logo
The Kanien'kehá:ka say a vast swath of Montreal's South Shore is theirs. They want their claim settled

The Kanien'kehá:ka say a vast swath of Montreal's South Shore is theirs. They want their claim settled

Yahoo02-07-2025
As development creeps closer to Kahnawà:ke's borders, Grand Chief Cody Diabo says the community near Montreal is fed up — watching homes and businesses get built on land they say has belonged to them for centuries, while a 345-year-old land grievance remains stalled in federal bureaucracy.
The Mohawk Council of Kahnawà:ke (MCK) launched an information campaign and a new website in the hopes of breathing new life into the land claim, known as the Seigneury of Sault St. Louis (SSSL) Land Grievance.
The area in question, about 97 square kilometres, extends beyond Kahnawà:ke's current borders and contains several municipalities across the Montérégie region on the South Shore.
"We have to right the wrongs from the past," said Diabo, adding that he's not settling for less than what's owed.
"Not only is there the past use that we've been prohibited from benefiting from, but future as well. Because as long as the lands are still not returned to Kahnawà:ke and they're being developed for different uses to other people's benefits, it's a concern."
The federal government accepted the grievance in 2003.
But Diabo said talks have been slow moving in the decades since, revolving around negotiation protocols — or "negotiating how to negotiate," as he puts it.
Michael Coyle, a professor specializing in Indigenous rights and dispute resolution at Western University, said that when Canada accepts a claim, that means its lawyers have decided Canada continues to have an outstanding legal obligation toward the First Nation.
"It doesn't commit [Canada] to reaching a particular agreement or to include land in an agreement, but it does commit them to negotiate a claim that they have found to be a valid claim," he said.
Meanwhile, Diabo said he wants the government to issue a directive pausing development efforts on SSSL or at least include the band in those discussions.
The SSSL includes Sainte-Catherine, Delson, St-Constant, parts of Châteauguay and parts of other municipalities.
In 1680, French King Louis the XIV granted parcels of land, a seigneury, to the Jesuits to set up a mission and for the use and occupation of the Iroquois, or Kanien'kehá:ka of Kahnawà:ke. The Kanienʼkehá꞉ka of Kahnawà:ke are part of the larger Iroquois Confederacy.
Historical documents show the grant stipulated that settlers would not be allowed on the land.
The Jesuits began granting part of the land to French settlers nonetheless. In 1762, a British general, Thomas Gage, ruled in favour of a complaint lodged by the Kanien'kehá:ka, reversing the concessions.
However, the matter was never completely settled and the Kanien'kehá:ka continued to be dispossessed of their lands through the years so that today, Kahnawà:ke's territory accounts for just over 50 square kilometres.
Diabo said the band wants to have a serious conversation with the federal and provincial governments to formulate a transition plan. As for the people living in the affected municipalities, Diabo said a successful settlement to the claim doesn't necessarily mean further displacement.
"We're not monsters at the end of the day, even though historically that's what happened to us. People moved in and then removed us from our areas," said Diabo.
"We're not like that."
A spokesperson for the federal government's Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada (CIRNAC) said the government has been working with the Mohawk Council of Kahnawà:ke in the spirit of co-operation and partnership to resolve the outstanding SSSL through confidential negotiations.
"We remain committed to a negotiated outcome that advances the priorities of the Mohawk Council of Kahnawà:ke," said Eric Head.
In a statement, the Quebec government said the negotiations are exclusively between the MCK and the federal government and that it is not participating.
WATCH | What's the Seigneury of Sault St. Louis Land Grievance?:
In Quebec, there are currently 22 specific claims in progress between various bands and the Canadian government.
According to CIRNAC, among the 115 claims concluded in the province, almost 60 per cent were settled through negotiation, while just under 40 per cent resulted in the finding of no lawful obligation on the part of the Crown. The remaining two were settled through an administrative remedy.
The government frequently chooses to settle grievances by offering land that they make available as a substitute to the disputed land if, for example, there are people living there, Coyle said.
In other cases they offer money which the band can use to buy private land.
A third possibility, which he said he hasn't seen yet, is the expropriation of private land to settle a dispute.
"We use expropriation in a lot of different contexts in Canada. It's being used in Toronto, for example, right now to build new subway lines," said Coyle.
Solutions demand creativity, he said. Diabo is hopeful they'll get there. He also hopes Kahnawà:ke's neighbours will get educated on the dispute and better understand his community's perspective.
"Rather than kick it down the road and … exacerbate the situation, let's settle it right now," he said. "We're here now."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

UK commits to aiding Palestinians but won't yet recognize state
UK commits to aiding Palestinians but won't yet recognize state

