Brown University in GOP crosshairs after student's DOGE-like email kicks off frenzy
FIRST ON FOX: A brewing controversy over a "DOGE-like" email at one of America's top universities has gotten the attention of Capitol Hill.
Rep. Troy Nehls, R-Texas, wrote to Brown University on Friday morning urging the school to reconsider any disciplinary action against Alex Shieh, a sophomore who sent an email mirroring the style of Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) that asked non-faculty university workers what they did "all day."
"Reports indicate that Mr. Shieh engaged in a journalistic act of contacting university administrative employees to inquire about their roles and responsibilities. This action, it appears, stemmed from his perspective as a student paying a substantial tuition fee and experiencing concerns regarding university facilities, leading him to question the allocation of administrative resources," Nehls wrote.
"Penalizing a student for what appears to be an attempt to understand the university's administrative structure raises serious questions about the institution's commitment to open inquiry and the tolerance of dissenting viewpoints."
Brown University Student Angers Non-faculty Employees By Asking 'What Do You Do All Day,' Faces Punishment
He also demanded more information on how Brown uses its $7.2 billion endowment to lower tuition and better the lives of students.
Read On The Fox News App
It comes at a time when American Ivy Leagues have been thrust under the microscope by the Trump administration, both for their soaring tuition rates and controversies surrounding antisemitism on campus.
Shieh had created a database of the 3,805 non-faculty employees who worked at Brown University and emailed them to ask, "What do you do all day?"
He wrote on X that he had been given a disciplinary hearing after being "charged with misrepresentation and violating the IT policy."
Tuition alone at Brown University for the 2025-2026 academic year is $71,700. Fees, food, and housing charges bring that up to about $93,000 per year, according to the school's website — and with indirect charges, annual costs are estimated at nearly $96,000.
"I urge you to reconsider any disciplinary action taken against Mr. Shieh and to reaffirm Brown University's commitment to protecting the free expression of all its students," Nehls wrote.
"Additionally, below you can see screenshots from Brown's website showing the performance of its $7.2 billion endowment, boasting a 10% annual return. Please explain how these funds are used to improve the student experience or bring down the cost of tuition."
Nehls previously introduced a bill that would significantly hike excise taxes on most larger colleges' endowment funds from 1.4% to 21%, in line with the corporate tax rate.
A Brown University official declined to comment on Nehls' letter directly when reached by Fox News Digital, but denied free speech was the larger issue.
Trump Admin Halting More Than $500M In Federal Funding To Brown University Over Antisemitism Response
"In spite of what has been reported publicly framing this as a free speech issue, it absolutely is not," Brian Clark, vice president for news and strategic campus communications, said in an email statement to Fox News Digital.
"At the center of Brown's review are questions focused on whether improper use of non-public Brown data, non-public data systems and/or targeting of individual employees violated law or policy."
"Brown has detailed procedures in place to investigate alleged conduct code violations, resolve them and implement discipline in instances when students are found responsible, and these will continue to guide our actions," Clark added. "Students have ample opportunity to provide information and participate directly in that process to ensure that all decisions are made with a complete understanding of the circumstances."
