logo
Vive La Resistance! The Heroes Who Oppose Genocide

Vive La Resistance! The Heroes Who Oppose Genocide

Scoop16-07-2025
Nobody has a bad word to say about the French Resistance in World War II, right? Who would criticise a group confronting fascism, right? Yet this month the UK group Palestine Action has been proscribed as a terrorist organisation by their government for their non-violent direct action against UK-based industries supplying technology to fuel Israel's destruction of the Palestinian people. Are they terrorists or the very best of us in the West?
Stéphane Hessel, a leading member of the French Resistance, survived time in Nazi concentration camps, including Buchenwald. After the war he was one of the co-authors of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), a pillar of international law to this day. The Declaration affirms the inherent dignity and equal rights of all humans. In later years Hessel (d.2013), who was Jewish, saw the treatment of the Palestinians as an affront to this and repeatedly called Israel out for crimes against humanity.
Hessel argued people needed to be outraged just as he and his fellow fighters had been during the war. In 2010 he said: 'Today, my strongest feeling of indignation is over Palestine, both the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. The starting point of my outrage was the appeal launched by courageous Israelis to the Diaspora: you, our older siblings, come and see where our leaders are taking this country and how they are forgetting the fundamental human values of Judaism.'
In his book Indignez-vous (Time for Outrage!) he called for a 'peaceful insurrection' and pointed to some of the non-violent forms of protests Palestinians had used over the years.
'The Israeli authorities have described these marches as 'nonviolent terrorism.' Not bad… One would have to be Israeli to describe nonviolence as terrorism.'
How wrong Stéphane Hessel was on this point. The British Parliament has just proscribed Palestine Action as terrorists despite them having never attacked anyone, never used weapons but only undertaken destruction of property linked to the arms industry.
Does Palestine Action really bear resemblance to Al Qaeda or ISIS, or Israel's Stern Gang or the IDF? Or, like the French Resistance, will they eventually be recognized as heroes of our time? Will Hollywood romanticize them in their usual tardy way in 50 years time?
In respect to the Palestinians, Hessel was clear that resistance could take many forms: 'We must recognize that when a country is occupied by infinitely superior military means, the popular reaction cannot be only nonviolent,' he said. In his time, he lived by those words.
Resistance - a precious band of brothers and sisters
Here's a statistic that should make you think. In the Second World War less than 2% of French people played any active role in the Resistance. Most people just sat back and got on with their lives whether they liked the Germans or didn't. The Jews and others were dealt to, stamped on and shipped out, while most of the French could trundle on unharassed. The heavy lifting of resistance was done by a small band of brothers and sisters who took it to the enemy. History salutes them, as we now salute the Suffragettes, the anti-Apartheid activists, the American civil rights groups and Irish liberation fighters. We're living through something similar now – and our governments are the bad guys.
I first learned that shocking fact about the composition of the Resistance from my history teacher at L'Université de Franche-Comté, in France in the 1980s. He was the distinguished historian Antoine Casanova, a specialist on Napoleon, Corsica and the Resistance.
