Cork City Council spent over €23,000 last year on 'robotrees' before their removal
Two payments for 'annual maintenance' were made to Green City Solutions of €14,497 on July 19 and €8,940 on July 24 last year.
The payments are higher than previous years, when annual maintenance costs were €16,778 in 2020, €17,755 in 2021 - when there were also repairs costing €2,396 - and €17,880 in 2022.
There are no records provided for maintenance costs for 2023 for the German-made 'trees', which were designed to filter air via so-called moss filters, absorb toxic pollutants and collate air quality data for analysis.
In November 2023, the Irish Examiner reported that a 190-page evaluation report of the devices concluded they provided 'no consistent evidence for improved air quality' either on the CityTree benches or 'in the immediate environs' of the machines.
The council commissioned UCC in June 2022 to undertake the performance study on the machines, at a cost of €2,500, and conducted on eight different rain-free days during June and July 2022.
A source of constant criticism since they were installed in 2020, UCC's Centre for Research into Atmospheric Chemistry researcher Dean Venables labelled them 'a costly and ineffectual gimmick'.
In September 2023, UCC emeritus professor of chemistry, John Sodeau, said the "trees" - which were removed from their wooden bases last month and placed in storage - were a waste of money.
At the time they were removed, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said of the initiative: 'People try things out, some work out, some don't work out'.
Just 'stumps' remain of the robot trees which have been removed from Cork City. Picture: Larry Cummins
The most recent annual maintenance payments were revealed to Cork North Central Sinn Féin Thomas Gould as a result of a Freedom of Information request.
He said: 'In a city that lacks benches, that has broken footpaths and too few real trees, it is insulting that this money was spent over a four-year period on a failed science experiment.
'When the studies in November 2023 failed to prove the effectiveness of the trees, we were told there would be extensive scientific study on them. How much has this cost? What did this report find?"
He said there "should be no more gimmicks in Cork City". "We need safe footpaths, accessible benches and sufficient rubbish bins to prevent dog fouling," Mr Gould said.
'These may not be glamorous initiatives but they will make a huge real difference in the lives of ordinary people in our city.' Cork City Council was asked for a comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Compensation payments for Cork boundary changes could push council into deficit, warns boss
Cork City Council is concerned that the uncertain duration and high cost of paying compensation to its sister local authority, Cork County Council, for boundary changes could place major regeneration projects for the city in jeopardy. Chief executive Valerie O'Sullivan has raised questions about the council's ability to finance such projects due to the burden of the annual compensation payments, which she claimed was 'unsustainable'. Under the terms of legislation governing the boundary extension of Cork City Council's administrative area in 2019, it must pay annual compensation to Cork County Council for a minimum 10-year period. Under the boundary changes, the expansion of Cork City Council's administrative area increased almost fivefold, with an increased population of approximately 85,000 covering areas including Douglas, Rochestown, Ballincollig, Blarney, and Glanmire. The first compensation payment to Cork County Council in 2020 was just over €13m but the annual figure had increased to €15.4m by last year due to inflation. Officials in Cork City Council have estimated that inflation could increase the overall compensation bill over the 10 years by at least €22m. Ms O'Sullivan's comments were made at a recent meeting between senior council executives and a delegation from the National Oversight and Audit Commission (NOAC) – a local authority watchdog – as part of NOAC's routine scrutiny programme. The council's chief executive said the issue of the compensation payments was 'something that is ongoing but never spoken about.' "It was a deal that was to last for 10 years, index-linked, and no one could have foreseen at the time the way interest rates would go – the way covid would come along and the war in Ukraine and all these things that have increased the interest portion in particular of that.' Ms O'Sullivan also expressed concern about the uncertainty surrounding what happens at the end of the 10-year agreement". 'We don't know what 2029 holds in terms of cessation or are working hard on that, I would say in partnership with Cork County Council, because they have to prepare for the cessation of the payment and we have to prepare for what the outcome will be,' said Ms O'Sullivan. You can't just drive a ship like Cork City Council into a deficit budget. However, Ms O'Sullivan said that is exactly what was happening as a result of the requirement to make an annual compensation payment. The council's head of finance, John Hallahan, also expressed concern about the uncertainty over whether the council will have to make further compensation payments after 2029. Mr Hallahan pointed out that Cork City Council required certainty on the issue as it will need to borrow in excess of €100m over the coming years to qualify for the 75% funding from the Government's Urban Regeneration and Development Fund for major projects planned for the Docklands and city centre areas. 'We need to have certainty brought after the 10 years,' said Mr Hallahan.