Fox News Digital's Rachel del Guidice contributed to this report.Original article source: Brown University in GOP crosshairs after student's DOGE-like email kicks off frenzy
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump and Musk: The 10 days that unravelled their relationship
The pairing of Donald Trump and Elon Musk, the leader of the richest country in the world with the richest person in the world, seemed a perfect match. But the last 10 days have seen the pair move from gentle disagreement to bitter acrimony. These are the public moments which brought their relationship crashing down. Speaking to CBS News, Musk criticises Trump's plans for a new bill on tax and spending - saying the planned legislation left him "disappointed". Trump later admits to reporters that he is "not happy about certain aspects" of the bill while at the same time being "thrilled" about some aspects, such as tax cuts. He doesn't comment directly on Musk's remarks, however. Musk announces he will be leaving the Trump administration after his scheduled time as a special government employee reaches its end. He had led a cost-cutting mission known as the Department of Government Efficiency (Doge). Trump praises Musk as the latter appears with a black eye in a press conference on his last day at the White House. Musk is "not really leaving", the president says, and will continue to be "back and forth" to the White House. Trump defends his "big, beautiful bill" in a post on Truth Social, claiming "many false statements" are being made about his landmark economic policy. Musk again attacks Trump's planned bill, calling it "massive, outrageous, pork-filled" and "a disgusting abomination" in a post on X. In US politics, "pork" refers to spending on projects in lawmakers' constituencies. It marks the start of an escalation in comments from Musk on social media. Musk calls for a new spending bill "that doesn't massively grow the [US government budget] deficit and increase the debt ceiling". Musk urges his followers to call their representatives to oppose Trump's bill. Musk quotes a series of old post on X by Trump, from 2012 and 2013, in which Trump criticises government spending. Speaking in the Oval Office alongside German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, Trump says he and Musk "had" a great relationship but "I don't know if we will anymore". He also says Musk is "upset" that subsidies for electric vehicles would be cut in his planned bill, affecting the billionaire's Tesla and SpaceX businesses. Musk responds in real-time to the broadcast from the Oval Office, dismissing Trump's assertions. Back at the White House, Trump tells reporters Musk knew "every aspect of the bill" and says he is "very disappointed in Elon". "False," replies Musk on X. "This bill was never shown to me even once and was passed in the dead of night so fast that almost no-one in Congress would even read it!" Musk resurfaces old Trump posts on X, highlighting moments when the president criticised America's budget deficits. "Where is this guy today??" he asks. Replying to another user on X, Musk says: "Without me, Trump would have lost the election." He goes on to say: "Such ingratitude". Still going, Musk claims on X that "the Big Ugly Bill will INCREASE the deficit to $2.5 trillion". Musk continues to quote old Trump posts on X about government spending. He asks: "Where is the man who wrote these words? Was he replaced by a body double!?" "Is it time to create a new political party in America that actually represents the 80% in the middle?" Musk asks in a poll on X. Trump starts posting on his Truth Social platform, saying Musk had been "wearing thin" so he asked him to leave the White House, and alleging that Musk "went CRAZY". Musk calls this "an obvious lie". "The easiest way to save money in our Budget," Trump continues in another post, "is to terminate Elon's Governmental Subsidies and Contracts". Musk alleges, without providing evidence, that Trump appears in the "Epstein files", referring to court documents and evidence collected by investigators into convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. Posting on Truth Social, Trump says he doesn't mind "Elon turning against me" and continues to defend his bill. Responding to Trump's suggestion that he could terminate government contracts with Musk's companies, Musk says he will "immediately" decommission the Dragon spacecraft - a craft that is capable of travelling to the International Space Station. Musk appears to endorse impeaching Trump while quoting a conspiracy theorist who shared his Epstein files claim about the president. Musk attacks another of Trump's signature policies - his trade tariffs - by posting on X to say these "will cause a recession in the second half of this year". Musk appears to soften, replying on X "you're not wrong" to another billionaire Trump backer, Bill Ackman, who had called for the pair to "make peace for the benefit of our great country". Trump describes Musk as "the man who has lost his mind" in an interview with ABC News and says he is "not particularly" interested in speaking to him. The White House tells the BBC Trump does not intend to talk to the tech billionaire today, after reports they would speak on the phone later. It is also reported by CBS, the BBC's US partner, that Trump is considering selling his Tesla car - which he had purchased when he was trying to help Musk promote his company. Tesla shares tumble as Trump-Musk feud erupts How bitter Trump-Musk feud escalated - and what happens next Trump and Musk trade insults as row erupts in public view
