Debt by cash transactions of over Rs 20,000 not legally enforceable: Kerala HC
Kerala High Court
on Friday declared that a debt created by a cash transaction of above Rs 20,000 in violation of the Income Tax Act is not a "
legally enforceable debt
" unless there is a valid explanation for the same.
Justice P V Kunhikrishnan made the declaration while allowing a plea for setting aside the conviction and sentence of a man accused in a
cheque dishonor case
.
Explore courses from Top Institutes in
Please select course:
Select a Course Category
Others
Management
Technology
CXO
Data Analytics
Product Management
Digital Marketing
Leadership
Artificial Intelligence
Data Science
healthcare
Public Policy
Operations Management
Cybersecurity
MBA
Degree
MCA
others
Finance
Data Science
Project Management
PGDM
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
28 Weeks
MICA
CERT-MICA SBMPR Async India
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
7 Months
S P Jain Institute of Management and Research
CERT-SPJIMR Exec Cert Prog in AI for Biz India
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
16 Weeks
Indian School of Business
CERT-ISB Transforming HR with Analytics & AI India
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
9 months
IIM Lucknow
SEPO - IIML CHRO India
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
The accused was sentenced to one year and imposed with a fine of Rs 9 lakh by a sessions court for the offence of dishonour of cheque due to insufficiency of funds in the account under section 138 of Negotiable Instruments (NI) Act.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Animal Advocate Begs: Never Do This With A Senior Dog
ExpertsInPetHealth
Learn More
Undo
In his appeal in the High Court against the sessions court decision, the accused claimed that as the amount of Rs 9 lakh given to him by the complainant was in cash, it was an illegal transaction according to the Income Tax laws.
"Therefore, a debt created by an illegal transaction cannot be treated as a legally enforceable debt," the accused had claimed.
Live Events
Agreeing with the accused's contention, Justice Kunhikrishnan said that if a criminal court "indirectly legalises such illegal transactions in violation of the IT Act" by treating them as a legally enforceable debt, it will be against the aim of the country to discourage cash transactions above Rs 20,000.
The High Court said that discouraging cash transactions above Rs 20,000 was also "a part of the 'digital India' dream of our country, which is propounded by our Prime Minister to save our economy and to curb a parallel economy in our country".
"If the debt arises through an illegal transaction, that debt cannot be treated as a legally enforceable debt. If the court regularises such transactions, that will encourage illegal transactions by the citizens. Even black money will be converted into white money through the criminal courts," the High Court said.
It further said that in such cases the accused should challenge such transactions in evidence and has to rebut the presumption under section 139 of the NI Act that "the holder of a cheque received it for the discharge of a debt or other liability".
In the instant case, the accused had rebutted the presumption by claiming that the complainant does not have the source to loan out Rs 9 lakh and therefore, the debt alleged to be due to him cannot be treated as a legally enforceable one, the HC said.
It allowed the accused's revision petition and acquitted him by setting aside his conviction and sentence by the lower court.
The High Court said if anybody pays an amount in excess of Rs 20,000 to another person by cash in violation of the IT Act and thereafter receives a cheque for that debt, he should take responsibility to get back the amount, unless there is a valid explanation for such cash transactions.
"If there is no valid explanation in tune with provisions of the IT Act, the doors of the criminal court will be closed for such illegal transactions," the HC said.
