Man who caused attack that blinded Alanna Quinn Idris had harassed her before
Alanna Quinn Idris who suffered injuries and lost the sight in her eye as a result of an assault on Ballyfermot Road on December 30, 2021. pic: IrishPhotoDesk.ie
A man who procured an attack on a young woman which resulted in her losing vision permanently in one eye had harassed her on several occasions beforehand, she has told a court.
Jack Cummins (21), with an address at Rossmore Road, Ballyfermot pleaded guilty to procuring the commission of assault causing serious harm to Alanna Quinn Idris on Ballyfermot Road on December 30, 2021.
Jack Cummins (21), with an address at Rossmore Road, Ballyfermot, Dublin - he previously pleaded guilty to procuring the commission of assault causing serious harm to Ms Quinn Idris on Ballyfermot Road on December 30, 2021. pic: IrishPhotoDesk.ie
It is the prosecution case he did so by making two phone calls to his cousin Josh Cummins (20).
Ms Quinn Idris (then 17) was struck in the face with the saddle of an electric scooter, which fractured her eye socket and left her permanently blind in her right eye. Her friend Louis O'Sullivan was also assaulted during the incident.
Alanna Quinn Idris who suffered injuries and lost the sight in her eye as a result of an assault on Ballyfermot Road on December 30, 2021. pic: IrishPhotoDesk.ie
News in 90 Seconds - June 24th
Jack Cummins further pleaded to violent disorder and assault causing harm. He has no previous convictions.
Two other men have already been sentenced for their roles in the attack on Ms Quinn Idris and her friend Mr O'Sullivan. A fourth man, who hit Ms Quinn Idris with the e-scooter saddle, has never been identified.
Sergeant Michael Noonan told Edward Doocey BL, prosecuting, today that the two injured parties and a friend had taken a bus from Liffey Valley Shopping Centre.
Jack Cummins and his girlfriend were on the same bus and there were no verbal interactions between the parties.
After they all got off the bus on the Ballyfermot Road, there was a verbal exchange between Jack Cummins and Mr O'Sullivan.
Mr Doocey said the State's case is that Jack Cummins procured the commission of the assault on Ms Quinn Idris by making two phone calls to Josh Cummins after this interaction and receiving one.
He told the court that a 'tacit agreement' could be inferred from the evidence. He also noted the presence of weapons and the outnumbering of the injured parties meant, 'there was always a risk that more than minor harm could be caused'.
Mr Doocey submitted to the court that this agreement was formed before any interaction between the four men interacted with the injured parties.
Jack Cummins was not physically involved in the assault of Ms Quinn Idris, but did strike Mr O'Sullivan.
The attack lasted one minute and stopped when passing motorists intervened. The four men then left the scene.
Mr O'Sullivan was treated in hospital for a cut to his head and a puncture wound to his arm, which required stitches. He also had bruising and tenderness.
Ms Quinn Idris underwent emergency surgery that night as she sustained a broken eye socket. She has since had numerous reconstructive surgeries to her right eye socket and a bone graft taken from her hip. She has lost vision permanently in one eye, the court heard.
Photos of her injuries and medical reports were handed to the court.
Darragh Lyons (21) of Weir View, Glenaulin, Chapelizod, Dublin 20, pleaded guilty to assault causing serious harm to Ms Quinn Idris, assault causing harm to her friend Louis O'Sullivan and violent disorder on Ballyfermot Road on December 30, 2021. He was handed a sentence of four and a half years in March 2023.
Josh Cummins (20) of Raheen Drive, Ballyfermot, received a five-year sentence, with the final two years suspended in November 2023 for his role in the incident
He pleaded guilty to intentionally or recklessly causing serious harm to Ms Quinn Idris. He further pleaded guilty to violent disorder, production of an article, a hurl, in the course of a dispute and to assault causing harm ot Mr O'Sullivan.
Reading her victim impact statement to the court, Ms Quinn Idris said she is now 'permanently facially disfigured' due to the attack.
She said this was 'not just a random incident between strangers' and told the court there had been other unpleasant encounters between them in the past.