Perhaps the low level of resistance is not surprising. Most of the people who put their bodies on the line in Occupied France during WWII were either communists or Jews. Good on them. Jewish people made up as much as 20% of the French Resistance despite numbering only about 1% of the population. This massive over-representation can, understandably, be explained as recognition of the existential threat they faced – but many were also passionate communists or socialists, the ideological enemies of the racist, fascist ideology of their occupiers. Looking at the Israeli State today, many of those same Jewish Resistance fighters would instantly recognize the racism and fascism that they opposed in the 1940s. We should remember our leaders tell us we share values with Israel.
For anyone not in the United Kingdom (where it is illegal to show any support for Palestine Action) I highly recommend the recently released documentary To Kill A War Machine which gives an absolutely riveting account of both the direct action the group has undertaken and the moral and ideological underpinnings of their actions. Having seen the documentary I can see why the British Labour government is doing everything in its power to silence and censor them. They really do expose who the true terrorists are. Stéphane Hessel would be proud of Palestine Action.
This week a former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert made clear what is going on in Gaza.
The 'humanitarian city' Israel is planning to build on the ruins of Rafah would be, in his words, a concentration camp. Others have described it as a Warsaw-ghetto or a death camp. Olmert says Israel is clearly committing war crimes in both Gaza and the West Bank and that the concentration camp for the Gazan population would mark a further escalation.
It would go beyond ethnic cleansing and take the Jewish State of Israel shoulder-to-shoulder with other regimes that built such camps. Israel, we should never forget, is our close ally.
Millions of people have hit the streets in Western countries. A majority clearly repudiate what the US and Israel are doing. But the big Western countries continue to enable the racist, fascist genocidal state of Israel to do its evil work. Lesser powers of the white-dominated broederbond, like Australia and New Zealand, also provide valuable support.
Until our populations in the West mobilise in sufficient numbers to force change on our increasingly criminal ruling elites, the heavy-lifting done by groups like Palestine Action will remain powerful forms of the resistance.
I grew up in the Catholic faith. One of the lines indelibly printed on my consciousness was: 'Greater love hath no man than this, that he lay down his life for his friends.' Palestine Action is doing that. Francesca Albanese is doing that. Justice for Palestine and Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa are doing this. The real question, the burning question each of us must answer is – given there is no middle ground, there is no fence to sit on when it comes to genocide – whose side are you on? And what are you going to do about it? Vive la Resistance. Vive the defenders of the Palestinian cause.
Rest in Peace Stéphane Hessel. Le temps passe, le souvenir reste.
Eugene Doyle
Eugene Doyle is a writer based in Wellington. He has written extensively on the Middle East, as well as peace and security issues in the Asia Pacific region. He hosts the public policy platform solidarity.co.nz.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Britain and France talk of recognising a Palestinian state. What would it mean?
Britain and France talk of recognising a Palestinian state. What would it mean?