The Hill

time6 minutes ago

  • The Hill

UK commits to aiding Palestinians but won't yet recognize state

United Kingdom Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Friday committed to increasing British aid efforts in Gaza and advocated for a peaceful two-state solution between Israel and Palestine. However, Starmer did not announce the UK's recognition of Palestine as a sovereign state a day after France said it would do so. 'We're scaling up our work. We are accelerating efforts to evacuate children from Gaza who need critical medical assistance, bringing them to the UK for specialist medical treatment,' Starmer said in a video posted to X. 'News that Israel will allow countries to airdrop aid into Gaza has come far too late, but we will do everything we can to get aid in via this route. We are already working urgently with the Jordanian authorities to get British aid onto plains and into Gaza,' he added. France became the first G7 nation to say it would recognize Palestine as a state on Thursday. 'The French people want peace in the Middle East. It is up to us, the French, together with the Israelis, the Palestinians, and our European and international partners, to demonstrate that it is possible,' French President Emmanuel Macron said. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu condemned the gesture. 'A Palestinian state in these conditions would be a launch pad to annihilate Israel — not to live in peace beside it. Let's be clear: the Palestinians do not seek a state alongside Israel; they seek a state instead of Israel,' he wrote on X. Israeli leaders have isolated tens of thousands of families and children in the West Bank leading to reports of starvation and a desperate need for foreign aid. On Friday, Starmer recommitted the UK's involvement in ceasefire talks and a long-lasting peace agreement. 'Alongside our closest allies, I am working on a pathway to peace in the region, focused on the practical solutions that will make a real difference to the lives of those who are suffering in this war,' Starmer said in the Friday post. 'That pathway will set out concrete steps to turn the desperately needed ceasefire into a lasting peace. Recognition of a Palestinian state has to be one of those steps. I'm unequivocal about that, but it must be part of a wider plan which ultimately results in a two-state solution and lasting security for Palestinians and Israelis,' he added.

U.S. Central Command says it killed senior ISIS leader, two adult sons
U.S. Central Command says it killed senior ISIS leader, two adult sons

UPI

time3 hours ago

  • UPI

U.S. Central Command says it killed senior ISIS leader, two adult sons

Gen. Michael E. Kurilla announced Friday that Central Command forces killed a senior ISIS leader an his two adult ISIS-affiliated sons. File photo by Leigh Vogel/UPI | License Photo July 25 (UPI) -- The U.S. Central Command announced Friday that it had conducted an operation in Aleppo, Syria, killing a senior Islamic State leader and his two adult sons. Those killed in the raid by U.S. forces were: Dhiya' Zawba Muslih al-Hardani, and his sons, Abdallah Dhiya al-Hardani and Abd al-Rahman Dhiya Zawba al-Hardani. The sons were also affiliated with ISIS, a press release said. Three women and three children also were there and were unharmed, officials said. "We will continue to relentlessly pursue ISIS terrorists wherever they operate," said Gen. Michael Erik Kurilla, U.S. Central Command commander. "ISIS terrorists are not safe where they sleep, where they operate, and where they hide. "Alongside our partners and allies, U.S. Central Command is committed to the enduring defeat of ISIS terrorists that threaten the region, our allies, and our homeland." The press release said the ISIS officials threaten the United States and coalition forces, as well as the new Syrian government. The attack comes weeks after the White House ordered a drawdown of U.S. military presence in Syria, which had about 2,000 personnel on eight bases in the area. Hundreds have returned home recently. Syria's Foreign Ministry released a statement earlier on Friday that said its representatives had met with American and French officials to "reinforce our cooperation on the shared fight against terrorism in all forms, and strengthen the capacities of the Syrian government to deal with security challenges through institutions of the state."

How to pronounce Ghislaine Maxwell's name
How to pronounce Ghislaine Maxwell's name

USA Today

time3 hours ago

  • USA Today

How to pronounce Ghislaine Maxwell's name

British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, the former girlfriend of convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, is making headlines again after meetings with the Department of Justice. A senior DOJ official met with Maxwell for a second day of talks on Friday, July 25. This comes as the Trump administration attempts to block the release of additional documents related to the investigation into Epstein's death. The disgraced financier died by suicide in August 2019 after being convicted in 2008 of soliciting prostitution from a minor. Maxwell is serving a 20-year sentence at a federal prison in Tallahassee, Florida, after being found guilty in 2021 of helping Epstein sexually abuse teenage girls. She is currently appealing her sentence. POTUS on socialite Ghislaine Maxwell: Trump says he hasn't considered pardoning Epstein associate Closed-door discussions involved Maxwell, her attorneys and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, President Donald Trump's former defense lawyer. Maxwell's lawyer said an initial meeting with the Department of Justice was "very productive." But how do you pronounce Maxwell's first name? How to pronounce Ghislaine Maxwell's name The French name Ghislaine is pronounced" Ghee-len" with a hard "g" The "s" is silent while the "laine" portion rhymes with "again." It can also be pronounced "lahn" depending on the accent of the individual speaking the name. Contributing: USA TODAY's Christopher Cann, Jeff Burlew and Aysha Bagchi. Natalie Neysa Alund is a senior reporter for USA TODAY. Reach her at nalund@ and follow her on X @nataliealund.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store