She said she believed Jack Cummins 'would harass and target me so often because he did not like me'.
Later, she said she felt 'so angry' as 'none of this would have happened if he hadn't made those calls that night'.
Evidence was heard that Jack Cummins and Ms Quinn Idris were known to each other. She had several earlier unpleasant encounters with him, some of which became physical.
In one of these incidents, he threw eggs at her and on another occasion, he pushed her to the ground after putting her in a headlock. The court heard this second incident occurred years before the events of December 30, 2021.
Sgt Noonan said it appeared this past engagement was why Mr O'Sullivan spoke to Jack Cummins after they got off the bus, saying: 'Do you like putting girls in a headlock.'
Mr Doocey said it is the prosecution's case that Jack Cummins made phone calls to his cousin as a result of this conversation, which led to the three other men arriving at the scene.
Keith Spencer BL, defending, said his client acknowledges he made the phonecalls, but 'did not intend the consequences which flowed – they are unfortunate and unforeseen'. He said there was no longstanding pre-mediation, but that it occurred in the moment.
He said his client maintains that his decision was made out of fear as he had been threatened and challenged by Mr O'Sullivan.
Mr Spencer noted the probation report assesses his client at low risk of re-offending
His client is engaged to his girlfriend who was present on the night and has a good work history. A number of testimonials were handed to the court.
Mr Spencer suggested his client has 'perfect mitigation' and his behaviour on the night was 'out of character'.
Jack Cummins read out a letter of apology to Ms Quinn Idris. He said he was truly sorry, wished he could turn back the clock and wished her well in her recovery.
Judge Pauline Codd said the court wanted to consider everything that it had heard. She adjourned the case to July 29 for finalisation and remanded Jack Cummins on continuing bail.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Pervert who said he was ‘sorry' after sending boy 2,500 sexual messages finally jailed
James Varian broke down crying and sobbed 'I'm so sorry' when confronted by the Sunday World after we asked why he felt it appropriate to send the deluge of sexual messages to a 15-year-old boy James Varian was convicted of sending 2,500 messages to a 15-year-old boy over a nine-day period and also of possession of 9,000 images of child abuse A pervert who told the Sunday World he was 'sorry' for his crimes, after he was given a suspended sentence for bombarding a teenage boy with 2,500 sexual messages, has been jailed for three years after the DPP appealed on the grounds of leniency. James Varian broke down crying and sobbed 'I'm so sorry' when confronted by the Sunday World after we asked why he felt it appropriate to send the deluge of sexual messages to a 15-year-old boy. Varian, now 31, was also discovered to have over 9,000 files containing graphic imagery of child abuse on his computer when gardai later searched his home. Approached by the Sunday World, Varian told us he could not explain his actions other than to say he himself had been the victim of abuse in his past. 'I'm so sorry … I'm so sorry,' he said when asked if he would take the opportunity to apologise to his victim. 'I have an awful lot of work to do now to redeem myself. I've a lot of counselling to do.' Asked why he had harassed the underage boy and downloaded such horrific imagery, Varian said: 'I had similar issues in my own childhood.' James Varian was convicted of sending 2,500 messages to a 15-year-old boy over a nine-day period and also of possession of 9,000 images of child abuse News in 90 Seconds - Aug 9th Asked if he was saying he was a victim of abuse, he responded: 'I was, yeah, unfortunately.' Details of Varian's harassment of the child were first made to known to gardai when the boy he targeted and his father went to their local garda station to complain. During follow-up inquiries, officers carried out a search of Varian's property and seized hardware including phones and computers. An analysis of the devices subsequently uncovered the presence of 9,000 files containing imagery of child abuse. The files included 7,781 images and 1,970 videos. Cork Circuit Criminal Court heard that more than 1,000 of the images and 300 videos fell into the most serious category of abuse imagery depicting children either witnessing or engaging in sexual acts. The majority of these, the court was told, were computer generated. Det Sgt Brendan Corry told the court that gardai had begun their investigations after they