Polehanki offers Whitmer-backed bill to restrict cell phone use in Michigan schools
However, members of the Senate Education Committee on Tuesday will hear testimony on a different proposal crafted by its chair, state Sen. Dayna Polehanki (D-Livonia).
Slated for introduction on Monday, Polehanki told the Michigan Advance her plan was crafted alongside the governor's office and has support from the Michigan Department of Education.
While Tisdel's plan would place different restrictions on students based on their grade level, Polehanki's proposal would require a district's school board or a charter school's board of directors to develop their own wireless communications device policy to limit cell phone use during school hours and cut down on distractions.
Tisdel's plan would:
Prohibit students in Kindergarten through grade 5 from possessing a wireless communication device on school grounds
Block students in grades six through eight from using a wireless communication device on school grounds during instructional time, breaks between instruction, lunch and recess.
Bar students in grades nine through 12 from using a wireless communication device during instruction time.
The school board and board of directors can also implement additional restrictions.
'It's important to me that our bill is not too prescriptive. I do believe that school districts should have control over exactly what their cell phone policies say. School districts know what's best for themselves,' said Polehanki, who taught high school for almost 20 years.
Polehanki's proposal also includes exceptions for emergency situations, medical devices and devices included in a student's individualized education plan, and permits a school's principal to create further exceptions.
'I am personally not comfortable with any legislation that would put an outright ban on a cell phone in the era of the school shootings,' Polehanki said.
'I just don't believe in an outright ban, but some schools may choose to do that. But the beauty of this bill is it's up to them,' she said.
Heading into the 2024-2025 school year, an increasing number of states began implementing or weighing cell phone bans, with the U.S. Surgeon General issuing two advisories on social media use and youth mental health.
Independent Health Policy Organization KFF reports as of March 5, 2025, nine states had banned or restricted cell phone use in schools, while 16 others, including Michigan, were considering restrictions.
The Columbia University Department of Psychiatry notes studies have found a link between heavy social media use and depression, anxiety, loneliness, and suicidal ideation.
While cell phone use in classrooms can be a problem, cell phone policies do work, Polehanki said. However these policies need to be understood and enforced, she said, and having district-level policy can help that.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
12-08-2025
- Chicago Tribune
Gov. JB Pritzker again makes Nazi comparisons after President Trump threatens DC-like takeover in Chicago
Gov. JB Pritzker on Monday likened President Donald Trump's call for possible National Guard troops occupying Chicago to when the Nazi Party in Germany 'tore down a constitutional republic' in the 1930s. One day after after Pritzker said he wouldn't rule out a presidential run in 2028, his remarks at a north suburban school district continued his war of words with Trump, who earlier in the day actually elevated Pritzker's presidential aspirations by saying of Pritzker 'maybe he has a chance' even as he insulted the Democratic governor. Trump brought up Chicago — as well as the major Democratic cities New York and Los Angeles — as he announced he was mobilizing the District of Columbia National Guard to address crime in the nation's capital, even though the crime rate in the city has fallen in recent years. 'If we need to, we're going to do the same thing in Chicago, which is a disaster,' Trump said before calling Chicago's mayor 'incompetent' — without naming Mayor Brandon Johnson — and saying the same of Pritzker and then poking fun at the governor's presidential ambitions. 'And now I understand he wants to be president. But I noticed he lost a little weight, so maybe he has a chance, you know? You never know what happens,' the president said Monday of the governor. 'But Pritzker's a gross incompetent guy.' Pritzker's political team didn't miss a beat, posting on the social media site X, 'Donald, thanks for the compliment!' before adding: 'Let's not lie to the public, you and I both know you have no authority to take over Chicago. By the way, where are the Epstein files?' — referring to the ongoing controversy regarding the investigative files of deceased sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein that reportedly include Trump's name. At the school event in Wheeling on Monday, Pritzker said Trump 'has absolutely no right and no legal ability to send troops into the city of Chicago, and so I reject that notion,' before further criticizing the president for his felony conviction last year in a hush-money case in New York, accusing him of defrauding his business partners, and saying, 'He cheats at golf, too.' 'You've seen that he doesn't follow the law,' Pritzker said. 'I have talked about the fact that the Nazis in Germany in the '30s tore down a constitutional republic in just 53 days. It does not take much, frankly, and we have a president who seems hell-bent on doing just that.' Pritzker previously made a comparison between Trump's second term and the rise of the Nazi Party in Germany. During his State of the State speech earlier this year, the governor, who is Jewish, likened the actions of Trump and his administration to the quick rise of Nazism in Germany, adding that he was 'watching with a foreboding dread what is happening in our country right now. … The authoritarian playbook is laid bare here.' The back-and-forth occurred one day after Pritzker said on NBC's 'Meet the Press' that he 'can't rule anything out' when asked about the possibility of running for president even as he runs for a rare third term as Illinois governor. On Monday, Pritzker said he loves the job as governor and insisted the 'only decision' he's made so far about his political future is his bid for a third term as governor. 