Developer fails in last-ditch bid to salvage approval for apartments near Royal Hospital Kilmainham
The disputed permission for five blocks, including an 18-storey tower, was granted, subject to 31 conditions, by An Bord Pleanála in March 2022 under the since-dismantled Strategic Housing Development procedure.
The site of the proposed development by HPREF HSQ Investments Ltd in Heuston South Quarter shared a boundary with the gardens of the 17th-century Royal Hospital Kilmainham (RHK), a protected structure.
In their High Court case against the board and the State, with the developer a notice party, architect Paul Leech and former
Irish Times journalist Frank McDonald
, argued that the proposed development would impinge upon a protected view from the RHK to the Phoenix Park.
READ MORE
This 'cone of vision' was designated in the Dublin City Development Plan to protect the setting of the RHK and would be adversely affected by the high-rise apartments intruding into it and overlooking the hospital's formal garden, they argued.
Last November, the High Court's Ms Justice Emily Farrell upheld the challenge by the applicants, represented by barristers Oisin Collins and Michael O'Donnell, instructed by O'Connell Clark solicitors.
She said the board failed to consider that the proposed development was a material contravention of the city development plan 2022-2028.
Last March, the judge refused to allow the developer to appeal her decision to the Court of Appeal. The developer did not meet the criteria for permission to appeal because it had not shown the decision raised a point of law of exceptional public importance or was desirable in the public interest, she held.
The developer then sought a 'leapfrog' appeal directly to the Supreme Court.
Its grounds included that the High Court misinterpreted the board's permission decision. It argued an appeal was in the interests of justice and that clarification of several issues raised would benefit other litigants in judicial reviews of planning decisions.
The board took a neutral position on the application for an appeal, while Mr Leech and Mr McDonald opposed any appeal because no issues of general public importance were raised.
In a recently published determination, a panel of three Supreme Court judges refused leave to appeal.
While the proposed development was 'substantial' and its location important, the case was resolved by the High Court in a 'clear and comprehensive' judgment, supplemented by further consideration when leave to appeal was sought and refused, the judges said.
The High Court applied 'clear legal principles' to the facts, they added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
25 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Robert Dunne, son of former supermarket tycoon Ben Dunne, dies in New York
The death has taken place of Robert Dunne, son of the former head of Dunnes Stores, the late Ben Dunne. Mr Dunne, who was 50, died peacefully in New York on August 1st. He is to be buried on Monday in Castleknock Churchyard, Dublin, following a Requiem Mass at St Mochta's Church, Porterstown, Clonsilla. The Brehon Law Society of New York, where Mr Dunne worked as a lawyer, said it was with 'deep respect and remembrance' that it heard of the death of its President Emeritus. 'Rob's unwavering dedication to justice, his leadership within the Brehon Law Society, and his enduring commitment to the Irish-American legal community leave a lasting impression,' it said, announcing that a month's mind Mass is to be held in New York on September 4th. READ MORE Mr Dunne grew up in Castleknock, Co Dublin, attended Trinity College Dublin and the London School of Economics, worked in Dunnes Stores in the Ilac Centre, Dublin, and later moved to the US to work as a lawyer. He is survived by his mother, Mary, siblings Mark, Caroline and Nicholas, and wider family. Condolences posted on recalled his time in Castleknock, at Trinity, in the Ilac Centre, and in the US. 'I lived in NYC for twenty years and attended many interesting legal events invited by Rob. His laughter was infectious and wit, second to none. May he rest in peace,' said Antoin, formerly of Manhattan. In a moving interview with The Sunday Independent last year Mr Dunne spoke about being the son of one of the State's top business figures and a man whose life was filled with extraordinary controversy. Among the events he recalled was his father being kidnapped by the Provisional IRA in 1981, being arrested in Florida in 1992 when having a panic attack after taking cocaine, and the way his mother stuck with her husband during the ensuing controversy and his father's continuing struggles with cocaine. 'I think my dad developed what we would now call PTSD and he needed counselling,' Mr Dunne said in respect of the effect of the kidnapping. The fallout from the events in Florida included an audit being commissioned of Dunnes Stores accounts, which led in time to revelations about payments to Michael Lowry and the late Charles Haughey, and the associated inquiries by the McCracken and Moriarty tribunals. Mr Dunne told the newspaper that it was the events in Florida and the fallout from them that led to his decision to study law. He eventually set up his own firm in New York. Asked what he would say to his father, who died in 2023, Mr Dunne said he would tell him he couldn't have had a better father. 'You made lots of mistakes, but you owned all of them. Please know that I am nothing but proud of you.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Independent ministers seek changes to inheritance tax system for adults with no children