It also made it clear that its findings would be prospective in nature.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
Nine from Gujarat indicted in US for illegal gambling operation
Ahmedabad: In a high-profile federal crackdown in the United States, nine men of Gujarati origin were indicted in a multi-million-dollar illegal gambling operation spread across six Missouri locations. The accused, all Indian nationals originally from Gujarat, allegedly operated skill game arcades as a front to run unlawful electronic gambling businesses, grossing over $9.5 million between 2022 and 2025. The nine people, four from Georgia, two from New York, one each from Washington, Arkansas and Colorado, were charged in a 72-count superseding indictment returned under seal by a federal grand jury in Springfield on May 14, according to a statement from the US attorney in the western district of Missouri. The superseding indictment replaces an indictment returned against one of them on Dec 10, 2024, and includes additional charges and defendants. The superseding indictment was unsealed and made public following the arrest of several defendants and in advance of certain defendants' arraignments on July 23 and 24, the statement added. You Can Also Check: Ahmedabad AQI | Weather in Ahmedabad | Bank Holidays in Ahmedabad | Public Holidays in Ahmedabad US attorney Jeff Ray emphasised the broader implications: "Illegal gambling operations affect the citizens of the neighbourhoods and communities where they are located as well as the local economy. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Cargo Ship Meets Pirates - Watch What the Captain Does Next! Tips and Tricks Undo We worked closely with our law enforcement partners to shut down this criminal conspiracy and bring those responsible to justice." "What began as a local investigation quickly expanded into a large, multi-jurisdictional case resulting in numerous indictments and a significant positive impact across our community," Springfield police chief Paul Williams said. The defendants allegedly ran businesses with names such as Big Win Arcade, Spin Hitters and Vegas City Arcade, masking them as legitimate entertainment centres in cities including Springfield, Joplin and Branson West. "This wasn't some low-level gambling scheme. It was an organised, multi-million-dollar criminal network that operated brazenly and believed it could stay one step ahead of law enforcement," said Mark Zito, special agent in charge, Homeland Security Investigations, Kansas City. The indictment, unsealed just before arraignments on July 23-24, charges all nine with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, operating illegal gambling businesses and conspiracy to launder money. Some are also accused of depositing or transferring over $10,000 in illegal funds in single transactions. "The federal indictment charges all nine defendants with one count each of participating in a conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to operate an illegal gambling business, and operating illegal gambling businesses from July 1, 2022, to May 13, 2025. In addition to the conspiracy counts, all nine defendants were charged with at least one count of wire fraud, and eight defendants were charged with conspiracy to commit money laundering," the document states. The Organized Crime Drug Enforcement Task Forces (OCDETF) of the US Department of Justice (DOJ) led the probe, working with the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Internal Revenue Service, Homeland Security, Missouri State Patrol and local police departments. Modus operandi According to the indictment, the defendants ran illegal gambling businesses under the guise of internet amusement arcade games, skill game arcades and adult arcades. "Between April 24 and Aug 28, 2023, one of the defendants registered six businesses online with the Missouri Secretary of State: Big Win Arcade, LLC; Big Win Arcade 2023, LLC; Spin Hitters 1, LLC; Spin Hitters, LLC; Vegas City Arcade, LLC; and Vegas Arcade, LLC. The indictment alleges that the defendants then used these businesses to fraudulently apply for business licence applications filed with the cities of Springfield, Joplin, and Branson West, and to obtain utilities contracts, lease agreements and business incorporation documents filed with the State of Missouri," reads the document from the US Attorney's office. The defendants hired local employees to work in their businesses, which operated contests of chance, gambling devices and slot machines in violation of Missouri and federal law. Five of the defendants participated in WhatsApp group chats where they communicated about the operation of the illegal gambling arcades from May 31, 2023, to March 11, 2024. The indictment alleges that the defendants transported the proceeds from the illegal gambling locations to several states to promote the ongoing illegal activity. They hid the proceeds of their gambling ring by depositing them in various personal bank accounts within the US and India. Over $9.5 million in US currency was laundered by this organisation in a little over three years, the document states. What is Operation Take Back America This gambling bust was part of Operation Take Back America, a sweeping DOJ initiative to disrupt transnational criminal organisations. It unifies the resources of the OCDETF, Project 'Safe Neighbourhoods' and immigration enforcement