New York Post
18 minutes ago
- New York Post
Kanye West and Bill Ackman are rooting for Trump and Musk to get back together
Hedge fund titan Bill Ackman and controversial rapper Kanye West both called for President Donald Trump and Elon Musk to bury the hatchet after their feud exploded in spectacular fashion. Musk accused Trump of reckless spending, called for his impeachment, alleged that he was named in government files linked to the late convicted pedophile Jeffrey Epstein and floated the idea of forming a new political party. The president lashed out at his former 'First Buddy' with threats of retaliation and character attacks. Into the fray stepped Ackman, a major Trump donor, who attempted to cool tensions by urging the two to reconcile. 5 Hedge fund billionaire Bill Ackman is offering to mediate the dispute between President Trump and Elon Musk. AFP via Getty Images 'I support @realDonaldTrump and @elonmusk and they should make peace for the benefit of our great country,' Ackman wrote on X on Thursday. 'We are much stronger together than apart.' Musk, who recently stepped down from his post leading the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), replied tersely: 'You're not wrong.' The understated response was taken by some as a sign that a truce could be on the horizon, especially with reports suggesting the two may speak by phone Friday. West, who has changed his name to Ye and no stranger to controversy himself, also chimed in with a plea for harmony. 5 Ye, formerly known as Kanye West, expressed dismay over the Musk-Trump beef. Getty Images 'Broooos please noooooo. We love you both so much,' he posted on X, alongside an emoji of two people embracing. Neither Ackman nor Ye's representatives immediately responded to requests for comment from The Post. Whether an olive branch will be extended remains uncertain. Trump does not intend to speak with Elon Musk on Friday, a person with knowledge of the situation told The Post. 'President Trump is focused on making our country great again and passing the 'One Big Beautiful Bill,'' White House spokesperson Karoline Leavitt told The Post on Friday. The Post has sought comment from Musk. The blowup marks a dramatic shift in a relationship that only months ago had seemed foundational to Trump's second-term plans. Following a July 2024 assassination attempt that nearly killed Trump during a campaign rally, Musk offered his full-throated endorsement of his White House bid. 5 The political partnership between Musk and Trump fell apart amid mutual recriminations that were posted on social media. Getty Images Musk later stood beside him at Mar-a-Lago on election night, celebrating the GOP's victory and was subsequently tapped to help lead the newly formed DOGE — an agency charged with slashing federal expenditures. Throughout the early months of Trump's second term, Musk was frequently seen at the White House, occasionally accompanied by his son X Æ A-XII. The Tesla and SpaceX CEO appeared to be positioning himself as a high-tech consigliere in the administration's inner circle. 5 Musk alleged that the president's name was included in government files linked to the late convicted pedophile Jeffrey Epstein. Molly Riley/White House / SWNS But tensions began to simmer this spring. Musk started publicly distancing himself from the administration in May, criticizing several policy decisions and retreating from his previous role as an informal adviser. The conflict went nuclear Thursday, with Musk launching a volley of blistering posts on X aimed at Trump's fiscal agenda — particularly his recent tax legislation, which Musk dubbed the 'Big Ugly Spending Bill.' Musk also insinuated that Trump could be named in the sealed files related to Epstein and threatened to retire SpaceX's Dragon spacecraft, jeopardizing a crucial transportation link between NASA and private space operations. 5 Trump accused Musk of being afflicted with 'Trump Derangement Syndrome.' AFP via Getty Images Trump hit back swiftly. During a White House ceremony later that day, he dismissed Musk's critiques as 'Trump Derangement Syndrome,' before turning to Truth Social to defend his economic policies and suggesting Musk had 'gone crazy.' He also reportedly discussed revoking government contracts held by Musk's companies. The highly public nature of the feud — and the speed with which it escalated — sent shockwaves through political and business circles, with some observers warning it could fracture the fragile coalition that has fused populist conservatism with Silicon Valley's libertarian streak.
USA Today
27 minutes ago
- USA Today
Musk is angry Trump used him. I'm frustrated we're focusing on the wrong thing.
