Pledges v reality: fact-checking the Weca mayoral election
The candidates drew lots to determine their order of appearance.First up is independent Ian Scott, who talks of a "new Frenchay Community Hospital and Urgent Treatment Centre". However, the Weca mayor has no powers over health provision.
Steve Smith, the Conservative candidate, advocates "stopping congestion-creating schemes like the A4 bus lane between Bath and Bristol".He is referring to a 2023 proposal for a bus lane on the Keynsham bypass, but that has already been halted by Weca, and nearly all of the candidates would keep it that way.
Mary Page of the Greens ventures into economic matters, writing: "After 15 years of cuts… instead of us being better off, it's just the multi-millionaires."But independent experts do not agree.The Institute for Fiscal Studies says we are all in fact slightly better off than 15 years ago.
Next is Arron Banks of Reform, who criticises controversial road changes made by South Gloucestershire Council.He says he would "demand the re-opening of Thornbury High Street to cars".But in reality the road is not closed to cars; they can drive along the high street to pick up or drop off.
Like many candidates, Helen Godwin of Labour wants more trains.She says she will "secure new railway stations including Ashton Gate, St Anne's, Brabazon, Portishead, Saltford and Charfield".But no securing is needed for two of those; work is already under way for Brabazon and Charfield.By contrast, two others, St Anne's and Saltford, are long-term ideas with no agreed plan or funding, which will not come in the next four years.
The last to make his pledges is Liberal Democrat Oli Henman; he talks of "developing a mass rapid transit system".He means trams or a metro, as previously proposed in Bristol, and in his campaign he says he would deliver it.But costs would be huge, so that would also not happen in the next four-year mayoral term.
Other information in the booklet is more certain.Postal voting to choose the next West of England mayor is under way.Polling day is 1 May, and voters are reminded that they need to bring a valid photo ID.The count, and the result, will come overnight.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Treasury ‘looking at' new property taxes to replace stamp duty
Government officials are looking at a potential national property tax, which would replace stamp duty on owner-occupied homes, The Guardian reported. No final decision has been made, but it is thought this national tax could help build a model for local levies to replace council tax in the medium term. Buyers pay stamp duty under the existing framework, if they purchase property worth more than £125,000. The new levy would be paid by owner-occupiers on houses worth more than £500,000 when they sell their home, with the amount due determined by the value of the property and a rate set by the Government. A Treasury spokesperson said: 'As set out in the plan for change, the best way to strengthen public finances is by growing the economy – which is our focus. 'Changes to tax and spend policy are not the only ways of doing this, as seen with our planning reforms, which are expected to grow the economy by £6.8 billion and cut borrowing by £3.4 billion. 'We are committed to keeping taxes for working people as low as possible, which is why at last autumn's budget, we protected working people's payslips and kept our promise not to raise the basic, higher or additional rates of income tax, employee national insurance, or VAT.' Chancellor Rachel Reeves will unveil any changes to the Government's tax policy at a fiscal event, such as a budget. Former government adviser Tim Leunig has previously suggested replacing stamp duty land tax with a 'national proportional property tax' levied on house values greater than £500,000, in a paper published by the think tank Onward. At a rate of 0.54%, with a 0.278% supplement on values over £1 million, the levy 'would raise the same amount as stamp duty'. Sir Mel Stride, Conservative shadow chancellor, said: 'The Conservatives have warned that more taxes are coming and now reports are emerging that the family home is next in the firing line. 'This tax grab would punish families for aspiring to own their own home. 'Under Labour nothing is safe. Your home, your job, your pension – the Chancellor has all of it in her sights. 'Rachel Reeves will tax your future to pay for her failure.'