were contacted in January 2022 by the teenage boy's father. He had discovered sexually explicit communications sent via the Telegram app to his son over Christmas in 2021 and early 2022. Varian, who had become aware that a complaint had been made against him, contacted gardai independently and informed them he believed they might be looking to speak with him. The court was also informed that around this time Varian contacted his victim and urged him to 'purge texts' and 'delete everything' in reference to their communications. Judge Dermot Sheehan was informed that Varian had entered pleas of guilty to possession of child pornography at the house where he lived at Ringmahon Road, Cork, on January 6, 2022, and a charge of using information and communication technology to facilitate the sexual exploitation of a child. Appearing on behalf of Varian, Jane Hyland SC noted her client was dealing with high levels of anxiety and had 'autistic traits'. She said he was not 'minimizing' what he had done and was deeply sorry for his actions. Suspending a four-year sentence, Judge Dermot Sheehan noted that Varian had contacted gardai of his volition, had no previous convictions and had expressed remorse. However, the case came back before the Court of Appeal last week after the Director of Public Prosecutions appealed the sentence on the grounds that it was too lenient. Returning judgement, Mr Justice John Edwards said that the sentencing judge's reasons for fully suspending the sentences were 'relatively sparse', giving only Varian's age and the fact that he was a first-time offender. The Court of Appeal sentenced Varian to four years in custody with the final 12 months suspended for a period of 12 months for the count of sending explicit messages. They also sentenced him to two years in custody for the count of possession of child abuse images, to run concurrently with the first.
Sunday World
2 days ago
- Sunday World
‘There's no way he killed himself' Jeffrey Epstein's former butler claims
'LOVED LIFE' | Former employee claims Trump offered disgraced financier a job during first term in White House In an interview that will heap renewed pressure on the Trump administration to make the Epstein files public, one of his closest aides said he spoke to the paedophile financier before he died and insisted he was in good spirits. Valdson Vieira Cotrin, who ran Epstein's Paris home, said he could not accept the official verdict of suicide and feared his own life was in danger. He also said he believed that Epstein victim Virginia Giuffre, who accused Prince Andrew of rape and died by suicide in April, was a victim of foul play. Mr Cotrin also made the extraordinary claim that Epstein told him he had been offered a job by Donald Trump in his first administration in 2016 – but that Epstein had turned it down. Donald Trump claims he fell out with Epstein in 2004. Photo: Reuters There is no evidence that the allegation is true and Mr Trump has maintained that he stopped speaking to Epstein in 2004 after they fell out over a business deal. But Mr Cotrin's recollection of a conversation with his boss will fuel a growing demand for the full Epstein files – the trove of documents from the criminal investigations into Epstein that allegedly name high-profile celebrities and politicians, possibly including Mr Trump – to be released in full. Jeffrey Epstein with his former butler Valdson Cotrin News in 90 Seconds - Aug 9th In his exclusive interview, Mr Cotrin, speaking on the record for the first time, also alleged: Mr Cotrin remains in possession of a number of photographs taken with friends of Epstein, including a photo of himself with Bill Clinton on the so-called Lolita Express, Epstein's private plane that he used to traffic underage girls and women for sex. The existence of the photo showing Mr Clinton on board Epstein's jet will also fuel demands for the former president to reveal his full dealings with Epstein. Mr Clinton was issued with a subpoena on Tuesday, demanding he give evidence to a congressional committee investigating the financier. Bill Clinton and his wife Hillary have both been subpoenaed to appear before the house oversight committee. Photo: AP Mr Cotrin also shared a photograph of himself with Epstein that was taken in January 2019 on his private jet, which may be one of the last taken of the financier. He looks puffy but is smiling and relaxed and notably wearing an Israel Defence Forces sweatshirt. Epstein has long been accused of being an operative for Mossad, Israel's intelligence service, although last month his former lawyer said that Epstein used to laugh off the claim. Mr Cotrin, who acted as Epstein's butler, chauffeur and cook in Paris, recalled driving his boss to Le Bourget Airport in Paris to catch a flight to New York, where he was arrested upon landing on July 6, 2019. I don't believe this was suicide. He loved life too much Epstein (66) was charged with sex trafficking underage girls and remanded in custody. He was found hanged in his cell on August 10. But Mr Cotrin is insistent Epstein would never have killed himself. Epstein had told him he was planning to negotiate with the judge in the case to secure bail, having been held in custody as a possible flight risk. 