logo
The NRL's representative eligibility rules are broken. Here's how to fix them

The NRL's representative eligibility rules are broken. Here's how to fix them

The Age3 days ago
He was born in Meadowbank in Sydney's west and played junior footy for Mascot Jets. How is he any less of a New South Welshman than the others who wear the sky blue?
Why can't the Sydney-born, Bronte-raised Victor Radley play for NSW if he chooses to honour his heritage and represent England instead of Australia? The Samoa-born Stephen Crichton represents NSW. The West Australia-born Kalyn Ponga dons the Maroons jersey.
After all, they all fulfil the main Origin criteria, which is to have resided in NSW or QLD prior to their 13th birthday. No one wants to change that aspect of the eligibility, but the tiering system was designed for an era before the second generation of migrant families, who call Australia home but are proud of their ancestral roots, had such an impact on the game.
If you go back two decades, the NSW Blues used 22 players in the 2005 State of Origin series. None of them were eligible to play for any regularly playing rugby league nation other than Australia.
In this year's series, across NSW and Queensland, there were 15: Brian To'o, Stephen Crichton, Jarome Luai, Payne Haas, Spencer Leniu, Stefano Utoikamanu, Ponga, Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow, Xavier Coates, Robert Toia, Valentine Holmes, Mo Fotuaika, Josh Papalii, Tino Fa'asuamaleaui and Jermiah Nanai.
Everything the NRL does over the summer needs to be done through the lens of what is best for international rugby league.
There will be an argument that a player must choose which country he wants to represent at a young age and be held to that nation for the remainder of his career. That model, however, is to the detriment of the international game.
Take Isaiya Katoa for example. He has the cultural ties to play for Tonga, New Zealand and Australia. If he was forced to choose Australia when he entered the NRL, he would have been waiting years to get in front of the likes of Nathan Cleary, Mitchell Moses and Daly Cherry-Evans.
The international game, however, would be poorer for not having Katoa represent Tonga. To avoid that situation of having a plethora of quality players on the sidelines, allegiances should be tied to World Cup cycles.
At the end of the 2026 Rugby League World Cup, each player must elect who they intend to represent over the next four years culminating in the 2030 World Cup.
Turn it into a television event. Have people on stage opening an envelope announcing that in 2027, Ponga will be taking his talents to New Zealand for the next four years.
Give the nations an incentive to go out and find third-party agreements with prospective corporate partners looking to aid the country's hopes of convincing a player to represent their nation over others they may also be eligible for.
It's the best way to try and minimise the discrepancy between the $30,000 Origin match payments and the $3000 players receive for Test matches, a move designed to make international football the pinnacle of the sport.
Forcing players to stick with their country of choice also doesn't allow for father time. Petero Civoniceva was a mainstay in the Australian team for a decade, playing 45 games for the Kangaroos.
It would be doing the international game a disservice to deny him the chance to represent Fiji in the latter stages of his career when he wasn't playing at a standard that warranted selection in the Australian team, all because he made a decision to represent Australia 15 years earlier.
Why shouldn't Utoikamanu represent his Tongan father, his Samoan mother, his Australian-born children and his Kiwi ancestory if he chooses to do so. He just needs to wait every four years to change.
Loading
At the end of the World Cup, any player from Harold Matthews all the way up to the NRL needs to select who they want to represent for the next four years.
It will then also provide a clear and competitive junior representative program that will allow under 17s, 19s and 21s international games for the younger players, rather than the schoolboy programs run at the moment.
The legacy of the V'landys-Andrew Abdo regime in rugby league is cemented. They will be remembered for saving the game during the COVID-19 pandemic, the venture into America through the Las Vegas season openers and the expansion into Perth and Papua New Guinea.
Now they could help transform rugby league into a genuine global sport by overhauling the outdated rules.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

I couldn't imagine living in such an eerie area. But my suburb is difficult to leave
I couldn't imagine living in such an eerie area. But my suburb is difficult to leave

Sydney Morning Herald

time5 hours ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

I couldn't imagine living in such an eerie area. But my suburb is difficult to leave

