Looser gun laws tied to thousands more US child shooting deaths
Jeremy Faust, an emergency physician at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and lead author of the paper in JAMA Pediatrics, told AFP he was drawn to the topic as a father wondering whether today's world is safer for children than when he was growing up.
"Mortality from car accidents has fallen dramatically, but at the same time, firearm mortality rose and replaced car accidents as the leading cause of death in children over the age of one," he said -- a trend unique among peer nations.
To probe this shift, Faust and his colleagues analyzed state-level data before and after McDonald v Chicago, the 2010 Supreme Court decision that extended the Second Amendment to state and local governments.
The ruling sparked a wave of legislation, some tightening gun laws but much of it loosening them.
The team grouped states into three categories -- most permissive, permissive, and strict -- and used Centers for Disease Control data on firearm deaths among children aged 0–17.
They ran an "excess mortality analysis," comparing actual deaths from 2011 to 2023 against projections based on prior trends from 1999 to 2010 and population growth.
The results were stark: more than 7,400 excess pediatric firearm deaths in states that loosened gun laws -- including over 6,000 in the most permissive group of states.
By contrast, the eight strictest states overall saw no excess deaths. The model predicted 4,267 fatalities, while 4,212 were recorded -- a near-match that bolstered confidence in the analysis.
"The biggest thing people always want to know is, what's the intent behind these?" said Faust.
"And I think what surprises most people is that accidents are a very small number of these deaths -- it's mostly homicide and suicide."
While the study showed strong associations, it cannot prove causation -- a key limitation.
But in a test of whether broader increases in violence might explain the trend, rather than changes to the law, the team analyzed non-firearm homicides and suicides and found no similar rise, a result that makes the findings "pretty compelling," said Faust.
Black children saw the steepest increases. While the reasons are unclear, the authors speculated that disparities in safe firearm storage could play a role.
There were some exceptions. Deaths rose in Illinois and Connecticut despite tighter laws -- though in the latter case, the spike was entirely attributable to the 2012 Sandy Hook mass shooting at an elementary school.
"Big picture, we have a major problem in this country," said Faust.
"But we also have a handful of states that are resisting these increases and, in fact, turning the other direction."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
18 hours ago
- France 24
Gaza rescuers say Israeli fire kills 31 in latest deadly shooting near aid centre
The Gaza civil defence agency said 31 people were killed and "about 200" wounded Wednesday when Israeli troops fired on people waiting to enter a food distribution centre. "We transported at least 31 martyrs and about 200 wounded as a result of Israeli tank and drone fire on thousands of citizens... on their way to receive food from the American aid centre," civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP. The Israeli military had no immediate comment. Bassal said thousands of Palestinians had been gathering since 2am in the hope of reaching the US and Israeli-backed food distribution centre. "Israeli tanks fired several times, then at around 5:30 am intensified their fire, coinciding with heavy fire from drones targeting civilians," he said. Medical officials at Shifa and Al-Quds Hospitals said at least 25 people were killed as they approached the aid site near the former settlement of Netzarim, southwest of Gaza City. Ten other people were killed in other Israeli military strikes in Khan Younis in the south of the enclave, they added. Restrictions imposed on media in the Gaza Strip and the difficulties of access on the ground mean the death tolls could not be independently verified. There have been a series of deadly shootings since the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) first opened aid distribution points in the Palestinian territory on May 27, as Israel faced mounting international condemnation over the humanitarian conditions. After similar incidents in recent days, the Israeli army said it fired warning shots to distance "suspects" who were approaching the troops and posed a threat. The war erupted after Hamas-led militants took 251 hostages and killed 1,200 people, most of them civilians, in an October 7, 2023, attack, Israel's single deadliest day. Israel's military campaign has since killed nearly 55,000 Palestinians, most of them civilians, according to health authorities in Gaza, and flattened most of the coastal enclave.