bodies. Aimed at dismantling drug cartels, fraud networks and illegal enterprises, the operation combines aggressive prosecution with intelligence-led policing. "Today's charges reflect the dedication of law enforcement, especially in Springfield, Joplin and across Southwest Missouri — to hold those who violate the law accountable," said FBI special agent in charge Stephen Cyrus. The Gujarat-origin gambling ring was one of the largest arcade-based frauds discovered under this national effort. Details of the case - Suspected illegal immigration status among the nine accused - Fraudulent business licences obtained in Missouri cities - WhatsApp used for communication; cash moved between US and India - Charged with wire fraud, illegal gambling, money laundering, racketeering - Federal case under OCDETF & Operation Take Back America - US attorney's office, FBI, ICE, IRS and local police departments involved in crackdown
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Pakistan tribal council threatens highway block over girl's murder
ISLAMABAD: A tribal jirga (council of elders) in Pakistan's Tank district has threatened to block a stretch of Indus Highway on July 29 after the killing of a nine-year-old girl sparked public outrage. Convened in Tank's Gul Imam on Saturday, the jirga issued an 11-point charter of demands, warning of a full blockade if authorities fail to respond. Indus Highway (N-55) is a critical national artery that runs along the river, connecting Karachi in Pakistan's south with Peshawar in the north and cutting through multiple provinces. The planned blockade at Pezu will impact trade routes, passenger transport, and military convoys. The protests gained momentum after a viral video showed residents confronting armed security personnel -- an extraordinary act in this militarised stretch of southern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The footage amplified long-standing anger over arbitrary detentions, raids without warrants, and what locals call collective punishment disguised as counterterrorism. 'Our decision to block the highway remains. If our demands are accepted, we'll reconsider. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Tummy Tuck Surgery In Russian Federation Might Be Cheaper Than You Think Tummy Tuck Surgery | Search Ads Undo If not, Pezu will be shut down on July 29,' jirga leader Abdul Qayum Kundi said. Police have registered a case in the girl's death, but authorities have yet to disclose any findings. Locals allege misconduct or negligence by security forces—claims that remain unverified but widely believed within the community. In a bid to defuse tensions, local officials delivered three sheep and (Pak) Rs 2.5 million (around $9,000) to the girl's family -- an act rooted in tribal custom, meant to symbolise remorse and reconciliation. But jirga members view it as a token gesture. 'This is hush money in ceremonial form,' said one elder. The jirga's demands include the release of detainees not proven to have militant ties, an end to forced house searches, and a halt to arrests of suspects' relatives. They also call for the return of confiscated weapons and an end to detentions based on vague accusations of mukhbiri (spying). The jirga's demands echo those of the banned Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement (PTM), which for years challenged Pakistan's security policies in its tribal belt.
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Did Epstein introduce Melania to Trump? Biographer makes bold claim; first lady's book says otherwise
Michael Wolff , Melania and Donald Trump (AP file photos) US president Donald Trump 's longtime biographer Michael Wolff has reignited controversy by claiming that Jeffrey Epstein played a key role in introducing Melania Trump to her future husband. Speaking on The Daily Beast podcast, Wolff said Melania was 'very involved' in Epstein's social circle when she was first introduced to Trump in 1998. According to Wolff, the connection was made through Paolo Zampolli, founder of ID Models, who helped Melania move to the US. 'She's introduced by a model agent, both of whom Trump and Epstein are involved with… Epstein knew her well,' Wolff said. He also questioned Melania's ties to what he called a 'culture of models of indeterminate age.' Earlier reports have linked Zampolli to both Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, who was later convicted for her role in Epstein's sex trafficking network. Melania, however, has denied the Epstein angle. She insists she met Trump at the Kit Kat Klub in New York, where she had gone with a friend. In her book Melania, she describes how Trump, already twice divorced, was there with a date but spent the evening talking to her. 'It was a refreshing departure from the usual superficial small talk,' she writes. Despite Trump's efforts to distance himself from Epstein, a photo from 2000 shows Donald and Melania at Mar-a-Lago alongside Epstein and Maxwell. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Option Trading Mastery: Mr. Gopal Shares His Laxman Rekha Strategy For Free TradeWise Learn More Undo Epstein himself once claimed that he introduced the couple. Donald Trump's links to Jeffrey Epstein came to the spotlight after The Wall Street Journal reported that attorney general Pam Bondi told Trump during a May briefing that his name had come up in justice department files connected to Epstein.