Musk is angry Trump used him. I'm frustrated we're focusing on the wrong thing. | Opinion President Donald Trump and Elon Musk are trading social media haymakers – and we all get to finally see that Republicans aren't actually serious about reducing the deficit. Show Caption Hide Caption President Trump gives his thoughts on Elon Musk amid clash on bill President Donald Trump responded to Elon Musk's criticism of his "big, beautiful bill" with disappointment as Musk responded on X. The honeymoon phase of President Donald Trump and Elon Musk's bromance has been waning for weeks, and now their relationship appears torn beyond repair just as publicly as it started. The pair exchanged blows on social media on June 5, with Trump threatening on Truth Social to strip Musk's companies of subsidies, while Musk took credit for the 2024 GOP victory and took to X to accuse Trump of being on the Jeffrey Epstein list. This ridiculous escalation distracts from the real point at issue, though. Musk seems frustrated that Republicans used him in their charade to balance the federal budget, frustrated that Trump used him for his own end. But he really should be frustrated that he was so gullible – because he should have seen all of this coming. Opinion: Musk erupts, claims Trump is in the Epstein files. Who could've seen this coming? I'm frustrated that this is the only thing receiving attention, considering the amount of work that needs to be done with the budget. Republicans used Elon Musk as a political smokescreen Whether Musk genuinely believed himself when he promised to cut $2 trillion (before quickly tempering that estimate) is up for debate. If he did believe it, he was entirely naive about both the current state of the Republican party and our federal government. Republicans thought they could use Musk as a political win and distraction, allowing him to claw back government spending through DOGE, while congressional Republicans authorized massive deficit increases. Even after accounting for the economic growth that the Big Beautiful Bill would stimulate, the bill is projected to add $2.4 trillion (yes, with a T) to the federal deficit over the next decade. This figure stands as a mountain next to the small pile of $2 billion (yes, with a B) worth of verifiable budget cuts from DOGE. All the while, Republicans and Trump sang Musk's praises, knowing that they would turn around and spend money that we don't have. But Elon should have realized it was all a show. Trump skyrocketed the deficit in his first presidency, and every promise he's ever given for a balanced budget has been a lie. As much as MAGA likes to claim otherwise, Trump's GOP is no different than the swamp creatures they like to criticize. Opinion: Elon Musk is frustrated with Republicans wasting DOGE's effort to cut. So am I. Those who are actually interested in cutting government spending, which I think Musk at least somewhat seems to be, should not attach the idea to political parties because they will inevitably disappoint. There hasn't been a genuine effort to produce a balanced budget since 2001, and there isn't likely to be from either Republicans or Democrats anytime soon. Trump and Musk have too big personalities to work together I'm not the least bit surprised that these two narcissists' relationship flamed out so quickly. There was never enough room in Trump's White House for both him and Musk's personalities. Trump has never maintained an extended relationship with somebody who is willing to disagree with him publicly. During his first term, Trump had extremely high personnel turnover rates, both in his cabinet and his aides. Trump's 'you're fired' catchphrase really says a lot about his approach to relationships. He is quick to turn on people who disagree with him or even just publicly embarrass him. Musk has been loudly advocating against Trump's "Big Beautiful Bill" for its impact on the deficit. After a week of Musk criticizing the deficit spending in Trump's bill, the president has clearly had enough. He cannot tolerate a dissenting voice from within his ranks. Trump and the GOP are now likely to kick a powerful ally to the curb, all because Trump is so vain that he cannot handle differing opinions. This is why the GOP is now made up of yes men, because they have allowed Trump to push all the spine that he can out of the party. Now that the sideshow of Musk is gone, Republicans have one less thing to hide behind. I'm not sure that makes it any more likely they act responsibly, but at least it's more transparent to Americans now. Dace Potas is an opinion columnist for USA TODAY and a graduate of DePaul University with a degree in political science.