NZ Herald

time3 hours ago

  • NZ Herald

Britain and France talk of recognising a Palestinian state. What would it mean?

That assault killed about 1200 people and led to the abduction of about 250 others to Gaza. The announcements raise questions about what the recognition of a Palestinian state would mean and what it can actually do. British Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaks during a meeting with US President Donald Trump at the Trump Turnberry golf club in Turnberry, Scotland, on Tuesday. Photo / Tierney L. Cross, the New York Times What is a state? The criteria for statehood were laid out in an international treaty in 1933. They include four elements: a permanent population; defined territorial boundaries; a government; and an ability to conduct international affairs. Recognition is an official acknowledgement that a would-be state broadly meets those conditions. It can occur even if an element is in dispute, including territorial boundaries. Like all legal questions, 'interpretation matters', said Zinaida Miller, a professor of law and international affairs at Northeastern University in the United States. The criteria for recognising a Palestinian state have been met at a basic level, many experts on international law say. A permanent population and land exist. The borders, while disputed, are broadly understood to be in Israeli-occupied territories, including the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, which was seized in 1967 in a war with a coalition of Arab states; as well as East Jerusalem, which Israel has effectively annexed. The Palestinian Authority is a government body that administers part of the West Bank and represents Palestinians. Its creation was authorised by the Palestine Liberation Organisation, which represents Palestinians internationally. While there are limits to what the Palestinian Authority can do, given the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Hamas' control of Gaza, foreign recognition of a Palestinian state would mean the establishment of direct diplomatic contact between the authority and the recognising nation. Recognition would also send diplomatic and political messages. It would acknowledge the Palestinian right to self-determination and reject the positions and actions of the Israeli Government that undermine that right, Miller said. 'A basis for added pressure.' A major consequence of recognising Palestinian statehood is that it provides a basis for 'a complete revision of bilateral relations with Israel', said Ardi Imseis, an associate professor at Queen's University Faculty of Law in Ontario and a former United Nations official. A country that recognises Palestine has to review agreements with Israel to make sure they do not violate its obligations to the Palestinian state. This would include political and territorial integrity, as well as economic, cultural, social and civil relations, he said. For example, if an aspect of trade aids or assists Israel in violation of the rights of a Palestinian state, then the recognising nation would have to cease that exchange. 'Practically speaking, recognition would provide a basis for added pressure to be brought to bear by civil society and lawmakers in the recognising state' to change policies and align them with other requirements, Imseis said. A recognising nation would not have to stop all trade with Israel, said Paul Reichler, a lawyer who represents sovereign states and has argued for the state of Palestine at the International Court of Justice. But if, for example, a country that recognises a state of Palestine imports agricultural products from farms belonging to settlers in occupied territories, those agreements would be aiding and abetting the commission of a wrongful act, he said. International law experts note that an advisory ruling from the International Court of Justice last year concluded, among other things, that the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories violated a prohibition on territorial conquest. A UN majority for recognition already exists. Most countries in the United Nations — 147 out of 193 — already recognise a Palestinian state. Britain and France would be joining them, and their position has extra heft because they are permanent members of the UN Security Council, with the power to veto any substantive council resolution, including on the admission of new member states. The two countries would be bolstering the stance taken by most other nations and sending a political message, but their shift would also have a practical effect. They would join China and Russia in recognising a Palestinian state and leave the US as the sole permanent member of the Security Council with veto power that is holding out. The state of Palestine currently has observer status at the UN, and that will not change if the US maintains its opposition to full membership. Prime Minister of Israel Benjamin Netanyahu. Photo / Eric Lee, the New York Times What is the goal of recognition? It is part of a political, diplomatic, and legal push to reach a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict despite resistance from Israel's current government. 'There are two peoples living between the river and the sea, not one, and they are entitled to separate states in which each of these peoples enjoys the full panoply of civil and human rights,' Reichler said. 'The only solution is two states, and it so happens that is what international law requires and is reflected in UN resolutions and in determinations of the ICJ,' he said. Although the declarations of Palestinian statehood may appear symbolic, 'small steps' like recognition 'make a contribution' to the goal of establishing two states, he said. Some nations, like Norway, once held off recognising a Palestinian state in the belief that recognition would someday emerge from a negotiated peace process. With such a process seemingly currently out of reach and outrage over Israeli policies growing, some countries have put recognition first in the hope that it would lead to a peace process. Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has said that the establishment of a Palestinian state would endanger Israel's security, and he has rejected the notion, particularly since the war in Gaza began. His governing coalition includes far-right ministers who are settlers and staunchly opposed to a Palestinian state, and he risks their abandoning the bloc if he indicates a willingness to consider it. In a statement yesterday, Netanyahu said Britain's announcement 'rewards Hamas' monstrous terrorism and punishes its victims'. This article originally appeared in The New York Times. Written by: Ephrat Livni Photographs by: Saher Alghorra, Tierney L. Cross, Eric Lee ©2025 THE NEW YORK TIMES

Trump wants Netanyahu to 'make sure they get the food' in Gaza amid crisis
Trump wants Netanyahu to 'make sure they get the food' in Gaza amid crisis