The Journal
2 days ago
- The Journal
Michael D Higgins says videos of emaciated Israeli hostages a 'shocking act of cruelty'
PRESIDENT MICHAEL D HIGGINS has condemned the footage released by Hamas of two emaciated Israeli hostages as showing 'a shocking act of cruelty'. Higgins made the comments in a statement released this evening. Earlier today, he spoke of the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza at Wexford's Fleadh Cheoil . He called on the UN to do more for the people of Gaza, and said that the current measure of air-dropping food into the ravaged territory was not good enough. This evening, Higgins said that the world is witnessing the lowest level of human behaviour 'with images like these occurring at the same time as children are deprived of medicine and mothers are deprived of water and the necessary means of addressing malnutrition as they watch their children die'. Advertisement Starvation and malnutrition has spread across Gaza. Six adults have died from malnutrition in the past 24 hours, according to the health ministry. This brings the total number of malnutrition-related deaths in the past five weeks to 82. Ninety-three children have died from malnutrition-related deaths since the current conflict began in 2023. As pressure ramps up on Israel to withdraw from the besieged Gaza Strip – or to lessen its heavy and frequent attacks, which have resulted in the deaths of tens of thousands of civilians – three videos released by the terrorist group they claim to solely target has led to widespread condemnation of Hamas and a declaration by members of the EU that the militant group must have no role in Palestine's future. In the footage, 21-year-old Rom Braslavski, a German-Israeli, and 24-year-old Evyatar David both appear weak and malnourished. The two young men were kidnapped and taken hostage during Hamas's attack on 7 October 2023. The footage of Mr David showed him digging what he said in the staged video was his own grave, triggering particular outrage. The EU, France, and Germany expressed shock at the footage and called it inhumane. French President Emmanuel Macron and German leader Friedrich Merz said that Hamas must have no role in ruling the strip once the war ends. Read Next Related Reads Gaza mother: 'My children ask for food, and I can give them nothing' EU tells Israel to 'stop killing people' who are seeking food and aid 'Humanitarian city' for Palestinians would be a 'concentration camp', says former Israeli PM 'We must have the total demilitarisation of Hamas, its complete exclusion from any form of governance and the recognition of Israel by the state of Palestine,' Macron said. Higgins said that actions such as this 'damages any cause to which [Hamas] attaches themselves'. 'All of these actions must not just receive the opprobrium of the world,' he said, referring too both the videos and malnutrition affecting people within Gaza, 'but must lead to practical actions that cannot wait until September to be addressed. 'I repeat the suggestion which I have made previously with regard to how Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter may provide a mechanism for ensuring safe access of aid.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Examiner
2 days ago
- Irish Examiner
‘We need Pride more than ever now': Solidarity and celebration at Cork Pride parade
The Pride movement is needed now more than ever, the 2025 Cork Pride parade heard amid mounting concerns that hard-won rights are being eroded. Organisers of the Cork LGBT+ Pride Festival issued the rallying call on Sunday as an estimated 5,000 people marched in or watched the colourful parade, and its giant rainbow flag, wind its way through the city to the Party at the Port — the climax of the week-long Pride festival, which had as its theme, 'A fearless future'. Damian O'Halloran, vice chair of Cork Pride, said the theme is not just a statement — it's a rhetorical question. 'Can we really have a fearless future, when around the world we are watching the hard-won rights of our communities being stripped away?' he asked. Cork City Council staff and friends at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. 'So today, we gather not just in celebration, but in solidarity. We gather to say: We will not be silent. We will not be afraid. And we will not be erased.' He praised those previous campaigning generations, and those who marched on Sunday. 'Because showing up is an act of courage. And in doing so, you're helping shape what a fearless future truly looks like,' he said. Speaking to the Irish Examiner after the parade, Mr O'Halloran said progress has been made but added: 'A lot of bullies now have a voice, they are standing up because they are not afraid anymore and when you see leaders across the globe demonstrating rhetoric like that, people aren't afraid anymore to say what they want because there is no sanction. "It's about policy, and that starts with the leadership of the country.' Lisa Lynch, Linda O'Mahony, and Kelly and Aisling O'Sullivan from Glanmire enjoying the Party at the Port on Kennedy Quay after the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. Denise Boyle, chair of Cork Pride, said the community has to keep marching. 'My message to young people here today is to be happy with who you are, and know that there is lots of support out there for you — don't struggle by yourself,' she said. Diarmuid Scully, a member of UCC's LGBT staff network, said that homophobia thrived in the past by dividing people, and making them afraid. Staff from Apple and their families at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade at the Grand Parade, Cork City, on Sunday. 'This sends out a massive signal to people that there is a community here, young and old, and that they are not on their own,' he said. 'There is a very cold wind blowing outside of Ireland. I think it will reach here in some form or another. Social media is the real terrifying thing because it allows 24-hour bullying. Lord Mayor Fergal Dennehy and Lady Mayoress Karen Brennan leading the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. 'The fact that the Pride slogan this year is 'a fearless future' tells its own story, and the theme of Pride in Belfast last week was 'never going back'. 'If you have to have slogans like that, it tells you there is something to fight against but that we will win against it.' Minister of State Jerry Buttimer, who came out as Fine Gael's first gay TD in 2012, said the community, and country has come a long way, with a new generation of people marching, but that people cannot be complacent. 'It's about holding the rights we have and ensuring that people are free to be who they are,' he said. Margarita O'Regan and Emma Clifford walking their dogs at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. Eimear McNally, 18, who is part of that new generation, said showing support for the rights won by the campaigners of the past, and keeping that support 'strong and present', is very important — especially today. 'People can be afraid to show real solidarity with tough causes right now and this is a day where everyone can express what they want to,' she said. Eurovision Fanclub president Frank Dermody at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. Nick Murphy, a member of the inclusive GAA club Na Laochra Aeracha, said the rise of homophobia is inevitable, given the rise of the far right across the world, and the echo chambers that exist on social media. 'This is why Pride needs to be. As long as people think like that, Pride will always be necessary,' he said. Claire Flynn, of Mammies for Trans Rights, said their group was founded because of concerning rhetoric from some places. 'We didn't want our children standing up and being front and centre, because we were afraid for their safety, so we said, as parents, we can stand up in front of them until it's safe enough for them to stand up,' she said.