Independent Ministers have pushed for changes to the inheritance tax system for the beneficiaries of estates left by people with no children. A campaign group known as Edit (End Discrimination in Inheritance Tax) has been contacting politicians as part of efforts to bring about reforms to the capital acquisitions tax (CAT) regime, which it says is 'grossly unfair'. Independent Ministers of State Michael Healy-Rae and Marian Harkin have raised the issue with Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe . Their separate interventions are included in records released under the Freedom of Information Act. CAT applies at a rate of 33 per cent on gifts or inheritances above certain tax-free thresholds that depend on the beneficiary's relationship to the person that gives them the gift or inheritance. READ MORE For spouses and civil partners, inheritances are free of tax. Children inheriting from a parent can receive up to €400,000 tax-free. For other relatives a tax-free threshold of €40,000 applies, while non-relatives can receive up to €20,000 tax free. Edit argues the thresholds that apply to the beneficiaries of the estates of childless adults are 'discriminatory'. One option Edit has proposed would be allowing people to inherit a home tax-free and to abolish the thresholds in favour of an across-the-board 10 per cent levy on all other assets. Mr Healy-Rae and Ms Harkin highlighted Edit's campaign in contacts with Mr Donohoe last March. Kerry TD Mr Healy-Rae included correspondence from Edit by saying it is a 'genuine campaign for people who do not have children', who are being 'unfairly' treated by the tax system. He said the information he enclosed 'may be helpful in future budgets'. This week Mr Healy-Rae said 'this is something I am very much pursuing and would like to see changed', though he did not offer specifics on what he would like to see happen. Mr Healy-Rae also said: 'I am acutely aware of the pressures on the upcoming budget', including 'the threat of tariffs to our economy' and issues such as the proposal to cut the VAT rate for the hospitality sector. 'I will continue to push for change on this and while it may not be possible for this upcoming budget it's something I'm focused on for the lifetime of this Government,' he said. In her email to Mr Donohoe, Sligo-Leitrim TD Ms Harkin told the Minister she received representations from a number of constituents on inheritance tax for couples who do not have children. She asked that the issue be reviewed 'with a view to increasing the threshold'. A spokesman for Ms Harkin said she has 'no further comment on the issue'. The Department of Finance said: 'It is a long-standing practice of the Minister for Finance not to comment in advance of the budget on any tax matters which might be the subject of budget decisions.' It noted that inheritance tax was covered in this year's Tax Strategy Papers, in which department officials set out options that inform the budget process. Government backbenchers Aindrias Moynihan and Shay Brennan of Fianna Fáil and Barry Ward of Fine Gael asked Mr Donohoe about CAT in parliamentary questions last month. As part of his answer, Mr Donohoe said: 'There would be a significant cost in making any further substantial changes to CAT' and 'the options available for setting CAT thresholds must be balanced against competing demands'.
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Ireland's biggest landlord sells 16 apartments for €6.6m and welcomes new rental regulations
IRELAND'S BIGGEST PRIVATE residential landlord sold 16 apartments for €6.6 million in the first half of this year, netting €1.6 million over their book value. Ires Reit's chief executive said that the Dublin-based company had achieved 'in excess of 25% premium to book value' in the sale of the underperforming assets. Advertisement The sales of the properties are part of the company's asset disposal programme. 'The first six months of the year have seen a step change in our operational and financial performance leading to significant improvements in margins and earnings,' said Eddie Byrne. He also said the company was 'well positioned to capitalise on the improving regulatory and market backdrop,' referring to the government's reforms that allow landlords to reset rent between tenancies. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