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Scottish Greens leadership contender on 'electoral risk' of focusing on climate
Ashmole, 58, is the only candidate in the party's co-leadership contest who is not an MSP, and will be third in the South Scotland list for the Greens. Despite this, he believes that being outside of the Holyrood machine would be an asset, allowing him to focus on grassroots campaigning and big picture climate change issues. 'I truly have no idea where I stand in the voting, I genuinely don't,' he told The National from his home in Peebles, Scottish Borders. While he believes he has plenty of local support, Ashmole isn't sure how this translates at the national level. He admits he has 'quite a different offering' compared to his competitors, Lorna Slater, Gillian Mackay and Ross Greer. READ MORE: I can take on 'climate change denying' Farage in TV debates, says Lorna Slater He insists that he doesn't want to 'bin' the party's current electoral strategy, but would take a different focus if he managed to secure one of the two co-leader roles up for grabs. One of the calls from the so-called Glasgow faction of the Greens, is that the party should focus on rooting itself in working-class communities. Ashmole, a research and development manager at a tech company in Edinburgh, admits he wouldn't describe himself as working class. However, he argued that politicians have a responsibility to help those struggling to heat their homes and pay bills, but also to have a 'credible' plan to tackle the fast-approaching threat of climate change. 'Most political parties just aren't going there because they know that people are struggling with all of those day-to-day concerns, and they want to talk about those concerns because they think that's where the votes are,' he said. 'And what I'm saying is that we've got to do both. If we aren't saying that the whole basis of actual survival on this planet is at risk within your children's lifetime, if we're not saying that, then who the hell is going to say it, right? And who the hell is going to deal with it? So I may be an electoral risk to the Greens … ' (Image: Scottish Greens/ Cami Glasgow) Asked to elaborate, Ashmole said that votes are 'typically won by talking about what's right in front of people's noses'. He said: 'I care about that stuff too – all I'm saying is that's not enough. 'We have to take responsibility, because we're meant to be providing political leadership in this country. Above all, the Greens are meant to be providing political leadership on issues of climate. These are matters of survival.' Ashmole added: 'I just want us to have both of those messages very loud and clear, and I think I'm probably of the four candidates the loudest and the clearest on that second category.' With the other candidates being MSPs, The National asked Ashmole how he would feel about an imbalance of being a co-leader outside of Holyrood, particularly in terms of media attention. READ MORE: Scots comedian to do one-off Fringe show while under house arrest 'I don't see it as a problem,' he said, adding that he would hope to be elected alongside a female co-leader. 'If there's an imbalance in favour of having our female Holyrood leader in the media a lot, that's fine with me,' he added. 'The natural tendency for them would be to focus on the policies that they are bringing through Holyrood and acting at the national level. 'There will be an entirely other niche for me, which is to talk about how well Scotland is preparing for the impact of climate change, to what extent both communities are prepared for the things that are coming our way. 'There's national action and Holyrood, and there's actually trying to co-opt the Scottish population to rise up and deal with the threats that are not being handled by modern politics, and realising the absolute horror of what is facing us.' Ashmole backed the Bute House Agreement, which brought Greens into government for the first time, and says he believes the MSPs did 'pretty well in the circumstances', after being handed 'broken' policies such as the ill-fated deposit return scheme. 'I think it's a fair criticism that we need to get better at communicating our policies and listening and working with communities to make sure that the solutions that we're proposing are not top down,' he added. 'That's another great reason for a co leader like myself, who's 100% out in the grassroots around the country, talking to councillors, talking to the membership, talking to local communities, finding out really what appropriate change looks like in the circumstances, rather than perhaps things that are too simplistic at a high level.' He insisted that there is a 'majority' of people in Scotland who are concerned about the looming climate catastrophe and that politicians are 'just fiddling around the edges'. 'I think they probably want to hear from us talking about that and talking about the implications of that as well, and that is what I will be doing,' Ashmole said.
South Wales Guardian
6 hours ago
- South Wales Guardian
Treasury ‘looking at' new property taxes to replace stamp duty
Government officials are looking at a potential national property tax, which would replace stamp duty on owner-occupied homes, The Guardian reported. No final decision has been made, but it is thought this national tax could help build a model for local levies to replace council tax in the medium term. Buyers pay stamp duty under the existing framework, if they purchase property worth more than £125,000. The new levy would be paid by owner-occupiers on houses worth more than £500,000 when they sell their home, with the amount due determined by the value of the property and a rate set by the Government. A Treasury spokesperson said: 'As set out in the plan for change, the best way to strengthen public finances is by growing the economy – which is our focus. 'Changes to tax and spend policy are not the only ways of doing this, as seen with our planning reforms, which are expected to grow the economy by £6.8 billion and cut borrowing by £3.4 billion. 'We are committed to keeping taxes for working people as low as possible, which is why at last autumn's budget, we protected working people's payslips and kept our promise not to raise the basic, higher or additional rates of income tax, employee national insurance, or VAT.' Chancellor Rachel Reeves will unveil any changes to the Government's tax policy at a fiscal event, such as a budget. Former government adviser Tim Leunig has previously suggested replacing stamp duty land tax with a 'national proportional property tax' levied on house values greater than £500,000, in a paper published by the think tank Onward. At a rate of 0.54%, with a 0.278% supplement on values over £1 million, the levy 'would raise the same amount as stamp duty'. Sir Mel Stride, Conservative shadow chancellor, said: 'The Conservatives have warned that more taxes are coming and now reports are emerging that the family home is next in the firing line. 'This tax grab would punish families for aspiring to own their own home. 'Under Labour nothing is safe. Your home, your job, your pension – the Chancellor has all of it in her sights. 'Rachel Reeves will tax your future to pay for her failure.'