1News

time3 hours ago

  • 1News

Trump wants Netanyahu to 'make sure they get the food' in Gaza amid crisis

President Donald Trump on Tuesday expressed concern over the worsening humanitarian situation in Gaza and urged Israel to get people food, seemingly recalibrating his stance on Gaza as images of emaciated children have sparked renewed worries about hunger in the war-torn territory. Trump, speaking in Scotland on Tuesday, said that the US and other nations are giving money and food to Gaza but that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has 'got to sort of like run it'. 'I want him to make sure they get the food,' Trump said. 'I want to make sure they get the food.' President Donald Trump and Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer, left, speak with the media during a meeting at the Trump Turnberry golf course in Turnberry, Scotland. (Source: Associated Press) Trump's comments seemed to result from the images in recent days of the worsening hunger crisis in Gaza and were more urgent than the resigned message he had about the 21-month Israel-Hamas war last week, when ceasefire talks derailed. His remarks also marked a new divergence from Netanyahu after the two leaders had become closer following their nations' joint strikes in Iran. ADVERTISEMENT The US president was asked if he agreed with Netanyahu's comments on Monday in which the Israeli leader said, 'There is no policy of starvation in Gaza and there is no starvation in Gaza'. 'I don't know," Trump replied. "I mean, based on television, I would say not particularly because those children look very hungry.' Trump says US will set up food centres in Gaza Palestinians carry sacks of flour unloaded from a humanitarian aid convoy that reached Gaza City from the northern Gaza Strip, Sunday, July 27, 2025. (Source: Associated Press) In the face of mounting international criticism, the Israeli military over the weekend began airdrops of aid, along with limited pauses in fighting in three populated areas of Gaza for 10 hours a day to help with the distribution. Trump on Saturday had expressed some resignation about the situation in Gaza after the US and Israel pulled their negotiating teams out of talks in Qatar to try to reach a ceasefire. Trump said last week that Hamas was likely 'going to be hunted down' and said of Israel, 'They're going to have to fight and they're going to have to clean it up'. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including the atmospheric river arrives, Epstein's girlfriend pushes for appeal, and Jennifer Lopez's wardrobe malfunction. (Source: Breakfast) ADVERTISEMENT But Trump seemed more inclined to action on Tuesday after reports of starvation-related deaths and images of people, especially young children and infants, struggling to get food continued to emerge over the weekend, drew international outcry. The US President, speaking as he visited with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer at his Trump's Turnberry golf course, said that the US was 'going to set up food centres,' but he didn't offer specifics. The White House did not immediately have more information about the food centres. International outcry grows louder Yazan Abu Ful, a 2-year-old malnourished child, sits at his family home in the Shati refugee camp in Gaza City on Wednesday, July 23, 2025. (Source: Associated Press) While Trump urged Netanyahu to do more to deliver aid, the US leader faced similar pleas. Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sissi said in a televised address on Tuesday that Trump is 'the one who is able to stop the war, deliver the aid and end this suffering". ADVERTISEMENT 'Please, make every effort to stop this war and deliver the aid,' el-Sissi said, addressing Trump in his remarks 'I believe that it's time to end this war.' Trump said Hamas has stolen food and aid trying to reach people in Gaza, but when asked by a reporter about what responsibility Israel has for limiting aid to the area, he said, 'Israel has a lot of responsibility'. But he quickly said Israel was also hampered in its actions as it seeks to keep the remaining 20 hostages kept in Gaza alive. An aircraft airdrops humanitarian aid over northern Gaza Strip as seen from southern Israel, Monday, July 28, 2025. (Source: Associated Press) When asked by what more can Israel do, Trump said, 'I think Israel can do a lot'. But he didn't offer more details and changed the subject to Iran. 'We have to help on a humanitarian basis before we do anything. We have to get the kids fed.' Starmer was more adamant than Trump, calling it 'a desperate situation' in Gaza. ADVERTISEMENT 'I think people in Britain are revolted at seeing what they are seeing on their screens,' he said. Vice President JD Vance echoed Trump's comments as he spoke Tuesday in Canton, Ohio and said the US was worried about the humanitarian problem in Gaza and seeing 'a lot of starving children'. 'Israel's got to do more to let that aid in, and we've also got to wage war on Hamas so that those folks stop preventing food from coming into this territory,' he said. US and UK leaders discuss Gaza as UN discusses Israel-Palestinian two-state solution Palestinians carry sacks of flour unloaded from a humanitarian aid convoy that reached Gaza City from the northern Gaza Strip, Sunday, July 27, 2025. (Source: Associated Press) Starmer, who faces pressure from his Labour Party to recognise a Palestinian state as France did last week, said the UK supports statehood for the Palestinians, but it must be part of a plan for a two-state solution. Trump said last week that France's recognition of a Palestinian state 'doesn't carry any weight'. ADVERTISEMENT 'I'm not going to take a position,' Trump said of recognising a Palestinian state. He added of Starmer, 'I don't mind him taking a position'. The comments came as the UN General Assembly brought together high-level officials to promote a two-state solution to the decades-old Israel-Palestinian conflict. Israel and the US are boycotting the two-day meeting.