'My comments about anything else really were that I am guided to a large degree and almost everything I do in my life about what I think is best for the people of the state of Illinois, and I continue to be guided by that,' he said. Mayor Johnson also fired back at Trump following the president's comments about him and Chicago, accusing Trump of spreading misinformation about crime in major cities and saying that 'if President Trump wants to help make Chicago safer, he can start by releasing the funds for anti-violence programs that have been critical to our work to drive down crime and violence. Sending in the (National Guard) would only serve to destabilize our city and undermine our public safety efforts.' Earlier this summer, Trump sent troops to Los Angeles, another Democratic enclave, to crack down on some unrest that resulted from protests over federal immigration authorities trying to carry out mass deportations. But on Monday in San Francisco, a trial began to determine whether the president violated federal law by deploying the guard to LA without the approval of California's Democratic governor, Gavin Newsom, another ardent Trump critic and possible 2028 presidential contender. Chicago, New York, Los Angeles and Washington, D.C., have all seen drops in crime and violence. For example, Chicago's 240 homicides recorded through Aug. 3 are 48% lower than the 463 slayings the city tallied during the same period four years ago, according to official Chicago Police Department statistics. Total shootings — fatal and nonfatal — have dropped by 57% compared with the same period four years ago, the statistics show. At the event in Wheeling, Pritzker also took on Trump's Health and Human Services secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has been often accused of peddling falsehoods about immunizations. At an event encouraging students to get immunized before the school year begins, Pritzker touted the benefits of getting vaccinated during childhood against measles, whooping cough and other diseases. 'Given what's happening at the federal government's health department, it's fitting that we are hosting this event as our children head back to school, because frankly some of our leaders in Washington need to head back to school to educate themselves about the safety and effectiveness of vaccines,' Pritzker said, flanked by various health and education officials in Wheeling. 'We teach our kids to listen to experts rather than conspiracy theorists. The kids here are well-educated so that they won't make bad decisions in life. We hope they won't, and they're taught not to. 'But I hope the uneducated skeptics, like maybe a Cabinet secretary or two, are out there listening,' Pritzker said, without mentioning Kennedy by name. 'So, I can offer them a quick reminder: Routine childhood vaccines are undeniably effective.'
The Hill
10-08-2025
- The Hill
Pritzker leaves potential 2028 presidential run up in the air: ‘I can't rule anything out'
Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker (D) on Sunday said he's not ruling 'anything out' when it comes to a potential 2028 presidential bid. 'I'm focused on running for reelection as Governor of the State of Illinois, and everything that I do really is focused on lifting up the people of my state,' he said to NBC's Kristen Welker on 'Meet the Press.' However, he continued saying, 'I can't rule anything out, but what I can rule in is that no matter what decisions I make, and I mean in particular about what I do here in the State of Illinois is about the people of Illinois. Indeed, any future decisions of mine will always be guided by that.' Pritzker announced his reelection campaign for a third term as governor on June 26. 'I'm running for reelection to protect our progress and continue solving the problems we face. I love this state, and it's the honor of my life to serve as your governor — to help lead through the most challenging of times and celebrate the most joyful ones together,' he said. Pritzker has been one of the biggest critics of the Trump administration in the Democratic Party, which has ramped up speculation that he might run for president in 2028. In February, during his State of the State address, Pritzker compared Trump's new term with Nazi Germany. During the 2024 election, he was also considered as a potential vice presidential candidate to run alongside former Vice President Harris before Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz was ultimately picked. He has also been in the spotlight this past week amid the tit-for-tat redistricting war in Texas. He adamantly criticized the president, saying that Trump was 'trying to steal five seats from the people.' Pritzker said he would block any efforts to arrest Democratic lawmakers in the state who fled Texas to block a GOP effort to pick up five additional House seats in the midterm elections. 'They're here in Illinois. We're going to do everything we can to protect every single one of them and make sure that — 'cause we know they're doing the right thing, we know that they're following the law,' said Pritzker.
CBS News
24-07-2025
- CBS News
Michigan lawmaker proposes bill that would encourage public schools teach cursive again
A Michigan lawmaker has introduced legislation that would develop a statewide cursive curriculum for public schools. State Rep. Brenda Carter, D-Pontiac, introduced House Bill No. 4675 in late June. If passed, the bill calls for the Michigan Department of Education to develop a list of model programs for cursive handwriting instruction by no later than June 1, 2027. While the bill would not require school districts, beginning with the 2027–28 school year, they would be encouraged to incorporate one of the model programs into their curriculum. Cursive had regularly been taught in Michigan schools, but the requirement was dropped from the state's curriculum in 2010. "Many children today are not being taught how to read or write in cursive — a foundational skill that not only enables them to sign their own name, but also gives them access to important historical documents, including many of our nation's founding texts," Carter said in a statement. Carter previously introduced similar legislation during each of her three prior terms. "I'm going to keep going to bat for this policy because of how important it is," she said. "This is a commonsense step to help ensure our students aren't left behind when it comes to a skill that connects them to both practical tasks and our shared history and culture." Carter says previous attempts received bipartisan support in the House but stalled in the Senate. The current bill has been referred to the House Committee on Education and Workforce, which has yet to hear it. Currently, 24 states require some form of cursive to be taught in public schools, according to Education Week.