AFP
a day ago
- AFP
Video misleads about safety of 6-in-1 vaccine Vaxelis
"A new vaccine is on the market for your 6 week old baby! It's never been tested against a placebo or for carcinogenic effects," claims a May 19, 2025 Instagram post from a Canadian content creator who regularly posts against vaccination. She is one of several creators who stitched their reactions next to a video with thousands of interactions from Jeffrey Barke, a founding member of America's Frontline Doctors -- a group AFP has repeatedly fact-checked. In the video, Barke reads from the package insert for Vaxelis, a shot given to simultaneously prevent infections caused by pertussis, diphtheria, tetanus, poliomyelitis, Haemophilus influenzae type b, and hepatitis B (archived here). "Studies that brought this product to market -- there is not a single randomized controlled study with an inert placebo. It's only tested against other vaccinations," he says, implying this is cause for concern. Image Screenshot of Instagram reels taken on June 3, 2025 Similar claims also appeared on X in French, German, Spanish and Croatian, spreading as officials with the US Department of Health and Human Services under Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. aim to shift the way vaccines are tested and approved. The posts also come as experts say vaccine misinformation is rampant online and may be contributing to falling vaccination rates across the United States and Canada (archived here and here). Vaxelis is not new, however. The US Food and Drug Administration first approved the joint venture of pharmaceutical companies Sanofi Pasteur and Merck for children six weeks through four years of age in December 2018 (archived here and here). It is also administered in Europe (archived here). Kelly Moore, president and CEO of the nonprofit co-authored the policy statement for Vaxelis from the US Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), a panel of experts that makes recommendations about the childhood vaccinations schedule (archived here). "It's an excellent vaccine," she told AFP in a June 2 email. In February 2019, the ACIP reported that Vaxelis was subjected to six clinical studies involving more than 5,000 infants six to 12 weeks of age (archived here). It said the studies showed Vaxelis "had an acceptable safety profile that is consistent with its component vaccines." Placebo testing Barke is correct that Vaxelis was not tested against an inert placebo. But experts said there is reason for that: it would have been unethical to do so. Clinical trial participants must be offered the existing standard of care, Moore said. It would be "entirely unethical" to withhold existing vaccines while testing a combination product that contains components already routinely given in those separate shots, she said. The World Health Organization has also pushed back against calls for changes to vaccination testing. "The safety of vaccines is held to an extremely high standard," WHO vaccine chief Kate O'Brien said May 1, 2025 (archived here). O'Brien stressed that the "gold standard" process calls for placebo testing when developing vaccines against diseases for which no immunization options exist. But when vaccines are developed to cover new strains or to offer a combination shot against multiple viruses, they are generally tested to see if they are as or more effective than the existing shots. O'Brien said it would also be unethical to give test subjects a placebo in place of "vaccines that are life-saving that are already licensed." Combination vaccines Barke further misleads by misinterpreting section 13.1 of the package insert, which says that Vaxelis was not evaluated for "carcinogenic or mutagenic potential or impairment of fertility." The language appears in documents for many routine vaccines, US health care group Novant Health explains on its website (archived here). "This merely means that there was no need for further testing because toxicology studies conducted at the preclinical phase showed no signs of adverse effects from the vaccine or its individual components," it says. There are also specific guidelines and rules for when a manufacturer needs to perform fertility studies. With a shot approved for use only in populations under five years old, studies in pregnant animals would not take place, said Kathryn Edwards, an expert in vaccinology at the Vanderbilt University Medical Center (archived here). "These vaccines have been used individually for decades in millions of people that there has not been a signal for infertility and no biologic reason why you would be concerned," she said in a June 4 email. Six-in-one shots, including Vaxelis, were developed to lower the number of injections for children, "reduce the burden of handling multiple different separate vaccines and to ensure timely administration of all the needed vaccines," Edwards said. The Canadian Paediatric Society and the Canadian National Advisory Committee on Immunization currently recommend children receive 5-in-1 or 6-in-1 vaccines (archived here and here). After a vaccine is approved, its safety continues to be monitored. "Combination vaccines have been shown to be no more reactive than separate vaccines, and no long term complications have been seen with combination vaccines," Edwards said. Such products have several advantages, including increased coverage rates, reduced need for additional health care visits and lower costs for distributing