Israel plays the hunger games
Israel plays the hunger games

Otago Daily Times

time3 hours ago

  • Otago Daily Times

Israel plays the hunger games

When it comes to the shocking actions the government of Israel is perpetrating on the people of Gaza, it is difficult to know how to express that indignation in suitably strong terms. The images of malnourished and starving Palestinian children appear daily. As understandable as it is that some cannot bear this sight and chose not to watch, we must make sure we don't turn away from them and from the awful realities of our world. They need us for their very survival and to later hold the war criminals to account. This is not the first time we have seen famine in recent decades, especially across parts of North and sub-Saharan Africa. More than 70 million people died from hunger in the 20th century, and many tens of thousands succumbed to acute malnutrition in recent famines in South Sudan and Somalia. Famine is of course a consequence of more than just crop failures for whatever reason. They are also the result of the malign influences of human behaviour, such as wars and political instability, and the inability to get food supplies where they need to be for whatever reason. What we are witnessing in Gaza is a deliberate stopping of desperate human beings from reaching food and aid. This is a despicable act, made even more shameful by the apparently indiscriminate killing of civilians by the members of the Israeli Defence Force. Almost 1000 Gazans have been shot dead or blasted by mortars or tank fire in the past two months while queueing for food. In the latest outrage on Monday, Israeli soldiers opened fire at food-collection sites killing at least 40 civilians. The civilised world is, naturally, appalled — just as it was shocked by the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel that killed 1200 people and resulted in a further 251 people being taken hostage. After nearly every shooting at a food-aid post, Israel's military either claims it knows nothing about the incident or its soldiers were feeling threatened by the crowds of Gazans. Meanwhile, Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is keeping up the pretence that nobody is starving in Gaza, calling it a "bold-faced lie" to say Israel is responsible. "There is no policy of starvation in Gaza. And there is no starvation in Gaza. We enabled humanitarian aid throughout the duration of the war to enter Gaza, otherwise there would be no Gazans," he said. Even United States President Donald Trump, not known for his humanitarian approach — and perhaps Mr Netanyahu's only remaining political ally — has expressed disgust for the situation and says he doesn't agree with his claims that nobody is starving. Mr Trump this week told the Israeli government to let "every ounce of food" into Gaza and said Israel bore "a lot of responsibility" for the crisis. "Some of those kids ... that's real starvation. I see it and you can't fake that." Airdrops of food and aid now being allowed into Gaza are widely condemned as far too little to make a difference when trucks with thousands of tonnes of supplies are being blocked from entering. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency head Philippe Lazzarini says "outrage and condemnation are no longer adequate for what is unfolding". Israeli human rights groups are standing up and accusing the government of carrying out a genocide. By not shouting vociferously about Israel's crimes in Gaza, many countries risk appearing complicit in those actions. The world needs to express its abject outrage about these barbarities and leave the Israeli government in no doubt it is now a pariah. 'Uffin and puffing Yes, Tauranga National MP Sam Uffindell, in your own words "how stupid do you have to be?" Looking for an easy target to shore up the government's views on council spending, Mr Uffindell hyperfocused and hyperventilated over the George St, Dunedin, revamp and the supposed $600,000 cost of one seesaw. Get your facts right. Three seesaws cost $244,700 in a total play space development of $586,000. As you said yourself, Mr Uffindell, "get yourselves in order".

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store