Imagine, if you will, a hand of God, in addition to assisting Maradona to win the World Cup for Argentina in 1986, coming down from heaven and scooping up a swathe of humanity from the Asian subcontinent in a north-westerly direction over Iran, Iraq, Turkey, and then a final quick dip in far-Western Europe. Picture that hand scattering these people in one of the fastest-growing residential growth corridors in Australia and you will perhaps grasp something of what Craigieburn is about: this enigmatic suburb you either take a quick rubberneck glance at on your way to Canberra or Sydney, or whose existence you maybe consider as you board a train upon the Craigieburn line and wonder what poor souls have to ride this route all the way to the end. Previously a land of sweeping plains, farms, and sheep runs, Craigieburn has evolved over the decades to become the suburban love child of Metricon and Lendlease. It embodies aspiration. The median house price is $650,000, and is where anyone and everyone can get their first taste of the great Australian dream. There is a distinct old and new Craigieburn: the former features classic brick-veneer homely residences, while the latter includes an impressive array of rendered and modernist mansions that wouldn't look out of place in Toorak. In 2010, I was living in Moonee Ponds and serving as an honorary chaplain to the Coburg Tigers VFL Club. Highgate Reserve in the less-developed northern region of Craigieburn, with its 'MCG-sized oval' was a second home ground to the Tigers. The team travelled up here to play Gold Coast during that quasi-internship season they spent in the VFL. The ground was packed, primarily as NRL code-hopper Karmichael Hunt was pulling on the boots for the first time. Gold Coast were thrashed, and Coburg took in the gate earnings that day, so everyone was happy. I mention this anecdote, as a central arterial road, Grand Boulevard, literally came to a gravelly stop next to the oval; there were no shops, few homes, no roundabouts, and I simply couldn't imagine living in such an eerie place. Fast forward to 2014, however, when I moved up here to take up a post at the local Anglican school for almost a decade: a young, low-fee, rapidly expanding educational centre that now boasts three connected campuses. The Melbourne Anglican Diocese purchased a historic sea-captain's homestead and acreage that featured in the 1983 film Phar Lap with Tom Burlinson. Incidentally, my office was also originally located in the archaic coach house where the Toecutter gang tried to abduct Mel Gibson's son in the first Mad Max film, but that is another story ... We moved to a newer housing area called Highlands, which features a very agreeable man-made lake and a Saturday morning Parkrun around it. I decided that I probably lived in one of Australia's most multicultural streets. In order, my neighbours were: Pakistani Muslims, Iraqi Christians, Turkish Alevis, Turkish Sunnis, Afghani Hazaras, Chaldean Catholics, Indian Sikhs, Punjabis and Hmongs, with a smattering of Anglos, Filipinos and Pacific Islanders in the multiethnic mix. Craigieburn is part of the gargantuan 3064 postcode. Its population of over 65,000 in 2021 made it Australia's second-largest suburb, after Point Cook. We are so big, in fact, that in 2020, we were declared special enough to have our own tailored lockdown. These were indeed dark days for many of the multi-generational abodes in the area, and the cutely named exercise of 'remote learning' was somewhat strained in an area where two-thirds of residents speak a language other than English at home.

I couldn't imagine living in such an eerie area. But my suburb is difficult to leave
I couldn't imagine living in such an eerie area. But my suburb is difficult to leave

The Age

time5 hours ago

  • The Age

I couldn't imagine living in such an eerie area. But my suburb is difficult to leave

Imagine, if you will, a hand of God, in addition to assisting Maradona to win the World Cup for Argentina in 1986, coming down from heaven and scooping up a swathe of humanity from the Asian subcontinent in a north-westerly direction over Iran, Iraq, Turkey, and then a final quick dip in far-Western Europe. Picture that hand scattering these people in one of the fastest-growing residential growth corridors in Australia and you will perhaps grasp something of what Craigieburn is about: this enigmatic suburb you either take a quick rubberneck glance at on your way to Canberra or Sydney, or whose existence you maybe consider as you board a train upon the Craigieburn line and wonder what poor souls have to ride this route all the way to the end. Previously a land of sweeping plains, farms, and sheep runs, Craigieburn has evolved over the decades to become the suburban love child of Metricon and Lendlease. It embodies aspiration. The median house price is $650,000, and is where anyone and everyone can get their first taste of the great Australian dream. There is a distinct old and new Craigieburn: the former features classic brick-veneer homely residences, while the latter includes an impressive array of rendered and modernist mansions that wouldn't look out of place in Toorak. In 2010, I was living in Moonee Ponds and serving as an honorary chaplain to the Coburg Tigers VFL Club. Highgate Reserve in the less-developed northern region of Craigieburn, with its 'MCG-sized oval' was a second home ground to the Tigers. The team travelled up here to play Gold Coast during that quasi-internship season they spent in the VFL. The ground was packed, primarily as NRL code-hopper Karmichael Hunt was pulling on the boots for the first time. Gold Coast were thrashed, and Coburg took in the gate earnings that day, so everyone was happy. I mention this anecdote, as a central arterial road, Grand Boulevard, literally came to a gravelly stop next to the oval; there were no shops, few homes, no roundabouts, and I simply couldn't imagine living in such an eerie place. Fast forward to 2014, however, when I moved up here to take up a post at the local Anglican school for almost a decade: a young, low-fee, rapidly expanding educational centre that now boasts three connected campuses. The Melbourne Anglican Diocese purchased a historic sea-captain's homestead and acreage that featured in the 1983 film Phar Lap with Tom Burlinson. Incidentally, my office was also originally located in the archaic coach house where the Toecutter gang tried to abduct Mel Gibson's son in the first Mad Max film, but that is another story ... We moved to a newer housing area called Highlands, which features a very agreeable man-made lake and a Saturday morning Parkrun around it. I decided that I probably lived in one of Australia's most multicultural streets. In order, my neighbours were: Pakistani Muslims, Iraqi Christians, Turkish Alevis, Turkish Sunnis, Afghani Hazaras, Chaldean Catholics, Indian Sikhs, Punjabis and Hmongs, with a smattering of Anglos, Filipinos and Pacific Islanders in the multiethnic mix. Craigieburn is part of the gargantuan 3064 postcode. Its population of over 65,000 in 2021 made it Australia's second-largest suburb, after Point Cook. We are so big, in fact, that in 2020, we were declared special enough to have our own tailored lockdown. These were indeed dark days for many of the multi-generational abodes in the area, and the cutely named exercise of 'remote learning' was somewhat strained in an area where two-thirds of residents speak a language other than English at home.