'I am like his brother [Mark Epstein]. I don't believe this was suicide. He loved life too much,' said Mr Cotrin. Mr Cotrin recalled seeing Epstein for the last time. Epstein, he said, was relaxed and had been talking about making more investments in his islands – he had discreetly bought a second, which Mr Cotrin visited – as well as spending more time in Paris. 'I drove him to Le Bourget Airport. It was a Saturday, because on Monday he was supposed to appear before the judge regarding all these accusations. 'When I got home, two young women rang, his main girlfriend who had been with him officially for several years, Karyna [Shuliak] and another who worked for him. And then they told me, 'Mr Epstein has gone to prison. He arrived in New York. The police were waiting for him'.' Mr Cotrin's partner, Maria Gomes de Melo, who also knew Epstein well, recalled that in Paris, Epstein had said goodbye to her and added: 'I'll be back next week', Ms de Melo told him: 'Sir, don't go.' She also questioned the official conclusion that he had killed himself. Epstein's brother, Mark, has suggested the financier may have been murdered, ordering a second post-mortem examination that tended to back up that assertion. 'On the Saturday late, we got the news that he had hanged himself, and honestly, he loved life too much to float away like that,' she said. The US department of justice has released nearly 11 hours of surveillance video from outside Epstein's cell in the Manhattan Metropolitan Correctional Centre, but a crucial minute from 11:58:58pm to midnight was missing. That has further fuelled conspiracy theories that Epstein was murdered to silence him. Mr Cotrin remains fiercely loyal to Epstein and insists he never saw his boss cavorting – let alone having sex – with underage girls. He said young women were hired to give Epstein massages and to cut his nails. 'The girls did that to him, but it stopped there,' he said. He gave an extraordinary insight into Epstein's world – and the rich and famous who would stop by for his guidance and hospitality. Mr Cotrin, who has joint French and Brazilian nationalities, worked for Epstein for 18 years, managing his sumptuous eight-bedroom Paris apartment on Avenue Foch overlooking the Arc de Triomphe. He lived in a garret flat on the sixth floor. But he also worked dozens of times at Epstein's properties in New York, Palm Beach, Florida and on Little St James, Epstein's private Caribbean island – dubbed 'paedophile island' – where he is said to have trapped and raped often underage victims. 'He trusted me completely,' said Mr Cotrin, who has not worked since his boss's death six years ago. 'I was his chauffeur, his cook, his housekeeper. I did everything in Paris, I was his only full-time, paid-up employee and worked for him from 2001 until his death. If someone could have seen something, it's Valdson, there's no one else,' he said. His interview took place in his French home over a beer and Brazilian bread and cheese balls that he says were a hit with Bill Gates. Upstairs, a large photo of Mr Cotrin and Epstein taken on the 'Lolita Express' hung on one wall, alongside another with the butler and Mr Clinton. Mr Cotrin reeled off a list of dignitaries who came to visit Epstein over two decades, including Prince Andrew, who he cooked for and chauffeured 'five or six times' in Paris and New York; Mr Clinton, whom he met once in Epstein's jet during a stopover in Paris; Peter Mandelson, now the UK's ambassador to Washington DC; Woody Allen; and Israeli ex-prime minister Ehud Barak, along with other Middle Eastern dignitaries. A photograph of Mr Mandelson with Epstein and Mr Cotrin taken at the Paris apartment on Epstein's birthday has been widely circulated, causing Mr Mandelson, the former Labour cabinet minister, huge embarrassment. Mr Cotrin has refused countless requests for interviews since Epstein was found hanged in his prison cell, but said he was breaking his silence to 'tell my truth' about Epstein, whom he refers to as 'Monsieur' or 'Patron'. Ms Giuffre killed herself at her home in Australia in April, aged 41. 