Dolphin catch increase could be ‘random'
PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES
A sixfold increase in dolphin captures since the introduction of onboard cameras could be due to a range of factors, including "random fluctuations", Seafood New Zealand says.
Fisheries New Zealand science and information director Simon Lawrence told the Otago Daily Times there had been a sustained change in reporting across the vessels within scope of the onboard cameras rollout and by last month, there had been 6.1 times more reported dolphin interactions since cameras had been on board fishing vessels.
Forest & Bird earlier this week said the increase suggested suspected under-reporting was in fact happening.
However, now Seafood New Zealand inshore general manager Tiffany Bock said there could be other factors at play.
"Yes, more dolphin interactions have been reported.
"We agree that it's good to have this information out there.
"The change is due to a number of things.
"We can't rule out random fluctuations, because we are talking about relatively small numbers (although obviously we want these numbers to get much smaller, fast).
"Also it is true that fishers are taking way more care about the reporting process.
"This is a good thing."
It was important to consider that before cameras, the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) was "always allowing for a certain amount of under-reporting in their calculations" of protected species interactions, Ms Bock said.
"Now we have cameras, we know their calculations were pretty accurate."
Furthermore, potential changes MPI was considering would only limit public access to the footage captured by onboard cameras, not the information gleaned from them, she said.
When announcing proposed amendments to the Fisheries Act in February, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones said he wanted to address industry concerns about "sensitive footage" from cameras on fishing boats.
Yesterday, Ms Bock said it was "really important for the public to know" that they would not be losing access to information about accidental captures of protected species under the proposed changes.
MPI published quarterly data about bycatch of protected species on its website and that would not stop, she said.
"Everyone will still be able to see how many birds, reptiles and marine mammals have been captured by fishing vessels and whether they were released alive and uninjured, alive and injured or dead.
"This information is put together from observers on fishing vessels and from what MPI officials see via cameras.
"It will continue to be published and is in no way affected by the proposed legislative changes."
hamish.maclean@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Pines, wallaby programmes set to continue
A $2 million work programme to control wilding pines and eradicate wallabies from Otago appears set to continue amid delays from the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) and no funding agreement in place. Otago regional councillors will tomorrow consider a staff proposal to continue the Otago Regional Council work programme on the National Wilding Conifer Control Programme and the Tipu Mātoro National Wallaby Eradication Programme from the beginning of this financial year on July 1, "even if there is a delay in the signing of the agreements with MPI". "For the last two years there has been a delay in MPI issuing the funding agreements for the Wilding Conifer Programme and Tipu Mātoro Wallaby Programme to council for signing," a council staff report said. "This delay has created issues for delivery of both national programmes. "To address this delay, it is proposed that council starts the delivery of works for the National Wilding Conifer Control Programme and the Tipu Mātoro Wallaby Programme from July 1, 2025, even if the goods and services agreements are not yet signed. "The council biosecurity budget can carry the financial risk, until signed agreements are received, to ensure continuity and effective delivery of the programmes." The report said from 2016 to last year the national programme had spent $140m in wilding pine control nationally. From July 1, last year, funding of $10m a year had been committed by MPI to the national programme. The council had entered two previous funding agreements on pine control, the report said. One was from 2020 to 2024 and a second one was for the 2024-25 financial year, which expired at the end of this month. There had been discussion with Biosecurity New Zealand staff and there was an understanding there would be a new five-year deal with variations for annual funding on offer. However, MPI had not yet provided the council with a draft agreement to replace the agreement that was expiring, the report said. Likewise, after the council established an Otago Wallaby Programme following increased sightings of the pests in 2016, the Tipu Mātoro National Wallaby Eradication Programme was set up in 2020. The national programme was given $27m over the next four years for control of populations outside of containment areas, such as the one in South Canterbury. Again, the council signed a 2020-24 four-year deal and a subsequent one-year deal that was due to expire at the end of this month, the report said. In the case of wallaby control, MPI had provided a draft agreement, the report said. Like the expected wilding control agreement, it was a five-year deal with variable annual funding, it said. The report said council staff had informed MPI officials the delays were having an effect on the council's processes. Staff would continue to argue funding delays should be "reduced" to make sure the programmes were delivered "as efficient and effective as possible". In order to get the work started, it was proposed that the council get to work on the control programmes with the understanding the funding agreements would arrive and chief executive Richard Saunders would sign them on the council's behalf if there were no surprises. "It is proposed that the work programmes may commence prior to signed funding agreements with MPI, if these are not provided early enough in the financial year," the report said. "Funding is highly likely to still be provided by the government, there will just be a delay due to how their systems work." For wilding pine work, it was expected the council's obligations would be the same as last year and $1.07m would be received from MPI. The council was expecting $950,000 for wallaby work, the report said. Biosecurity New Zealand pest management director John Walsh told the Otago Daily Times yesterday the funding was secure. "Biosecurity New Zealand recognises that a delay to release funding has caused some issues for the council. However, there has been no reduction in funding available and we've been working collaboratively with the council to support the delivery of these programmes," he said.