the product, according to the US Center for Disease Control and Prevention (archived here). Adverse effects Barke's video highlights the potential risk of Guillain-Barré syndrome -- a condition in which the body's immune system attacks the nerves, sometimes causing temporary paralysis. He also points to apnea, which is a pause in breathing, as a risk. But Edwards said Guillain-Barré syndrome is "very rare in children." Cedars Sinai Hospital says on its website that most children diagnosed with Guillain-Barré syndrome "recover fully with no complications" (archived here). Rachel Greenberg, associate professor of pediatrics at Duke University School of Medicine, researched apnea risks when vaccinating premature infants (archived here). "While there is a temporary increased risk of apnea after vaccination, the risk posed by vaccine-preventable respiratory and other infections to unvaccinated infants is far higher," she said in a press release about her January 2025 study (archived here). The most common side effects reported following a shot of Vaxelis are pain or swelling at the injection site and fever (archived here). Melody Butler, founding executive director of Nurses Who Vaccinate, said parents weighing the risk of rare, serious adverse events should remember how many children still die from vaccine-preventable diseases (archived here). "We've become so spoiled that we don't even know what these diseases do to the human body," she told AFP June 4. "We're very fortunate that we don't see these diseases firsthand." Ingredients Barke's video also targets the vaccine's ingredients, a tactic regularly deployed by activists who claim, without evidence, that immunizations are dangerous. In particular, he questions aluminum and formaldehyde. Aluminum is naturally found in the environment, and humans ingest it through drinking water and some foods, including breast milk and infant formula. Aluminum boosts immune response, reducing the amount of vaccine required to provide immunity (archived here). Aluminum-containing vaccines have been used for decades and have been administered to more than one billion people without problem, the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) says on its website (archived here). Formaldehyde, meanwhile, is "essential in human metabolism" and can be found in all humans, according to CHOP (archived here). It is used in vaccines to help prevent bacterial contamination during manufacturing (archived here). "There's more formaldehyde in a single apple or pear than in a vaccine," Butler said, dismissing the residual amounts passed to the body during vaccination as "negligible." Read more of AFP's reporting on vaccine misinformation here.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Looser gun laws tied to thousands more US child shooting deaths
Jeremy Faust, an emergency physician at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and lead author of the paper in JAMA Pediatrics, told AFP he was drawn to the topic as a father wondering whether today's world is safer for children than when he was growing up. "Mortality from car accidents has fallen dramatically, but at the same time, firearm mortality rose and replaced car accidents as the leading cause of death in children over the age of one," he said -- a trend unique among peer nations. To probe this shift, Faust and his colleagues analyzed state-level data before and after McDonald v Chicago, the 2010 Supreme Court decision that extended the Second Amendment to state and local governments. The ruling sparked a wave of legislation, some tightening gun laws but much of it loosening them. The team grouped states into three categories -- most permissive, permissive, and strict -- and used Centers for Disease Control data on firearm deaths among children aged 0–17. They ran an "excess mortality analysis," comparing actual deaths from 2011 to 2023 against projections based on prior trends from 1999 to 2010 and population growth. The results were stark: more than 7,400 excess pediatric firearm deaths in states that loosened gun laws -- including over 6,000 in the most permissive group of states. By contrast, the eight strictest states overall saw no excess deaths. The model predicted 4,267 fatalities, while 4,212 were recorded -- a near-match that bolstered confidence in the analysis. "The biggest thing people always want to know is, what's the intent behind these?" said Faust. "And I think what surprises most people is that accidents are a very small number of these deaths -- it's mostly homicide and suicide." While the study showed strong associations, it cannot prove causation -- a key limitation. But in a test of whether broader increases in violence might explain the trend, rather than changes to the law, the team analyzed non-firearm homicides and suicides and found no similar rise, a result that makes the findings "pretty compelling," said Faust. Black children saw the steepest increases. While the reasons are unclear, the authors speculated that disparities in safe firearm storage could play a role. There were some exceptions. Deaths rose in Illinois and Connecticut despite tighter laws -- though in the latter case, the spike was entirely attributable to the 2012 Sandy Hook mass shooting at an elementary school. "Big picture, we have a major problem in this country," said Faust. "But we also have a handful of states that are resisting these increases and, in fact, turning the other direction."