‘Don't mention my son's name again': Aaron Woods fires shots after being labelled a ‘coward'
‘Don't mention my son's name again': Aaron Woods fires shots after being labelled a ‘coward'

News.com.au

time6 hours ago

  • News.com.au

‘Don't mention my son's name again': Aaron Woods fires shots after being labelled a ‘coward'

Former NSW Blues forward Aaron Woods has fired back at his Origin critics, weeks after his comments on Billy Slater sparked one of the most iconic State of Origin feuds. The Triple M host was the latest guest on Paul Kent's podcast Kenty Primetime where he revealed he later spoke to Slater's former teammate Ryan Hoffman. Hoffman labelled Woods a 'coward' on the ABC for calling Queensland coach Slater a 'grub' before Game 2 of the series this year. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. 'Ryan Hoffman came out and called me a coward, and then he back flipped and said he didn't,' Wood's explained. 'We had a conversation. I said, 'look you can call me whatever you want, just don't ever mention my son's name again with things that didn't happen', because Buster didn't get a photo with Billy.' Hoffman's comments were centred on claims Woods had asked Slater to take a photo with his son Buster earlier in the season before he later slammed the Origin coach to create an Origin narrative. The claim originally came from former Origin forward and NRL360 host Gorden Tallis who took aim at Woods labelling Slater a grub ahead of Game 2. But Woods has now clarified the situation with the alleged photo, which occurred at Magic Round while commentating for Triple M. 'We're up at the top boxes of Suncorp Stadium, I was going to take my little fella downstairs, Buster, because he was going to be a ball boy for the 3 o'clock game on the Saturday arvo which was Newcastle v Souths,' Woods said. 'As I was going down the lift, we were right at the back, everyone jumped in, then we get down to I think level 3, that's where the Channel 9 and Fox boxes are. 'Billy Slater rocks in with his producer from Channel 9. We go downstairs, everyone gets out, Billy's there at the front, I literally walk out, I walk past, I shake his hand, 'hey Bill', I say to Buster to shake his hand. 'Once he shakes his hand we walk away, Buster goes 'who's that Dad?' 'I go 'mate, he's one of the best fullbacks to ever play the game'. My young bloke is only five. And that is all that happened. 'So from that, there's only three people that would've said something to Gordy about that. So someone's dropped the lip and had a little complaint, wasn't too happy.' The entire ordeal looked to become a major talking point among league fans as Queensland rallied after the saga to come back and win the next two games and take the series shield back from NSW. The story blew up particularly with Slater's response in which he suggested Woods was unaware of the mental health concerns his words could have on people, controversially referencing late Maroons coach Paul Green, who suffered from CTE. It left Woods admitting he felt partially responsible for the whole situation. 'A little bit. I was so confident because Game 1 I don't even think NSW played well,' he said. 'To win up at Suncorp, to be up there in enemy territory and the way they played, I would've thought we'd go to Perth quite excited. 'You go over there and then the performance in that first half, I was just like 'oh my God, far out, what have I done here?' Just really stirred the pot.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store