Otago Daily Times
28-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
‘Bat' photo not worth batting an eye over
Bat, leaves, rubbish bag or black undies? PHOTO: SUPPLIED A grainy photo taken in a Dunedin park which sent social media batty was probably just a clump of leaves. Biosecurity New Zealand and the Department of Conservation (Doc) said they were investigating a possible sighting of a native Australian bat in a Dunedin park after a grainy photograph, first published on social media platform Reddit, got a lot of attention online. However, yesterday Biosecurity New Zealand animal health incursion investigations team manager Kelly Buckle said the investigation had concluded and no evidence of exotic bats was found. Staff conducted a search of the park where the suspected bats were observed, Ms Buckle said. No non-native bats were found, neither was any evidence of the presence of exotic bats. Further, the ''poor resolution of the image'' supplied to Biosecurity New Zealand meant bat experts could not identify any visible physical characteristics typical of bats. ''There isn't an obvious pathway for flying foxes to accidentally arrive and survive in Dunedin. ''On balance and given the distance from which the suspected bats were observed, it is possible that the bat-like objects were in fact leaf clusters that resemble the shape of flying foxes.'' When the Otago Daily Times reported yesterday that Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) and Doc were investigating the possible sighting, readers also questioned whether the image was indeed a bat. ''Someone has a good imagination,'' one reader said. ''Wonderful artistic use of a black plastic rubbish bag,'' another said. ''Dried-up leaf - it is autumn,'' yet another said. ''Or a pair of black undies, everyone's gone batty.'' Previously, MPI said there had only ever been two exotic bat finds within New Zealand's borders, both were little red flying foxes. One was found dead in 1926 southeast of Hamilton and another in Marlborough in 2024. — APL
Otago Daily Times
22-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Dolphin catch increase could be ‘random'
PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES A sixfold increase in dolphin captures since the introduction of onboard cameras could be due to a range of factors, including "random fluctuations", Seafood New Zealand says. Fisheries New Zealand science and information director Simon Lawrence told the Otago Daily Times there had been a sustained change in reporting across the vessels within scope of the onboard cameras rollout and by last month, there had been 6.1 times more reported dolphin interactions since cameras had been on board fishing vessels. Forest & Bird earlier this week said the increase suggested suspected under-reporting was in fact happening. However, now Seafood New Zealand inshore general manager Tiffany Bock said there could be other factors at play. "Yes, more dolphin interactions have been reported. "We agree that it's good to have this information out there. "The change is due to a number of things. "We can't rule out random fluctuations, because we are talking about relatively small numbers (although obviously we want these numbers to get much smaller, fast). "Also it is true that fishers are taking way more care about the reporting process. "This is a good thing." It was important to consider that before cameras, the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) was "always allowing for a certain amount of under-reporting in their calculations" of protected species interactions, Ms Bock said. "Now we have cameras, we know their calculations were pretty accurate." Furthermore, potential changes MPI was considering would only limit public access to the footage captured by onboard cameras, not the information gleaned from them, she said. When announcing proposed amendments to the Fisheries Act in February, Oceans and Fisheries Minister Shane Jones said he wanted to address industry concerns about "sensitive footage" from cameras on fishing boats. Yesterday, Ms Bock said it was "really important for the public to know" that they would not be losing access to information about accidental captures of protected species under the proposed changes. MPI published quarterly data about bycatch of protected species on its website and that would not stop, she said. "Everyone will still be able to see how many birds, reptiles and marine mammals have been captured by fishing vessels and whether they were released alive and uninjured, alive and injured or dead. "This information is put together from observers on fishing vessels and from what MPI officials see via cameras. "It will continue to be published and is in no way affected by the proposed legislative changes."