'And what about Virginia [Giuffre] Roberts?' Mr Cotrin said, adding: 'I'm scared because after what happened to them, poor Valdson, who knows?' Mr Cotrin never met Mr Trump – Mr Trump and Epstein had fallen out over the sale of a property in Palm Beach in 2004. However, Mr Cotrin said that Epstein had boasted of being offered a job by Mr Trump after his surprise first presidential election win in November 2016. The claim – if true – would be dynamite, although there is no evidence to back it up. Sources inside Trump's first administration have told The Telegraph that Mr Cotrin's recollection appeared fanciful. Activists put up a poster showing Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein near the US Embassy in London. Photo: AP Mr Cotrin said: 'I can tell you one thing [regarding Mr Trump]. A few days after Trump's [2016] election, Mr Epstein arrived in Paris on Monday or Tuesday, and I went to pick him up at the airport. 'He said: 'Valdson, you saw that Trump is the new US president?' ''Yes,' I replied, 'I saw it on the news in Paris'. ''Well, Trump asked me to work for him in the new government'. 'I said: 'Congratulations. I'm happy for you,' in my bad English. 'He said: 'No I didn't accept.'' I asked no more questions as it wasn't my place Mr Cotrin insisted Epstein was not in the habit of trumpeting false claims in such a confidential setting. He said his boss made no mention of what position that might be. 'I was surprised because I would have thought such a position could be interesting, but I asked no more questions as it wasn't my place,' Mr Cotrin said. 'In my job, one waits to be spoken to. 'But in my opinion, if he did turn it down, it was because he liked his freedom, I think he didn't want to be controlled by anyone.' Mr Trump has not been accused of any wrongdoing in the case.
Sunday World
3 days ago
- Sunday World
Masked gunman got pizza instead of cash in Dublin takeaway robbery, court told
It was alleged that man accepted two pizzas, exited and gave one of them to the accused who left the area. A masked gunman threatened to shoot a food delivery man in Dublin but got away with a pizza instead of cash, a court has heard. Robert Lynch, of no fixed abode, was charged with attempted robbery on June 22 at Clarehall Shopping Centre car park, Dublin 17, and unlawful possession of a hinged knife with a four-inch blade as an offensive weapon at the time of his arrest on Thursday. He was denied bail when he appeared before Judge Cephas Power at Dublin District Court today. Garda Jordan Martin, Coolock station, objected to bail due to the seriousness of the offence. A man holding a pizza box. Close-up. News in 90 Seconds - Aug 8th Citing the strength of the evidence, he alleged that the attempted armed robbery took place at 3.10 am when a lone male approached an Apache pizza at Clarehall Shopping Centre, and spoke to one of the delivery drivers sitting in a vehicle outside. The contested bail hearing was told that he then "produced a firearm from his jacket pocket, pointed it at him and demanded he hand over any money." It was claimed Mr Lynch told him, "He would shoot him if he didn't hand over any money." The driver then offered to go into the pizzeria to get cash. Garda Martin said the accused allegedly told the driver he would send another man into to collect. Garda Martin stated Mr Lynch walked to a nearby underground car park to speak to another male who then went into the pizza restaurant for the money. He reportedly told workers he had been sent over by his friend with the gun. Garda Martin said the staff told him: "They had no money to give but would give him some pizza." It was alleged that man accepted two pizzas, exited and gave one of them to the accused who left the area. The court heard that the driver told gardai the man who approached him had a gun, and that what appeared to be a firearm could be seen on CCTV evidence. Garda Martin agreed with defence solicitor Eoin Lysaght that an ID parade was not held, and it happened around a car park, but stated there were not many people in the area at that time. He also conceded that no firearm was recovered. Mr Lynch made no admissions on arrest and has yet to enter a plea. The court also heard he was not awaiting trial for any other offences. Judge Power remarked that the case would likely go forward to the Circuit Court, which has wider sentencing powers, but stressed the accused had the presumption of innocence, and he noted the defence had exposed issues in the case. However, he refused bail and remanded Mr Lynch in custody to appear at Cloverhill District Court on August 14 for directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions. Legal aid was granted.
