegal mining in the state. The Centre-appointed Commission of Inquiry, headed by Justice M B Shah, had estimated a loss of Rs 35,000 crore to the state exchequer. A Sessions Court in Goa discharged him and 16 others in the case in February this year. Earlier on Thursday morning, Canacona MLA Ramesh Tawadkar resigned as the Speaker of Goa Legislative Assembly. 'From the day I took the responsibility, I tried to do justice to the post [of Speaker]. I treated both the ruling and Opposition legislators as colleagues. I earned the respect from the Opposition, just as I earned it from the ruling side. I have a slight regret that I was not able to complete the full five-year term as the Speaker. I have to take this decision with a heavy heart since the party has given me a different responsibility with a view on the 2017 assembly elections,' said Tawadkar. Tawadkar first became a minister in the Parrikar-led Cabinet in 2012 and held Sports, Youth Affairs and Tribal Welfare portfolios. He quit the BJP after he was denied a ticket in 2017 Assembly elections and contested as an Independent. He returned to the BJP in 2019 and was elected as an MLA in 2022, after which he became the Speaker. BJP state president Damu Naik told The Indian Express, 'Tawadkar comes from the ST community and has been associated with the party for a long time and has worked at the grassroot level. Kamat was the chief minister. So, both are quite experienced. The decision has been made in order to strengthen the party as the state goes to polls in 2027.' Three BJP legislators – Calangute MLA Michael Lobo, Siolim MLA Delilah Lobo and former Art and Culture Minister Govind Gaude – were absent from the swearing-in ceremony. Gaude, a tribal leader, was dropped from the Cabinet after he levelled corruption allegations in the department of Tribal Welfare – a portfolio held by CM Sawant. Naik dismissed any suggestions of internal dissent, saying, 'They may have prior engagements.'
India Today
19 minutes ago
- India Today
BJP to hold protests against alleged conspirators targeting Dharmasthala temple
The BJP has announced statewide protests across all assembly constituencies in Karnataka for a week starting Friday, demanding swift action against alleged conspirators accused of trying to defame the Dharmasthala state president BY Vijayendra said the Congress government had failed to act against the alleged conspirators while being quick to act against Hindu workers. 'A party worker Poovappa, a Hindu worker, who is 81 years old, police went to their house at midnight and they took photos. Police are active when it comes to Hindu workers. When the Congress government is active in taking actions against those people, why haven't they taken any actions against the conspirators in the Dharamastala case?' he questioned. advertisementHe further added, 'It's not just BJP devotees all over Karnataka who are demanding action against this. Act immediately, and they should take serious action. So, BJP decided to carry out protests in every assembly constituency in Karnataka for next one week.' Raising the slogan 'Dharma Rakshanegagi Dharmayuddha', Vijayendra asserted that the party's demand was straightforward. 'Our demand is simple, the state government should take action immediately. Our stand is very clear, justice needs to be given to the family of Sowjanaya,' he the Special Investigation Team (SIT) inquiry into the case, Vijayendra said the BJP was not questioning the state government's decision to constitute it. 'As far as the investigation is concerned, we are not interfering in it. We are not questioning the state government's decision. Now after Minister Dinesh Gundu Rao, Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar made statements that there is conspiracy, now when there is a series of bad publicity and propaganda in social media, BJP as Opposition can't keep quiet,' he that the matter concerns religious faith, he added, 'We have to respect the temple and sentiments of devotees. So the demand is that the state government, without wasting any time, should act quickly, take action against those conspirators who are involved in this.'- EndsIN THIS STORY#Karnataka
Indian Express
19 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Congress & SP pushed country into crisis, served only their families: UP CM Yogi Adityanath
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath said on Thursday that the Congress and the Samajwadi Party pushed the country into an identity crisis after centuries of exploitation by the Mughals and British, and that the two never worked for inclusive development, serving only their own families. Speaking at the inauguration of a cement plant in Etah, Adityanath claimed that the district once synonymous with crime and mafia rule has now transformed into a hub of investment and industry. 'Eight-nine years ago, Etah was known for land encroachments, and the poor had no voice. Today, it is known for law and order, power generation and industrial growth,' he said. The Chief Minister said the nearby Jawaharpur thermal power plant generates 1,500 MW power, while Shree Cement's unit worth Rs 750 crore has created 500 direct jobs and more than 3,000 indirect employment opportunities. 'This investment is not only about jobs but also about strengthening of trade, transport and distribution networks — the real foundation of Atmanirbhar Bharat and Viksit Bharat. There was a time when even a commodity like cement was rationed and would be available only through connections, making house construction extremely difficult,' he said. 'How could development take place with such an intent and policies?' he asked. India, which was 11th in the world economy in 2014 due to the policies of the Congress and SP, has now risen to 4th place under PM Modi and is set to become the third-largest economy within two years, he claimed. Uttar Pradesh too, he said, has risen from the seventh-largest state economy in 2017 to the second-largest today, the CM added. He credited this economic turnaround to strict action against the mafia and rioters, which restored investors' confidence. 'UP has received investment proposals worth Rs 45 lakh crore, out of which Rs 15 lakh crore have already been executed, creating employment for 60 lakh youth,' he said. He added that 60,244 youth, including many from Etah, were recruited into the police force without any discrimination. Under the Mukhyamantri Yuva Yojana, 70,000 young entrepreneurs received interest- and guarantee-free loans to set up enterprises. The Chief Minister noted that 'bells and ghungroos' of Etah's Jalesar remain an integral part of worship and musical performances. The state is preparing a roadmap for Viksit Bharat by linking this cultural heritage with modern development, he said, adding: 'In the Legislative Assembly and Council, a 24-hour discussion was held on key sectors, and experts will now visit every district to train youth and prepare district-level roadmaps with public participation.' The state, he said, will honour every promise made under the industrial policy.
